We met friends here on a Sunday at 12:30 with a party of 8, and overall it was a mixed experience. The host greeted us quickly and had tables pulled together in the back without much of a wait, which we appreciated. Our server was attentive at the start--she took drink orders as each portion of our group arrived and kept things moving smoothly. As we got closer to closing time (2:00 PM), service shifted a bit. About 15 minutes before closing, as we were wrapping up, our server stopped checking in. This was our first visit, though friends in our group had been once before and described it as "just okay," which felt accurate to us as well. We always like supporting local spots, and this was an easy meeting location, so we were hopeful. It's also worth noting they currently hold a strong 4.5 rating, and it seems like many locals really enjoy this place. That said, the biggest drawback for us was the portion size compared to the pricing. One person in our group ordered a Reuben, and the meat didn't even cover the bottom slice of bread--with not enough to redistribute. The fries portion was very small (more like a kids' serving), and the plate was around $13. That seemed to be the general theme--nothing tasted bad, but nothing stood out, and portions felt light across the board. Atmosphere-wise, it's what you'd expect from a diner--casual, relaxed, and easygoing. We'd consider going back for convenience, but it's not a place we'd go out of our way for. With a few adjustments--especially around portion sizes--this could easily match the reputation it already seems to have with locals. read more

Shoutout to our local community heroes like Mallory and crew. The venue is like the best feeling of a hometown diner! The atmosphere is just the perfect smell of eggs and bacon, the familiar sounds of coffee brewing and staff hustling, and the warmth of the staff knowing their regulars by name and remembering their orders. Mallory has made every trip to this venue feel like we have known each other forever. She is attentive, personable, and kindhearted. She will make sure that your order is to your liking and if not she is quick to make it right. The staff pretty much moves like a well oiled machine. All the staff that I have met have been so hospitable. The patrons are happy to have good food, good atmosphere, and great service! Taste the Love! My favorite breakfast: over easy eggs, white toast, extra crispy bacon, and extra crispy potatoes. Yummm! Me and two buddies Bob the coin man and John meet up at the same bat time and same bat channel!! Love it!!! It's like Happy Days meets the Breakfast Club!!! I'm hooked!! read more

See all

I visited here at noon on a Sunday. My party (a group of 8) was quickly greeted and brought to a table. The server was great, not too overbearing but not too avoidant. The place had a relaxed, friendly vibe that didn't make you feel like a bother when asking for something. I even overheard a server go up to the kitchen to make sure that they put the potatoes on the side instead of in somebody's food. Unfortunately for us the food is where we felt the diner fell short. My family got the Strawberry Waffles (no whipped cream), the Breakfast Bowl (add sausage gravy), the Kids Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup, and the Reuben with fries. The good- The fries and homestyle potatoes (in the breakfast bowl) were perfectly crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The tomato soup had a really good flavor. The waffle was perfectly cooked and the strawberries were ripe. The not so good- The prices simply didn't match the amount of food we received. The Reuben didn't have enough meet to even cover the bread. The grilled cheese had the same problem, it had barely any cheese on it. The breakfast bowl was about the same size as a bowl of cereal. We all left satisfied but unfortunately not full. Tldr: Great Service, Good Tasting Food, Okay Portions. read more

See all

Love this place the biscuits and gravy are absolutely delicious. Great service friendly staff neat place and usually a short wait. We go after church and there fast and the food and service is great. The breakfast is to die for. My favorite breakfast place. read more

Hits everytime. They crisped the hashbrowns and bacon perfectly, buttered and charred the biscuit, and kept our coffees full. Diner food may be simple, but when there is sincere intention and thought put into food, it goes a long way. So long in fact, that I had to write a review on it. The service was also quick, and friendly. The booths were comfortable, and we thoroughly enjoyed our meal. We will be back soon. read more

Have been here several times love the eggs Benedict always perfect. Have always just had breakfast eggs and home fries are great.

