This used to be the paragon of fine dining in Tulsa, and it is unfortunate how far it has fallen. The wine list is a pared down selection of the past, and although the food menu has kept most of the classic selections, the kitchen is clearly just going through the motions. Both of our steak entrees appeared more boiled than grilled, and in one case, the meat was overcooked outside and nearly raw inside. In another case, a hair was cooked into the steak. The staff is spread thin, so waiting for both drinks and food takes some patience. The atmosphere is still pleasant both indoors and out. Polo Grill seems to be surviving on its reputation from the past and the memories of its aging patrons. read more

Brought my wife here just before we got married for a date night and I'm glad that she had a great experience. I've come on number of occasions for lunch meetings and the menu never disappoints me. The service is like a kiss of heaven when I'm here and I enjoy bringing people into the space with me and getting their reaction as a first timer. The apps are always good and the bread before the meal never fails. read more

Polo Grill - Ceviche - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Very good steakhouse in the Utica shopping area. It is a cool spot that's a little romantic as well as pub style (?) up front. Decided to make reservations for the day before valentines and it was a good move. The crowds everywhere were crazy today.. The app of queso dip was really good as were the drinks. We both got NY strip steaks cooked to our desired doneness along with green beans and mashed potatoes. They both were really good. We got key lime pie and bread pudding for desert and they were spectacular. We wanted to eat a bit there and keep more for leftovers to eat while we stay in and it rains the rest of the weekend but we ate more as it was just that good. We are definitely glad to have went to Polo on our first Valentines in Tulsa. Will definitely return read more

See all

The Polo Grill offers an amazing daily happy hour special. From 2:30 to 5:30 pm M-F, they offer $5 vodka and gin martinis and house wines, including a sparkling option. $10 appetizers are also on offer, with a nice selection for varying tastes and cravings. (Unfortunately, their addictive calamari is not on offer) On a beautiful 75 degree early afternoon, my wife and I took an outdoor patio area table. The vodka martinis were standard size, with house vodka (Khor), which was fine. I also had a nice glass of sparkling wine. For snacks, we had the hummus plate, salmon tartare, and ceviche. The portions were very generous, and we probably only needed 2 of the 3! The hummus and veggies were very good, with a generous amount of both - veggies were crisp and fresh. The salmon tartare was really nice - perhaps a bit saucy for my preference, but still a solid dish. The ceviche was very good, with a variety of fish including a few calamari - perfect avocado, and just enough citrus and some zing to keep it fresh. Tostada chips, thin bagel chips, and other crackers accompanied our dishes - more than plenty of dipping options! Our service was very good, and we even had a nice chat with the chef/owner. I look forward to another easy afternoon on their patio. read more

See all

Food was excellent Service was also excellent One of my favorite when coming to Tulsa read more

Delicious dinner in one of the private party rooms. The smoked salmon was perfectly prepared and served over hearty grits. Key lime pie for dessert was just the right tart and sweet, accompanied by homemade whipped cream. Felt like it was a very good value for the price and the service was flawless and polite. read more

We finally got around to trying Polo Grill's social hour. That's something we've been planning for a long time Their menu calls social hour the 5 and dime. All social hour drinks are $5 and all social hour appetizers are $10. That keeps it simple. The drink was easy to choose. We don't like margaritas or sangria and we weren't in the mood for wine or beer. That left the martinis. You get a choice of gin or vodka, dirty or dry, and olive or twist Since the martinis were made from well liquor, we chose vodka. We find less expensive vodka tastes much better than less expensive gin. The well gin is Bentley and the well vodka is Core. Our dry vodka martinis with twists were delicious and shaken enough to be icy cold Just like we like them. We are curious about Bentley gin. For appetizers, we had the Arancini and ceviche. The cerviche included salmon, which was a surprise. The Deep Fried Arancini had a good presentation and the sauce had a spectacular flavor. The Polo Grill is delightfully elegant. It's a pleasure to enjoy a happy hour drink and snack in such elegance. Thank you to Bryan for giving us such good service. Hope to see you again on our next visit. read more

Polo Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great food and service! A favorite place in Tulsa! Very pleasant ambiance with a lot of character!

