The Antico Pizza is one of the best pepperoni pizza we have ate. We make it a point to eat somewhere different each night on vaca but we keep asking our selves "we should go back to Piesanos!" Little pricey for a pizza but wow it was delicious. The girls had pasta meals and loved them. Will be back!!! read more

Another great meal with great service in this cute casual dining. They never fall short of anything. The food is always great. The service is always spot on and the prices are very reasonable for the portions you get. Been here several times already everything we have ever ordered has been perfect. read more

See all

Phenomenal! We drove 30 minutes to try this stone fired pizza and it was absolutely worth it! The complimentary rolls that they give you are drizzled with a balsamic dressing and are delicious! We shared a pizza...his half was meat eater and mine was the antico (add ricotta). When I tell you this was the BEST pizza we have had in a looong time I mean it! The crust was perfect, the flavor of the sauce was so good and the cheese pull was superb! To add a cherry on top our service was wonderful! Definitely a must try, we will be back! A+++ read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Half Antico (add ricotta), half Meat Eater - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We ordered a large to go pizza while spending the week in St Augustine. It was very easy to place an order. The pizza was ready when promised and best of all was the tasty crust filled with toppings. read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We often vist for the great Pizza and Calzone, we had a less than awesome experince and Jorge made it right and was super about it. But the real treat was our next visit with Julianna smile and warm welcome and really knows how to make a customer feel special. Jorge worked his magic and we left thinking we need to come here more. For the best Pizza and Calzone in St Augustine visit them and see how dinning should be. read more

We had a great experience today at lunch. The food was hot, fresh and came out fast. The cannoli's were delicious. They were accommodating for our small dog on the patio and even turned the heaters on for us. Craven was our waiter and he was so kind and attentive, we definitely recommend coming here! read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Margarita Pizza Lunch combo Spicy Rigatoni Alla Vodka - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We in the past have loved this place, food generally is great and the dinner rolls are amazing. HOWEVER, tonight we had a reservation, walked in and I said hello to the hostess with a smile, absolutely NO response from her, she just looked at us with no response, no emotion, no smile just a blank stare, she then said "can I help you" she actually made me feel very uncomfortable and we thought about leaving. First impression of a place is the first face you see, she FAILED miserably. Bright spot was our server, very sweet, seemed over worked, her sections were all over the place, she was definitely working her butt off and remained very professional and sweet. read more

Thanks Piesanos for a great meal and wonderful service. Our waitress, Brianna was so cheerful and took care of everything we needed. The restaurant had plenty of tables and can handle large crowds. We saw quite a few parties of 6 plus people. I was a little worried because of the large crowds that our food would take a while, but it was delivered in a decent amount of time. The food was hot and great tasting. Delicious read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green olives, and extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Had lunch here to celebrate my daughters graduation! We were a group of 12pp. I have to say the service was amazing, the food was delicious and the restaurant has great ambiance. My daughter loves the food here and to celebrate her big day here was perfect. I do wish we had taken more pictures of the food . I would definitely recommend for anyone to stop by and check it out. read more

Chicken Parmesan delicious. House rolls oh my gosh so good. Large pizza called the captain. Very good. The pizza is a solid nine out of 10. Old-fashioned was good but a little too sweet. I'd still give it an 8. read more

See all

As always the food was amazing. We had a margarita pizza and spaghetti with meatballs. Emily was such a sweet and effective server. She made certain we had a great experience. The dining room was very clean and it was nice and quiet. read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Spaghetti Marinara - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The garlic sticks, ceasar salad, meatball and antico pizza were excellent. We really enjoyed all the food.

Take out Chicken Piccata was the best ever!!! I have not been able to eat much lately but I cleaned my plate--it was so good!

Still waiting for the Manger or the owner to reach out to my friend that had a b day party for her husband almost 2 week's ago. The manger agreed that the staff and the party was ran pretty unprofessional and was gonna follow up and apologize to my friend and maybe give her a discount. But after telling me he would call he's yet to do so. Then I called the other day and they hung up on me the place is so unprofessional and ive had it with being nice to the so unprofessional staff. I hear the same owner owns all of them ive yet to hear from him obviously they dont care about customer service and making and keeping a customer. Totally unprofessional read more

We were visiting the area and found this restaurant on Yelp! So glad we did. Pizza was delicious and service was great!

Tried Piesanos for the first time and overall enjoyed it. The restaurant itself is clean with plenty of seating and our server was friendly and attentive. I had their Italian Veggie pizza which was delicious and better than I expected it to be. The only thing I didn't care for was the bread rolls, which is hard to say because of how much I love bread. But they mix something in with the oil (I think balsamic vinegar?) and cover the bread which gives it an acidic taste that is just not good in my opinion. I've never had that at an Italian restaurant before and I think for good reason. I think a better option would be to serve it on the side and let people dip the bread or avoid it. All in all not a big issue but definitely worth mentioning. Would go back for the pizza regardless. read more

See all

The food was ok. Pizza hurts my stomach anymore so I ordered fettuccine Alfredo. It was ok. The pizza my daughter had was pretty greasy but no complaints from her. Pictures attached of additional friends joining us for dinner read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Their complimentary rolls - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Awesome pizza!! We are so excited to have finally found a great pizza place in St.Augustine! We're new to the area and have tried a few others that always disappoint. We loved the food, price & customer service. read more

We don't like, pizza and pasta not good :( take lot time and the pasta arrive with out the chicken. never again.

Food was delicious and delivery quick! Got the bolognese lasagna and Caesar salad. Servings small but not disappointing

This is our favorite place ever. We always make sure that when we are in the area we stop in. We made a point this trip to try new things during our visit. We weren't disappointed with any options we had. We tried the lunch special personal pizza, siracha hot honey pizza and the ravioli for the 15th anniversary. Everything was amazing and the service is always top notch. Can't wait to come back again. read more

See all

One of our favorite go-to restaurants. Consistently good food and service. Pizzas and pastas are very good. They also have a great cauliflower pizza option that doesn't taste like cauliflower. read more

visiting St. Augustine and found Piesano's on the internet search. what a find! it is heir 15th year anniversary...wish them many more...and they have a few specials. one is a Lasagna Pizza! oh yeah! Ricotta and seasoned ground meat, sauce, and more cheeses! the crust was crispy on the bottom but tender chewy on the rest! Or pizza came to the table quickly! It was hot and looked amazing! we ate on the patio as we brought our 6# Yorkie with us. Even though we were out doors, our waitress kept checking on us. the husband enjoyed the beer selections too. if and when we return to Florida, I will search out Piesano's. They are only in Florida for now! read more

See all

A Family Tradition! We love making the trip from Jacksonville every year to visit this amazing spot! The calamari is always incredibly fresh, the drinks are top-notch, and the food is simply outstanding! The whole family looks forward to our annual visit, and we're never disappointed. The quality and service are consistently exceptional! If you're a great food lover like us, or just looking for a great dining experience, this place is a MUST-VISIT! *Highly recommended!* read more

Atmosphere was great, really cute decor. Service was fantastic, our waitress Emily was patient and friendly. There was a slight problem with the food, for example the broccoli was spoiled a bit and after telling our waitress they fixed it and apologized. Pasta was a little bland and tasted of just oil. Other than that I would recommend this restaurant. Just dont get the shrimp scampi.. read more

Never had a disappointing meal here! The Caesar salad is perfection. The spaghetti and meatballs are perfect. Lasagna cannot be beat. Honestly, I've never had better rolls in my life. Hands down and over and over again, 11/10 experience, start to finish. read more

The waitresses at this place is the worst ever!! This was 12-6-25 around 9 . I understand it's a high class place but come on. She didn't ask if we wanted refills or dessert nothing. Then came out to argue about her little tip! She was the worse waitress and a big B**** , also rude as hell at any restaurant I have ever been to I do not recommend anyone going here ever read more

Always get good pizzas here. The service is always great too never have to wait too long. Some of the best pizza around! read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Italian veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Food is great, the staff is always amazing, we love going to eat there, and their cannolis are sooooo good!

The food is always delicious and the service is one of the best here in St Augustine! Piesanos is my Italian cuisine destination that always delivers to my best expectations. I highly recommend read more

Best gorgonzala salad I have ever had and the rolls just melt in your mouth. Pizza is also delicious.

Glad we found this place and we're not disappointed. Nice open seating concept with outdoor patio as well. Very nice menu selection with many pizza combinations to choose from or build your own. Very nicely done pasta dishes as well. The "garlic" knots were heavy in garlic and lite and fluffy. read more

See all

Always had good food here but the eggplant Parmesan today was almost inedible. I couldn't even cut the eggplant with a fork and barely with a knife. Eggplant was paper thin and tough. Mainly breadcrumbs. Really bad. read more

Food is always good, our server Lizzie is the BEST!!! Always makes sure we have everything we need and keeps our drinks full !!! We love this Piesano's location, one of our favorite places for pizza too !!! We dine in often , and love bringing family here when they're in town visiting us , they love it too !!! I highly recommend this place and be sure to ask for Lizzie read more

I have been here several time. I've even ordered for my job. But this time was completely different. The pizza was not cooked correctly. It was pale on the bottom. The sauce tasted way different and just the overall look of the pizza was not appealing. I spent over 50.00 on a pizza and wings that was horrible. We even put it in the air fryer to see if maybe it would be crispy and cooked. Nope still bad. I am so disappointed with the food. It was just bad. I dont know if they have another pizza maker but that was the worst pizza I have ever had. read more

We love pizza. Piesanos has been hit or miss for us in some places, but this store in St. Augustine is the best wood-fired pizza in the city. Service Is very good here. Food quality is better than other Piesanos. Prices are high though. read more

They need to work on the crust, No pizza should the cheese mushrooms and red peppers slide off the crust.

My favorite in town! Best pizza and always great service! Easy pick up and dine in. Excellent desserts too!

We were doing a little holiday shopping and happened to stumble across this pizza place. Fortunately for us, they were not too busy and were able to accommodate us pretty quickly. We had the cheese pizza, my personal favorite kind of pizza, and their rigatoni bolognese. Overall, the food and service was good and may come again to try other items on their menu. read more

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine - Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

worst place ever i will never go there again SCAM charge me for pizza that i wate for hour and still no pizza i told them i will not wait any longer cancel my order and they refuse to give me refund read more