We've never been to Bison, but the 4.7 star review on google has been tempting me for a while. First impression was the restaurant was cute. It looked clean. The hustle and bustle of Friday night dinner plans hadn't started yet and there was plenty of seating. We were seated and there were crumbs on our "clean" table. We were moved and the floor under that table was sticky. Our server, who never introduced themselves, came and took our drink and appetizer order. Our sodas came out flat. The server didn't charge us and replaced them with waters. Our appetizer eventually arrived, the spinach, artichoke dip. The parmesan on top was not melted, we removed it like a sheet of paper. We told our server, who said, "oh yeah, I should've told you that it is better when you take it home and microwave it to really melt the cheese then it's really good". Even if we did enjoy the spinach dip, which we did not, there aren't enough pita chips to eat the entire appetizer. Those would be an additional charge. During the appetizer conversation, I did put my empty water glass to their side of the table to make a refill more simple. They started to walk away without even realizing the nonverbal gesture I made as to not interrupt our conversation. I verbally asked for more water and they forgot about it. I did witness the "ah-ha" moment when they remembered they had forgotten. My wife's grilled salmon had no real flavor, sitting on top of a basic bed of rice. Her tabouli was lacking. I can't forget to mention that when her side salad arrived, the food runner simply asked, "is this yours?" It was slightly off-putting. I never thought about my dining experience being altered by the food runner, but "side salad with ranch" versus "is this yours" is a minor detail that can apparently affect the experience. The server didn't come by as often as I felt they should. They did their verbal checks with the appetizer and the meal, but didn't see them do any walk by checks, until I asked for the bill. My burger was nothing to write home about, but it was good. The fries were undercooked and the thousand island dressing tasted like Kraft dressing. I ate half my burger and my wife ate a small portion of her salmon. We paid 60$ for food we barely touched and we took none of it home. I would rather pay 60$ at Chili's or Texas Roadhouse. We take those leftovers home. I would like to say that I would give Bison another chance, but that won't be the case. Too many mishaps on this visit to make us want to return. My wife was very tempted to talk to the manager, but I was more ready to just pay the check, leave, and take this experience as a sign to never return. read more

So the plate looked great but the rough Thing was the steak was med rare for n the middle came doin and for a filet at 6 oz.... Should have been butter and this thing was more like a sirloin. I loved the sear in the meat but it was borderline line turn it back ins. The other problem I had was there first two bites was almost like it sat on an ice cube. Was very weird. Potato was pretty decent and the sprouts weren't too bad but could have used a sprinkle of shredded Parmesan cheese. Our server was great but the speed could have been just a little quicker. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I ate here for the first time and everything I tried was delicious! They have rolls with cinnamon butter and a wonderful Onion blossom. I went on a Monday night and did not have to wait, I was shocked the place was not more packed. I order the steak, mac &cheese and fries which was perfect. My parents ordered a chicken fried steak which was huge and the Brussels sprouts which they said it was amazing. This restaurant is a must try, and they have daily specials! read more

Bison Steakhouse - Steak, Mac & Cheese, and Fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I ordered the ribeye steaks, well done with two slices, mashed potatoes and asparagus. The 20 ounce steak was more of a center cut steak than a ribeye steak. The steak texture was more dense, than tender. The ribeye moist flavor was missing from this steak. Our server wasn't friendly and very short of hospitality; The table was cleared off, but not wiped off. I liked the western atmosphere and decor of the restaurant. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Stopped by Bison Steakhouse while I was visiting the Tulsa area and had a great meal. The steak was cooked well, the portions were generous, and the loaded baked potato was excellent. Service was friendly and attentive. Solid steakhouse in Broken Arrow and definitely worth a visit if you're in the area. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Ribeye steak bone in and loaded baked potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

So I got takeout and the cabbage rolls were definitely not up to par. They needed to be reheated longer and the rice was a little crunchy so it wasn't fully cooked. I also tried the stuffed grape leaves, which were really good, but I'm used to having Taziki with them and I feel like for $10. I should've got at least 10 of them. I decided to eat in for lunch and the lunch menu is amazing. It's a lot of their regular menu items same portion as dinner but for a lower price which is such a great deal. My waitress was amazing. Service was on point. And this time I got the trio appetizer, and the cabbage roll was perfect. The hummus the tabouli everything was so good. I tried the pork chops for the first time. They were really good and I love that I can get asparagus as one of my sides and it's not extra. I also had a Caesar salad, which was so fresh and good . I wore Pisoneros shirt and got a free appetizer this time as well as when I did take out and it's so great that they do a free appetizer with that T-shirt. read more

