1/15/26 - out of curiosity I asked the guy if they carried arancini (rice balls)? I don't know why? You don't see them on too many menus. He said they haven't put it on the menu yet, but they do. So I ordered one. It took a while to come out of the kitchen. I was surprised at the size of them. Fairly large. They come with a side of marinara. I was surprised to see there was mozzarella, fresh peas, and little cubes of meat inside. They weren't greasy either; which could happen when you deep fry some things. I asked if they were made in house, the guy at the counter said they do. You can get them at Restaurant Depot; in bulk. Either way they were pretty good, and filling. read more

See all

Another day at Antonella's for their slice. Their slices are big and very tasty. They are convenient located. Antonellas is large for a pizzerias. Shawn and the others guys are friendly and always with a smile read more

See all

Decided to order from here after a few years of trying other places & I found it to be a bit of a letdown. I ordered wings to start, asking to have them cooked well done so they were crispy (failed). To follow I had an eggplant sandwich (average) & chicken scarp dinner, which I requested extra hot peppers. Think they thought I said no peppers bc there literally d were none. Overall, it was all edible but I was disappointed. Won't be returning. read more

Food was delicious. Ordered fried calamari and a personal cheese pizza. Both were delicious. Went there once before and again now it did not disappoint!!!!! Thank you Shawn for your service it was all excellent!!!! read more

See all

Very friendly staff and THE perfect house salad every time!! (With the veggies that come with it - outstabring!). Love the pizza as well. And one of their chicken entrees that's spicy and lemony (comes with penne). A favorite that we go back for many times as well as my parents. read more

So average it's not even worth a review. Their salad pizza used to be really good years ago now I don't even feel like ordering it based on some slices I got recently. Such a disappointment overall read more

We used Antonella's in Fishkill for catering at our gender reveal and they were fantastic! The food was delicious, the portions were generous, and everything was ready and delivered to us right on time. Our guests were literally begging us for to-go containers because they wanted more... That's how good it was!!! We had between 40-45 people at this event, and their full size trays were plentiful. The management and staff were so accommodating and easy to work with. I'd recommend either stopping in or giving them a call to place your catering order. They make the whole process simple. We were so happy with how everything turned out that we've already passed along their info to multiple friends and family. Highly recommend Antonella's for any event! read more

I just called for a pizza delivered with half onion and they wanted $28. dollars. They are out of there mind. I called my go to Pizza and Stuff $22, no brainer read more

Refund my money. Pizza was awful and the mozzarella sticks inedible I took one bite and tossed then right in the trash

Family wants Good NY pizza and I needed Gluten Free. This place was the best! Also has traditional Italian pasta and meat dishes. Allergy sensitive and went above and beyond to make sure the food was good. read more

Ok great pizza selection and pizza rolls! Goood prices and great selection of pastas! And portions are large.

Nice owner. Very polite. Very clean inside. And the meatballs are amazing. Would recommend to anyone

Got take out from here Waited 30 minutes for salads to be made Dry Chicken & Soggy Croutons Their customer service there is horrendous when you call to complain Was offered a credit to get a new salad. They can keep that credit they would not give me my money back. read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Cesar Salad with Dry Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

Perfect take out salad So happy to find a place with a healthy take out grilled chicken salad that was delicious, fresh and chicken grilled perfectly (thin and soft- but rubbery!!) read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

We loved their homemade mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, homemade sauce, and most of all, their pizza!! We were a group of 7, and Shawn took excellent care of us all. read more

See all

Great food and fast friendly service. The pizza here is among the best in the area. As close to NYC pizza as you can get.

Excellent Pizza and great customer service. I ordered "to go" and the food was ready very quickly.

We were really in the mood for pizza and Antonella's is one of our favorite pizza spots in the area. I was super excited to see that they were still offering takeout. Our order was ready really quickly and despite the challenging times we are in, the service and quality of food has NOT suffered. Antonella's continues to bring forth a great experience and and gave me something to look forward to. They offer most of their pizzas in a gluten free version and they taste so good! Not to mention how plentiful the toppings are and how fair the pricing is. I'm always stuffed afterwards and have left overs for the next day. Honestly I'm so thankful that this place is still up and running, offering normalcy and a little bit of happiness to customers like me! It means a lot. read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Gluten free pizza with sausage and pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

From our wonderful server to every last bite, this place is amazing! Our wonderful server was so sweet, smart and kind to every question and made the BEST suggestion ever, THE BADA BING WINGS!!! (Fabio's own special recipe!) Glazed in honey, sriracha, spicy red pepper oil...so crisp outside and tender meat inside...and GIANT wing sizes...they are simply delicious! (The wings were so good I ordered two dozen mild to go for all week appetizers at home!) We also started with fried ravioli and mozzarella stix (SO CRUNCHY outside and perfect melts inside), then two (fresh from the garden it seemed) Caesar salads, one grilled chicken and another with the skirt steak, BOTH were amazing! Don't make me choose! Not crowded, no wait, such quick, good service and food delivery! Presentation on plates is Insta worthy (forgot to take pix we ate so fast lolol but here's my leftover raviolis for lunch next day and still perfect!) Enjoy this classic hometown favorite soon! Either location! read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Fried Raviolis - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