Went in around 10 am on a Saturday morning. Seated and had drinks right away. I had the gravy and biscuits with a side of grits. Food was so delicious and fresh. The biscuits were so tasty and buttery. Can't wait to come back read more

Food was Great, Service was Excellent, Ambiance was Laid Back Nice Vibes! Omelets The Best had a Greek Omelet and a Cheese Steak Omelet

The place was dirty and I don't know why nobody else said that Anyway I had a waffle I should have stayed home and eat a frozen waffle it would have been better This place is a dump And the staff is like a bad tv show 10 thumbs down ps the food doesn't look like the picture unless you are blind read more

Stopped in for breakfast while visiting. Large space inside, we were seated immediately. Started with some coffee while we looked over the menu. I went with the fried fish breakfast and added an egg. The fish for the day was mahi. The portion was large. I didn't finish my food. Everything was good though and service was great. read more

See all

Western omelette and hash browns were great along with hot coffee. Services was very nice and prompt always hot coffee in my cup. I'll be back. read more

It was ok but skimpy servings. Waitresses seem to cater to tables and locals. If you aren't a local I wouldn't recommend sitting at the bar for breakfast service. My omlette was decent. Small portions of potatoes. I requested dry wheat toast and it was definitely made about an hour earlier. I requested replacement of hot toast and she gave me same exact room temperature as my first serving was and coated with butter. I was in town in visiting and plan to be back in town next month, probably won't give it a 2nd shot. There was zero prebussing even though everyone near me didn't have creamers and plates piled up like I did. read more

We decided to do a family breakfast with the kids and grandkids. I Yelped Moultrie Creek Diner. It had mixed reviews. It's close to our house so why not try it. It's 9am, good time to go have breakfast. We arrived and was greeted immediately. Even though the business had a few customers, it wasn't enough that we waited an additional 10 minutes before we were seated. Valerie was our server for today. She had a few tables. She apologized for the inconvenience. She took both our drink and food orders. As we sat talking, Valerie brought our drinks. The sweet tea had an after taste. She switched it for Sprite. The sprite tasted like it was out. It was pure carbonated water. This too has to be corrected. Our food came..... I got the biscuits and gravy with scrambled eggs on the side. Jacobie ordered the 2 eggs breakfast. 2 eggs, sausage, grits with cheese, toast & hash browns. Ayden ordered the kids Grits with cheese, sausage and scrambled eggs. Jessica ordered the Breakfast bowl...grits, bacon, sausage and eggs in a bowl. We ordered one to go for Jasmine. Hubby got a peach waffle topped with whipped cream and scrambled eggs. The food was in large portions. It was just okay. Kids ate with no issues. Even though the sausage Pattie's was way over cooked. Jessica and John had no issues with their food either. My gravy and biscuits were only warm in the center of the plate. The edges were barely lukewarm. Because there was so much I was able to eat the insides with no issues. The food is also reasonably priced. The bill for 6 people came out to $89. It was just okay. As we left, we were thanked by the staff for stopping by. I saw this with other patrons as well. Southern Hospitality was in Full Effect. I loved this part. We'll try again when we return home for our next Florida trip. read more

See all

Good food great service breakfast is good tried a lot of the menu loved everything I tried and lunch is good the hamburger is yummy and I can't forget the hot coffee read more

First time at Moultrie Creek Diner. Thanks to Yelp reviews we thought we would try them for breakfast. Glad we did. First impression- yep in a strip mall- from the outside it looks a bit small but once inside there is plenty of seating. Our waitress Eva met use at the door and seated us right away at a booth. There are lots of tables in the back - had a large group (looked like regulars that come here often) sitting at a large table. When you enter there is seating at a long counter and behind the counter a row of booths. Very welcoming staff - we got our coffee and waters quickly. Food arrived quickly. Love when your coffee cup is filled regularly. I had the ham and cheese omelette with potatoes and rye toast (2 pieces) plus added a pork sausage Patty. Wife had the Breakfast Plate eggs scrambled with potatoes and pork sausage with two large biscuits. Potatoes are crispy must give them a quick fry. Definitely plenty of food. Prepared well - served hot like it should be. So friendly staff - clean - great food and service. With a good tip bill came to $42.60. Yep gone are the days of cheap breakfast- but you get what you pay for. They are open for breakfast and lunch. Plenty of parking in front. It's a 5. Give them a try. read more

