I heard great things about the Purple Olive from some co-workers, and of course it's #7 out of 262 St Augustine restaurants on Trip Advisor, so I figured it was worth the drive from Jax to check it out. Date night!
When we arrived, the main dining room had just filled up. It would have only been a 10-15 minute wait but we opted for a table now (to get to the good stuff!). Probably should have waited: the view of the kitchen isn't very pleasing (not a 'chef's table' kind of view). So I think by that choice we lost some of the ambiance of the place. I hope the owners can improve that side of the house soon.
I do belive Deidre was our waitress (server? what's the proper term these days?) . The service was good, and maybe she was filling in on a short handed night, but there were a few lapses that I was surprised about. The prices at the Purple Olive are very reasonable, and the food tastes great, but I was expecting a high end experience from the reviews I've read. The server should know the menu, or at least have notes to answer any questions. An easy one like 'what cheeses are on the cheese plate' should not elicit an 'I'll check'.
Moving on, we had heard about their incredible crab bisque, and so had to order that. It was very good, with some nice pieces of crab, and not even a hint of a crabby/fishy taste. Nice smooth flavor throughout, with a nice pepper kick also. While we prefer a cream based crab 'bisque' (which is not technically a bisque, I know), the Purple Olive's crab bisque is the best true crab bisque we've had!
For entrees my wife ordered a Chef's Grill filet with the Brandy Peppercorn sauce, medium rare. It came out on the well done side of medium, and Deidre handled it well and quickly and we got one done medium rare. It was a great filet and didn't need the peppercorn sauce to be excellent. The sauce had nice flavors, but was more the consistency of a gravy.
I had the duck (I always get the duck where-ever I go, but it has to be compared to the wild duck I grew up on with Mom's cooking, so I have yet to find a resturant duck that is as good as wild duck). The duck was nicely roasted, a perfect medium rare, with a good crust on the skin (and it had a nice layer of fat, so the meat was moist and tender) . The port wine mushroom sauce was rich and smooth and wonderful. Overall it was a great duck, one of the best I've had (outside Mom's kitchen of course)
I can't remember the name of the dessert we had, but it was something chocolate with a crushed nut crust, and was very good. I don't think you could go wrong with any of their locally made desserts.
So overall I give it 4 stars: really good food, at really great prices, but not into the Great category overall. No twists or interesting combinations. They cook traditional food very well. If we are in St Augustine again, we would probably eat there if we didn't have another new place picked out to try, but I don't think we'll be driving an hour from Jax just to eat there again. If you are in St Augustine, give the Purple Olive a try, and I know you won't be disappointed. read more