Yes you can still buy slices somewhere!! So shocked to find pretty darn good pizza in this old outlet mall's kinda/sorta food court!! Was on a bad date and was starving so went inside out of desperation to avoid her. Saw this pizza and noticed quickly it is that good pizza parlor type pizza typically found in NY. Been back a few times and have had regular, Sicilian and spinach. All good. All really good. Good guys working there too. Take pride in what they are doing. And normal prices!! And not trying to overdue the pizza so they can overcharge like other pizza places these days. There are other pizza places nearby but to me there is no comparison. read more

Great NY Style in of all places a mall food court. Combo slice deal with drink was about $7. read more

Rufino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great New York style pizza! Prices are about the same as every other pizza place around. Very easy to order online. We got the cheese and "the special". read more

I liked my companion's chicken parmigiana calzone best (I just had one bite), followed by my pepperoni pizza (good for the first bites in the center, less good in the less-dense outer part of the pizza), followed by the pepperoni calzone (still pretty good, but a bit rich with all that pepperoni). For those three items, two small sodas, and a free water we paid $22-something. It's a decent choice in the food court which I'd use again. 3-4 stars. It seems to be the only restaurant still open in the food court at the Premium Outlets. read more

Really, really good NY styles pizza. From a food court? YES! straight up it's my favorite in the area. PS I lived in New York for eight years. read more

These other reviewers must be on something to say this is great or even good pizza. I'd like to know what they are smokin'. Ordered a pie with the dough still pale and half raw underneath. Maybe this place was 'ok' at one time, but today. Forget about it!! Don't waste your money. Plus, the prices are ridiculous for what you actually get. Being born and raised in NYC, THIS is not Brooklyn, NY pizza. I'm sure these folks are hard working here, but the pizza, 1 star. read more

Great pizza , awesome customer service from the staff. This was my first time ordering from Rufino's and it didn't disappoint. I placed my order over the phone and the time I was told the pizza would be ready, they were ready and waiting for me and my team. I will order from them again. read more

Rufino's Pizza - Store front - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

If I'm around the outlets shopping, I usually stop by for a slice or two of pizza. I feel like it is under rated, maybe because of the location or because it is in a food court but regardless, it is great pizza. read more

Rufino's Pizza - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Best pizza in North Florida. Thin and crunchy. Drive 45 minutes just to have this pizza.

Very thin and crispy cracker crust, exactly the way I like it. I wasn't expecting to like the slice so much but it's really one of the better slices in the area. Definitely recommend if you like NY style pizza. read more

Rufino's Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Delicious pizza pie. Great tasting garlic knots. Pizza is always fresh. We have been many times and never disappointed.

Their pizza is tasty, crust is perfect and prices are reasonable. This is now my must go place for pizza whenever I'm in St. Augustine

Pizza is out of this world, Joe the pizza maker makes fantastic pizzas and pretty fast as well. Prices are way too high for just a slice of pizza but well worth it. It would be a 5 if they brought their prices down like how they used to be. read more

I was really impressed by this place. The food court is not very inviting but decided to give it a try and yep...worth it! The pizza was awesome and the garlic knots...OMG! We had the one with ricotta cheese!!! Yummy! Will go back again for sure. read more

Ambiance 0, pizza 10, service 10, outlet mall location, so what if food is great and fresh

Some of the best pizza around this part of Florida. Hidden gem at the outlet food courts. They do pizza by the slice or pies. The regular pizza is good but the grandma slice is a 10! Can't wait to be back. read more

Rufino's Pizza - Grandma - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Took me 57 years, but I finally did it!!! I found the BEST PIZZA in the world!!! Don't waste your money on another hum-drum pizza!! Check out Rufino's!! I know I'm going back very soon!!! read more

Nyc pizza without the airfare! I'm from nyc and this is real deal, in fact, better than most nyc pizza, easily the best I've had in fl. They use the great ingredients: grande mozz, Stanislaus tomatoes, all trumps flour. dough is fermented overnight and tastes fabulous. This place is worth seeking if you're from nyc or just want to taste what nyc pizza is all about. bravo! read more

I called in order for pickup. Went to Refino's, they're located in the Outlet Mall at the food court, to pick up my order. They told me 20 minutes, but I showed up about 10 minutes early. There were two people working, both very friendly. The person making the pizzas was clearly working very diligently. The young man, helping, was assisting and taking orders. We ordered three pizzas, Hawaiian, mushroom and onion and a pepperoni. They were done New York style. They only serve one siza, XXLarge or what you'd consider family. We played $70.00 for the order. This is not for those looking for a bargain. The taste was very good. The whole family enjoyed the pizzas. Everything tasted fresh and the dough was obviously homemade, nothing frozen. The sauce was okay, but the cheese was not the cheap stuff other pizza parlors use. They do serve by the slice if you want to give them a shot. I definitely recommend them. read more

This is a good little pizza joint in the middle of the outlets. We stopped in for a quick bite because we were shopping and my nephew got hungry. Pizza is one of the things he will pretty much always eat so this was a good option. The line wasn't too long and it went by fairly fast. You order your slice of pizza, calzone, or other items and they throw it in the oven to warm. By the time you pay it is warm and you are on your way. The pizza looked good, greasy, but what pepperoni pizza isn't? My sister and I also got these little pinwheel things with ham and pepperoni rolled into pizza dough. It was small but just enough to hold us over until dinner. The prices are decent, especially since there are limited options in the mall. I would return if I were shopping and wanted a quick bite. read more

Over three years coming here while traveling thru and the pizza is still amazing! Fresh, delicious and authentic NYC style pizza. Don't be fooled just because it's in a 'food court', you don't want to pass it up. read more

