This place is delicious! Worth the wait- my kids got the pepperoni pizza, my husband has the Brooklyn special while I got the caprese pizza. Nobody asked for more than one slice because it was so fulfilling and tasty. The guy who grabbed our order was very nice and so was the cashier. The prizes are outrageous; I paid $61 in total for four slices and four medium fountain drinks. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It definitely reminds me of my childhood in the 90s- the restaurant is outdated and crowded but the pizza was good so I would definitely come back.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Also, I read on google that this was a cash only establishment; it's not. I definitely paid with card. read more

Pizza Time is a happening place, for sure. The line goes out the door and the display of pizza is mouth-watering. Many unusual combinations and unusual styles of pizza, thick and thin, are offered. Portions are very ample and pizza is served hot and fresh over the counter. There is indoor seating. The service is fast and friendly. The employees keep the line moving. It's very satisfying. read more

I was excited to try this place after seeing the huge sign claiming it has the "2nd Best Pizza in the USA." Unfortunately, the experience didn't come close to living up to the hype. The pizza itself was extremely disappointing. The crust was bland, the sauce lacked flavor, and the overall taste was nowhere near what I would expect from a restaurant making such a bold claim. I've had far better pizza from small local shops with no awards hanging on the wall. To make matters worse, the staff was rude and unwelcoming. Customer service seemed to be an afterthought, and interactions felt more like an inconvenience to them than an opportunity to serve paying customers. A great pizza place can sometimes survive mediocre service, and great service can sometimes make up for average food. Unfortunately, this place had neither. The "2nd Best Pizza in the USA" sign may get people through the door, but the food and attitude will make sure they don't come back. I definitely won't be returning. read more

I came back after 3 or 4 years. The pizza is still delicious and huge. We got Margherita, Genovese, and Mushroom and Spinach White (so garlicky). They now take credit cards instead of just cash, which is much more convenient (although you do pay a little extra to do so), BUT they are now charging almost $10 dollars each for specialty slices. Seriously!? read more

Pizza Time - Margherita and Genovese - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

What a total disappointment for a restaurant rated #2 best pizza in the United States. The only thing that was good from here was the beer. I ordered a maragherita pizza and it was super bland basically had no taste of anything. The garlic rolls came with thier special ingredient - cooked hair. Gross! And customer service was mediocre. You can tell they hate their job. Oh and the prices are ridiculous 70 bucks for this nasty food. The restaurant has seating so you can sit and eat. Just a small restaurant. Never coming back again read more

Voted #2 Pizza in America by Trip Advisor. Literally the customer line was to the door and within minutes the line stretched outside. The line went very quick and appeared managed well with only serious staff behind the counter working the six door ovens. Waited only five minutes for my cheese and pepperoni pizza slices and watched hungry customers peering at the countless pizzas going in and out of the ovens. Six - nine dollars per slice and cash only. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Grabbed one of the open tables and stared for a few moments with excitement at the oversized slices.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]For some odd reason pizza boxes are forbidden at the tables.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] After the first bite I realized the hype was true. Excellent crust with garlic sauce and loved it. read more

See all

Pizza here is voted 2nd best in America. It's a bit greasy and there's some flop. You can order by the slice and there's a ton of options. I got the margarita, and it was good overall. The garlic bread was decent and service can sometimes be a long line. But overall good food and good vibe for Brooklyn pizza. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance feels like an nyc walk in.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] 7.8/10 read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

They're #2, they're #2! I really enjoyed their very honest advertising as the #2 pizza place based on an article they were featured in and displayed in the front window. I told my kids, nothing but the second best for them! Anyway, joking aside, it was an okay experience. It took a really long time to get through the line in the front. It was frustrating since they asked you what pizza slice you wanted, but there was no way a customer could see all the pizza options. We ended up just going with cheese slices with the kids and I got the chicken parm slice option. How was it? Okay. Overall, our full family review was that the slices were perfectly mediocre, okay. Would I get in the line again and wait all that time? Probably not. But I'm glad we could try the #2 pizza. But I've had much better. read more