See all

Chilean Sea Bass was excellent. The Sirloin Steak was cooked exactly as ordered and was tender. The baked potato was loaded with the perfect amount of toppings. The broccoli was not as tender as we like it, but the seasoning was good. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Chilean Sea Bass. 6 ounce Sirloin Steak. - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I found the restaurant just by googling one evening! It seemed to have a nice website with photos. A friend admitted that they had been to it soon after it opened, and were not impressed. I thought...well, it can't be that bad! We arrived about 6:30 pm and the parking lot was packed and I thought...oops, I should have made reservations for 4! However, upon entry, we were immediately seated and our guests were seated quickly by a very kind staff! Soon, we were charmed by fresh warm homemade rolls complete with a scoop fresh of butter and also cinnamon- butter...Wow! Since the place was busy...service slowed a bit, so more fresh warm roll were delivered again...Darn the luck! Food was delivered and all the four of us were blown away by the quantity and quality of the food! Silly me... I ordered the "house special" for the evening...Huge Chicken Fried Steak...my sides: sweet seasoned carrots and apple sauce (both very large servings!) My wife and our friend's orders were also quite large servings and everyone brought home food! Now, we are thinking about taking grandsons to dinner there...their appetite will be well covered by quality and quantity!! Case closed!! read more

The food here is so good & Hannah (i think is her name) always does an amazing job. This time we halted the salmon, rice, and it was really good! They could work on the potato skins because they barely put any seasoning on them, or green onions... but it's probably one of the nicest restaurants in Broken Arrow. Nice place! Definitely our go to! read more

See all

My husband and I went for Valentine's Day dinner and did not make a reservation. We did go a little early 4:45pm, but only had to wait about a 30 min wait to be seated. The service and food were both excellent! We will definitely be back! read more

Great food and service! The waitress was so engaging and kind! We thoroughly enjoyed our steak!

Best chicken fried steak, and best Brussel sprouts and Mac and cheese. Good friendly service! Good atmosphere! Friend had steak very tender and cooked just right. Salads are very good and blooming onion. I've been there 3 times! read more

Food and service were great! Had a bison porterhouse that was cooked and seasoned perfectly.

Nice place with friendly wait staff.. food was good and will be going back.., the cabbage rolls were perfect...

The food was delicious and service was amazing..They have a very friendly and knowledgeable staff

Food is awesome at Bison Steakhouse! If you have children with Autism please support this establishment because our nonprofit has monthly events for our community and the management understands us by sponsoring gift cards. read more

Karessa was our server, not only was she sweet to boot, but over the top, as she stayed on top of our drinks, including my bardrinks. This was our 1st time eating here. Dillon was so kind, warm & so sweet when he brought us our cabbage rolls & onion bloom and our dinners. My advice to anyone-come w an empty stomach because you will leave with plenty of leftovers!!!!! Amazing food!!! read more

We got there a little before 6:00pm and were seated immediately. We had some rolls with butter offered and these were a welcome start. Butter seemed sweet. Rolls were warm and fresh. After browsing the menu, we got elected to open up the flood gates with a Blooming Onion. I'd say this is comparable if not better than most other onion blossom offered by restaurants. One side, in particular had just the right amount of crispiness, but the other side was a bit mushy. Had it been evenly crispy, It'd place in the S-tier. We each ordered a sirloin steak -- mine was medium and my wife's was well done. They were both "cooked to perfection" as the menu stated. Although mine was seasoned a bit too much, the flavor profile of the seasoning well complimented the natural char flavoring with which it was cooked. Cutting into the meat I felt like I was an infomercial host trying to sell viewers on some new Japanese knife. It was like cutting into butter. Even my wife's well done steak was strangely tender. I'd rank their steaks in the A-tier but closer to the S-tier than the B, for sure. For the sides (two sides per entree), we split fire roasted corn, steamed vegetables, seasoned rice, and asparagus. Fire roasted corn had some kick to it that we both appreciated. Maybe a little bit of cayenne pepper. Anyways, had that sweet heat combination of which we're fans. A-tier Steamed vegetables: typical mixture you'll get from most steakhouses. Broccoli, carrots, zucchini, and cauliflower doused in a buttery oil with shaved garlic. I do believe I tasted hints of Parmesan in there which helped to differentiate it from those aforementioned places. Otherwise, run-of-the-mill. B-tier. Seasoned rice: completely forgettable. Maybe even a little off-putting. Had a weird taste to it despite being topped with a fresh green herb. D-tier. Asparagus: this one wasn't bad, but I've had better grilled asparagus stalks from local restaurants. They weren't bad, though. C-tier. The atmosphere seemed alright. Seating was a bit cramped. Even walking to the restrooms, it felt like i was going to bump into the staff. Sink water was immediately hot. Only one urinal, though. Large flat screen TVs on the north/south walls so this is the kind of place you could go to for a big sports watch. We had only water. No bad taste but I we cannot comment on any of the drink selections or desserts. Server didn't really give us an option. She seemed like she was maybe ready to get us out for the Saturday night dinner crowd. Verdict: we will return. We surveyed the offerings at neighboring tables and their burgers, chicken tenders, and chicken fried steak looked worthwhile to try. So, it'll be another date night and I'll update accordingly. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Sirloin steak Seasoned rice Asparagus - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

