Antonio's New York Style Pizza

oh my. this is THE best place to get a new york thin crust slice of pepperonI! perfectly seasoned…read more excellent undercarriage, fabulous sauce and cheese!! I have gone to other local spots but came in here when my regular stop wasn't answering their phone. so glad I tried this place. perfect!!!!!!

Amazing authentic pizza/italian food. Family owned and everyone there is eager to serve the second…read moreyou walk through the door. If you're hungry and heading down town to see the nights of lights or just to walk around on the bay front and take in all the sites downtown has to offer, stop here first and fill up your belly with some delicious food!

NY style pizza! No way!!!

See all

Interior decor

Pizza Time

3.5(1.5k reviews)

We originally were gonna go over to Pizza Alley to try their pizza but they decided to close early…read moreso we ended up over here. The nice thing about this location is you can order a whole pizza or you can just order slices of pizza. That's nice because you can try different flavors if you want to or just get a slice depending upon how hungry you are. I got the Italian Burratta and a slice of the Hawaiian and my husband got the pepperoni. The crust is definitely thinner, but they reheat the pizza because they've been sitting out to get the nice crust on the bottom of it and make it crispy. They put my husband's pepperoni pizza in first and then they put mine in and I wish the Italian burratta would have cooked for a little bit longer because the cheese would've melted a little bit more when I cut into it. The Hawaiian pizza also ended up just being kind of lukewarm. The Italian burratta pizza I will say was incredibly fresh. I really enjoyed the flavors on this pizza. The Hawaiian was great. Their Canadian bacon is shaved super thin. The gentleman who is working behind the counter was super friendly and chatted with us as the pizza was being reheated and because it was so late in the night we had the entire place basically to our self. There is a whole lot of air-conditioning going on, but it's enough to get out of the heat

We shall start with the good. The staff was friendly, there…read moreis a wide selection of pizza, and food. When we walked in, we saw signs saying that this was the 2nd best rated pizza in the US by trip advisor. Food looks good, and big portions are guaranteed. Now, sadly I must say, if this is the second best pizza in the US, we have fallen far. Don't get me wrong, is it good? Sure, is it in the top 10 pizzas I've ever had? Maybe and that's a stretch. We ordered 2 slices, and garlic balls. The put the slices into the oven, to reheat, took about 8 or 9 minutes, then served. For that and 2 drinks with tip about $43. Not overly impressed, especially for the price, it was good but not great.

Margaritas

See all

Meat Balls

Carmelo's

4.1(394 reviews)

5.3 mi

Huge slices for a great price very cheesy. The meatballs are super tasty and flavorful service is…read moregreat very and polite. Cute hole in the wall - not too busy and very relaxing vibe.

Lunch today. Yep a slice of pizza and a side salad-- so yummy Brooklyn took excellent care of us…read more Plenty of parking out front. 5/5

May 2023

"Pizza by the Slice" Pepperoni

See all

June 12, 2024

Pizzalley's Chianti Room

4.1(645 reviews)

Good food Good service…read more Good atmosphere Descent Pricing for downtown Saint Augustine A little hard to get to and parking is easy to find but $15 for the whole day so if you're going downtown, think about having a bite here and parking and doing your walking from there it's a good location. I think that it delivers what you would expect to get which is a big plus. I recommend it We found a place by accident. Hopefully you'll find it on purpose. It's worth the hunt.

We tried to go here for dinner one night, but because it was low season, they decided to close…read moreabout an hour early from their posted closing time. So we ended up going over here the following night for dinner and I think it's important to note that there are two dining locations. One is kind of the basic alley that you would expect there are a few booth seats and the bar area in the front, when you walk all the way to the back is when you'll find the Chianti room, which is a full dining restaurant with full table service. We chose to sit in the front portion of it, which at first glance looked like they were closed, but they have one server that servicing both the bar area and the tables in the front. They have a pretty extensive menu definitely Italian heavy. We got an order of the breadsticks and then we split an order of the chicken fettuccine Alfredo. The breadsticks were OK very dense and felt a little dry. The chicken Alfredo was very good. Alfredo sauce was delicious. It actually was perfect to dip the breadsticks in to give them more moisture. Chicken is really well grilled loved that it was not breaded as so many locations do breaded chicken with their Alfredo versus grilled like this location does. They do do happy hour from 3 to 6 and probably one of the best happy hour deals. As when you order a drink you get a free slice of cheese pizza. Not sure if it's just because it's low season that they're running a special but definitely a great deal.

See all

Nonna's Trattoria

3.9(432 reviews)

5.3 mi

We stoped in to this adorable place for an early dinner. We were greeted and seated immediately…read more It's a small place with inside and outside dinning. It has an open kitchen concept that we like. We were immediately served water and their amazing dinner rolls! We ordered a glass of Merlot and a homemade Sangria. For our meals we shared a very nice Caesar salad. Four our mains we had Bolognese and Chicken Fettuccine! Both meals were absolutely delicious and the portions were huge! We followed up our dinner by sharing a piece of Limoncello Cake. It was so light and refreshing. This was a wonderful dinning experience. We highly recommend it and will visit the next time we are in town!

Ashley and I had never heard of Nonna's Trattoria but we stumbled upon it on a lazy Sunday…read moreafternoon. We had already eaten lunch and I couldn't make sense of ordering anything else but I did get a Sangria that they had on Happy Hour/sale that I really enjoyed. The staff was friendly and very welcoming too. I know we will come in sooner rather then later for a quick lunch or early did after last time.

Bathroom

Delicious Spaghetti Meatballs Chef Specialty

See all

Real Peel Pizza

4.9(11 reviews)

5.2 mi

THE BEST PIZZA IN STA!! We were absolutely blown away by the pizza here, there's nothing even close…read moreto compare! Real Peel pizza is a food truck located next to Muggsy's bar. We ordered the beesting (hot honey and pepperoni) and Bianca (Gorgonzola and lemon zest). I wish I could give more than 5 stars for how incredible they both were. The pizzas were cooked to perfection and the ingredients tasted so fresh, They also use sourdough so it is naturally more gut healthy! We got our pizzas in about 15min, the service was great! Muggsy's also has a nice selection of seating, with a front and back patio, and some indoor seating as well. The back patio is very cute and a great space to hang out. We will definitely be back for more, the pizza was amazing!!!

Hands down the best pizza around. The crust is sourdough perfection. The toppings allow all the…read moreflavors to shine through instead of glopping them on and weighing down the pizza. There is no greasiness either. Normally I find mushroom pizzas tasteless but not this one. Garrett is the pizza master and you should definitely check out his food truck. There is indoor and outdoor seating at Muggsy's Bar where the truck is parked.

See all

Five Star Pizza

4.0(227 reviews)

4.5 mi

Great service, Great Pizza! The crust had a great taste and…read morethe toppings were fresh and flavorful.

One of the few places in St Augustine open late for food other than Denny's or an Americana…read morerestaurant. I ordered the chicken bites and garlic knots. The knots were drowned in a flavourless oil with some garlic. I threw them out. They did however have good ranch and hot sauce for the chicken. I would give them a second chance w the pizza if I was in a pinch for a late night meal.

Awesome cheese pull on my double pepperoni!!

See all

Thin crust pizza

Uptown Pizza

3.3(321 reviews)

6.0 mi

We stumbled upon this charming hole-in-the-wall pizza joint just a couple of minutes away from the…read morebustling downtown area of St. Augustine, and it turned out to be a delightful surprise. This place offers a refreshing escape from the crowds, which was exactly what we were looking for. The pizza was served fresh and piping hot. The quality of the ingredients was pretty good. We shared a 10-inch pizza and that was enough for 2. On a Saturday night, just before Christmas, it's no surprise that the place was very busy. Despite how busy they were, the servers I interacted with were an absolute delight, super friendly, and attentive. Their outdoor area is great and we were very pleased to see that they had plenty of outdoor heaters outside!

The young lady working out front, pleasant and helpful, food cake out quickly and served at the…read moreperfect temperature. The food was large portions , however only mediocre. My soda from the fountain machine was totally flat, almost like there was no soda water at all, I couldn't drink it and had to change to iced tea. The garlic knots were huge but not much garlic butter used on them. The two meatballs that were served with the spaghetti were pretty large , menu stated they were 3 oz each. The marinara sauce with very tomatoey but not much of any other flavor in the profile

See all

Mellow Mushroom - Saint Augustine

3.9(333 reviews)

Food was great. Service was great. Very surprised that there weren't many reviews…read more. Will be going again!!

