We loved everything about The Potholder Cafe in Eagle! The staff was friendly, the service was quick and non-intrusive, and the food was outstanding. You could choose to eat inside or outside on the patio. We went for the Mother's Day special...yum:) read more

Just a little update since I was able to sample the lunch menu. I ordered the hot pastrami sandwich with fries and a side of ranch dressing for dipping. Food came out quickly and my order was not only accurate, but appetizing. The pastrami was actually hot, with mustard that slightly oozed over the top of the meat and crispy, perfectly dilly pickles throughout. The bread was perfectly toasted, leaving a slightly soft yet crispy, buttery texture. The fries were battered and fried to the best balance of crispy outside, soft centers. The ranch was herbaceous and harmonious with the fries. Every bite was utterly scrumptious. I would order this sandwich again and again. The service was attentive and friendly. My friend had never been here before and was incredibly impressed with the service and food as well. This is quickly becoming one of my favorite places to visit! read more

See all

We visited The Potholder Cafe in Eagle for Father's Day brunch, and it was the perfect choice. This charming family-run restaurant is warm, friendly, and full of that classic diner feel we love. The staff is genuinely nice and makes you feel right at home. The menu offers a fantastic variety of breakfast scrambles and all the traditional favorites. My wife ordered the French toast, which she really enjoyed, while I went with one of their breakfast scrambles and it was excellent. The sourdough toast is amazing. We've been here a few times now, and the quality has always been consistently great. If you're in the area and looking for a welcoming spot with solid, delicious breakfast food, I highly recommend The Potholder Cafe! read more

The Potholder Cafe Eagle - Lots to pick from! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

The food was incredible. Plenty of it, presented very well, and super tasty. Coffee was good too. The servers were excellent. They operate as a team, so whoever is passing by your area is available and interested in serving you. It's a small enough café, to where you don't feel overwhelmed with too many people. It was just right. Exactly just right. read more

I just got in town last night from my trip to SLC. I wanted to spend some time with my daughter so I suggested that we go out for breakfast. And honestly, I didn't want to cook breakfast. The Potholder Cafe has been on my to go list so I took today as an opportunity to go check this joint out. It was a quick drive to the café which is nice. Walked in, was instantly greeted and it was seat yourself so we found a comfy table in the secondary dining area. The chairs they have here are so comfortable! That was the first thing I noticed getting myself situated. Whoever chose the chairs, good job! Kaitlyn came and dropped off menus to us. Coffee and orange juice was ordered I did Kaitlyn if I could possibly grab fresh creamer from her that wasn't in a communal dish. She offered to grab me a little portion of half and half from the back. I thought that was so kind of her! Drinks were dropped off and food was ordered. My daughter got the Loco Moco with some toast. I got the Baja scrambled with some spinach added to it. While our food was being prepared, we got to check out the decor. I love that our Idaho flag is represented at the restaurant. The country, farm chic decor makes the vibe fun and homey. Our food came out shortly and it was hot of the grill. You can smell the spices used on my ground beef. The spinach was bright green and fresh all over my scramble. There were pieces of olives, tomatoes and green onions sprinkled throughout my eggs. It looked delicious! I got a huge helping of hashbrowns which is shared with my daughter. There was enough for the both of us. My daughter's Loco Moco looked tasty! It was a hamburger patty topped with a fried eggs, covered in gravy. And underneath all that goodness was steamed white rice. The coffee was hot. Our food was really good. I enjoyed my scramble very much! Each bite was different cause of the ingredients in my scramble. Kaitlyn did a great job taking care of us. I guess my only complaint is that my daughter's meal was 17 bucks for a hamburger patty with a scoop of rice, 2 eggs and some gravy. Honestly, I would have expected at least another portion of it. I just don't see where the 17 dollars comes in for that amount of food. I do look forward to coming back, especially with my husband. He loves a good chicken fried steak. I would like to enjoy brunch somewhere closer to home than heading downtown to our Sunday local joint. Everything about our meal was great today, I guess we will just have to make sure we order something that has a good amount of bang for our buck the next time we come in. read more