I liked the margarita pizza nice place to grab a slice after a drink or two. I wouldn't say it's the best pizza in the country at all not even close that's a gimmick. Big tourist vibes here if you like that sort of thing. read more

Very popular restaurant in main shopping area of St Augustine. I ordered their so called world famous slice of Grandma's pizza. It was not that great. Truly lacking in the garlic flavor I'm used to in a grandma's pizza. You can only buy by the slice when eating in this Pizza Time restaurant. read more

Pizza Time - Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The atmosphere was vibrate and busy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The staff was very helpful and friendly. My Hawaiian and Chicken Parmesan pizza was absolutely delicious. My potato ball was filled with meat sauce. The marinara sauce was very good. My meal was enjoyable. read more

Pizza Time - Potato ball - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Let me start by saying we came here thinking pizza slices were still somewhat inexpensive compared to other places to eat for a quick dinner. So, with that said, it's safe to say we were naive. Typically, we understand that any tourist spot you go to, the prices will be higher than some other spots that are less touristy. However, he we were still expecting cheaper slices of pizza. I mean they're slices and I can buy whole delivery pizzas for the same price they're charging per slice here. Now granted, their prices are also very much within eyesight as soon as you walk in. So, it shouldn't have been such a surprise, but we just ordered what we wanted and thought it wouldn't be that bad. Then, we realized they didn't take credit or debit cards until we got to the register. It was CASH ONLY. 4 slices of pizza, 2 water bottles and a small cup of pepperocinis came out to $53. My husband and I put our cash together to pay for the tab. Yeah, it makes sense to some people for it to be that pricey, but we just didn't expect slices to be that much money. The pizza was good. It's wasn't super cheesy, but the marinara pizza sauce was tasty and not overly loaded on the pie. Honestly, I was hoping the cheese and sauce would've been more fused together in pure delicious harmony, but it was like they heated up old pizza slices in the oven that had been sitting out for a long time. To me, the pizza didn't taste like an authentic NY pizza, but it was still pretty good. The service was decent. You could tell it was the end of the shift for their employees, based on their tired faces and lack of smiling enthusiasm. I guess I had big hopes for this place and it just wasn't what we were expecting out of that whole experience. read more

I kept hearing about pizza time but thought "it's just pizza, it's probably nothing special...you can get pizza anywhere." But as soon as I walked by and saw the giant balls of burrata on the pizza slices, I knew we had to stop in and try it. The Sicilian style pizza is truly special and a must-have, and if you're a fan of burrata cheese, you have to try the burrata pizza. I think the low reviews saying that it's "average or mediocre" only tried the thin ny style pizza. read more

See all

I want to start by saying if I was basing this purely off of the pizza it would be 4-4.5 stars not 3. That being said the food itself is not the only metric. The restaurant is cash only which is pretty inconvenient (for me atleast, I'm aware some carry cash) and it is very expensive. I got four slices of pizza total, two for me & two for my girlfriend as well as a water bottle. That came out to about $40. I know it is in a touristy area but every other restaurant was reasonably priced. Your only option is to buy the pizza by the slice which isn't necessarily advertised. I'm not a ranch on pizza person but my girlfriend is and she was pretty disappointed to hear that they didn't have any. Overall, great pizza but is overpriced & cash only is not ideal. read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The pizza was pretty good. No complaints about the flavor. But it's not amazing. Lots of options. But I can't help but think about how expensive it was. I got two slices and a bottle of water and paid 22 dollars. The water was an entire 5 dollars. Yes the slices are pretty sizable, but I've gotten big slices of pizza for much less. service was good though. read more

Wonderful pizza, salad and garlic knots! If you're looking for a delicious meal or snack while in St Augustine- definitely visit Pizza Time! read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The pepperoni pizza was solid here! One slice was about $7, which is worth it at least once. The sauce is very good and the crust is thin and crunchy. They have lots of different types, along with Sicilian slices. read more

See all

This place is ranked 2nd best pizza in America located in the heart of St Augustine! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Super crowded like a New York Town Square Joint ![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Slices are huge and delicious like everything else in the menu, just expect a loud and exciting crowd! My rating 9.7 out of 10 read more

