This is my fave pizza place in st Augustine. I don't get to go very often, but if anyone asks me where to get a slice here that's my recommendation. The sauce is perfectionz read more

Delicious pizza delivered to our hotel quick and hot! The toppings are generous Highly recommend read more

I've eaten pizza all over the country and this is by far my favorite. meats are not greasy, crust is cooked perfect and the prices aren't too bad for the excellent product you are getting read more

Carmelo's - Carmelos special less the peppers - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Yeah, never again. Had high hopes from the reviews but obviously these standards are pretty low. Took about 45 minutes to get one pizza, then we watched it sit on the counter for a good while people built pizza boxes. We approached to get it ourself and was told they'd bring it to us.. which they did eventually after more waiting and watching. Eventually the girl with pink hair finally brings it. When we asked for plates we were explicitly told " I only have two hands" with a lot of sass. Well no shit. Maybe bring plates before hand so we don't inconvenience your ever so important box building. But what can you expect from a gas station pizza place run by children. Had we known before hand that the pizza comes with being disrespected we would've passed. Only reason we didn't address this with a manager when we were in is because watching how everyone was working, slow, unmotivated, and low energy is telling of how management runs a the business. Hope yall invest in the kids and truly teach them hospitality. This wasn't it. read more

The best Italian pizza around. They serve other things but really, if you're looking for a good pizza like what you can get up north, this is the closest. Being inside isn't much to look at but just get the pizza to go if the ambiance isn't up to your standards. read more

7/10 - 8:40pm - party of 2 As soon as we arrived in St Augustine, we headed to Carmelo's! I am elated that it is exactly as delicious as it has always been! We shared the beer garlic knots on the planet. So soft with loads of fresh garlic and pesto. Pure perfection! I had a slice of their specialty pizza and my son had one of gigantic Stromboli's. He let me have a smile bite lol. Service was wonderful as it always is, the beer was cold, and we watched the Res Sox whip the Yankees so all in all, it was a perfect night. I had the Ancient City Matanzas Red Ale. This is from a local brewery specializing in ales. We went to their brewery and bought 5 packs for the trip home. Check them out! read more

Carmelo's - Ancient City Matanzas Red Ale. Warning: 24 oz mug is harder to balance as it gets empty. I bet this mug weighed 20+ ounces before the beer. - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Wife and I were on vacation for a week recently in St Augustine. Ended up eating at Carmelo's twice that week. First time I had a chef salad and wife had a calzone. Both were awesome. Second time we had their veggie pizza which was also one of the best pizza's I've ever had. read more

Found this by accident but a great surprise for a quick lunch. Pizza was delicious and meatball with sauce fantastic. The customer service not so great as when I asked for a fork the girl pointed at the dispenser with the forks and said nothing. The dispenser was dusty. Cussing from someone in the kitchen (f bomb) not sure if he is a manager or owner. Food 10, atmosphere a zero. read more

See all

Carmelo's is incredible. New York style pizza great price point nice people that work there most of them are students from the college. I've never had a bad slice.. read more

Looking for a real good pie in the Saint Augustine area...? This is a great place call. Carmelo's makes a great and consistent pie every time I order. Love the cheese to sauce ratio...slightly tangy and definitely not greasy. read more

Very good pizza but beware if ordering online because a $25 pizza turned into $41.00. They charge a $2.99 service fee, $3.99 delivery fee and then door dash automatically adds a $7.00 tip read more

I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE!! Okay let me start off by saying, every single time I've went in here my food has been hot and ready like a little Caesar's promotional ad, the service their is top tier I get there wait about 20 minutes max and have everything I ordered come out perfectly. And the ambiance is just amazing. This is one of my most favorite pizza places out of everyone in Saint Augustine!! read more

Great little pizza place. The food is amazing and the prices are excellent for what you get. Friendly staff. Don't judge this place by the outside looks. It's worth the visit. read more

Food is great. Cauliflower crust pizza! Service order was ready when we went in. Ambiance looks nice to eat in I have only done take away. read more

Those sliced meatballs . Ordered the Carmelo's supreme 20" and a side Greek salad. All was phenomenal. Got a slice of caramel cheesecake as well, but haven't torn into that yet. My new favorite pizza (I will not disclose who you de-throned) read more

Food is amazing, love their pepperoni pizza for kids and their coconut cake is great .too bad they don't offer it on their Yelp menu

The service was fantastic - the staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, offering great recommendations. We started with the Appetizer,which was bursting with flavor, and the as a main course, which was simply outstanding. The pasta was fresh, perfectly cooked, and paired with a rich, flavorful sauce that was just the right balance of savory and tangy. read more

Cassie Was the greatest! Pizza was robust. Lots of toppings. Crust was thin and crunchy! Fabulous experience. St Augustine Best Pizza! If you're visiting this is a must have! Thank you! TCastagnoli! We will be back! read more

