If I could leave zero stars, I would. This wasn't just bad service, it was a complete failure in communication and leadership. We had a reservation, arrived on time, and were told our table wasn't ready. It was a beautiful evening and we weren't in a rush, so no issue there. When an outdoor table opened up, we waited for it to be cleared. My husband went back inside to let the hostesses know we'd be sitting outside instead, and they said that was fine. I had actually tried to reserve an outdoor table earlier and was told they were first-come, first-served, so this seemed perfectly reasonable. Unfortunately, things quickly went downhill. A waitress came out and told us we couldn't sit there. We explained the situation, and she became visibly irritated and went inside. Another staff member came out and insisted we hadn't checked in at the hostess stand. When I explained again that we had, she repeatedly implied we were lying, even stating she had been at the stand. Both my husband and I had spoken to the hostesses, so this was confusing and frankly inappropriate. I firmly offered to go inside to clear it up with the hostesses, but she continued to question our honesty. At that point, my husband asked her to be nice, and she walked away. Meanwhile, the guests at the table next to us commented on how poorly we were being treated, which validated how strange the situation felt. We befriended them and talked and laughed while we waited. 20 minutes - no menus or drinks. My husband went inside and asked for a manager. 30 minutes - nothing. 40 minutes - still nothing. When I asked a server, she told me the manager was the same person I had "yelled at" (which was actually kind of humorous because though I was firm, I did not yell). She then told us the only other option was to speak to the owner, adding that he would likely just ask us to leave. At that point, we called a friend who is a well-known and respected local chef. He said this experience didn't surprise him and described ongoing issues with the owner/chef at Stonehorse. He stated, "He's a talented chef, but has horrible management and customer service skills." Interestingly, the regulars sitting next to us said the same. What's most telling is that we tried this restaurant a few months ago and left before being seated because the atmosphere felt negative. No one was smiling, and the energy was off. After tonight, it makes sense. It's unfortunate, because the location is great and the food may be as well, but leadership sets the tone, and it shows. This was hands down the worst dining experience we've had, and I would strongly caution others before going. read more

Ambiance = 5 stars Service = 5 stars App's = 5 stars Salad = 5 stars Pizza = 4 stars Wines = 5 stars Loved the location and vibe. Beautiful day and outside seating is marvelous. App's are fantastic...focaccia bread, a must have (Do not skip this!). Had a fantastic, well apportioned salad that is worth sharing. The pizza had the opportunity to be 5 star all the way. Crust, char...perfect! Had the Hawaiian and the BBQ chicken..,could have outdone themselves, but WAY too many large onions! Dropped it to a 4 star for me. I guess if you're a big onion fan, then perhaps it's spectacular, but Hawaiian should haven't any. Right? Feel like that's a miss on the chef's part. Wish I would have asked them to 86 them. ‍ But solid place...give it try, have everything I suggest above, but if you are just "meh" on onion...I'd recommend asking them to either lighten or hold them all together. read more

Favorite lunch spot in Tulsa! Salmon Caesar & sweet potatoes truffle fries are my go-to! Lunch tip: Make a reservation. They can be busy. Understandably so! read more

A consistently great place to eat. Fantastic menu and great service. Chill atmosphere and good location. When I'm in Tulsa, I always stop through here at least once. A+ read more

Hands-down, my favorite restaurant in Tulsa. Tim is a genius. We were just in last week. My teens will lose it if truckstop meatloaf is not ever around again. Chicken with 40ish cloves of garlic. The market is unbelievable as well. This is my favorite place!!! read more

Stopped by on this warm, beautiful Thursday afternoon with the goal to have a cold beer on the outdoor seating area. The ice cold F5 IPA mi not disappoint. My eye wandered over the menu and I settled on a Chicken BBQ pizza. Amazingly good. Mission accomplished. read more

See all

I visited Stonehorse Cafe for the first time on a random Wednesday afternoon. I'd say that I had a nice experience considering it being my first visit. My server was great and the atmosphere was nice and calm. Everything I ate was amazing, my favorite was the BURRATA and Focaccia, I'd come back just for that (I did)! read more

See all

The pizza crust was soggy Mashed potatoes were extremely salty. Bread served cold. Service was not impressive. Extremely long wait and they were not that busy. No kids menu or flexibility in menu choices. Ambiance was not good. Extremely loud inside, bamboo plants look weird, cleanliness was not the best. I would say Stonehorse is slowly going downhill. I would not recommend this restaurant read more

