Best pizza we've had in years! The Grandma slice is similar to a Margherita but with garlic. Margherita was delicious also, we got two slices each to go and we ended up eating them in-store as they were hot and smelled so good. We were just passing through the area so it was a pleasant surprise. The staff was nice and they had many types of slices ready to go at the front. Will def stop by whenever we're in the area read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - Delicious "Grandma's" & Margherita slices - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Food-great. Would definitely recommend and visit again. North Jersey style pizza locally owned and operated. I would be willing to bet you will not be disappointed if you try this establishment for your pizzas/italian style food options. read more

This is a great Pizza spot that offers more than Pizza. Large portions. Food is always hot and fresh! Called 10 minutes before close. They took my order and were amazing! Friendly service and good vibes read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

First time here. When we enter the place we were grated by Anthony. We ordered a pepperoni pie. 100% recommend this place. Great service. Pizza was delicious, really good place and ambiance. read more

See all

I'm back again! Whenever I go to FL I come here! Good service, great food but I always get the pizza! This time they now make a 'razor thin' crust. I have no idea how it isn't hard like a cracker. It's soft and wonderful! lol read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - 2pieces thin crust sausage and pepperoni! Yum!!! - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The food was great eggplant rooting! Service was spot on. The ambiance looks like a great pizza place. read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - Bar dining - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

had eggplant parm and the eggplant was so thin it was more batter than eggplant no flavor at all very bland even the sauce, chicken parm meat so dry and hard !! Chicken with broccoli rabi same dry and thin. read more

So glad we stopped here! The food is absolutely delicious and tastes authentic. Huge portions, fair prices, and a great atmosphere. If you want real Italian food without the tourist trap feel, go to Romano's. read more

See all

From Boston n tried many pizza places n enjoyed. This place was the best... delicious.Awesome service ..place so clean. My biggest point is, I went in as a Stranger n left feeling like family . read more

The food was awful and I have absolutely no vendettas towards the owners or staff. This place claims to be authentic Italian but at best, they are so below sub par, that I need to warn the owners and the patrons too. To the owners, why don't you get an Italian cook book or a chef that knows and understands what it takes to make Italian dishes. I ordered the spaghetti white clam dinner...I had to search the dish for the clams even though they did garnish with THE SMALLEST clams in shells, but there still were no clams to speak of in my plate $20. The absolute worst was that that plate had zero taste, it was so bad that I had to open the grated cheese container and put the entire contents into my plate and it STILL HAD NO FLAVOR! They claim to come from North New Jersey. I had lived in New Jersey for 30 years and New York combined and I am 3rd generation Italian, I know my heritage dishes. My companions had complaints too, one had the broccoli rabe with sausage and the sausage was burned so badly. My husband had the chicken parm, it was ok but he asked for more sauce, they brought what was no more than a 1/4 cup, the waitress never informed us that there would be a charge of $1.40!!! The receipt to justify their desperation lists it as "1 LARGE - Extra Marinara. A bottle of house wine with a twist top which we opened ourselves, $42 and it wasn't even good. My other companion, was up all night with a stomach ache after consuming their eggplant rollatini! The owner boasts about the food, she has got to be kidding! The only patrons of this establishment are most likely people that do not care or know what authentic Italian food really tastes like. I tell you that the inside has 3 sections, pizzeria, dining room, bar/lounge/booths...not a bad set up for horrible food. read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - The $42 bottle of twist top wine. - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

So glad we stumbled upon this pizza place tucked in the corner of the plaza. Apparently they took over from the previous owners, remodeled, and just reopened in February. We don't live in St Augustine but we'll definitely come back to this place whenever we're out here for the beach. Margarita pizza was light and delicious with a crisp crust. The meatballs app was juicy and the sauce was light. Sooo good. My husband doesn't even really like meatballs and he ate them. Wish I took a photo but we ate receiving too fast:) Dining area was clean and comfortable. Lovely music playing. What's not to love about this place. read more

Elite pizza. Got a cheese pizza and it didn't disappoint. I eat pizza about 5 times give or take within a year and I'm glad to say this scratched the itch. Great service and cool environment inside. Will come back fasholy. read more

Food is alway cooked to perfection. pizza always hot and tasty. Services this provided by LORI,excellent as usual. two dining room one pizza side and one old world. Great place to EAT! ray &dory S read more