We ordered a meatball parm wrap and we got a small cold meatball chopped up in a wrap. No sauce or cheese. read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Worst meatball parm wrap ever - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Accommodating, friendly, above and beyond.The staff were so gracious and couldn't do enough for us. We felt right at home. Came in with a party of 5/6 and it was no problem and we were welcomed. Pizza is terrific, best in the area by far. Sean and Allison, thank you! read more

Was really happy to have their pizza. We live 45 mins away. Was in the area figured oh let's bring some home. Got all the way home. Ordered a gluten free half cheese/half pepperoni. Got a gluten free half cheese half eggplant. Yuck!!! read more

I love this place so much they have great tasting food and there inside is very nice and is perfect to have a dinner, and I've never had a problem with there service since they are always so nice and I just love this place! read more

Great pizza! Would definitely recommend for any one who lives in the area. They have great service and a variety of sides in addition to their mouth watering pizza. read more

This is a wonderful family restaurant. Perfect for a big group, a party of two, take out or delivery. The presentation isn't "high brow," this you can enjoy your meal in blue jeans, and leave the Jimmy Choo shoes at home! Super clean, great service. read more

It's okay, but you do get your best bang for a buck. In a tight squeeze we will order from here. Sicilian is pretty good though. read more

One of the best Italian restaurants in Fishkill and the area (they have multiple locations). They deliver and serve large party treys and are our go to for last minute company. The salmon platter & grilled calamari are incredible. read more

Great food, family atmosphere. Buffet style meals where your food is consistently served fresh, hot and delicious... delicious pizza...

Going down the tubes..Its a hit or miss restaurant...either its ok or sucks.Ordered a chicken ceasar salad n shrimp parm hero. $32.00..Now they don't give bread out..We picked up n found out when I got home.Called n says they charge now Wished they would of told us..See ya read more

Was in the Fishkill/Beacon area only for a couple of days for a wedding. After looking online for pizza places I stumbled upon Antonella's. I wasn't disappointed! Ordered a cheese pizza with basil. Order came in about an hour straight to my room at the hotel. Pizza was hot, perfectly cooked, good sauce, great cheese, and they didn't skimp on the basil! Ended up ordering another pie the following night before I flew back to the midwest. If I'm ever up that way again I'll definitely be ordering from them again! read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Excellent food at a reasonable price. The service for delivery is timely so your food arrives hot.

Sadly it's gone downhill. Maybe additional pizza making training is required I have had really good meals here in the past but the pizza is just average read more

he food is STILL EXCELLENT although I miiss the beautiful reataurant atmosphere and the friendly waiters and waitresses. My favorite Sole Francese is STILL the beat in. the county! Bwtter than Stephano's and Giovanni's. we go and pay the dinner menu for lunch, we just use paper plates and forks in the pizzeria area. Excellent food tastes just as well! My only recent complaint that has me unfortunately ordering at other olaces who can deliver in the evening. The female manager is not scheduling delivery staff for evening hours. I cannot deive at night. And the last three times I have called this same manager has been rude in replying. 'We don't take coupons anymore' then ' We don't have deivers. They've gone home. I am hoping my fave owner will step in and check scheduling. We always buy for 4, plus appetizers. Everytime it is close to $100 and worth every penny. I hate spending my money at other shops. Thank you for at least 15 years of quality meals so carwfully made. read more

We were passing through and stopped for a quick slice. I had the Grandma pizza and my son had a slice of ziti pizza and a slice of chicken bacon ranch. Absolutely delicious! We don't live too far away so we'll definitely go back. Highly recommend! read more

This place is just not good. I've never been a fan sometimes my family likes it. But everyone agrees last two times. No one in my family wants to order from here again. Food was greasy, tasted old and was cold. Sorry not sorry. Someone who never ate here did not finish food. They threw it out. I'm ok with so so food but when everyone said this food was not good. Then that says something read more

The pizza is not bad, but their super-rushed-hang-up-on-you-because-I-don't-have-time-for-you attitude sours the whole experience. I wish they understood that. I would really go there and order more if it were not because of that. I only order from them when I don't have a choice--not the place you want to be in your customer's minds. read more

We went with a group of 23 people for dinner after a baseball tournament. Sean was our server. The accommodations and service was amazing! Huge menu and all the dishes were delicious! Highly recommend to anyone! Would definitely be returning next time we are in the area! read more

Visiting from California and had to stop into Antonella's Restaurant and Pizza to pickup some authentic NY pizza. Wonderful service from our waitress Barbara who provided a complimentary asker of garlic knots, she's the best. Pizza was delicious too. I miss NY and obviously the pizza too, can't find it in Cali. They have a full menu. read more

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Garlic Knots! - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

I've been a consistent customer of Anotella's for several years but it wasn't until today that I will no longer be returning. I politely said that I am picking up an order and for the name, after the man at the register called me over. To which he proceeded to help someone else then returned and said "why are you yelling at me". I was beyond disappointed as someone who works in the industry that his customer service was that poor. read more

I am a customer as well as someone who provides a service to them. I clean their hoods and exhaust systems in their kitchens so I get to see how they keep their resturant and food. Besides the food and pizza tasting great the way they keep their kitchen clean as well as keeping their hoods up to date I can't give this place enough stars. All of their health practices are an A+ I would recommend this place to anyone and everyone. Keep up the great work guys read more