When I say amazing... I mean amazing it the my most favorite pizza I ever had. We live in central Florida and I can tell you I will definitely be back. I try pizza everywhere and this if 100% the best in st Augustine read more

Carmelo's - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

One recommendation - order at the counter. Last time we ate in - first time there it was awesome. This time ordered online - cook a LITTLE lighter became give me a RAW pizza, extra cheese became gross amount of cheese and not cooked - so really ew. One look and no one who is experienced would consider that a pizza you would hand someone who said a little lighter (based on how dark their slices are cooked) we will try again next visit. read more

The best eggplant parmesan ever! Wish they didn't put it on top of spaghetti. Would be better to put the spaghetti on the side so one could really appreciate the wonderful creamy eggplant. Too bad we don't live closer or we would be here daily! Also the eggplant parmesan meal is enough for 3 people. Otherwise plan on taking 1/2 home. read more

I ordered lasagna and the peanut butter pie. Both were outstanding! Delicious, generous portions and reasonably priced. I'll return when I'm back in Saint Augustine for sure. Cheers to the chef and friendly staff! read more

Carmelo's - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great NY style foldable pizza! Small cozy venue. Good prices and very good pizza! Service is friendly and very efficient.

Service was great, food was better. Great hidden gem! Recommend for everyone!!!!!!!!!! read more

See all

One of our favorite places to eat. We had guests from out of town that were in the mood for pizza. We got the antipasto salad, the large pizza with half pepperoni and half mushroom well done and the garlic knots. Everything was excellent! The service is always great here! We didn't save any room for dessert. I highly recommend this awesome pizza place. read more

See all

We went for the first time, cute place, service great the server was helpful with our picks. The pizza is delicious, if you like spice the Datil sauce on the wings are sweet and the spice is great!! Garlic knots are really good not to much garlic which was perfect for us. Loved the place and definitely will be back. read more

The Woman who answered the phone was very rude and unprofessional. My family and I have been ordering and coming here for decades! I called asking about hours and got told "nope, merry Christmas. Bye." And was hung up on. Sad to think they would let someone like her represent their restaurant :( read more

Food was good. Slow service as only 1 waitress but she did well. Always cold in this place/no matter the time of year.

Let the adventure begin.......We drove out to St. Augustine on a beautiful Saturday afternoon after being told a few weeks ago from a genuinely nice couple who sat next to us at Jax Fish Fry that Carmelo's has some of the best dishes and great pizza. We took their advice. Wow...they were right! I just wish I got her name so I can express my thanks! :). We are always up for what's really good near or far especially after a long week of many early Monday morning flights (husband) and working at home (me). This cute restaurant is tucked in a corner next to a gas station and not far from Georgie's Diner. I will say St. Augustine is always beautiful and stays busy with tourists especially on a nice spring day. We came at the right time at 4:00 as seating was tight and got lucky with the table booth as that was the only one available. I always say it's a very good sign when the house is full! :) The ingredients/homestyle sauce to the meat lover's supreme pizza and baked ziti were beyond excellent.... This is the "D' Best" pizza I have ever had! I will honestly say I am not even a big fan of pizza/ziti or spaghetti as I got older because I haven't found a place I really truly like. Lol. I believe we found it...yes! Far drive to pick up and go back home on Racetrack Rd traveling on US1. It was a 25 minute drive. I will definitely add this nice establishment to my "favorite places" drawer list when pizza and Italian dishes comes to mind and just dine in. We started out with the fried mushrooms as an appetizer; very good! Homemade ranch to go along with it, just right-not strange or salty at all. Baked ziti came out next and the best sauce I have ever had. Pizza came last, nice, gooey cheese and warm. Ohhh it was L-O-V-E for me! The crust wasn't too thick or too thin. I was already overwhelmed and full after sampling the fried mushrooms and baked ziti. Lol. We packed it all up to eat the next day. Still good too! Highly recommend! Great menu. Lovely experience. Left full but happy. Will definitely be back to try other Italian dishes and to make room for tiramisu or carrot cake as we were definitely too full to even consider a slice "to go". read more

See all

It was good really good but we ordered two pizzas and some cheese bread and mozzarella sticks and when we ate the mozzarella sticks there was no cheese in the middle read more

While in St.Augustine my father in law turned us on to this place and I'm a huge fan of great pizza. Now you may pass by this place if you weren't looking for it. Connected to a gas station, the inside is quite large with out door seating available. Now, pizza is their main thing but the menu is pretty large, a lot of bar food. However I came for the pizza. They have a great deal of 2 slices and a drink for 6 dollars, which you can't beat. I got the pepperoni and a Sicilian slice. The pepperoni was fantastic, great cheese, pepperoni was fresh, small crunch but not over cooked. Not a lot of grease, and the crust was the best part, not doughy, good crunch, great balance of crunch and dough. The Sicilian was fantastic too, good flavor, cheese was perfect. Overall, a great place to stop by and get really good pizza. read more