As we recently moved here after many years, my search has ended for a pizza place equaling back north. I stopped the other day on a whim to try one plain slice on the takeout side and spoke with a young and very nice family member, tried the slice and came back the next day with my wife to dine in the restaurant. He seen us, came out and promptly greeted us, love the GREAT attitude. Anyway we shared a Chicken Marsala dinner which was outstanding and best I've ever had. Also shared a Margherita Pizza which was great. The crust and sauce often make the pizza and wow they did as well as the cheese and basil. I just had 2 leftover slices this morning. Atmospheric, service were very good and prices very reasonable. What made us even happier is we understand they're opening a smaller place over at St Augustine Beach which is very close to us. Romano's keep up the good work. read more

If you want some of the best pizza you've ever had, come to Romano's and taste the magic that Brian (the Pizza chef) creates. He is always there in the back with a smile whipping something up. The dough is perfectly crispy on the outside with soft dough in the middle- cooked to perfection. read more

First time trying this place. This pizza was terrible. The crust wasn't cooked, the cheese was not even melted on the pizza. It cost me 35 to have it delivered and I dumped it. Never going back read more

Delicious, handmade, and fresh! One of our favorite Italian spots in St Augustine! Highly recommend. read more

This is the Cheers of Italian restaurants/bars! Every pizza, Italian dish, salad, app and dessert is served as if you are family! Quality food for fair prices and comfortable atmosphere! Every server goes above and beyond to make you feel welcomed! read more

Dinner was amazing here tonight and not just because of Valentines Day. We eat here often mainly the pizza but tonight we switched it up and the baked Ziti and Expresso Martinis were amazing and i definitely can't forget the homemade split pea soup. read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - Expresso Martini - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Food was terrible, meatball appetizer was so hard, ricotta was in a plastic cup. Bar pizza, sausage tasted like pork sausage was luke warm. The server Ava F was horrible! Waited forever for our drinks, I ordered a melbac wine and she brought me a beer. So slow, no urgency at all. When she brought the bill the beer was still on the bill. Had a 10% on the entire bill but because of happy hour, we would have to pay for both beers to use the coupon. Won't be back!!! read more

We had a pizza, and were able to customize it with 1/2 of one kind and 1/2 of another kind. The waitress, who's name started with a J, was absolutely fabulous and extremely courteous. The salad was fresh and I really wanted to try the pasta but was just too full. I would highly recommend this restaurant! read more

We're making the rounds to find the best pizza in St Augustine and Romano's Pizza and Restaurant was next on our list. We only tried the pizza and the stromboli and antipasto for take away, not the restaurant, in this review. Overall we enjoyed the meal. I thought the Grandma pizza knocked it out of the park, loved it. Crust was fairly crisp but the cheese, sauce, and spices were totally on point. My daughter loved the pepperoni stromboli, thought it was the best one she'd ever had. The antipasto was very good, but we've had better and that may just come down to personal taste. The house dressing was excellent. Surprisingly, our son just didn't care for the sausage and pepperoni pizza. I did not try it myself but he wouldn't finish it, and he loves pizza. I wish I had a better explanation other than he's a typical moody thirteen year old boy. It did look good. Staff were very friendly on the phone and at pickup. Here's a tip - they will ask you if you are calling their specific location because there is another pizzeria with the same or similar name in the region, and people have mixed them up resulting in orders that were not picked up. It's not a big deal and they only do it with new customers (they must save your info in their system for future calls) so just be ready for it. Tip # 2 - The restaurant is on the right, but the pizzeria is on the left. Go into the door in the far left. In between the two entrances is another door with a sign pointing to the right, where the restaurant is. But the restaurant doesn't open until evening so the door will be locked if you are there earlier in the day for pizza. Head left, and you'll quickly see the entrance. We would order again for the Grandma and stromboli, and I'd like to try the Italian food in the restaurant, so we'll likely be back. read more

See all

Good food! Good service. Reasonably priced. Having to use 85 characters is ridiculous. I will keep me from commenting in the future.

Legit pizza for Florida. Has the NY style. Crust stood out to me. Nice place to go get a za and pitcher of beer. Nice people offering great service. read more

We used go here often. I'm not sure if they sold the business but the service was terrible. Our pizza had the wrong toppings and the ceasar salad was a joke. And the bill was $80.00, definitely not returning. read more

Really bad pizza. very bad lasagna. Perhaps cooks or management have changed? Usually our go to place for Italian but will not be going back. read more

We stopped in for some pizza and cannoli's. The service was great and personable. We loved the pizza with ricotta and veggies. Ended up coming back multiple nights for late night cannolis. Highly recommend. read more

Been going to Romanos for years. It a nice local business. The pizza is always great. Service is good.

