I've thought a lot about what to write in this review. My household has eaten here several times, yet we just can't get to a point where we really enjoy the food. Our general consensus is that the menu is disjointed and just not that good.
Decor: For the most part the decor isn't bad. The hokey farmer's market sign needs to go and there could be some small touches to improve the experience. Paper straws, salt/pepper grinders, candles, etc. This location has an advantage of location, dining room size, and outdoor seating.
Food: I have eaten SEVERAL meals here. The ONLY one I can say is GOOD and worth doing over again is the Bacon Mac and Cheese ($16). Really. Everything else is either severely overpriced (versus slightly overpriced), odd texture, tiny portions, and/or suffers from poorly aligned flavor combinations.
From the current menu (July 2017) here are my comments...
Oven Roasted Beet Salad ($9): This was probably my biggest disappointment. I love roasted beets. They are a staple in my household. For starters, this dish is tiny. Size aside, the time that I encountered this it ended up being inedible. The horseradish goat cheese is awful. Please do not subject your mouth to this. Combined with the arugula and very acidic vinaigrette...you won't be able to taste anything after it. I actually could not even eat all of this tiny portion. The hazelnuts are whole, roasted, no seasoning or anything to add dimension. So much more could have been done with this dish all around. The actual beets (less than one entire beet) was good. I would rather have a plate of those, crumbled goat cheese, a bed of spinach, and a warm mustard vinaigrette.
Tomato Salad ($10): The pickled onions and mint are weird with this. It's like a caprese salad trying to be "fancy". We do need to talk about the price point though. Fresh, local "slicer" tomatoes are somewhere around $3 per pound. There is a very small amount of cheese, less than two tomatoes, and then some herbs...the amount of actual work that goes into this dish is minimal and the price point is high.
Stuffed Mushrooms ($10): I am a huge mushroom fan. You get 3 mushrooms. 3. That is $3.33 per mushroom. The "stuffing" is also a bit odd. Don't expect to get warm, cheesy, gooey, herby, flavorful stuffed mushrooms. The root vegetable mixture has an odd texture that does not compliment the mushrooms. These suffer from the same issue that most of the menu suffers from, which is trying to be "fancy" with a lot of big words and a lack of follow through with actually producing solid dishes.
Farm Table Trio ($12): This is a prime example of the disjointed menu. This is a FARM TO TABLE "themed" restaurant. Really. It is a theme at this place. Roasted red pepper and jalapeno hummus, quinoa tabbouleh, and olive tapenade with "pita points". The only ingredient that I could identify as farm fresh was the jalepeno. The pita is not bad. The rest could have been better. A lot better.
Other items I have eaten here were the braised short ribs (when they were served over polenta), the shrimp and grits, and a slice of cheesecake (not made in house).
As someone who actually supports local farmers and local food (which to clarify a point from another reviewer...these are not marketed as organic offerings) this restaurant has a lot of room for improvement. As a consumer you aren't able to know exactly what items are coming from a local farmer or from a non-local source. I want to look at the (very limited) menu and know who provided the vegetables on my plate, where the steak came from, etc. I did note that the updated menu makes a point to note the listed farmers are "past and present". Out of the most recently displayed list of farmers I know (and have worked with) 3 of them and do enjoy independently purchasing their produce. The wonky part about the current menu is that the seasonal offerings are limited and not celebrated: no melons, corn, peaches, etc.
With a cohesive menu that highlights seasonal, local products that is executed well this place could be packed on a regular basis. A few suggestions they may want to consider is doing "Sunday Supper", offering Southern classics, pulling back on trying to be "fancy" and focusing on genuine, simplistic dishes where the produce is able to really shine. I would love to see some options such as an entree portioned summer salad, grilled vegetable kabobs, flatbread with roasted garlic, tomatoes, basil, balsamic reduction, from scratch biscuits, hoe cakes with pimento cheese, etc. Simple pasta dishes with house made sauces, fresh mushrooms and other seasonal vegetables could be lovely. Toss in a side of locally crafted bread, you easily have a $15 pasta entree offering...add grilled meat for an additional charge. read more