We had a great experience here! First off, it's a carry out only place - or maybe I should say, there's no option to dine in. We weren't clear on that until we walked in and saw the "No eating in lobby sign". It was fine with us, we just took it back to our hotel room next door. There seemed to be only one employee working but he was fast. We only waited 17 minutes from placing our walk in order to receiving it and 2 others came in to pick up what they had ordered prior to us. To me, he was fast & efficient. We ordered a large Meat Deluxe and it was SO good. Light on sauce, which is exactly how we like it and large slices. We both agreed it was really good and we'd definitely go back. read more

See all

Mediocre pizza in a good location. It's not terrible and for the price per slice it's a good bargain but I wouldn't buy a whole pie here. Get slices when the pie is fresh that's when their pizza is the best. Otherwise go to bronx house it's better read more

This little hole in the wall has one of the best Italian subs that I've had in a long time; the bread is nice and fresh, the meat sliced to perfection and topped off with tasty Italian dressing. The Greek salad is the star of the show for me.. a very generous amount of all the veggies and feta cheese. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

We literally live across the street from this place Had pizza 3-4 times over 8 years. It's the worst. Go get a frozen grocery store pizza instead, or another pizza place. read more

It was good pizza and that is far as I would take it. This a take out only operation from what we could see. Many multiple options for pizza and sandwiches. Limited selections on Soda and drinks. We ordered the medium meats deluxe pizza plenty of slices I would say about 8. Nothing much to say about this place. Service was good only one person working tonight so it takes some time. Sorry but this would not be equal to New York Pizza got a long way to go for sure. I am from the Bronx and this did not remind me of any pizza I have eaten in The Bronx read more

BEWARE Wait time originally was 45 mins, after 1.5 hours told they were over booked. Seems like a very small place with not much capacity for high number of orders. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great place for a quick bite after beach time. Ice cream shop next door as well to eat while you wait.

Tried several years ago and it was very good and I believe the original owners. Now that we live here, we thought to try again and not so good. Pizza and Italian hoagie were a bit bland. I asked for little more sauce on puzza and hoagie and they ended being like they should be except they charged more. Of all the pizza places we've been they never charged extra which would've been fine if the product was better here. It's doubtful we'll go back read more

The pizza was good. The people were polite and professional. The price was reasonable. It's all good read more

The family was craving sub sandwiches so we ordered from Antonio's. I was a little wary because of a past negative review, but our sandwiches were great! We ordered over the phone and 15 minutes later walked in and picked up our bag. Bread is fresh, light and fluffy and they were packed with all our favorites. read more

See all

Avoid this "sandwich shop" at all costs. They serve an absolutely pathetic attempt of a sandwich at a hefty price. As noted in the photo, they plop one piece of an unknown "meat" that they allege is ham, some form of cheese, and lettuce and an unripe tomato on a roll. Then, for some ungodly reason, they heat the "sandwich" and wrap it in aluminum foil. Subway makes a better sandwich. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Way overpriced for ok pizza. Slow service, guy working acted like I was inconveniencing him when I asked why my medium pizza was $20 , he said I had an old menu read more

Delicious pizza! We're staying at the embassy suites and the lunch food is mediocre. Anthony's pizza was such a yummy treat! Sausage and pepperoni hit the spot! read more

The worst pizza I have bought in my life. Flat dry tasteless and dead cold. Don't know how they are still in business.

Good food and friendly staff. Food was completed in time for pickup. We had a large ordered and everything was done correctly.

We called & ordered a plain cheese pizza to pick up last night. It was ok but next time I'd chose a different place. The sauce didn't have much flavor & cheese was skimpy. Crust was ok but overall we were underwhelmed. It would have been nice if they included little packs/containers of parm & red pepper flakes & oregano for us to sprinkle on the pizza but nope. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

I don't understand how they can call themselves New York Pizza. It was a lot like frozen pizza you get from the grocery store which sometimes isn't bad but this wasn't one of those times I don't think. They were small slices also. read more

I have lived here for several years And have never tried this pizza place. I'll never do it again. I asked for bacon they give me Canadian ham. The cheese is awful. There's nothing about this pizza that is appealing at all. I just wasted 50 bucks.. I called the pizza place and of course there's nothing they're going to do about it at I do not ever suggest this pizza place don't ever go there. This is the worst pizza I have ever had. I do believe read more

The recent ownership has ruined the reputation of this wonderful pizza shop. Before COVID this pizza New York style was phenomenal. My two today are beyond awful... Hardly any dried out cheese, tasteless, The dough is like thin rubber the pepperoni toppings were dried out like they were sitting in a tray all day long. This is one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. avoid this business at all cost. Their white pizza was just as bad as their pepperoni both of them horrible the crust was not crispy. I called up and the manager claimed his pizzas are fine nothing wrong with them New York style.. Avoid avoid take out !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

ZERO STARS this is THE WORST pizza I've ever had in my life. Looks and taste stale, old, and over cooked. Where's the sauce? Paper thin. Jaw is sore from trying to chew the one bite I took. Basically oil and nasty cheese on stale dough. Don't waste your money & time stopping here. We threw everything out read more

See all

This is a decent little place to grab a quick bite near the beach. Had an Italian sub that was nicely toasted and fairly well-made but nothing exceptional. The sandwich and a bottle of pop set me back $20 but that's probably par for the course in this area. read more

The pizza was thin crust which I like. The reason for 2 stars is they made my extra large pepperoni pizza half cheese. When I called they said ok sorry bring it back and we will give you a new one. Well we are all hungry and DON'T want to wait 45 minutes because of their mistake. So imagine my surprise when the girl got pissy with me because I was frustrated. Rude staff members make for poor ratings. read more

It's hard to make bad pizza ... but Antonio's has figured out how. It's floppy and droopy and the veggie supreme lacked the advertised mushrooms and green peppers. Yuck. read more

Pizza was great, went back a second time and got large pepperoni pizza. Highly recommend. Ordered and picked up in 20 min.

