We went back after 3+ years to try it again and we can say it was awesome and our server Allie made it even better. She redeemed our negative experience and we will be back!! She was great and the food was excellent!! read more

We just tried 1843, and it was such a wonderful experience! Although the restaurant itself is on the smaller side, the Christmas decor was absolutely breathtaking and made the entire space feel warm, cozy, and special. The food was delicious, and the portions were huge, definitely great value for the quality and flavor. Everything we ordered was spot on!! The only drawback is honestly just how far away we live from it, but even that won't stop us from coming back. It's that good! We originally went to celebrate my husband's birthday dinner, and I was pleasantly surprised by the local, welcoming vibe. Even better, it's extremely kid friendly, which makes it a perfect spot for both special occasions and family outings. We're already looking forward to bringing our kids next time. Highly recommend this place. 10 stars all the way. We can't wait to go back! read more

1843 On Broadway - Smoked Pulled Pork Mac N Cheese - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

See all

First of all the food was excellent. The cheeseburger was cooked perfectly and the burger had a nice crust. My wife's 'piece' of catfish had a light, crispy coating and was cooked perfectly. Both dishes were accompanied by fresh cut fries which added a nice touch to the meal as was the perfectly concocted Bloody Mary. Our bartender was very friendly and for the most part, attentive. We enjoyed the ambiance of the elderly building which made us feel we were in Coweta during its younger days. Our only complaints concerned value. My wife's wine was $12 for a glass of 14 Hands blend..... outrageous. The catfish dinner consisted of one medium sized fillet and fries for $17......no slaw just tartar sauce. A return trip to 1843 is a possibility but not a priority. read more

Our waiter Steven made us feel as though we were guests in his home, offering drinks and telling us the specials and most importantly not rushing us. The food was awesome as well as the presentation, which is always important to ensure a great experience. Down home feel at its best. This is a must if you're checking the boxes, they check all five stars. read more

My friends and I went on a Saturday after a wedding and they still had a brunch menu going till 2 PM. I was very excited because the regular menu though it looked OK nothing was calling me and breakfast just sounded great. I was able to get the lemon blueberry pancakes and let me tell you they were packed full of blueberries with a wonderful lemon sauce on top And they were just perfect. My friend enjoyed her coconut shrimp and the dipping sauce it came with was a mango ketchup. My other friend had their burger and said it was a very good burger and it was quite large so she took leftovers home. The waitress was very on top of refilling. Our drinks was nice and answered any questions we had. It was very clean and had a nice interior. read more

See all

Great food & service in a very pleasant setting a must stop when you are in Coweta. I had the hamburger which was great. My wife had the coconut shrimp which was better than a well known seafood restaurant in OKC. The mashed potatoes and green beans were fresh made and delicious . read more

Everything! Service, food, wait time...all was good! We have nothing but good things to say about this restaurant in Coweta! read more

See all

BEWARE!!! Food was great again and my server was amazing as well. Ambiance was relaxed. However, unless they change their practice of upcharging you without telling you that they were going to, i will not go back. I got a steak here and asked for double mashed potatoes instead of one side of mashed potatoes and one side of chefs vegetables. They said no problem and then when i got the check i noticed that they had added a $2 substitution charge. I asked the waitress if there is anything they dont charge the upcharge for and they said no and that ANY substitution results in a $2 charge.... This is insane and it is exactly why i wrote this extra review to warn others. read more

1843 On Broadway - Sirloin with their home made mashed potatoes (i only had one side on here but it comes with two!) - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

This was the burger special and the fries that came with it . Very disappointed hopefully they do better next time cause I really enjoyed the burger read more

1843 On Broadway - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

See all

We always have an amazing time when we come here. Never had a bad service. We came here on Valentine's. Always great specials. My halibut with lump crab and hollandaise sauce with Parmesan cream risotto and roasted root veggies was wonderful. This place is adorable and deserves recognition. Sweetest servers. read more

See all

So this is my second time I have had 1843 for their burger special and the first time I did I was disappointed at how little fries they give you . So I chalked it up as a bad night Or off night . Fast forward to Today and they give me the same maybe less my 7 year old son can eat more fries than what I was giving . Very disappointed. I will say the burger was very good 6 out of 10 . read more

Great food and service. Very nice atmosphere and the drinks are amazing. If your in the area worth a try

The Cajun Ribeye was outstanding. The Cajun seasoning and tenderness make this steak simply deluxe! I'll have to have go get another one again. Great service and Atmosphere to! George Dakil ABOC Precision Optical read more

In my opinion, Taco Tuesdays have become mediocre at best. It's rare that they offer steak tacos anymore. Things picked up a notch two weeks ago when they offered a very tasty teriyaki taco but even though they showed it in today's FB post, they didn't have any. Our server Kailee is always a pleasure. It seems a cloud of complacency has settled in within the ranks of upper management read more

Disgusting! The iced tea tasted bitter and foul, the nachos had off queso, the chicken fried steak had the worst gravy made of just water, flour and jalapeños it ruined the steak, and to top it off the kids chicken tenders marinade must have been rancid for days. We sent back the nachos and our entrees barely eaten but paid full price but what would we expect from a restaurant that's serving rancid food and tea to save on food costs? I did like their Halloween decorations but if they don't improve they won't need them again. read more

Normally the service is good, but tonight we waited over 30 minutes for our food. Our waitress was very apologetic and explained that they had a big party going on upstairs. She told the manager who did come by our table with an apology--but we felt that some kind of compensation should have been made. Even a small discount or the offer of a free dessert would have been nice. Also We would have appreciated getting a heads up that service in the dining room would be delayed so we could have gone elsewhere. We will go again as the food is very good and servers very nice and accommodating. read more

Ordered the smoke meatloaf because friends who have been here said not to get the steak for the price. Meatloaf was luke warm. One slice was warm, one was cold. How does that even happen. I assume the meatloaf is pre made, frozen and then just warmed to temp then the plate was left there while the rest of the party's food was cooked. First time here. Won't be back. Salad and cocktail was decent. read more

1843 On Broadway - Smoke meatloaf - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

Porter Peach Pork Chops on special tonight. Still the best place in town... no, the whole area! read more

See all

Tried this place for the first time today. The food was alright. We would come back, but the grown woman who brought our deserts out practically threw our plates at our table and we didnt enjoy that one bit. Every restaurant has an off day. Every server and every bartender has them, too. But like, take five deep breaths back in the walk-in cooler. Step out for a smoke, or whatever keeps you from being a menace. Lord have mercy. read more

The service was awesome...the food was amazing and the price was great!! I would highly recommend 1843 on Broadway!!! read more

See all

Went there for my birthday in February. I know kind of late review but I loved it! The drinks were good but not great only because the bartender was new, they need to train her to make quality craft drinks if she's going to be working here. So I just ordered beer and shots to make her life easier. Anyway, the steak was amazing. All their food has always been great here. The server was cool --she was kind of young but handled our 7 person group pretty well. Def would recommend. The atmosphere is really nice inside and they have a great menu, read more

I'll start with I will certainly be back to try this place again. We were just in the area and decided we wanted to stop for a late lunch without having to drive back to Tulsa. We were given brunch menus. (It was Saturday around 1:30.) We really didn't want breakfast again (and their brunch menu is all breakfast related). Most everyone that came in soon after us got both the brunch and the regular menu. We should have asked. Anywhoo, we ordered the 1843 Hash to split. They plated it in two separate bowls and added a perfectly poached egg to each. The has was great but both servings were setting in a pretty hefty pool of grease. That didn't keep us from eating it all BUT it was a lot of grease. I would have loved to have seen the regular menu for an appetizer. Cool spot in downtown Coweta. Like I said, I would try it again. read more

1843 On Broadway - Half portion of 1843 Hash. - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

BY GEORGE Don't delay Get yourself a STEAK. Yes sir you won't be disappointed. Great steaks exist rit here by Jimmity. read more

My wife and I invited friends to lunch at 1843. It was convenient and it is a nice restaurant, that we thought they might enjoy. It had been over a year since we had dined there. Chicken Tequila Pasta (Today's Special), Smoked Cheddar Burger, RWB Salad, and Blacken Salmon, was our order. I said that I would try a burger on the next visit. It didn't happen, instead, I had the Blackened Salmon. It was a large fresh fillet of Norwegian salmon with house spice rub, flawlessly grilled to a crusty finish. A honey siracha drizzle decorated the plate and glazed the salmon filet. The tangy, sweet and spiciness complemented the mild flavored salmon and the pepper corns in the rub. The garlic mash potatoes were perfect. A pleasing trace of garlic could be tasted, but it was not overpowering. The asparagus was fresh, tender and steamed leaving a little snap in each bite. An excellent meal. All meals were enjoyed. The plates were empty when we departed. The receipt said Abigail was our server. Good job, Thank You! I was going to tell the chef what a great job he did on the mashed potatoes, but I was afraid he would figure out that I was the guy that was bitchin' about 'em and the gravy in my first review. If he reads this, he got the message. We will try not to let so much time pass, before our next visit. read more

I'd say this is probably the best nice restaurant in Coweta. We have never had a bad meal whether it is a steak or a salad. Always great and can't find better in Coweta. read more

Service was decent. The food was the worst. The meatloaf was terrible. It was like it was blended into a loaf and it was so greasy that acid indigestion hit within 45min of a couple of bites. Literally. It was served with a gravy on top of it and then a cup of bbq sauce to dip it?? I was let down. read more

This was our first visit and we will be going back. Hands down, the best French Fries in the greater Tulsa area. Staff were very friendly and attentive. The whole visit was a pleasant surprise. read more

The atmosphere is really unique. The service was above and beyond exceptional- our waitress was great! This is my second time to eat at 1843, I've been really happy with my food both times. Definitely would go again! read more

Pretty cool ambience because of the history hanging on the walls, food is delicious and presentation great. The drinks are top notch, staff super accommodating . read more

Good selection good flavor nice ambiance but the greatest is the service!!! Chris was warm and friendly and so sweet to have roses for clients on Mother's Day. They have Sunday breakfast menu so I'm bringing my friends after church. Why stay in Broken Arrow, so busy! I'll update read more

It smelled extremely bad as soon as you walk in the door. The portion size was extremely small. The burger was burnt. The tea was ok until they brought me a refill and it looked like a cup they had poured several leftover drinks into it. The waitress panicked when she saw it but there was no apology. NEVER AGAIN WILL I GO THERE! read more

Yummy!!! I started with a small Caesar that was nice and light and tasty. Then tried the buffalo wings that were the best I've ever had and I love wings! I had a margarita to drink that relaxed me lol. And I finished with a strawberry shortcake. So delicious. The vibe is classy and cool. Will definitely come back. Oh and the owner Kevin is exceptionally sweet and accommodating. read more

1843 On Broadway - Strawberry shortcake - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

See all

The food was very good. Nice find in an unexpected place. Filet with blue cheese crust was delicious. The deserts were also very good.

Been meaning to give my hometown upscale restaurant a try for some time and dang, I've been sleeping on this place! The chicken fried chicken made me go back for seconds the following weekend. I got it with the gravy on the side, with real mashed potatoes and green beans. Worth the drive for a decent meal read more

1843 On Broadway - Chicken Fried Chicken, mashed potatoes, green beans. I had the gravy served on the side. - American Near Me - Coweta, Oklahoma

Huge portion and very good chicken fried chicken. Very friendly staff. Really enjoyed my meal!

We eat there once or twice a week.. The food is very good, wait staff is always polite and clean.. 1843 is just the kind of place Coweta needed. Lots of atm read more

The place looks very nice. It is clean. The staff is friendly. However the food is where this place fails. For example: chicken fried stake, I like gravy. How we they only serve jalapeño gravy. Can't make this up. By itself it was very bland. read more

This place was definitely unexpected in the town of Coweta. Has a good vibe with open floor and bar area. Customer service was on point as they were able to accommodate a reservation last minute; the server was absolutely sweet and attentive. I was impressed at the hand made mozzarella cheese sticks as usually people offer frozen. These were fresh and homemade. I'd say overall the food needed little more flavoring as it came off a bit bland. The Pork Belly and Mac&Cheese could've use a little more of the protein. read more

See all

Great service, great food. You won't be disappointed! It's worth the trip from Tulsa

Decided to stop in on a Saturday morning after running errands. We loved the atmosphere, and our server was great and very attentive! My husband had the chicken fried steak breakfast and loved the jalapeño gravy. I had the breakfast tacos, and they even made it a vegetarian version for me! Can't wait to come back and try their dinner menu! read more