Good food. Friendly staff. Love the environment:) Me and my boyfriend try to go once a week because it's so good! Our server Maria (I believe) is wonderful read more

We've been to Romanos before and I remember not being too impressed, but we tried it again because we wanted to give it another shot and I was craving some Alfredo. I was with my husband and 8 year old. My daughter wanted Alfredo and I was told they couldn't make it in a kid size (pretty much every restaurant I've been too will make it) she said we could get a small which was $14. I'm not paying $14 for my 8 year olds meal. So I got a large for us to share. My husband got a calzone and I will say it was one of the better if not best calzone I've ever had. Our waitress was okay. There was only two other tables she was serving in the whole restaurant and I felt like they got a lot of visits back to the table and she barely waited on us. A man who I'm assuming was the owner talked to the other tables and asked how they were doing, but ignored our table. Not sure if the others were just regulars, but it felt like we were ignored. Their fried ravioli as an appetizer was mediocre along with the Alfredo which I probably could've made better at home. If you're going here stick to pizza and calzones and take out is probably best. read more

We have always driven a half hour in order to get Romanos food. There are plenty of Italian restaurants closer by but Romanos was worth the drive. Their pizza was excellent, New York style. Last night we placed an order for pick up. I did not look inside the box before paying. When we got home and open the box we were very surprised. The pizza was flat, thin, one slice had no cheese and no toppings. We called the restaurant and explained to the woman that perhaps she gave us the wrong box. She said "that is hand tossed, that's right." I messengered Romanos last night and have received no answer. I will be calling them today to see if I could get a hold of the owner. We took photos of the pizza and saved two pieces, one of which contains no cheese and no toppings. I don't think the owner is aware of what goes on in his absence read more

See all

Service is impeccable, always a smile and appreciation for being there and pizza never disappoints! Cheese is fresh and flavorful.

Romano's is delicious and always consistent. I love their garlic knots and Alfredo! Their food always comes out hot and on time!

I would have given 5 stars if I could have found the cheese on my Supreme pizza. GrubHub delivered it hot and so far the most traditional flavorful pizza we've found in St Auggie. The crust was the desired crisp/chewy we love. Toppings and sauce delicious. Threw in an order of fried ravioli. Garlicky and almost crisp with a rich tomato dipping sauce. Hubby's pepperoni and anchovy was really tasty but the toppings were sparse. We feel that a small 12" pizza for almost $20 each could have some decently generous toppings. Still, the best local pizza so far. read more

Ordered chicken piccata- chicken kinda on the tough side and rubbery & not enough piccata sauce for my taste. Caesar salad was disappointing - I don't like dressing on the side for Caesar salads & the amount of dressing 'on the side' provided, wasn't enough. Never could find the waitress to ask for more. read more

Wow. I am speechless. Say goodbye to Carrabba's. Say goodbye to Olive Garden. This family owned and operated restaurant has so many wonderful things to write about I don't even know where to begin. I've always loved Romano's pizza. My friend and her parents are from New Jersey so they are very particular about their pizza. They LOVE Romano's and order all the time. So, I knew their pizza was good, but I had never dined in and had any other meal with them. Boy was I missing out. I took my mother here for dinner yesterday. We sat in a comfortable booth and were greeted by our wonderful waitress Sheila--warm bread in hand by the way. The bread was served with olive oil and balsamic vinegar dipping sauce. So good! I ordered the Alfredo and my mother had the Marsala. Both were exquisite. The Alfredo was so creamy and fresh and the chicken Marsala so tasty! Such big portions that we both had leftovers for lunch/dinner today. I knew I had to try their cannolis. Gosh they were so good. My mom had the bananas foster cheesecake with a Creme Brûlée top. She said it was amazing! I'll be dreaming about this place until the next visit. The service was wonderful, the food was to die for, and the menu was great for any diet. Please go support this local business! read more

Very poor customer service when calling for delivery. Rude and made us feel like we were an inconvenience. Will never return.

Placed an order for 4 pizzas at 3:50pm asking to be delivered at 5:15pm. Told it wouldn't be a problem. Didn't come until 535pm and was cold. Also ordered one speciality pizza w Broccoli Rabe and they put spinach not Rabe. read more

On walking in I was greeted by a friendly and professional waitress I'd had on a couple occasions before, but she said she was working a different room tonight. The waitress I got was either inexperienced or wished she were somewhere else. My "seafood pasta" was tasty, but unremarkable. I think I'm going to revert to Casa Benedetto. It's pricier, but the servers are consistently super-attentive. read more

We visited Romano's at lunch time for slices of pizza: we had the eggplant parmesan, the chicken sausage and a white pizza with ricotta all were excellent the spicing on the chicken sausage was a little strong but delicious and the garlic knots were a little dense and chewy but delicious as well! Also the waitress was one of the nicest I've ever had in any restaurant so I will definitely be back to try more items! read more

Romano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - Desserts Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida