There are a ton of things to like about La Val's Northside, making it hard for me to decide how to start off the review. I've eaten here MANY times, and I've never come upon anything on the menu that I didn't like. The great thing is that seemingly similar items actually give you vastly different impressions. My problem is that I'm always in the neighborhood, so I eat at the same places very frequently, causing me to branch out into different things on the menu that I wouldn't normally order.
For example, I would never typically get any kind of pizza without meat, but the options at La Val's are actually superb. The days when I walk in and the Slice of the Day is their Margherita (light olive oil, mozzarella, feta cheese, fresh tomato, fresh basil, garlic) definitely give me that funny feeling inside because I love that slice SO MUCH. The Athenian style is also quite good despite the lack of meat. But lately I've been fixated on the plain cheese slice. I swear they must do something different to it because I've never tasted a "plain" cheese slice that tastes so complex. It's like they sprinkle MSG or THC or something else amazing on top, I can't stop eating it. Of course the combo and other meat-tastic slices and pies are good as well.
What I like about the pizza probably comes down to the crust - you can tell they spent a while trying to get the right balance of crispy and sturdy, and I think they nailed it. For total value the "mini" pizza is the best way to go, you get a pie about twice the size of a "personal" you'd order anywhere else, they toss the dough right in front of you, and you can have whatever you want on it. Plus a free soda. I went through a phase where I had a mini mushroom salami linguica and black olive for lunch about 3 times a week. It's like 6 bucks out the door, which is pretty amazing if you ask me.
The Ceasar salad (with or without chicken) is another favorite (and you get a load of it), the Greek Salad is also good, and the fruit salad and "Tiramisu" (totally inauthentic but delicious nonetheless) are also nice treats though I'd say those two are overpriced, particularly in comparison to the rest of what I usually get for lunch (a huge-ass slice and a soda with refill for three bucks? Sign me up!). The pastas are also good for a change of pace, I like when they have the Penne with meat sauce on special (six bucks for pasta, garlic bread and soda).
Service is about what you'd expect - for the most part quick and efficient, usually friendly. But during lunch this place gets BUSY. So expect to have to wait a few extra minutes to pick up your food. They expect you to stay on top of your number and watch the electronic boards for when it comes up, they pretty much won't call the numbers out, so if you want your slice hot, you kinda have to lurk in the "lobby" area. I've had some pretty funny conversations with some of the cashiers they've got, which is nice to show some personality.
There's also a sweet beer selection, though I normally don't take advantage of this because I'm usually eating lunch. I think the beers are like 3 bucks for a pint, which is pretty damn good considering you can get a Boont Amber or a Stella for half the price you'd pay at the Mallard or wherever.
Atmosphere is cool, they usually have semi-indie rock playing on the overheads and ESPN showing on two big-screens in the dining rooms. Again, during lunch the place gets packed but if you can hold off til 1 or 2 in the afternoon you can pretty much have the run of the place. They'll even change the channel if there's something you wanna watch. For nice days there's picnic tables out in the courtyard too.
I live in Albany so I don't get delivery from here that much, but I've talked with the drivers a few times when I was hanging around playing the arcade games, and they seem pretty cool. One guy told me some funny stories that I'd never have thought would really happen about delivering pizza.
All in all I have to say this La Val's exemplifies what a 5-star Yelp review means to me. Good food, plentiful portions, good price, strong and fast service. I imagine I'll continue to eat here for a good long while. read more