Stopped in here with the family to have some fresh made pizza and some pretzel and cheese bites,…read moreeverybody just felt like pizza that night, but they also have some really good food on the menu. this restaurant is a busy place, but the service is very prompt.

Mellow Mushroom - Saint Augustine - The House Special: Red sauce base with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham, Applewood smoked bacon, mushroom

The House Special: Red sauce base with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham, Applewood smoked bacon, mushroom

Stuffed Portobella Mushroom

See all

Avocado Hogie

Prohibition Kitchen

4.1(2.3k reviews)

We stopped in here for lunch on our first day as this is always a must go to when we are in this…read morearea. We chose to sit at the bar as there was a line of people waiting for tables. The bar meanwhile was completely open and it is seat yourself. We both ordered chicken wings, extra crunchy with the whiskey rub on them. The rub is a little sweet, but we requested them to hit it lightly so that we didn't have as much sweetness on the wings. We also got an order of the pork rinds which are cooked fresh and you can ask for a dusting of the whiskey rub on those as well. They were very good, but they are a large order so definitely be prepared to share. I also got a cup of their beer cheese soup - I would not order it again. The texture was a little off for me and it felt like it was probably at the bottom of the cooker. The first bartender we had was OK, but felt like he was just going through the motions. The second bartender that took over our service was much friendlier and checked in on us periodically.

This is one of my favorite spots in St Aug to stop by for drinks. It's almost always crowded but…read moreworth the wait for a seat at the bar. All the bartenders are so wonderful and fun people. This time we didn't have food. Just drinks. I tried a Goodbye Earl. If earl grey is involved, I'm in! It was quite good. The lemon was the heaviest flavor. I would have liked it even more if the earl grey shined thru a little more. My friend had the Madi Cola which was also good. A little too sweet for my palate but it was good! The vanilla rum was great in there. It was interesting on this trip because it was the middle of a weekday. It wasn't too packed but still bustling. The place does really have a bit of a speakeasy feel and they often have live music if that's your thing.

Interior

My friend had this Peanut butter milk shake with whiskey

See all

Madi cola

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Vapor K.

9 years ago

They do not serve single slices after 3:45 p.m. This place is all about making a quick dollar from everybody. Especially those from New York or in Philly and Pennsylvania. This guy is running a South Florida ripoff scam! Don't even bother going there. His food is good, but if you think you're going to get a slice your f****** wrong. He only wants to make a dollar and sell you a full Pizza. F*** this guy he would have no space up north where the real competition is! And f*** his pizza because they're not that good! It's Florida's version of a real pizza from up North. read more

Todd S.

5 years ago

Garlic knots were awesome and the pizza was delicious. The service was above and beyond.

Sandra G.

2 years ago

Great food and the sweetest, kindest owners! The food is always hot,delicious and fresh.

Antonio's New York Style Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Restaurants near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Coffee near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Breakfast near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Desserts near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Things to Do near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Parking near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Dinner near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Burgers near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Shopping near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

BEST of Saint Augustine, Florida Movie Theatre near Antonio's New York Style Pizza

People found Antonio's New York Style Pizza by searching for…

Best of Saint Augustine

Things to do in Saint Augustine

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Antonio's New York Style Pizza also viewed

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach

3.4

(155 reviews)

We recently tried out Antonio's Pizza at the beach in St. Augustine. We had the goal of finding…read morepizza on the beach right near the St. Augustine Amphitheater and this worked out perfectly. My only wish was that this was a bit of a sit-down restaurant but we ended up hanging out on the beach for about 15, 20 minutes. We were able to pick up the pizza and then find a local bench to sit at while overlooking the ocean and the waves, which is beautiful. In general there was quite a bit of variety in the pizzas to choose from. We were happy that the pizza tasted good, was neatly made, and had quite a generous amount of cheese. If you are ever at the St. Augustine Amphitheater around there, try out Antonio's Pizza at the beach

The pizza was amazing. It was ready when I walked in and the whole family loved it. I would…read morerecommend it to everyone!