Oh my Gosh. Talk about GREAT food & a Happy place, Then my o my don't wait. don't hesitate, Load up the cars and head here, Before EVERY Tulsa Oilers hockey game. I eat here, What a GREAT selection & a fun time, Look out Crazy Steve amybe there, So by Golly. look out Steve is back in town, read more

Let me start by saying, if I weren't looking for it, I would have never known what and where it was. But I must say I like the decor. The experience was one of the best I've had in Tulsa. Our server was amazing! Kind, respectful and made some incredible suggestions. I ordered the shrimp and grits and a wedge salad and it was to die for!!! The grits had the most interesting flavors and was smooth and creamy. The shrimp was seasoned and grilled just right! Together each bite was better than the previous one! read more

Polo Grill - Shrimp and grits with a wedge salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

We visited Polo Grill recently for the first time recently; it was for dinner on a weekend evening. I've very pleased to report that we had an exceptional dining experience from end-to-end :-) While we were there they had a piano-player providing background music; it's a very nice touch, and highly conducive to enjoying your meal. Service was attentive without being overbearing; our server was efficient, friendly, and gave us several spot-on recommendations. The food was both delicious and very nicely presented. Tip: The portions are not oversized, but still more than adequate :-) I won't hesitate to return - highly recommended! read more

See all

I went at lunch and sat at the bar. Had the perch at the recommendation of a friend. The fish was ok. I liked how it was fried and it was juicy, but I thought it was under seasoned. The drinks were great. Well-balanced and thoughtful. Bartender clearly knew her stuff. read more

I actually had the same meal today as I did in my first review... Just because it was that good of a lunch! read more

See all

This used to be a great place. In fact our kids' school used to do events here with the students. We tot a business dinner recently and all I can say is that this place has really gone downhill. While our waiter was excellent, the food was bleh. Bisque was a little on the canned Campbell's soup side of taste which is different. Salad was fine. Steak was underseasoned and I only had a couple of bites. I didn't even finish it. The management does not seem to care and was frankly rude. I'm thinking this place has changed hands because I've never seen a place in Tulsa go from so good to bad. read more

Polo Grill - Utica Square, Tulsa (American) Note on Ratings: Scores are out of 100, emphasizing food quality. This review is based on my subjective opinion, primarily in fine dining. Introduction: Polo Grill, a longstanding fixture in Tulsa's fine dining scene for over three decades, beckoned me for an appraisal after its lofty reputation endured the test of time. Despite Tulsa's culinary evolution, Polo remained a beacon of excellence. With great company in tow, it was time to explore if this venerable establishment still held its own among Tulsa's culinary giants. Atmosphere: Polo's ambiance blends Midwest charm with modern country elements, creating a captivating setting rooted in old-world, country club vibes. The decor, lighting, and artful wine displays contribute to a relaxed dining experience. The diverse elements - from themed decor to sports-focused elements - might cater to a wide audience, albeit occasionally lacking clarity in identity. Service: Bella and Sam, our servers, delivered excellent, personable service. Bella's menu insights enhanced our experience, ensuring our needs were met throughout the evening, aligning with top-tier fine dining standards. Food: Lime bacon-wrapped shrimp, a delightful first appetizer, blended sweet undertones with a tangy lime sauce, elevated by a hint of heat from the jalapeno glaze. However, the beef tartare struggled to find balance due to an overwhelming beef flavor and chunky accompaniments, resulting in an unbalanced dish. The Arancini balls boasted a crispy crust but fell short in texture and flavor harmony. The lobster and crab bisque stood out, delivering a velvety, briny essence with cognac undertones, a standout rendition. However, the filet of beef tenderloin oscar style disappointed with overcooked portions and lackluster accompaniments. Dessert redeemed the meal with a satisfying chocolate Grand Marnier cake, complemented by vanilla bean ice cream, providing a creamy, flavorful finish. Overall: Polo Grill's generous portions and diverse ambiance may appeal broadly. Service and ambiance are commendable, yet the food quality and execution leave room for improvement. While some dishes were satisfactory, none stood out as exceptional, with a significant letdown in the steak dish. Polo Grill's unique dining experience and reasonable prices may still attract many despite its culinary inconsistencies. Atmosphere: 13/20; Occasionally ambiguous but overall pleasant. Service: 13/20; Good service, meeting fine dining expectations. Food: 36/60; Several good bites, some great, but overall room for improvement. Overall: 62/100 Price point: 1 drink; 2 appetizers; 1 entree; 1 dessert: $100.00 read more

See all

An experience to remember! I order a snack that cost over 50.00! My intent was ordering a meal that fed me worth 50.00. The lamb chops from Colorado for 50.00! ITS FROM COLORADO!!! Didn't know Colorado was known for its lamb. I figured paying a price for three lamb chops from New Zealand would be more respected than from up the street. Flavor was basic. Nothing to be excited about. It was a basic Tulsa flavor of salt and pepper. Which suites many? The sweet potatoes were delicious, but it wasn't enough on the plate. It reminded me of my Grandmother sweet potatoes made on Thanksgiving. Maybe she should've started a business! I also ordered the burger because the dinner size price lunch portion Colorado lambs wasn't enough food. I don't care for battered fries. Fresh cut at an establishment like this is of proper order. I ordered the burger well done. Again it reminded me of my grandmothers. It was delicious. Reminded me of home cook. Again nothing special. No house sauce. Simple. This place has promise, but it needs help in the kitchen. Service was excellent! On point! I would go for a nice drink, pleasant atmosphere, and great service. But make sure you eat before you go, or order the burger! read more

See all

Came In for just drinks but decided to have dinner the food looked so good. Had the seafood pasta and chocolate cake which was amazing. Service and ambiance was great as well. Will Definitely be back read more

Polo Grill - Featured Gin cocktail on the cocktail menu - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

The atmosphere is classy, the service is incredible and the food does not miss a beat. They have an extensive wine selection and a very comfortable restaurant and bar. Excellent place for a nice date night or somewhat upscale business dinner. They have been in business 40 years with the same owner/chef, who is very proud to serve the community. read more

Polo Grill - They have excellent beef, sourced locally, filleted in house. - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Amazing customer service, amazing food, and the ambience was stellar. Many menu options that aren't too pricey. I will continue to go to this restaurant. read more

New Year's Eve Fiasco. 24 hours before our reservation, an email informed us that our selected time was changed. A phone call to the restaurant provided a far less than satisfactory answer. When we arrived, we were escorted to the far backside of the establishment and the three of us seated in a cold room at an 8-top table. Really? When we asked for the manager and explained the now worsening fiasco, she moved us into a nicer part of the restaurant. Now we learn that the entire menu is prix fixe at $95 per person. Small portions were suitable. Nothing was outstanding. Filets were acceptable. With tax and tip we spent $400. Good bye, Polo Grill. read more

Great Ambiance. Service was professional. The food was good but could be a bit more high end.

Consistently awesome ! Pricey !, but isn't that the way excellence should be. On this day it was a beautiful fall afternoon for lunch and David Brunner was playing his guitar on the patio. Never a disappointment here and it never hurts to call for a reservation! read more

See all

We thoroughly enjoyed this restaurant. It's located in Utica square where most the cool shops are, so this place is an added plus, PLUS because of that alone. I believe the young, dashing, gentleman's name was Jordan that served us. He was charming, accommodating, and wonderful! He had us laughing. Jordan had us seated outside, and he saw that I was uncomfortable because the sun was hitting our direction and saw another table under a tree had been cleared. He made sure that it was ok to relocate us before seating us there, while another staff (older gentleman) was trying to tell us the table was for another party. PROPS to our man, Jordan, he fought for us and assured us that the table was ours for keeps! So there, thank you, Jordan! The food...c'mon! Excellent! Check out our choices! Ever so fluffy pancakes for my princess, a nice tomato bisque...calamari, 2 kinds of shrimp appetizers, both breaded. The lime glazed shrimp was my fave! There was a fresh hummus and veggie plate I didn't see on the menu that was being served, that I had to have for picture worthy purposes! That was good! We also enjoyed our eggs benedict and a juicy burger. The prices, reasonable! I was pleasantly surprised, and I look forward to returning here. All around, great experience! read more

See all

Old school classy restaurant in Utica square. This place has been around for years and never lets you down. I've only been there for lunch or dinner yet recently discovered their brunch. Filling, delicious and affordable. I got their chocolate chip pancakes and a side of eggs. The pancakes came out in 3 and huge and fluffy. Chocolate chips throughout i couldn't finish the entire thing and the side of eggs there was easily 4 eggs not like your typical side of 2 you get most places. The complimentary bread basket featuring their delicious blueberry muffins, cornbread etc is to die for. If you finish that entire thing you don't need a ton for your main dish i promise. Service is always so attentive and they even had a live guitarist during brunch saturday. read more

See all

This review is of the food. The service was fine. Ambience is good. The food, just not worth the price. For starters, they don't serve bread. They used to. Now they give you a random small plate of Kalamata olives. So strange. It peeves me when you order a Caesar salad that literally by definition has a handful of ingredients and one of those is missing: no croutons. Instead they put a chunk of garlic. So bizarre. My salad had so much leftover cheese and garlic I was tempted to ask for a to-go container. The waitress also up-charged us for a large salad when we said we were going to split one without even asking. Potatoes were fine. Steak was flavorless and even after sending the first one back, I still didn't care for the cook on the 2nd one. Also had to flag the waitress down to tell her about the cook on the steak. A nice place generally will wait and ask if you're happy with your steak. I had to add salt and pepper and didn't finish it. For $205, we won't be back. read more

See all

Last night I had to talk my wife into ordering carryout from Polo Grill because they served served her a rare Howard Warren last time we were there, but she reluctantly agreed. I called and ordered and explained on the phone that is was IMPORTANT that the Howard Warren be well done. I ordered the hamburger medium well with cheddar and a salad. $70 after tip. As you can see her HW was literally raw inside when we got it home. It's a churched-up hamburger patty Polo Grill, you cannot be serious that you can't make one well done. I angrily drove it back to the restaurant with the receipt that clearly said WELL DONE. Bar service was curt and incommunicative while I waited for a replacement. No offer to comp it or even a glass of water while I waited. Got home with her new meal and discovered that they had made my burger with Swiss cheese instead of cheddar. $70 for essentially two burgers and a salad and both burger patties are screwed up. Nicely done, Polo Grill. The restaurant and service have really gone downhill here. Avoid. Too many other good options right there within Utica Square. read more