I love this place the quiche is excellent, I work at Westlake ace hardware and the owner comes in frequently to get their knives sharpened and I express to him and my co workers that they have the quiche in tulsa and what happens next is the owner Tim Inman brings a quiche on Monday to the store for me and coworkers to share. However I was off that day because of oral surgery issues but they meaning my fellow coworkers called me and saved me. How terrific is this, he didn't have too but he did and meant the world to me as he thought of me at the store. Give good service means you get good service definitely 5 stars Jim Sorrell read more

The food is amazing. We started with the crab cakes. They were amazing. I did not like the mango ketchup (the dipping sauce) but it grew on me. Then we shared the halibut (the special of the night), spicy shrimp risotto (absolute fave), and the blue salad. The service was fast. Our waitress was knowledgeable, funny, and amazing! The ambience is nice. You can sit inside or out. I have done both and it honestly just depends on your mood. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Crab cakes (split) - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Totally unacceptable and scummy hidden surcharge added to our bill. Food was not good enough to warrant having to pay the kitchen extra money for no reason. Pay your cooks an appropriate wage if you appreciate them so much. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Hidden surcharge on bill - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The service? Amazing. The food? SO GOOD. The lamb shoulder pasta was delicious and had so much meat. Great portion size too. My husband got the beef tartare and he was actually super full by the time he finished it. The portion was so big for this dish! I was impressed. The tres leches....oh my gosh. My husband never tried tres leches and we both are indifferent to coconut in/on desserts, but we loved this. We could have cried. It was incredible. Love this place so much!! read more

This location is in Utica Square on the corner, there are lots of options for parking. We were able to get a table quickly. It is a smaller restaurant but they use the space well. There is some fun decor. The service was great, our waitress was excellent. She stayed on top of drinks, was great with checking in and recommending items. The food was really good. The group tried a variety of items, I loved the salmon - it was light the broth was yummy. The truffle fries were so good and it was a huge order even sharing with the table, it has to be taken to go. It is definitely worth a try, if you have some shopping to do and want to grab a bite. read more

See all

This is my first impression of Stonehorse Cafe. So far, it is my favorite place to eat in Utica Square. Once in a while, creativity leads to great innovation. Most of the time, this is not the case. Fortunately, the kosher chicken ravioli is awesome. Stonehorse Cafe has a daily Tim's pick that changes from day to day. On this particular day, I am so happy I took risk and tried the kosher chicken ravioli which is the most unique ravioli you'll ever have. It's kosher chicken (chicken tenders) and stuffed ricotta ravioli in chicken broth. It truly is a soup and as a Vietnamese American, I love it. I feel like this brings out the flavor of the ricotta cheese. So many things about Stonehorse Cafe that make me want to come back. Good food, cute waitress, and Utica Square are just a few reasons. To be continued... read more

See all

I love the restaurant, but a super fan of their market! It's not big but the selection is wonderful. I am obsessed with their southwest avocado wrap...it's so good. I typically eat half and save the other half for another meal. I bought their everything crosswind recently and put their egg salad on it and it was so delicious! It his staff is always friendly and help too. It's a grate place to stop for to go sandwich or items for dinner or entertaining. The crab cakes, Caesar salad, chocolates, and bakery items do not disappoint! read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Everything croissant with their egg salad made at home - yum! - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

We went to Stonehorse for dinner and were both stunned and disgusted when our meal was interrupted by BUGS scurrying across our table between us! Management couldn't have handled the situation any worse than they did, and then (to add insult to injury) the food was sob-par. Tip: Even without the insect problem, the prices here are WAY too high when you consider the poor quality of their cuisine I'd suggest that you skip this place and eat anywhere else! read more

See all

I didn't know what to expect from Stonehorse Cafe, but it wasn't this! Delectable. Will absolutely return. The bartender was so sweet and attentive. You could tell she had relationships with all of the regulars that came in. It was so lovely to see! Fresh bread, caprese salad (could have been my lunch!), and the chicken and spinach ravioli were all so wonderful! read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Chardonnay and fresh bread - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Please note: There are a lot of unethical and legal issues concerning this restaurant at this time. Final Score: 62/100; Average Intro: Stonehorse Cafe in Tulsa's Utica Square epitomizes the Oklahoma dining trend where quantity often overshadows quality. Owned by Chef Tim Inman, this well-known establishment has been a Tulsa institution for years. I decided to revisit Stonehorse after almost a decade to see if anything had changed. Let's eat. Atmosphere: The ambiance at Stonehorse Cafe was confusing and slightly uncomfortable. Upon entering, I was greeted by a mix of seafood aroma, char, and an unidentifiable scent. The dark decor, close-set tables, and loud environment detracted from the dining experience. The restaurant was cold enough to give me goosebumps that lingered throughout much of the meal. The vibe felt confusing, with dark tones, a dark carpeted floor, black walls, and some off-white accents. Average service. While the initial enthusiasm was notable, service gaps became evident as the evening progressed. Our party felt neglected at times, despite the restaurant being less than half full. Some dishes were explained in detail, while others were not. One of our party wanted another drink, but was never asked if she wanted one (We acknowledge that we could have spoken up, yet the restaurant was at less than half capacity and high caliber service at a fine dining restaurant has certain standards and expectations. Food: Stonehorse's extensive menu includes nearly 50 offerings. We opted for a blind tasting: Italian Cheese Bread: Massive with good texture contrast, served with refreshing pesto and butter. The bread is massive, with cheese baked into the center. It has a good textural contrast between the crust and the center. Jump Gulf Shrimp: Well-cooked shrimp with a tangy, sweet cocktail sauce featuring diced cucumber for added freshness. The shrimp were cooked well, and the cocktail sauce had a tangy, sweet flavor profile. The sauce featured diced cucumber at the bottom, adding a crisp freshness to each bite. Wood-Roasted Medjool Dates: Sweet dates with smoky chorizo and undercooked bacon, resulting in a chewy texture. The dish features significantly sweet initial notes from the date that can overpower the other components. The sauce had a smoky cumin flavor profile that added some heat to the back of your throat. However, the bacon was undercooked in some areas, resulting in a chewy texture in some bites. Spicy Lobster Bisque: Velvety with rich, salty seafood notes, butter, cream, and sweet sherry. The bisque had a velvety texture with small chunks of lobster throughout. The flavor profile featured initial notes of rich, salty seafood fading to middle notes of butter and cream, with lingering end notes of lobster and sweet sherry. It is a well-composed bisque with a coherent and elegant flavor profile. 50/50 Pizza (BBQ Chicken and Chicken Basil Pesto):** Crust had good crunch, but the pizza was topping-heavy and soggy in the middle. The crust had a good crunch at the back end with a nice char. There are some critiques of the pizza. First, the ratio of crust-to-topping is topping-heavy, causing the toppings to fall off each slice. Second, the pizza's texture was soggy and wet in the middle, caused by the serving dish and the pocket of air that formed, allowing the juices to soak into the crust. Scottish King Salmon: Beautifully cooked with fingerling potatoes, lump crab, and tangy béarnaise sauce. This is a well-composed, beautiful dish. The salmon is cooked to perfection with an excellent sear, as are the fingerling potatoes. Creekstone Beef Tenderloin: Rare beef with roasted goat cheese that overpowered the delicate flavor. Bland vegetables and decent potatoes. The beef tenderloin was cooked to a beautiful rare and rested upon chunky grilled red onion. The roasted goat cheese is tangy and can overpower the delicate flavor of the beef. Maple-Glazed Carrots and Pecans: Fork-tender carrots with a nutty, sweet flavor, though the syrup ratio drowned out the carrot taste. One critique is that a considerable amount of syrup formed at the bottom of the dish. When it congealed, the ratio of sauce-to-carrot drowned out the carrot flavor. Mexican Sweet Corn: Al dente corn with smoky chipotle and cotija, though the chipotle flavor dominated. The corn was cooked al dente and had a crisp texture. Overall: Stonehorse Cafe remains true to its roots, prioritizing quantity over quality. While nothing was particularly bad, dishes like shrimp cocktail and bread were merely average. The extensive menu aims to please a broad audience but lacks mastery. Stonehorse is akin to an upscale Charleston's or Chili's, catering to those who prefer portion size over culinary finesse. It will likely remain a staple in Utica Square, appealing to the tastes of many Oklahomans. read more

See all

I like to make it to Stone horse Café about once a quarter. Good lunch or dinner spot for higher end food in Utica square. Great date night spot if you don't might medium noise level as the tables are in rather close proximity. If you love dates you must try the wood roasted medjool dates. The beef tenderloin tartar with white truffle is also a treat. On this specific outing we got the house focaccia. If you like warm bread, this is very tasty. It's served a healthy size of burrata, pesto & olive oil. Great appetizer for four people to try or two people if you're hungry and absolutely love incredible fresh warm bread as it's cut into four pieces. I almost always get the beef tenderloin steak, which is served with goat cheese on top. (Must try if you're obsessed w steak like myself) I don't think I've ever tried a dessert here, but I can imagine that they are very good. For cocktails they make a good espresso martini and if you're looking for something refreshing the "in good spirits" always hits the spot for me. It is a reposado tequila cocktail with muddled rosemary, grapefruit, st Germaine & egg whites. (I'm typically not a grapefruit in the drink person. But they know what they're doing with this) I think it has some other ingredient as well but it's escaping me. This is a popular Tulsa restaurant so it tends to fill up quickly. Sometimes it seems like the servers are a little short staffed or overwhelmed. I would say I've never had a "bad experience" here, but some servers are better than others. It's fairly priced and the food is consistent so I will continue coming back and recommending stonehorse. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - 8 ounce beef tenderloin with goat cheese - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Food and server were tops, no question. The tea that is offered tues-fri (I believe) is a fantastic value, tons of food, and so so fun. Why 3 stars? As follows: 1- we were seated in the back corner, directly next to 3 things: (A) a service station where silverware gets wrapped up, lots of manager/server discussions happening, much back and forthing; (B) the server locker cabinet where we got to witness the change in server times, lots of body spraying, discussions, purses put in/out. Felt awkwardly personal, like we were in their locker room; (C) the kitchen, just too much noise and movement happening to relax; 2. *Very loud* inside when busy. Sit outside if you can, patio looks beautiful; 3. I find the decor here distasteful. Many enormous paintings/photography of female anatomy. Some are sensual in nature (men's restroom), some seem to mock the female form (photo above the bar), and some are shocking (the 3 foot "seed" or "oyster" photo? - maybe it's just a straight up vagina, it's hard to say and also rendered my photos unusable). It's not "eclectic," it's unappetizing, and truly anachronistic for current society. If I had known I would not have brought my family there. Obviously not everywhere has to be kid-friendly, but it was a very polarizing vibe and even I was not comfortable. This will prevent me from returning. read more

Not a fan of the undisclosed junk fee they add to your bill. Lacks transparency and ruins a nice night out.

I did not know what to expect and thought it was ok. Not really my style but but will admit the food was good. I choose the Beef Tenderloin Tips w/mushrooms & gnocchi. Not exactly sure of a return visit, the lunch time was quite busy for a small restaurant and the wait was much longer than anticipated. read more

I have friends that love this place so we meet here for lunch at least a couple of times a year. They do have a very varied menu. Friends love the quiche. I got the blue salad which was perfect for lunch. It is a great place to day lunch and have a cocktail. read more

I've enjoyed the food and beverage offerings at stone horse cafe for meals and high tea. The service has always been on point and the decor charming. I have to say, though,my absolute favorite is the high tea. Just make sure you allow enough time and enough belly space. Don't worry, they will let you take home the inevitable leftover food. read more

See all

Ordered the hamburger to go, oh my goodness, it had an onion ring, grilled onions, no fresh onions, and those big fries fantastic. It was delicious. read more

Checking out Stonehorse Cafe. Basically we went to check out the Saks of Fifth and while just wandering around, we got hungry, so fist thing we did was pull out Yelp. Funny thing, Oklahomans use google more than Yelp. After scrolling around, we decided that this was the spot, so we stopped on in. First, walking in, this place had a really nice clean atmosphere. Everything was real bright and we were immediately welcomed. Looked at their menu and it had a very solid menu. Seemed like a French inspired menu. Ordered Potato's, Tuna Tartare, Mussels and & Brussel Sprouts to start out. It was all good. I ordered their Wood Roasted Long Island Duck Breast w/ Duck Sausage and Shrimp Risotto. Amazing. Definitely, if you're in town try this place out and let me know what you think. I'm gonna visit this place again when I'm in town. read more

See all

We went here for brunch not sure what to expect and this exceeded our expectations. My friend had the granola and the white pizza and I had the chicken Caesar salad. If you like Caesar salads you will love this. It had fresh Parmesan with the most delicious house made Caesar dressing. I had a slice of her pizza and it was also delicious.We shared the guacamole which was the best guacamole I've ever had, the chips were freshly fried. I definitely recommend stopping by their deli market. I got the lobster bisque since they didn't have it in the restaurant. Amazing ambience, staff, and food... 10/10 recommend! read more

See all

Food is always perfect Service is on point Ambiance is nice and soothing I would recommend coming here for just sitting at the bar and relaxing by yourself or going to the dining area and a date night. Their drinks are always perfect. They are quality craft cocktails. read more

Food: 3/5 Overall the food here was very good and reasonable for the prices. We ordered the wood fired dates, onion rings and cesar salad pizza. The dates we're good, personal preference but I didn't love the sauce on them. The chorizo on them was very good. I do not think I would order this item again. We also good a side of onion rings which were good and a large portion. The cesar salad was just not my favorite, but the rest of our group loved it! Just know it's a white pizza, so don't expect your typical sauce. Service: 2/5 We were very disappointed with the service here. Our waitress was not very attentive and we had to ask her to take our order, she wasn't checking on us much. She also had us take the plates from her which was odd instead of here putting them on the table. Too bad about this, hopefully others had a better experience. Overall: 3/5 I would come back here to try more of their menu items but was disappointed with the service. read more