Tony's Pizza

4.1

(155 reviews)

Great pizza. Picked up pizza so don't know about ambiance. Price acceptable for close to beach.read more

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY! This was literally the worst pizza I've ever had and certainly not "New…read moreYork style". I really have no idea how this place is so highly rated. It must be because of the lack of options in the immediate area. Supporting small businesses is so important and I absolutely hate to be so harsh but this was not only horrible but also expensive. People need to be warned. 1.) the watery sauce had zero flavor. Literally almost to the point that I couldn't taste it at all. 2.) this place doesn't understand moderation. The soggy pizza was topped with WAY too many toppings and it's really took away from the pizza. 3.) SALTY. This crust/dough was incredibly salty. Almost inedible. Crust is my favorite part of the pizza and this was just yuck. 4.) Poor quality ingredients. The mozzarella was especially bad. It looked and tasted so low quality. 5.) It truly did not taste fresh at all. We were pretty hungry so we practically force fed ourselves two pieces before sadly just throwing away the rest of it - which is not in our nature to waste food. Do yourself a favor and pick up some cheap frozen pizzas. You'll be happier and save money.

Romano's on the Beach

4.1

(244 reviews)

Back again. Brick oven pizza....NJ STYLE. Yummy. Glad you are back Phil, and the CA wine...Cabernet…read moreSauvignon was delicious , and only $6.00. The total bill was fairly priced too. The waitress JENNA was super sweet, and great service.

I can no longer recommend either location. I called to order several Pizza's, and we were told they…read moregot rid of their 18" pizza's and replaced them with smaller sizes for around the same price. In addition they eliminated some of the pizzas. I asked for their website to view their menu and they gave me a website that was trying to sell systems to restaurants. We ended up driving to the restaurant to order in person. When we went in there were a few staff standing around with no customers at all (seemed especially odd on a Saturday evening). They asked if we wanted to order to go. We looked at the menu and were directed to their other location and told they offered what we were wanting. We didn't care to drive all over town just to order pizzas so called them to place an order only to find that they misled us and they had also gotten rid of the larger pizzas and some of the kinds we had wanted to order. I'm not certain if they changed owners but they certainly didn't seem to want to be bothered.

Carmelo's

4.1

(394 reviews)

Huge slices for a great price very cheesy. The meatballs are super tasty and flavorful service is…read moregreat very and polite. Cute hole in the wall - not too busy and very relaxing vibe.

Lunch today. Yep a slice of pizza and a side salad-- so yummy Brooklyn took excellent care of us…read more Plenty of parking out front. 5/5

Five Star Pizza

4.0

(227 reviews)

Great service, Great Pizza! The crust had a great taste and…read morethe toppings were fresh and flavorful.

We stopped here while in st Augustine for a few things. It was a cute little place and my boyfriend…read moreand I got two different pizzas, some cheesy bread and I got a ceaser salad. The service was great our waitress was very friendly and helpful in giving my boyfriend a suggestion on what to get, he always asks the waiter/waitress their opinion since they know best since they work there and he wasn't disappointed. We started with the cheesy bread and it was pretty good. My Cesar salad was absolutely AMAZING. Loved it. He got the Chicago deep dish pizza and he had never had one before. He LOVED it! It was a lot of food. I got the hot honey pizza and it was a flatbread pizza. I wasn't the biggest fan of the pizza and I'm not entirely sure why. The one thing I can pinpoint is that there was a lot of honey on it and sometimes it was way too overpowering. It was also a cute little place. I will say if you are coming here for pizza you definitely want to make sure you have time. The deep dish pizza takes about 45 minutes (it says this on the menu so it isn't a surprise which I love.) and the flatbread pizza was I believe 30-35 minutes. So we were there for quite a bit waiting but it was a pretty nice place!

A number of people told me to visit Hillary's for some great pizza, and I have no doubt that they…read moretruly enjoy the unique flavor and texture of Chicago Pizza - it's not exactly my style, but Hillary's does do a nice job overall of providing a nice dining area, excellent Greek salad, and a quality of pizza that many others enjoy. I found the pizza better on the second day when I reheated it at home. I found the outside of the business not so enticing, being right next to a check cashing store. Once inside however, the Chicago themed artwork, lighting hanging from the rafters, and the bar area we're all quite attractive. Service was also good on the day of our visit, we were told that the standard thick crust Chicago style pizza generally takes between 45 minutes and an hour to prepare, in case you're expecting to enjoy in-restaurant dining. Pricing for a salad and a shared pizza with drinks, tip and tax average about $30 per person, a reasonable value. Overall, the quality of the product is excellent, it's just not necessarily my preferred style of pizza.

180 Vilano Grill & Pizza

4.2

(328 reviews)