My steakhouse salad was good with the steak cooked to my liking. However, the dinner rolls were not piping hot but they were soft. Iced water had an after taste. The server checked on us a few times but did not refill our soda. read more

See all

Have been meaning to try this place since they opened because they are close to home. I called at 5 pm to ask if they took reservations, the young lady on the line said they only take reservations for large parties and two people would be seated immediately. My wife and I showed up at 6 pm and they were packed. I do have to give them credit, they seated us pretty quick (@ 5 minutes). The Interior is nothing fancy (old Applebees), and they had the tables packed pretty tight because of some large parties that were seated. We started with the cabbage rolls as an appetizer and I was truly impressed. Nice spice on the filling and just the right amount of cook one the rolls. I would highly recommended them. I chose the beef kabobs with bison chili and sweet corn; my wife went with the Sea Bass with a side salad and mashed potatoes. The kabobs were well cooked and flavorful, but the real hit to me was the chili which came out with sweet cornbread. It was solid! Not award winning, but they matched up well and it was great. My wife said the salad was crisp and a good portion. Her sea bass was cooked well and not rubbery: she said she enjoyed it. Portion sizes are large so we're took lots home for another meal tomorrow. Price is just okay. The appetizers and some entrees like the kabob and burgers are nicely priced, but the steak and seafood are in the low to mid $30 range which is higher than some good chain restaurants. On the plus side, the service was fast and friendly. The food came out well cooked, warm, and quickly. With tip we got out of there for $95 for two people. Worth the value, but not somewhere you can afford every week. Still we will come back and definitely do the cabbage rolls and try more of the menu. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Our server Ava was awesome We went for my sweet hubs birthday & he got the new sweet & spicy boneless hot wings. We always enjoy their rolls & honey butter. We shared a delicious ribeye with a loaded baked potato & side side that were super . Since it was his birthday they gave us peach bread pudding on the house it smelled so yummy. We'll have it later when we're not so full. We'll be back they next time we have a celebration perhaps our 37th Anniversary ! read more

Bison Steakhouse - New appetizer s&s hot wings - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

This "was" a good restaurant. However, the past 2 visits have been a disappointment. It took 45+ minutes to get our meal. 2 of the dinners were incorrect. The pork chops were overcooked and very dry. The waitress was overwhelmed due to lack of staff. I hope the owners can get it together. Not sure if we will go back. read more

Reasonable prices, nice portions, delicious food. And have to mention the rolls! Had steak first time, pork chops second time.

I had the spinach artichoke chicken and it was grilled perfectly, but there wasn't much spinach or artichoke, and not enough sauce for the rice. The mashed potatoes were room temperature when they got to the table. My dining companions said the Brussels sprouts were excellent, and the steaks were decent Service was friendly, wait times were reasonable, so it was fine. read more

The food is always top notch, delicious and appetizing. They're also very sweet about when we get half portions they divided on two different plates for automatically in the kitchen. You can see that in the salmon and tabouli picture where they divided the meal for us. Amy was an excellent waitress. It takes care of us so nicely. In addition, the ambience is lovely for the family or friends to get together and have a nice evening meal. read more

See all

We tried Bison earlier this week. We started with the Mediterranean plate (hummus, tabouli, & one cabbage roll) and the complimentary bread. The hummus was okay, the tabouli was mediocre, but the cabbage roll was amazing. Bread was okay. It paired well with the sweet honey butter. Next, I had the house salad with ranch. I am assuming they make their ranch dressing with miracle whip. It was gross. For the main course, we split the filet with Brussel sprouts & French fries. The main course was good. I would order it again. My daughter tried the children's burger & fries. She liked it. Service was excellent. Our waitress was attentive. Ambience is casual. TVs were around the restaurant playing various games and one was playing The Office. The restaurant has the bar in the very center, so it feels like an Applebees (it used to be one). If you want to go to a steak house with your family, give it a try. If you want romance, I have plenty of other reviews of places that are more equipped with an intimate setting. read more