Rufino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

I think maybe it was the owner or a manger but he was soooo so so kind. My friend and I got pizza here and we decided to get an order of the garlic rolls and it comes with 3 garlic rolls and I was willing to let my friend have 2 and myself just 1 but we got to my car to eat and we open up the box and he put two garlic rolls in each of our box and I thought it was the sweetest and kindest thing ever :') it truly made my day. I love the food here, I always look forward to it when I shop at the outlets. read more

Food court at the outlet stores? You're kidding, right? Wrong. Get ready for a surprise. This place has AWESOME New York style pizza. I know; I lived in NYC and grew up near it. This is the real deal. By the slice, no less. I'm not the only one who thought so, either. One member of my party -- ex Hoboken -- took a couple of slices home for a worker-bee spouse. How is all this possible? Check it out: The proprietor is from Brooklyn. Will definitely be coming here again. Possibly ordering ahead for pizza to take to the beach, etc. Worth coming to even if you hate the outlets! read more

Rufino's Pizza - Counter in the food court. - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

I honestly didn't believe the other reviews comparing this pizza to NY pizza. So I gave it a try myself and I'm glad I did. This pizza has been the closest I've found to the pizza up north. Delicious. Can't believe they are in this dinky food court lol, they would definitely be successful with a full storefront! read more

Great pizza in a food court? Didn't think it was possible. But just had a slice of the grandma's pizza. A nice thick corner with the perfect blend of sauce and cheese. Crispy and perfectly seasoned. This pizza is worth taking a drive to an outlet mall and skipping the shopping for. read more

1 star is all I need to say, price, quality, and customer service experience isl not worth the experience

When at the outlets take some time and have lunch at this location. It is also a great place to stop and sit for a bit since it is midway in the outlet. Very good pizza and I love the sauce. The chairs are not comfortable but that is not the restraints fault but the outlets. If you need just a small bit you can do that as well but be ready for big pizza slices. read more

Hidden Gem. Go get a cheese pie. Everything is Always perfect.Dough has the correct amount of salt, chew, crispy,perfect.

Decent pizza for the area. Seems hard to find pizza around the world of golf area. Sold by the slice and they are big and filling. I'd come back and try some more. I'd like to try the calzones or the Stromboli at some point. The garlic knots are decent too. read more

Rufino's Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Ok got a pizza here Tuesday night. Today is Thursday. Ordering another pizza. Simply excellent!!! read more

I moved to The Jax area (St johns county) a year ago from Long Island New York, wasn't expecting the pizza to be great but then I discovered this place! Tastes just like New York and they have great garlic knots. My brother had talked to the owner and he is from Long Island! I heard he worked at mother Teresa's in garden city New York. If you are in the area and are debating between this place and pizza time, I would say just go with this place, although pizza times pizza might be better, this place is much more quiet (it's in the outlet food court) and its free parking unlike pizza time. read more

My family and I were out shopping and my 4 year old was hungry. As soon as we walked into the food court and I saw Pizza I knew where we were going. My son is a typical 4 year old, he loves a couple of different foods and wants them all the time. Pepperoni pizza is one of those things my son can not get enough of. Usually food court food isn't all that wonderful however this pizza was actually very good looking. The slice was quite large and my son ate the entire piece even the crust!. The pizza was a little greasy, but what pepperoni pizza isn't. I also ordered my sister and I these pepperoni and ham rolls. They were very tasty and was a nice snack to hold us over until dinner. We ordered our items and while we waited to pay the food was heated in the oven. By the time it was my turn to pay the food was hot and we were on our way. The service was fast and the employees were pleasant. It was a good place to stop for a snack. read more

My family and I were on vacation and came across this place online, and decided to give it a shot because we saw in the reviews that the pizza is just like New York pizza. I've gone to New York a few times and I really missed the pizza from there so I thought, "why not?". This pizza definitely exceeded all my expectations!! I will definitely be coming back anytime I'm in town! This place is a must for all pizza lovers! read more

We pulled off of I-95 on our way back home from Disney World to grab a quick bite. Thanks to you we found this place in a food court of all places. It is, hands down, the best pizza I have ever eaten. I highly recommend. read more

Had Grandmas and Pepperoni. Delicious and great New York and thick crust. Will definitely be back.

Good cheese pizza and garlic knots. Better than Sbarro. Their marinara is very good. Nice little family run business.

For years, the pizza was impeccable; however, such quality food cannot compensate for incompetence. For several years, Ruffino's pizza had one manager that was quite efficient and respectful towards his customers. The staff was also quite small to avoid confusion in regards to orders posed by customers. It is until now that the status quo has been broken. A terrible manager and excessive employee base has defiled this restaurant. I've ordered here and my order hasn't been expedited while several customers after me (whereas I've already paid) have their food distributed. Customers who were in the line had their orders quickly given to them even when they haven't paid and still, my food wasn't given to me. But what was absolute insolence was the fact that when I were to receive my pizza, an employee -who promised that my order was ready- took my order and gave it to another customer. There were no apologies given, I furiously took my money back. Until now Ruffino's was a good place to eat at the outlet mall at St. Augustine; however, I advise otherwise since management has taken a turn for the worse and employee competence is nonexistent. read more

Born and raised in New York and i have to say this is by far the best pizza you can get in saint augustine. If you live near the outlets you need to try this place! The owner is hysterical and the pizza is delicious, 5/5 star read more

Overall, good tasting pizza. The last thing I would think that an outlet would have good food. Not a bad price for a slice and the two guys were friendly, quick, and nice. I would eat there again. read more

Honestly the best pizza I tried in St. Augustine. I am looking to move here from NY and have been visiting frequently. I tried Carmelo's, Pizza Time and Rufino's. Rufino's slices are by far the best and taste just like NY pizza. I will 100% return. read more