See all

With the closure of Alien Cafe and the fact that The Griddle can easily turn into a 90-minute commitment on weekends, I figured it was finally time to try Potholder since I'm in this area all the time anyway. They really lean into the whole "bringing California brunch culture to Idaho" thing, so maybe my expectations were too high going in. But honestly... this was a pretty rough experience for me. I ordered the huevos rancheros because what feels more California brunch than that? When my plate came out, it looked weirdly plain and honestly kind of sad. Then my friend's huevos rancheros arrived and hers had all the toppings, sauces, avocado, etc. So apparently mine was missing half the dish. When I politely asked about it, I got a surprisingly snarky response that immediately made the whole thing uncomfortable. I really don't think I was rude about it at all. But the part that genuinely grossed me out was the mimosa tower situation. Two of the four glasses at our table literally had lipstick stains on them, and the others were cloudy/smudgy enough that we noticed immediately. That's the kind of thing you can't unsee once it's sitting at your table. I honestly don't really understand the hype because this place is constantly packed. Maybe we just caught them on an off day, but between the mediocre food, awkward service interaction, and dirty glassware, I don't think I'll be back. I'd personally rather wait for a table at The Griddle or have a calmer breakfast at Rembrandt's instead. read more

The selection! Excellent choices, healthy choices and really great taste. The staff is wonderful, friendly and tentative. I definitely recommend this place for satisfaction. We are from out of town and happy to have had a chance to meet the you wonderful owner. Thank you. read more

The food was hot, the service was good, the food also tasted great. We went there for the first time yesterday. My wife had Mary's Aphrodite, and I had the Complex burger. Both were fresh and very tasty. The waitress, was very nice and personable. This is a smaller restaurant, but I would highly recommend it. read more

This Potholder Cafe is one of a small chain of Southern California originated eateries with the same name and based on my first visit, I think the same menu is used here as in all of them. The owners are a daughter and father team, I think, and they are currently residents of Eagle. Open from 7a to 2p with a two-plus page laminated menu of breakfast offerings and lunch offerings on the back suggesting a pretty fixed menu, not changing seasonally.. They have updated to brighten the space that was formerly home to a beloved by many and locally owned lunch and dinner spot, Stuffed Olive. They get a lot right here and I wish for them great success even if it isn't the kind of menu that would lead me to eat here often. And that is all about my food preferences and in no way an issue with their food. SERVICE: We arrived right at noon and they were busy but service was excellent for being friendly and informed about the menu and the wait on food was merely a matter of a small kitchen trying to serve a lot of people from an expansive menu, I think. Were stars for service alone, they would easily be 5. Service here is light years better than the two other in-town breakfast / lunch spots of The Griddle and Rembrandt's. VIBE & SEATING: We were offered seating at the only open table that was in their overflow dining room. We appreciated the lack of music, one can carry on a conversation better, and I asked if that was an all-the-time thing or just this time thing. I was told the main dining space is wired for music but this room is not. Works for me! There is seating outside as well. All tables are standard height and I also appreciated they provide some "elbow" room between them in arranging both the main and overflow dining room. EATS: In a nod to the past, my husband and I shared a Club Sandwich ($15) and it came on rye toast (even if too lightly toasted) and without mayo, just as we requested. (Do you know how many restaurant kitchens can actually get that 'no mayo' request met? Answer: Few. :-) ) We can count on the fingers of one hand with some leftover how many times we eat fries during a year, but we had them here and they were delicious and came crispy hot. The fries were coated with something that seemed to add to the crispiness. Worth every calorie. Portions seem huge and looking at the tables around us, plates had food remaining or people asked for to go boxes. It seems as if part of the schtick here may be serving huge amounts. That is a thing for some people, although not mine given I am one of "those" who is concerned about food waste in the U.S. where 40% of food goes into landfills (and a lot of that starts in restaurants). We weren't the only ones in the dining room sharing an item; the server brought an extra plate with the meal to make sharing easy and they didn't charge us a share charge. We tipped $10 on that $15 sandwich to say thank-you. (When we share something, we often tip the server as if we had ordered two items.) Re those same two in-town breakfast - lunch spots I mentioned earlier in these comments, based on this single experience at Potholder and multiple experiences at the others before we said "we're done", the food here is better too. PARKING: The strip mall has a lot of spaces but it seems often full around this eatery, just as in the Stuffed Olive days. ACCESSIBILITY: There are 2 ADA compliant spaces in front of the restaurant but they are the only ones for the entire side of the parking lot. (The lot does not meet ADA minimums for number of spaces but that is a strip mall owner deficit, not the restaurant owner's.) Level in from walkway through both entry doors. Adequate clear floor space to get to tables. I wasn't using a wheelchair today (although on other days I might since I have had multiple sclerosis since college) and it seems some 4 tops would work for diners using wheelchairs. The uni-loo was marked accessible but I didn't check it. GOOD FOOD NEIGHBOR: If you arrive after Potholder closes or if they're full or if you are hankering for Greek food, local family owned and operated Kosta's Taverna that is directly across the parking lot and open for lunch and dinner is a top notch option. read more