See all

Our recent visit was much better than our last visit (10 months ago). Primarily due to the service. The food is consistently very good. This visit, we started with dumplings which were very tasty. They were slightly browned on one side and served over a sesame seed oil/ soy sauce mixture. I had the salmon and my wife had the duck. Both were very good; however, a couple of bites of duck were grisly. The salmon was served over stalks of asparagus and a side of more dumplings in the same sauce. I knew this when ordering and the server mentioned, but I went ahead. Maybe too much of a good thing. I won't do that again. The real star of the evening was the service. The server was new, but eager to provide excellent service. She did miss a couple of things and I was about to wave down the floor manager when she showed up. The manager must have seen me looking his way so he came on over, helped the new server out and discreetly kept an eye on our table the rest of the meal. The server's sincere desire and the manager's attentiveness to provide top notch service was very much appreciated. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Salmon and dumplings/ Duck and potato - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Love eating at this place! The fresh market is amazing to eat at when you want a nice fresh wrap or sandwich made to order! If you don't have much time, they have a lot of premade options as well - don't even get me started on the dessert selection! So many options! The chef Kacey is always so sweet. It's also always very clean in the cafe! read more

The food was really good. The bread was hot out the oven soft inside with a crunchy outer shell. The beef tenderloin was fabulous and the pizza was also delicious. The cheese plate was ok but not great. Would have been better served with a softer bread. The almonds were wonderful along with the jam. The ambiance was interesting and but very loud inside would have loved to sit outside on such a gorgeous day but they were very busy. The service was ok some servers were a bit short tempered others were very sweet but lacking in checking in with us. And it took a long time for our food. Although it was worth the wait. read more

See all

The food was perfectly prepared. $60 for lunch of one entree and two appetizers with no drinks seemed excessive? We stopped at Stonehorse Cafe in Utica Square for lunch on a Saturday. We were seated right away even though the inside and out were fully packed. The service was very good. It was very loud, difficult to have a conversation. The decor was a bit confused with multiple styles but lots of interesting things to look at. The crab cakes were okay. The maple pecan carrots were well balanced very sweet with a tiny spicy kick and the scalloped potatoes were divine. The table water was warm and the bottom of the clear glass carafe seemed to have a rusty brown ring. Overall it wasn't bad but once was enough, we wouldn't go back. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Scalloped potatoes - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Hawaiian pizza was delish, but we waited an hour for it. A little noisy for me, but I'm not super young. Also, salad was incredible. I can remember the name, but it had Brussels, mint, dill... Apple cider vinegar dressing! read more

Food was great. Unfortunately, service at bar was poor. Only 1 person, and they expect her to handle it all. I have mixed feelings. I like the food, but have higher expectations on service. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Cheese plate - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

I stopped in today for a snack and beverage with my bestie because neither of us had been here before. Generally speaking ordering guacamole is a safe bet in a restaurant...but I just wasn't too crazy about this one honestly. It looks kind of cool but it's hard to eat with the homemade chips (which need a bit of salt). This is supposed to be spicy, but unless you cut up the roasted jalapeño that comes on top of it...there is no spice at all. The tomatoes are just cherry tomatoes that are halved and the cilantro is so stringy. Like I said, it looks good...but wouldn't order it again. Aside from that, while I like that the wait staff has freedom in their clothing choices...they really should be careful wearing mini skirts. While eating I glanced toward the kitchen and one of the wait staff wearing a brown corduroy mini skirt flashed her nether region while leaning and reaching toward the kitchen counter. Fortunately she was wearing underwear, but still not something I wanted to see while eating. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Spicy guacamole and chips - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Food too salty. California pizza was awful. Server got snippy when we weren't ready to order. Okay it's a week later and I'm still steamed about this overly priced eatery with Denny's quality food and service. read more

Stonehorse Cafe - Dry pizza - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Always the best food and service in Tulsa! Have had meals here as long as they have been open, one of very few where I have never had an "off" experience. Consistency in every facet. read more

GREAT spot to grab cocktails with the girls! We sat outside and enjoyed drinks. The sangria was great! Stone horse has the best home cooked bread they serve as an appetizer. Make sure you ask for the oil to dip it in! Heads up. Service is slow, but that seems to be the accepted standard at the place read more

See all

The place was packed but we still got in, seated and were fed in a reasonable time. Menu was varied and all of our dishes were good, even if the description and the meal did not line up to our expectations. read more