See all

One of the worst breakfast places I've been to and it was recommended by a local. We came in and were not greeted by anyone but the cooks and waiters all looked at us for about 10 minutes. It wasn't even full. We were finally seated. Menu looked okay but pricey. I got the burrito for $15 and it has zero sides. The burrito wrap was not even warmed on the grill and the insides were just sloshed in there. I can't even remember what my husband got but it was forgettable and average. 2 breakfasts, one coffee set us back over $35.00. Servers was nice but overworked I still gave her at $10 tip. read more

We went a few days ago for breakfast. Mallory did a great job taking care of us. Had the Hangover Burrito that is amazing with gravy on it. The Chicken & Biscuits with gravy were also really good. At breakfast, they serve lunch. Had the Fried Shrimp that was very good. They have large servings at very good prices. This is a great place that locals go to. read more

See all

What a true hidden gem!! You would never know this place is here and from the outside it doesn't look like much. Inside it's much larger than it appears, very clean, open, and well decorated. Lots of local artwork on the walls. Staff was friendly and attentive. Food was absolutely amazing!! Read no further- go give it a try, you won't be disappointed!! read more

Moultrie Creek Diner - Fried Shrimp, Mac n cheese, apple and cucumber salad - Diners Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

I'm on a mission to try every breakfast establishment in my new home area, and the Moultrie Creek Diner was on the list. Happily, we had a wonderful dining experience and will definitely be back. My daughter ordered the chicken and waffles while I opted for old reliable, ham and eggs, dressed up with a side of grits and rye toast. And coffee. Lots of coffee. Everything was delicious! The ham was not sliced from the supermarket deli and full of flavor. Eggs were fluffy and well scrambled. Rye toast crunchy and tasty. Grits were awesome. I am so sorry I missed out on grits for most of my life, but plan to make up for that in the future. Waffles were good, fried chicken juicy and delicious. Coffee flowed faster than we could drink it, and was hot and tasty. Strong, like diner coffee should be. It's not all about lattes and Monin syrup shots, you know. Sometimes you just want a good cup of joe, and the diner is where I rely for that experience. They did not disappoint. Prices were reasonable, and service was phenomenal! Lori was so friendly and accommodating as though we'd been coming there for years. The menu has some interesting choices including pork roll, and they make their own shrimp salad. We'll be back to try out some more items! read more

See all

This diner is a hidden gem in Saint Augustine. The breakfasts are cooked to perfection. The fried shrimp is outstanding. My favorite is the veggie plate with homemade pickled beats, collards, Mac and cheese, and homemade cucumber and apple salad. Very refreshing. All other breakfast places in the area don't compare to the Moultrie Creek Diner breakfast. A must do. read more

First time.. pleasant diner... staff was very welcoming, had a very good omelette and grits. Nice customers at the eating bar area. Will be back 4 sure. read more

Great Florentine eggs Benedict, great service. Clean, non assuming environment. Will be back!

I use to love this place. food is ok except for the potatoes being undercooked. The service was not great, waitress never checked up on us, was waiting for my coffee to get topped off way too long had to flag down the waitress that wasn't serving us, ours was busy setting tables and putting silverware out , I would understand if the place was crowded but it wasn't . Just disappointed the service use to be great!!! read more

Best shrimp in St Aigustine. Eat there at least once a week servers are very good and it. They also have excellent breakfast.Pat L

We have been here several times now, but only for breakfast and have enjoyed our food each time. The sausage is house made and the biscuits are yummy, I have missed the corned beef hash every time , but it is on my list to try! Great local breakfast place. read more

We had an excellent breakfast and lunch here this morning. Mallory recommended the fried chicken sandwich and it was delicious. The bacon the bacon and egg dish was very tasty. We had such nice hospitality from Mallory and the food was hot and very good. I would recommend this place Hundred percent. Thanks for a great start of our day. read more

I'm so picky with eggs Benedict. They nailed it. They make creamed spinach fresh on grill. I added bacon which was beyond perfect. Now yes I did as for poached over hard and got runny eggs but I'm used to that happening so I just ordered scramble eggs. A 1st diner to make creamed spinach over poached eggs with hollandaise sauce read more

Moultrie Creek Diner - Best eggs Florentin - Diners Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Great fresh food. Was very good and we will be back. Kick ass good shrimp and chicken.