See all

The Potholder Cafe has officially landed in Eagle & it's here to stay!! We went for breakfast on a Saturday morning & loved it! We sat down right away & the service was on point. Whether you choose to sit inside or outside, there will be plenty of room for everyone. The food was delicious & the portion sizes did not disappoint. While you're here, I'll let ya in on a little secret.. the chorizo & egg breakfast burrito is actually 2 burritos & you still get to choose a side.. it's a lot of food!! Yum! Speaking of a lot of food, Tim's Dug Out should be renamed the breakfast of champions.. it has all your favorite breakfast items & perfect for the person that wants a little bit of everything & can't settle on just one thing. If you're giving this place a try, you better come hungry! Happy Yelpin Y'all read more

See all

Great service! Food was delicious and generous portions. It was a lovely morning on the patio with our senior dog being able to join us. Will definitely be back. read more

Excellent family run café. Food is good and plentiful. Staff is pleasant and accommodating. Friendly atmosphere of a local breakfast spot "where everyone knows your name" read more

We've been looking for a replacement breakfast spot since Squeeze In closed (and broke our hearts). Enter The Potholder Cafe! Filling the void of the Jack Johnson is the banana nut pancakes! My mom ordered the Popeye's omelet, but then ate my pancakes. Good thing I can share! Will be back! read more

The Potholder Cafe Eagle - Simple breakfast with scrambled eggs, turkey bacon, and a smart upgrade to banana nut pancakes! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

We came in few days ago while visiting family nearby . We had a wonderful experience with very friendly & happy server and really great breakfast ! read more

Great little Cafe with extensive menu. Patio seating is dog friendly. I did the chili cheese omelet and now feel like a fatty!

A great early morning breakfast spot in Eagle! Our waitress was delightful and we got our food quickly. The food was pretty good and there is a lot to choose from. A quaint, cozy restaurant. read more

See all

I love The Griddle... but Potholder kicks their butt. Darling little family-run cafe with exceptional food and even better service.

Nice staff and good food. We ate outside with our dog. We will be back. Had the huevos rancheros

A nice newer place for Eagle comfortable seating Owners are fantastic Menu might be a bit excessive but is different from the average breakfast establishment service is excellent and the food prep is very good and well done read more

Best breakfast in Eagle!!! Unique menu with the classics but several different items to try.

We stopped in for breakfast and had a really enjoyable experience! The restaurant is spacious, clean, and the staff are friendly and attentive. First visit: We ordered an omelet and pancakes--both were delicious and hit the spot. Since we liked it so much, we came back a second time. I got the breakfast burrito, which was delicious. My husband tried the Mr. Potato Head potato/omelet and loved every bite--he said it was hearty, well-seasoned. The only minor nitpick: The salsa that came with the burrito tasted a lot like store-bought Pace Picante. It was fine, but in a place with such great food overall, homemade authentic salsa would take it to the next level. All in all, a solid spot with good portions, welcoming vibes, and tasty breakfast options. We'll definitely be back--highly recommend! P.S. It was a bit too cold and we left our jackets on. read more

Great, great service definitely one of a kind must go. Definitely try for breakfast I always love me a good omelette with some potatoes can't go wrong. read more

Absolutely love this place !! We eat here every Sunday after church service. They always take good care of us. We have two toddlers and it sure does help when the staff is helpful. The food is delicious and we often split a meal because the portions are generous. read more

We weren't able to get in it was a 45 minute wait....must be good but not excessable. We will try again.