Bison Steakhouse - Cabbage roll - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

The Bison Steakhouse was amazing! The service was wonderful. The steak Diane was split between my husband and myself. This is just 1/2 of the steak. Tender, juicy, and full of flavor! Cooked perfectly! Best steak I have had in a long time. Well worth the stop!!! Environment was comfortable and the service was spot on and fast! read more

Bison Steakhouse - Steak Diane - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Very busy on a Saturday night. Waited over an hour for seat. The waitress was friendly and kept us satisfied. Food was well prepared and actually quite reasonable. Will definitely return when in the area again. read more

Read your bill if you drink liquor...we had 2 margaritas and the liquor tax ALONE was 30%. We did bring it up to manager but he didn't do anything for our bill but said he would check into it. Buyer beware, we won't drink there again except water. read more

While the service was acceptable, the steak was overcooked, and the Brussels sprouts had an unexpectedly sweet, grape-jelly flavor. This restaurant may appeal to those who prefer well-done steaks and very sweet vegetable sides. read more

We wanted try to somewhere new today. The food was really good, we were pretty impressed. We both got steak and very well priced and cooked just right. The sides were just as good. The service was top notch. Our glasses stayed full and the waitress was very attentive. The atmosphere was just alright, too many TVs in my opinion but it was very clean and comfortable. We highly recommend this restaurant. The prices are very fair for the quality of food and service. read more

Fantastic food and service. Chicken fried steak was delicious and huge! Looking forward to when we can go back next time we are in town.

The service was great. Amy K was brilliant. Thank you. The food was great as well. We ate steaks, jalapeno poppers and even carrot cake. They didn't have a wheel barrel to get us to the car, so we had to walk. ..... the environment was clean and sports bar-espec, but nice. read more

It is open. The Bison Burgers are on the grill as I write these words. Broken Arrow didn't need another Mexican, Chicken or Pizza restaurant. A Steakhouse, Yes! A Steakhouse that serves Bison even better. A Steakhouse on the south side of town in New Orleans Square, perfect! The Bison Steakhouse is in the structure that was previously the Oasis and before that possibly an Applebee's. It is nicely decorated, roomy, comfortable with a large full bar centered in the room. It offers a relaxing environment to enjoy a few drinks and a good steak. I have been waiting for the Bison Burger, a full half pound patty, served with simple burger trimmings, not embellished with some weird concoction of sauces. This one comes with cheese, which I almost had them to hold. The cheese turned out to be mild and didn't distract from the 5-star, perfectly cooked as ordered, med-rare ground bison. Excellent! The restaurant is well staffed. Josh was the friendly attentive server we had. The restaurant has only been open a week. So, I figure the kitchen staff is still learning the ropes and Management is still tweaking recipes and accepting feedback. My only suggestion would be to find milder pickles for the Bison Burger. These were a little overpowering for the mild flavored Bison meat. Next time I will just remove them, unless they come up with a better version. My wife suggested that the steak fries could have been left in the fryer for another couple of minutes. I am going to give the restaurant a month or so the settle in, and then the real test: a Bison Ribeye steak. I am looking forward to it! read more

See all

it seems to be the basic setup for a restaurant walk in greeted bar area in the middle booth and tables surrounding it ... so it didn't really pop out in style. The service was good and the food was excellent. They offer a Bison Burger which you don't see on a lot of places so that makes it a drawing point. read more

See all

Great food. Great flavor! This place is worth trying out. The chicken tenders and gator bites are off the charts. Steaks are fantastic!

Probably the best under the radar restaurants in the B.A. or Tulsa areas. Steaks are always perfectly prepared and the sides are outstanding. read more

07-02-2024 1:30 PM had their Smokehouse Burger [medium] and it is huge, was delicious [and messy - need napkins] with tabouli for lunch. I cut the half-pound burger in half to handle better. [yeah, right!] read more

Bison Steakhouse - Smokehouse Burger - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

We have only eaten here 3 times. Service is good if they aren't busy. Food has always been good and large portions. Atmosphere is slightly better than the previous restaurants in this location. Try it! read more

Nice, clean restaurant with HUGE portion sizes. Everything was very yummy and the service was very good.