Pizza was acceptable. Place was closeby preferred other ones but they are closed on Mondays. We got an 18 inch pizza for 21+ with tax. New york style with mimimal chees and pepperoni. Next to Ritas ice cones read more

Certainly not world famous. This has been the worst pizza I've ever eaten in Florida. It looks like a cool place from the outside, but once you go inside you realize there is absolutely no service, you can't eat there, they have limited supplies, and a piece of just plain stinks. The small side salad I had was OK but certainly not worth six dollars. I live in this area, and I can say with certainty this is a tourist trap read more

We ordered two pizzas and chicken parmesan; the food was mediocre, not great at all. When prompted to tip at checkout, the pre-generated tip amounts weren't accurate. So, the 20% suggested amount was actually 30%. This is dishonest and enough of a reason for us not to return. read more

The pizza at Antonio's is great, but that's about it. The chicken sandwiches and entrees we ordered were made with spongey type chicken and inedible. We will stick to just pizza at this restaurant in the future. read more

Friendly service! Good pizza! Easy pick up because of spacious parking lot. Great when you need a night off kitchen duty:)

Stayed at Anastasia State Park and asked if anyone delivered to the park. Her answer was Antonio's Pizza, they deliver right to your site. Great menu, great service and the pizza and antipasto was delicious! read more

This is my favorite pizza in St Aug, and I have been a customer here for 7 years now! I usually love toppings but this pizza is great even with just cheese! Always ready when I go to pick it up and the staff is so friendly :) read more

I was at st augustine beach staying for almost a week for vacay and this pizza place is literally a 2 min walk from the hotel i was staying at and the pizza was chef kiss they also give out individual slices if you ever want to just buy one or two instead of a whole box. I got a small when i went and it's six slices i ate four...oops and my brother ate the last time and he had already eaten two other slices before that. I would definitely recommend !! read more

The pizza is good and the price point is also good but my god why are the employees SO MEAN??? We just left a few moments ago. The woman working looked like serving us (we just needed two slices of pizza) was physically painful for her. They only had two slices left so they asked if I wanted them to bake another pizza for our third slice. The man seemed happy to do so but I didn't want to wait 15 min so we just went with the two they had. She keeps asking me what kind I wanted. And of course I asked what the existing slices were - the guy finally said that they were all cheese and they just add the toppings. The woman acted like I was an idiot for not knowing how it worked. Then my son (11) saw a jar for charity on the counter and asked me for a dollar. I happily obliged. But he wanted to know what charity it was. So he asked the woman who looked at him flat out and said. FOR CHARITY. He asked, "yes but what kind of charity?" She said "CHARITY!!" So I finally stepped in and I said yes. We see that but he just wants to know if it's for like- animals, or heart disease etc... she rolled her eyes and asked another man who said it was for a boys home. We put in our dollar and left as soon as we got our food. In this climate? Dont be a rude ass to your customers. Will not be back. read more

This is by far the best pizza in St Augustine Beach! The flavor in the sauce is delish and I love the NY style slices. The subs and gyros are a common go-to also. If you're in town stop by for a slice or pie, you won't be disappointed. read more

Man. I wanted to like this pizza but it was gross. It taste like chuck-e cheese pizza ..... don't claim New York style of your not really about that lifestyle. Also we asked for a slice and they said they didn't have single serve so they offered us a pizza that had been called ina and forgotten about ...... at full price .... read more

My husband and I each ordered an 12" Italian sub to eat at the beach. Both had very little meat inside - one or two pieces of what looked like mortadella and a few small pieces of pepperoni. There was also some shredded mozzarella with lettuce and tomato on it. We waited 30 minutes for them, then went to the beach before we opened them. We should've gone back and asked for our $25 back. Would not recommend this establishmen. read more

Damn good pizza. We're visiting from Ohio. Im 47 years old. One of the best pizzas I've ever had. Boom read more

It was our last night in St., Augustine we decided we wanted to try a pizza place. I'm glad we did. Food was great. Service was great. The young man even helped us out with a care package of forks, napkins, and condiments went back to the hotel with the pizza. read more

First visit, had a bad experience here on a weekday afternoon. The restaurant is seat yourself or you can order at the counter. It took a while for anyone to notice us at our table. The server was very nice but their clothes looked dirty, which is not comforting at a food-service establishment. We really only wanted to order a couple slices but the menu says that the lunch special Pizza By The Slice runs from only 11-3, and since it was around 430p we did not order slices. However the next two customers who came in ordered and received single pizza slices, so we were quite disappointed by that bc we felt that our only option was to order whole pizzas. We ordered two pies; they were not the worst pizzas we've ever had, but definitely not good quality. The Greek pizza had good ingredients but every item was crunchy/undercooked. The pizza was hot but there were so many toppings that water dripping from our pizzas. After removing a slice or two from the pan, the other slices were sitting in water... The other pizza was pep and sausage, and after picking up the slice, all the meat and cheese toppings slid right off the dough. This one was also a very wet pizza. This restaurant says it's New York style pizza but it was not what you'd expect: thick crust, normal size slices. Would not return. read more

Stopped in here after a short stay at the beach and it was great; simple yet tasty NYC style pizza. By the slice combo was good; 2 slices plus a drink for $6. Staff (cook, maybe owner???) was super friendly and personable and accommodated our gluten free request thoughtfully and proactively, which was super cool. Thanks! read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all