Carmelo's - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

This is a family favorite pizza location in the heart of St Augustine. They are very small, but so worth it if there is ever a wait! The staff is always phenomenal and the food is amazing. We always find time to stop here when we are in the area! read more

Carmelo's - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This place is a bit away from the busy St. Augustine downtown/Castillo De San Marcos area. It's a 10- minute walk and about 0.5 miles from the crowd. It's a great NY-styled pizza place. They sell pizzas by the slice and are huge too! Their salads are bigger than a regular salad at any place. They also have spaghetti and pasta dishes. My son loved their marinara sauce. We didn't order any desserts because we were stuffed from the food. They also hace a small market attached to the restaurant with a to-go area. The service was quick, ordering + eating took us about 40-45 minutes. Staff were very nice! read more

My dad decided to choose this place for dinner since he was craving pizza and it was closer to our hotel. The service was prompt and kind. We decided to order the insalata mista salad with olives, artichokes, peppers, onions, greens, feta and tomatoes. We ordered Italian dressing. For whatever reason, they brought us 2 dressing containers and charged us for one. We didn't even finish half of one and only noticed on the check at the end. Nonetheless, it was only 75 cents extra so we didn't say anything about it. The salad was really tasty. My dad and I ordered the pizza 16" called Ortolana pizza but with only half the pie with sausage as Im vegetarian. It comes with mushrooms, spinach, roasted red peppers, ricotta cheese, Italian sausage and sliced tomatoes. I don't think the mushrooms were fresh but the flavor was pretty good and the dough was nice and thin. Overall quite tasty. The servers were all nice. At the end, it took a while to get our check. Fairly tasty in a surprising place. read more

Carmelo's - mushrooms, spinach, roasted red peppers, ricotta cheese, Italian sausage and sliced tomatoes. Ortolana with only half sausage - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I only had their pizza once or twice but have also stopped in the gas station part of the store. My most recent trip here was for the gas station/convenience store part to purchase lottery tickets for hubs on his birthday. The aroma of pizza was definitely a turn on and had me tempted but we had a big dinner planned. Our first time here, we ordered pizza to go, right as we were leaving town. Someone had highly recommended this place to us so I wanted to see if it compared to my NYC pizza. It was so long ago so I cannot remember exactly what I picked up. I want to say pepperoni for hubs and I believe I ordered a broccoli and chicken slice. I do remember it being pretty decent. Everything in town closes early and Carmelo's is open later than many restaurants but still closes at 10pm/11pm. The service is quick. The staff were not bubbly but I did not sit down in the restaurant so that may be a different experience. I do believe they have table service as well. read more

LOVE THIS PIZZA! We got the Carmelo's Supreme and it lived up to its name! Staff was super nice although really busy. Pizza crust was perfection. There are not many tables but there is a bar and a smaller group of tables inside the marketplace where one can order pizza by the slice. We will be back and will recommend it to other pizza lovers. read more

Absolutely the best pizza in St Augustine hands down. I will definitely be back. It's a good value to boot.

Went for a pizza pie after the distillery tour. Great pairing opportunity actually but I digress. Kept it basic and ordered the 16" large cheese with extra sauce. Got waters cuz I had fire in my veins that needed expelling. Service was fast and friendly. Pizza came in short order nice and hot with tasty gooey cheese. Here's the deets: Cheese - gooey and tasty. Could have used maybe a bit more but that's what extra cheese is for right? Sauce - had a nice tang but not too much to overpower Crust - a little bit of crisp and no bubbles to ruin it. Liked it Cook - we asked for it a bit lightly cooked and it was. No burned areas Atmosphere - it's next to a gas station so don't take anyone on a first date here. On that note in the gas station you can buy the same pizza as well. Bears investigation read more

Okay yeah open in the box this looks like a pretty good football style pizza. Picking it up not swampy at all little bit of Grease she's good. Nice undercarriage. Take a minute it'll melt your face off when it comes out of the oven. One bite everyone knows the rules. nom nom nom Okay good got a little New York style to it just the right amount of pepperoni I'd have to give it a aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa. 7.7 read more

My friend and I stopped in because we were craving a slice of deep dish pizza, there were only a couple people when we came in and after ordering, we were told they were out of the slices of Sicilian. No big deal, we got different flavors. Now it was getting packed, and after waiting a while, we noticed other people who came in after us were getting their food. Finally our food comes and they forgot my friends order of Mozzarella sticks, I brought it up and server apologized and offered to put the order in but take it off the receipt, which was nice, but because we had already waited so long my friend said it was fine to just cancel them off the order. The pizza was ok, I like the thin crust with the sandy bottom, but it was a little greasy. The veggie sandwich,.which I was glad they offered, had grilled eggplant and zucchini, tomatoes, pesto, and provolone, and because of those veggies, the sandwich was very watery. Despite the pesto, it also didn't have much flavor. I would love to come back to try the eggplant parm or actually get a slice of the deep dish to try it out, but would probably get it to-go so I wouldn't have to deal with the wait again. read more

See all