My boyfriend and I were excited to try Oberlin. Here are our thoughts:
Service: Pretty good. Our server was friendly, attentive, and very knowledgeable. They were able to make some excellent suggestions and made sure to check on us periodically. There was one dish we got that both of us didn't like at all - and it's a dish we're both familiar with (Cacio e Pepe) and this one just wasn't...right. We each took a bite and left it. For $20, I would have appreciated the server asking what about the dish wasn't to our liking but instead whisked it away from the table (and not off the bill).
Ambiance: Lovely. Other reviews we'd read said that the volume in the restaurant (specifically the music) was too loud. We didn't find this to be the case at all.
Food: Over all, enjoyable - and we'll come back but try other items instead. We started with the raw black bass - AMAZING. Next, the raw scallops. A little heavy on the mayo, but otherwise we enjoyed it very much. After that, the Lamb Tartar with warm bread. Lovely...though my boyfriend enjoyed it more. Then, the Japanese Sweet Potatoes - I loved this! Be careful - the spiciness creeps up on you! But nicely sweet to balance it out. Then - the Cacio e Pepe... this, we did not enjoy at all. We're both familiar with Cacio e Pepe, my boyfriend more so as he's also enjoyed it while in Italy and it's literally his all-time favorite meal. The homemade pasta just fell apart as we each tried to eat our first bite, as if it was over cooked. While, yes, Pepe means pepper - this version of the dish had so much pepper that we could not enjoy it (and my boyfriend LOVES pepper!!). I couldn't get the front of my tongue to stop burning, and that was just after 1 bite. I also didn't feel like the sauce quite came together...it was watery, not silky. This is the dish that we didn't eat beyond each of our first bites. It was simply not enjoyable, especially with the over-doneness of the thick pasta. An off night perhaps?? Who knows. Lastly, we got the cheesecake... this was not a style of cheesecake we're used to and it was enjoyable enough, though the olive oil seemed unnecessary. My boyfriend asked me if I loved it (cheesecake is my favorite) and I said "I'm...enjoying it..." but not enough to finish it, and that's a first for me and cheesecake lol. It was...ok enough, but I wouldn't order it again. The top is supposed to be a warm colored brown...caramelized beautifully... (and we'd seen a picture of this very cheesecake from Oberlin that had been posted online), but this was so dark/burnt that it had become quite bitter.
Beverages: For the lovely selection of tastes, I do wish that they offered more for libations. I'm a pickier drinker, so I stuck with the citrus cordial and, quite honestly, LOVED IT, but I think it could have been a stunner with some vodka added. (I could have asked I suppose, but nothing else on the drink menu implied that they even had vodka, so I didn't ask - my fault, I guess). My boyfriend enjoyed his Negroni fine enough. We're not wine people - so some truly interesting beverage concoctions really seemed like they'd be fitting here, but were not.
Will we come back? Yes. We look forward to trying the entire Raw selection plate as well as the full seabass that we saw another table get - it looked wonderful. read more