I'd give this a 4.5 -- not a full 5 but more than a 4!
After hearing about Etto from a friend who lives in San Francisco (who had read about it on a food blog), I figured we'd have to go eventually. Luckily the beautiful weather this weekend tempted us to venture to Logan Circle -- we arrived around 6:45 and were told the wait for a table for 2 would be about 35/45 minutes. We decided to wait with a drink at the bar, which was really enjoyable. It was nice to actually take our time and have a long meal - made it seem more like an experience rather than just a meal! We stood by the bar and watched the bartender and the cooks at work, which was great! We got to pick out what we wanted to order by what looked good when it was being made. The bartender was very personable and it was nice seeing the different drinks she was making also. We could have sat at the bar and eaten there - in the time we waited, different sets of seats for 2 opened up 3 times. We didn't have a problem waiting though and we kind of wanted the full experience of sitting at the table.
The drinks were good - my boyfriend got wine, which was a pretty small pour for $12, but he said it was good wine. I got a cocktail for $11, which was a little bitter for my tastes but it was definitely strong. Once we were seated, we ordered a 1/2 liter of the wine on tap, which was best after sitting for a bit. Wine was definitely the way to go though as it was a perfect complement to the pizza. We got the eggplant parmesan and lamb sausage and lentils to start -- the eggplant parmesan was definitely a good choice. The eggplant was cooked perfectly and covered in cheese and a great tomato sauce. The fresh bread on the side was amazing on its own but even better covered in that tomato sauce. We made sure to clean the plate! The lamb sausage and lentils was also very good, especially if you like lentils. Both were flavored well -- it just seemed like a strange addition to the meal. It was very good though.
For our main entree, we split a margherita pizza. The crust was great - thin with a perfect amount of char. We didn't have any pieces that were burnt, as others have said - just some typical charred spots like you would expect from Neapolitan pizza. There were large spots of the pizza without cheese, but that's usually how margherita pizza is. Luckily those spots were still covered in really tasty marinara sauce. I normally don't like the cheese-less spots, but I liked them just as much as the rest on this pizza due to the thin crust and great sauce. The cheese spots are still the best though :) The fresh basil on top was a nice touch as well. Although $17 is expensive for a pizza, I thought the serving was actually pretty big, and we were full with just $47 of food. Our alcohol actually cost almost as much. We also got the chocolate salami for dessert -- it was cute in that they wrapped up the chocolate fudge in thread like it was real salami. It also had nuts throughout. Although it was tasty - I don't think I'd order it again. if you like nuts and chocolate though, you'll probably like it.
The service was great - from the hostess to the manager (who might've also been the owner?) Our waitress was very perky (best word I could think of - she was unusually happy) and gave good recommendations. She and the rest of the staff (including the manager) did a great job keeping our water refilled and taking away plates. They also replaced napkins and utensils after each course, which was a very nice touch. Overall, we had a great experience at Etto. I think it can be pricey depending on what you get, but it doesn't have to be. The food is great and the atmosphere is charming. read more