Yummy pizza! A lot of signs around it so you know that it is the second best pizza in the country. You should bring your own cash cuz they are cash only and the ATM inside has a three dollar service fee. Very yummy flavors. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The inside has a lot of seating and you order slices up at front and they bake it for you.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]On pretty St. George street.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Pizza Time - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Didn't want to give a pizza place a 5 because it isn't my go to, but I think it may have been the best slice I've had. Marguerita, the Burrata as good as burrata I've had outside of Italy (but haven't had a ton) and for sure the best I've ever had on a slice. I'm partial to a thin crispy crust which this had and I liked the tomato sauce. Didn't really need it but would've been nice to have more basil. read more

I love pizza and I like different styles and different toppings so this place checks all the boxes and they offer a number of sides that are unique and fresh - being it's a pizzeria you don't have to commit to a whole pizza and you can pick and choose your slice or slices depending on your mood. What a great business and location although I don't consider this a pizza destination it is very convenient and although touristy it does provide great quality and great customer service - the prices are well a little extreme at $10 for a large a slice but considering the location it except-able and people are willing to line up to experience it. We stopped in to grab a slice after walking around town and having skipped breakfast before driving here from NSB for the day. I liked it, especially the crust and found all the ingredients top shelf served by a very friendly staff so after thinking about it, it's cheaper than my last McDonald's drive-through lol. We love to day drink on St. George Street and Pizza Time is a great stop between bars to grab a slice and a bottle or two of water to hydrate. This was our first time trying this place but definitely won't be the last so bring your cash and get ready to be impressed... read more

See all

We had adinner reservation at Columbia but when I walked by here and smelled the deliciousness and saw the line, I had to check it out..the variety of Pizza they offer is amazing...I took a piece of Grandma to go and it was absolutely delicious, the crust and all...a must try when I'm the area! Remember to bring cash, no cards! read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Enjoy delicious pizza on St George Street!! Pizza Time is a fun outing. We always go when we visit downtown Saint Augustine! The garlic knots are incredible and my absolute favorite. (3 for $3 with sauce.) I've tried several different pizza slices, they have all been really good! They have a different selection every time we go. Overall a nice experience. The people are friendly and they warm up your slice in the oven so it's always toasty on the bottom and the cheese is warm! They are always busy, but you can usually find a place to sit in their cozy dining area. Note they ONLY TAKE CASH so be prepared for that!! The pizza is $5.50-$9.75 each slice and soda cup with one refill or bottled water is $5. read more

See all

It was 6:48PM at St.Oggy's and we know it's Pizza Time after a leisurely stroll within America's most ancient city (good excuse to carb up too lol) Got to try the Grandma square special, the white mushroom and Meatza pizza-all were very delicious really, but the Meatza gets the most flavor with all the protein goodness packed within the dough. Got to taste the Morelli authentic Italian beer as well. It was refreshing enough and paired well with pizzas. The ambiance and service was good, just chill, as customers are enjoying their meal with family and friends. They were only accepting cash during our visit so make sure you got them handy. And of course, tip accordingly :) #supportlocal904 read more

See all

Overpriced pizza place with solid pizza and service .In the heart of downtown Saint Augustine makes it a convenient choice .

Great pizza! Although I was stuffed I couldn't pass up grabbing a piece of pizza! Yummy! Must try! read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I came up to St. Augustine on a work road trip--the nation's oldest city, founded in 1565 by Spanish explorers, where every corner drips with history. Cobblestone streets, Spanish forts, haunted taverns... and smack in the middle of it all? Pizza Time. Because nothing says "America's oldest city" like grabbing a New York slice in a shop that's constantly packed. History may be Spanish here, but the flavor is strictly Brooklyn. Pizza Time has been hyped to the max, even crowned "Best Pizza in Florida" by magazines that clearly never drove down to Steve's Pizza in North Miami or Andiamo's in Miami's MiMo District. Is it the best? No. Is it a damn good contender? Absolutely. This isn't state champion pizza--it's top 10 with swagger. The slices are huge, thin, and foldable, just the way a proper slice should be. Cheese that stretches, sauce with tang, crust that fights back just enough. You grab one slice, you immediately want another, and you look around to realize--yeah, this place is always full. It's not fine dining--it's survival of the hungriest. The menu rotates with fun flavors, so it's not just "plain or pepperoni"--you'll see loaded veggie pies, white pizzas, and slices that look like someone dared the kitchen to go bigger. This isn't pizza, it's culinary graffiti--loud, messy, and unforgettable. And the service? Fast, friendly, and patient--impressive considering they deal with hordes of tourists every day. You'll get a smile with your slice, which in tourist-town Florida is rarer than a parking spot. Pizza Time isn't the best in the state, but it's the best excuse to eat carbs in a city built before carbs were invented. Pizza Time is a must-stop in St. Augustine. It may not dethrone Miami's heavyweights, but it's still serving some of the best slices in Florida, hands down. The city is magical, the history is rich, and the pizza hits the spot after a day of exploring. Is it the best? No. Is it worth it? Absolutely. Because sometimes in the oldest city in America, the only history that matters is the history of your second slice. read more