This is a family run business that has a special touch of personality with exceptional food. Mercedes and Hallie are now like family. The remember your name and always deliver a smile along with great conversation. I love their omelette's with hash browns. The sourdough toast is a must try. We will make this place our go to breakfast and lunch destination. Well done Potholder Team read more

I can't say enough good things about this spot! From the moment we sat down, everything felt welcoming. Friendly service, cozy atmosphere, and the smell of comfort food coming from the kitchen. I ordered The D-FIB, and it was a total standout. The fried steak was perfectly crispy with that satisfying crunch in every bite, and the hash browns were spot-on; golden, flavorful, crispy edges with a soft, buttery center. You can tell they actually season their food here, which I really appreciate. My husband went with the Breakfast Tostada and declared it "the best tostada he's ever had." That's saying something, because he's pretty picky when it comes to breakfast. The kids were all smiles with their Mickey pancakes, which were fluffy, adorable, and a big hit. Everything tasted fresh and made with care, and the portion sizes were generous without being over the top. It's so nice to find a breakfast spot that nails both quality and flavor. We'll definitely be back! I'm already eyeing a few more dishes on the menu for next time! Highly recommend if you're looking for a place that does breakfast right. read more

We had brunch here this last week. It was so good, the service was phenomenal and the food was fresh.

Great to have a new, really good breakfast spot here in Eagle! Extensive menu (something for everyone), very friendly & attentive service and delicious food! 'Will be back to try more! read more

Great service! Best breakfast in town! Live the vibe. The sourdough bread is fantastic!

We used to eat at the Potholder in Long Beach so we were so excited to see this location. Our server was darling and gave us the absolute best service. The owner came by and chatted too. The food is delicious. So flavorful. We will definitely be back! read more

The Potholder Cafe Eagle - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Tasted just like being home in Long Beach! Brought back so many memories of weekly breakfasts with my parents. They would have been so happy to see this in Idaho!!!!!! We will definitely be frequenting! read more

The Potholder Cafe Eagle - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

service 5 stars. Our waitress was very attentive, and made sure everything ok. It's a good breakfast spot..food was average. read more

Staff very friendly and attentive. First time coming in and the menu is a mile long, so many great options. I looked around at others plates and everything looked great. Serving was huge and only $13 and some change. Fantastic, home run. Highly recommended read more

The Potholder Cafe Eagle - The Thursday special. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

What an enjoyable experience for lunch today! Our server Mercedes P. was kind, gracious and patient with us ladies. The food was very good and plentiful, fries were outstanding! read more

Great service, good food. Make sure you're Hungary when you go there because my wife and I had to take boxes home. Restaurant was clean, bathrooms were clean. read more

Update: We enjoyed our first visit, last week, so we brought my daughter and her boyfriend here this morning. We were met by, I believe, the owner, who immediately sat us, though it was 10:30 on a Saturday morning, at a nice corner table. I do have a complaint for this visit and that was the blonde, female that served us. While she took the drink order for my wife and I (before our daughter and her boyfriend arrived) fairly quickly, she seemed to have forgotten us. We had to wait nearly 10 minutes until my daughter arrived, and then she brought my coffee, my wife's OJ, and waters for the four of us. She took their drink orders--OJ and coffee--and then again seemed to forget us. Another server, a brunnette young woman, came to refill my coffee, and I had tell her that the other OJ and coffee had not been delivered. She promptly got those for us. It took a while, but our server came and took our order. I ordered the Sam's Breakfast Bowl without sour cream, my wife and daughter ordered the Frankie's standard breakfast, and my daughter's boyfriend ordered the french toast. When the orders arrived, mine had sour cream on it, and the boyfriend's order was wrong. Fortunately, the owner saved the day, giving the boyfriend the wrong order of french toast PLUS his correct order at no extra charge, and he took my dish back and removed the sour cream. Between the owner and the other server, they saved the experience for me, and so I still give it a 5 star. However, I would hope that our server get some more training, or improve if she has experience, because otherwise there will be customer complaints. read more

This place is GREAT! Wonderful food. Fresh tasting and large portions. Great customer service as well. They pay attention to details. Can eat inside or outside. Love this place!!! read more

The bacon is so good. The people there are really nice. However it can get pretty busy. Other than that it's a nice place. Little small though. read more

Poor communication skills and time management by the kids running the place. Half of them seemed bothered to be there.

The people are very nice. The food is average at best. However, the price of the food is outrageous. We spent over $100.00 for 3 people just ordering average breakfast for 2 and 1 person only had a child size fruit cup, coffee and a muffin. The muffin tasted like it was from boxed cake batter. Would be just ok if the prices weren't so high. read more