Polo Grill - Howard Warren carry out ordered well done. - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Went here on a recommendation from a friend. It is tucked in to Utica Square and a little hard to find, but worth it. One; get a reservation. It wasn't busy when we were there, but it wasn't a large location and make a reservation if they take one. Makes life simple. Things didn't start out that great. We arrived and were seated at a nice booth. And waited. And waited. And.........waited. After about 10 minutes our savior: Daisy came by. She offered us bread, and then about 5 minutes later brought us water. For the rest of the night we would lack for neither. After about 20 minutes we were approached by the wait staff who apologized and said there was a mix up. We were given menus and they were very gracious and offered us complimentary drinks. The rest of the night was fabulous. Daisy always filled our water, and the food was fantastic. My wife had the filet with potatoes and asparagus; I had the bone in pork chop with sweat potatoes and Brussel sprouts. The sides reminded me of Christmas they were so sweat/savory. And the meat was cooked to perfection. As a parting gift they offered us a free dessert. They were very much welcoming and on point once they got into gear. Very much worth the visit. read more

Amazing high-end cuisine with excellent service and classic continental cuisine atmosphere. Be prepared to spend $70 per person if you get drinks and dessert. read more

Can't believe I haven't written a review previously but here goes for several visits. The last eat stop was for lunch on the patio. As usually attention to details at every turn. The wine by the glass will always be pleasing and often something you haven't heard of before. The bottle selection is always an adventure and love it. This visit included horseradish crusted shrimp which were a great treat. As always the tomato bisque and garlic bread were a meal within themselves and make it difficult to order other items but Caesar salad is the real deal, not a pre-made dressing poured over. This is a place you will never be disappointed read more

Small portions for the price. Service was good and the ambiance was pleasant. The seafood my friend ordered was great. read more

Whole place smelled like bad fish, hostess wasn't at her stand for like 5 minutes when we walked in, and was very rude to us when she eventually came back, and when she did, some lady walked up and guided us to our "table"... they just stuck us in the corner of their bar, inches away from the hostess stand. read more

We attended a wedding dinner here. Everything was very nice. Quiet and attractive surroundings. The service was top notch. The food was good with nice bisque, salad, and tenderloin. We'll have to give this place another try sometime. read more

Went for brunch a couple of weeks ago. We weren't impressed with the quality of food or drinks. We had the smoked salmon with eggs. The service was good which is why I'm going with three stars. Atmosphere was fine. We just didn't enjoy the food or drinks. read more

Disappointed, 6 adults sat @ tiny table-not comfortable. Also not selling budlight & running out of Mich Ultra :-/

Excellent food. The portions are not oversized. Lobster bisque, best in Oklahoma! The Caesar- delish! The appetizers are well executed & the main dishes are superb. A few of my favorites are the calamari (slightly spicy), the lime bacon shrimp & the risotto (add chicken & make it a meal!). Steaks are excellent as is the salmon. Grits, asparagus, Brussel sprouts, oh my! My favorite dessert is the house made bread pudding, no raisins :) read more

Having been a server at multiple restaurants for about 10 years I am usually hypersensitive to bad service. You will not find bad service at this restaurant I just finished eating there and it was literally the absolute best customer service I have ever experienced eating at a restaurant. The meal was phenomenal and again just the experience from the minute I sat down to the minute I left their service staff is the best that I have ever experienced. Great job!! read more

1. Service was terrible. We sat outside for an easy 20 minutes before anyone came to take our order 2. When we got the calamari it was obviously old. Overcooked. Hard as a rock. I'd say worst I've eaten in Tulsa. 3. Drinks subpar 4. Cake:...I could tell it was good when it was fresh but the cake part was dry. Been sitting a few days. Won't be back. When I explained the calamari they said they could make it again. I'm like no thanks. Not hungry. We still had to pay for it. read more

Food and drinks are excellent and the atmosphere is calm and inviting. The service was also excellent. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Polo Grill is another one of my new favorite restaurants. It's no secret that it's on the pricier side, but the food quality is very good. Our server was super nice and offered us great recommendations. The staff worked hard to accommodate our needs. The food was pretty good, but not great, especially given the price. I got chicken which was very tender and flavorful but I didn't love the mashed potatoes or vegetables that came with the dish. The fries are great read more

Polo Grill - Bone in Frenched Chicken - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

One of our favorites we hadn't been to in quite a while. One of the best atmospheres and Tulsa and it is hard to find better live music in the background. read more

See all