Its one of my top pizzas around and one of my wife and i places to eat in St. Augustine. It's an only cash pizza place, make sure you have it if not, there is an atm right there. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's not a super big pizza shop, but it has some good seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Most of the time there is a line out the door. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The window is a beautiful thing to look at, you see all the pizza making and all of the types of pizza flavors they have.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The slices are pretty large each one is about $9-$10 a slice, and let me tell you its completely worth it. Our favorite is the Genova, which is a white pizza with chicken, ricotta, and herbs. Also the chicken parm is delicious and the garlic knots are to die for; they are hot, soft, and definitely have garlic. Drinks are separate. They have calzones, salads, potato balls and large pizza orders. Its a good place to have lunch or a quick slice. It is definitely filling but worth it, it requires a nap after back at the hotel lol. read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Excellent selection. But went with classic cheese and a Pepsi. To yeah I wanna go in the Harley Davidson store and there's there's like a vintage jewelry store we can pop in the people who are complaining about cash only, there's literally an ATM behind register. Cashier doesn't ring you up until your foods ready. Signs everywhere to show process, we had a wonderful time. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Clean bathrooms too![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] How much was it read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I've been here every time I visit St. Augustine & i love it every time. (although it is definitely more expensive than pizzas I've had in New york with better flavor) but still good for location and craving a pizza. Price range from $5-$9 a slice, with most being around the $8 mark. Garlic knots are $6 for 3. The flavor of everything is overall good, i love the sauce that comes with the garlic knots. The pizza is really good. The staff is also always really sweet and helpful. They only take cash as well so be aware and take cash! but they do have an ATM available incase you forgot. Overall 8/10! read more

See all

Allegedly, this pizza place is ranked #2 in the U.S. by TripAdvisor and CNN, so naturally, we had high expectations. We called ahead for a 20-inch cheese pizza and were told it would be $35. We decided to add olives to half of it, unaware that this seemingly simple decision would bump our total to $45--a fact we only discovered at pickup.But, remaining open-minded and optimistic, we forged ahead. We also got three potato balls. The wait was about 30 minutes. The people working there were lovely and they had plenty of seatings in the space. They let us know that the restaurant no longer has an online menu (so all the pictures floating around online are outdated). Instead, they only take orders based on what's available in the case that day, in person. In a moment of weakness (read: hunger), we stared into the case and added an order of garlic knots (3 per order) to the mix. At checkout, our grand total was just over $70 for a pizza, three garlic knots, and three potato balls. Whew, because we only had $75 in cash and it is a cash only business. Here is a honest review of the food: 1. the pizza wasn't terrible--it was what one expects from a NY slice, nothing unique. The pizza itself reminded us of Costco pizza, but greasier, and we were disappointed by how floppy it was--the bottom lacked any crispness. 2. Upon closer inspection, there were 34 olives in total. Perhaps they were hand-picked this morning in the Mediterranean and flown in first-class since they costed $10? One can only hope. 3. The potato balls are quite delicious, but again, they costed $6 each. Here's our budget tip: Get the $1 garlic knots, add some marinara and cheese powder, and make your own slice. It might just be the best deal on the menu. Oh wait--you have to order at least three of them. But still better than paying $6.50 per slice for what we got. read more