If you are looking for some good old fashioned diner food, this place has got you covered. With great food, great service, and great prices, you'll be back again and again. It may seem basic, but I am a girl who loves eggs, bacon, toast and potatoes for breakfast. As simple as this order is, many people get it wrong. Eggs cooked wrong, bacon not crispy or too crispy, potatoes soggy or underdone. Toast stale or covered in fake butter. That is why I was pleased when the entire meal was perfect. Their potatoes are the best part--super crisp on the outside and fluffy on the inside. My mom loves to get the eggs Benedict with the biscuits. So good! They also have mimosas if you're feeling like really having a good brunch! Our waitress was super attentive and nice! I hope to see her again soon! This place is just all around great. I'll be coming here more often! read more

Moultrie Creek Diner - Diners Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

We have been here a few times before. For the most part it is a typical diner. The food is good, but until today nothing really stood out to me. This morning I got the Greek omelet. It is by far the beat Greek omelet I have ever eaten. Besides being filled with Gyro meat, onions, tomatoes and feta cheese they put tzaki sauce on top, which absolutely made it for me!!! It was so delicious!!! I will definitely be back and fingers crossed it will still be a special! read more

Always stop here for breakfast when in town. Food is served hot and is down home country cooking. Popular with locals. Grits are the best!!! read more

The food was great and our waitress- Mallory was courteous and did a awesome job! It's nice to see these local restaurants that offer great food and service. I would highly recommend this place to anyone and we will definitely be back!! read more

Great little diner for breakfast or a quick lunch. Would recommend to anyone in the area!

Decided to try out this place while in town visiting friends on our way home. Not many restaurants in this area. Maybe the reason they seem to NOT care. Food was well priced. However quality was not up to par. I had the waffle and chicken sausage. Waffle was super dry and completely tasteless. Chicken sausage was man made and loaded with so many spices it couldn't be eaten. My husband loves spicy food and he wouldn't even eat it. Service was good. read more

I live in St. Augustine and still searching for my regular breakfast spot. Well, I found it!! My breakfast was exactly how I wanted it. The server was so friendly. I will definitely return. So, I returned the next day. My husband had the fried shrimp. He thought it was the best he ever had and he's from South Georgia. My fish Sammy was delicious and the mac and cheese was outstanding! This is our go-to breakfast and lunch place for sure. read more

Over easy eggs were "ok" the first time I went but potato's really dry. Had a BLT the second time & the bacon was not freshly made & crumbled really easily, nor was there any Mayo n the bread - had to ask for it. Third time I ordered a grilled cheese & when served it looked like someone stepped on the sandwich & it was soooo greasy! read more

The service was outstanding!! Alissa the waitress is without a doubt the best waitress I've ever experienced 10/10 would recommend & 10/10 would go again read more

Strip mall resteraunt with average made to order food. Prices are a bit high. Good parking

Stopped by on our way back to Tampa from St Augustine. A little gem tucked away in a strip mall. Such friendly staff. The place was immaculate. A smaller breakfast menu, but not disappointing. The waffle with peach compote was delicious. My husband had the Southern Benedict. He said it was very good. Service was great. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

I enjoyed my visit to Moultrie Creek Diner. I had a server, (Alexis?) who was above and beyond professional and courteous, not "rush-rushing" me at all. She had beautiful long ginger hair and her head was shaved close on one side. She was absolutely gorgeous, which always makes for a an exceptional morning meal. Amazing service and eggs were poached perfect. Alexis was definitely helpful with menu suggestions. The way the breakfast sausage is stamped out is truly flavorful. I'll be back for sure. I really wanted to try your Belgian waffle and also omelettes. Nest time. As I left, an older attractive woman in a topaz Lululemon shirt thanked me for coming in. Cool experience and great vibes all around. read more