See all

Excellent pie by the slice!! Bring CASH only. No debit or credit cards. Price are very reasonable and slice are NY size. Cheese is gooey and not greasy. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambience is loud and busy but fun.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Italian music serenades you while you eat.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Fun. read more

As far as value it's one of the best deals in the area! Me and my wife both ate a lot for $20. I loved the ny cheese pizza and the grandma pizza. The garlic knots were very good as well! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Place is older has character and everything was clean![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The man with the shaved head and tattoos was the nicest and very helpful! I knew it was too much food but sold me on getting the grandma slice. read more

Pizza Time - NY cheese & Grandma pizza plus knots - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Walked in at 9:58 and confirmed with the lady up front that they close at 10:30. We were then turned away because they said that they were going to go ahead and close when we got in read more

The pizza here looked absolutely amazing. I eat more pizza than almost anyone you know other than Dave Portnoy. The line was out the door. When I got inside , there were so many pizzas to choose from that it was really hard to decide which one. I finally decided on a roasted mushroom , pepperoni and parsley. By the way , you can only order by the slice. People behind me had a big group and had to order 8 slices instead of a pie. Guy puts my two slices in the oven and I'm moving down the line with my tray... passing even more amazing pizzas that I didn't see when I first got in. I then also saw they had Mountain Dew ( I'm a huge fan and most places only have Coke products). Then it happened .... As I moved closer to the register I saw it , a sign "CASH ONLY". Holy Shiz... REALLY? So I never got to to take just one bite I haven't been this disappointed in a long time. Cash only ?? Are they the Cody family from Animal Kingdom laundering money ‍ read more

We saw the sign that showed Pizza Time was 2nd to be the USA's best pizza. We were excited to try it out. We got a cheese, a pepperoni and a bottled water and all equal to $20... When we checked the receipt, all three items were categorized as "FOOD" the bottle of water was $5. This establishment also do not take cards. They only take cash. The pizza were about average and the prize of the meal did not seat well for us as well. We were pretty much over charged for our dinner. read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The food was really good, and every dish was packed with great flavor and cooked to absolute perfection using fresh, high-quality ingredients. Along with the delicious meal, the service was good, and the friendly, efficient staff checked in just the right amount to keep our drinks filled and ensure everything arrived hot. [[HIGHLIGHT]]On top of that, the ambience was fantastic, offering a welcoming atmosphere with great lighting and a relaxed vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Good customer service combined with such a comfortable, inviting environment made for a highly satisfying dining experience that definitely delivered![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

This is a tourist trap. We live here but finally went to try it to see. $10 a slice. Wasn't anything fancy. Flavor was meh. They pop it in the overnight but it still was not hot. Cash only. Waste of $10 read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Super duper disappointed! Service by this employee was amazing! She cleaned all the tables and set up our table for us as 8 people! She was wonderful and so funny too! Dining room was clean and tidy because of her. The pizza is the only pizza place on the strip so of course it brings the hype and when you see others in the line for the demand, you join too! We have been wanting to try this place but every trip we make, the lines are too long. Bring from NY, this wasn't going to be my first rodeo. It missed the mark for me. There are no prices and a fountain drink is $5.33. What the heck. Okay then. I think we got 4 slices and 3 garlic knots and we paid about $44. Wouldn't mind if it were delicious but the first crispy bite was promising. It got soggy and hard from there. U got the chicken parm and I had to discard some of the chicken bc it was chewy. Not high quality ingredients in my opinion and it's CASH ONLY! I wouldn't return but hey, people seem to love it and they're never slow. Try it but I'll pass next time! read more

See all

Thin-crust pizza, delightfully crunchy, and loaded with ricotta, sautéed fresh mushrooms, and mozzarella. Cash-only policy a bit surprising, but they have sign posted prominently, plus an ATM machine conveniently near the cashier. But you have to ask yourself: is this slice twice as good as anyplace else? Is the utility equal to a whole Costco pizza? I hereby leave a rating reflecting an inability to determine whether to be positive about the pizza or negative about the rest of the experience. read more

Pizza Time - Mushroom white slice, $9.75 + tax - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida