Just want to tell you about an absolutely horrible experience we had at this restaurant Came in with our family of 5 Ordered Salad 10 piece boneless wings - 2 flavors came out lukewarm warm 10 piece wings - 2 flavors came out cold 10 piece wings - 2 flavors came out cold 10 piece wings - 2 flavors asked for well done came out cold Kids meal came out like warm We told the server she was like no worries I will have them remade. Our 13 year old realized he made a mistake and wanted boneless instead of classic and asked since she was having them remade if he could get them boneless, she said yes. When we got our new wings 1 set of 10 came right warm not hot. The classic she had changed to boneless came in flavors no one asked for. And the other set of boneless came in another set of flavors no one asked for We told her and she said said sorry but In the end we ended up eating and having to settle for the incorrect food. When she asked if we wanted a box she brought it to us. And end up taking the extra wings that were the wrong flavors anyways and trashing them so we couldn't take them home. And to top it off when we walked up to the restaurant 6 staff members were hanging out outside and when we left 6 were still hanging out outside including our server who just left us. Horrible experience would not recommend this place read more

Great food, friendly service, and a fun atmosphere. I ordered the House Special minus the veggies and it was loaded with meat, cheese, and flavor. The slice was huge and definitely hit the spot. My daughter had the kids meal, which was basically a cheese pizza on hoagie bread, and she cleaned her plate. The staff was welcoming, our food came out quickly, and the vibe inside made for a great place to sit down and relax. read more

See all

I love mellow mushroom pizza and the cloud 9 wings. Service is great! They say the crust has a bit of molasses in it! Back again today and want to add it would be nice to have a lemon slice in the iced tea. read more

I would have thought that Mellow Mushroom could have come up with a better response than "oh no". I can tell you that if I was responding to Yelp reviews as Mellow Mushroom, my response would have been immediate, please accept our apology, please come back and let us make it up to you with a free pizza. Just so you know, that ship sailed. I will never spend another dollar or recommend Mellow Mushroom to anyone. read more

Stopped at mellow mushroom and Saint Augustine saw Joe passing and we're like we need to eat there for dinner. I got a small pizza with dairy free cheese pepperoni and pineapple and my mom got a small cheese pizza with marinara. I also ordered a sprite and she ordered a Coke zero. I love the ambience of this mellow mushroom- so the inside of this mellow mushroom meets local living with funky art around state of Florida there is a giant triptych on the wall of like alligators dolphins surfers and ocean items there is a giant fossilized alligator on the wall; in the bar area there is like a Mural around the top talking about the Spaniards coming over and the Indians in Florida with a bunch of trippy mushroom drawings. No let's talk about the highlight of our meal our server was attentive, kind, and very nice. Sarah is phenomenal server; she needs a raise. She's amazing and very good. SARAH IS PHENOMENAL 100/100 read more

See all

We Love their pizzas and salads! I like that their food is consistent at the different franchise locations but they all have a lil twist on their menus. This location can be a little tough to get to though. They offer some good lunch deals and have trivia on Monday nights. It can get a little loud when it's busy. Still a great spot to hang out and kid friendly. read more

Delicious food, fast service, good beer selections on tap, and Monday night trivia! Thai dye pizza and honey sour Dogrose brewing are my favorites! Trivia starts at 7pm every Monday! read more

Hostess sat us in the way far corner. All windows were shut down. Felt very isolating. There really wasn't many people in the restaurant. The Bruschetta we ordered came with the topping already on top of the toast. Soggy, fell apart, too much balsamic vinegarette drizzle. Too wet. Pizza was great, love the crust at Mello Mushroom! Can someone explain, why do the serving staff disappear when you're ready for the bill? Then, once you've got the bill, if you're paying cash, you better have exact change, or you're waiting another 15 minutes. read more

Worst Mellow Mushroom. Ordered 2 different salads, spinach artichoke dip, wings, smash burger, tots and pizza rolls The dip was cold in the middle had to send back. Wings....they didn't have any. Smash burger.... fair. Asked for mustard brought back as eating the last bite. After others were finished, I hadn't received my food, Had to ask where the pizza rolls were. "Oh you did not get those"? Brought them to us and they were cold. Just looked at me ....I said here touch them. Then he agreed. Inquired about what the issue was and asked to see a manager. Waiter responds that all pieces need to work together. I commented that they were obviously not working together. Manager never came to our table. The place was relatively empty when we got there. We all ate in shifts as everything arrived that way. Absolutely pathetic service and no one cared! Will not return read more

Thought I left MM back at Saint Augustine! Yay! There's one next to my house! Now I can have all MM yummy over calories pizzas that are so amazing like the vegetarian Holy Shiitake anf Kosmic Karma yummy read more

I only stopped in here for a drink and an appetizer and it was good. There are drink specials and a happy hour. I just had a domestic draft beer served nice and cold. My wife and I split an order of the cheese bread. Enjoyed everything here. read more

Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine - Murabella - Full Bar - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We have ordered here over delivery apps about 3 times. Each time they have messed up the order. Just received our delivery today which had a salad made incorrectly and in the wrong size. Called the restaurant, manager said deal with it through Uber Eats, not their problem. Previous time we had a delivery, they completely forgot one of our pizzas. That time they actually fixed the problem and delivered us a new pizza. Not sure why they decided not to care today. read more

We do love this pizza so we cameback again! They are very busy, Saturday at 7:20 PM, 50 minutes waiting time. I ordered my strawberry lemon limeade, no alcohol but still strong so I mixed with half a glass of water and oh Boy, I am addicted. I love the great white pizza, that didn't come cut all the way through, I hope next time they do. My family decided on created their own pizza, pictures here. They do have live music on Saturdays after 5:00 pm, very nice very nice. We had a great time here today. read more

See all

Placed a to go order. Order was correct, well put together and made quickly. Haven't had a chance to dine in yet. read more

Trivia and amazing pizza's and pizza rolls! The restaurant was full of laughter and talking. The food came fast, and same as the drinks! This was my first time here, AMAZING!! read more

I like mellow mushroom, but they don't allow you to Apple Pay and they don't tell you that until the bill comes. Only them in Walmart. Stop being so cheap. read more

The worst service I ever had ... manger told me to kick rocks when my table was filled with garbage ..... wouldn't recommend.

Our server, Montana, was great, we had just a short wait. The house salad was delicious. The medium veggie pizza, regular crust, was excellent and enough for us to have leftovers for the next day. We'll be back soon. read more

Bartenders at the bar were horrible night of Jan 30 2026. slow, and not attentive at all, wasn't even very busy. They need better help behind the bar. Managing would go a long way. Food is always good. read more

Server, John, was fantastic the kitchen needs to be fixed and the bar tender is non existent!!!! This place will not last read more

Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine - Murabella - If you can't do it right why bother?! Mellomushroom get your kitchen in order!!! - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I just visited the Murabella location in St Augustine and ordered to go for the very first time and I was not impressed with the food portions. I ordered an Elevated Cobb salad and I waited 35 minutes for it which is not an issue for me. But when I received the salad, it was nothing like I expected as I paid close to $20 and it was a very small Portion for the price I paid, similar to a side salad from McDonald's which you pay only $6 for. I ordered a chicken add on I only received one small crumbled piece. The website picture for this item shows several slides of pieces of chicken that I was supposed to receive and I did not. . The staff was very friendly and I did inform them that I would not be visiting again as I can go next door to Zaxbys and receive and amazing high quality and larger portion of a Cobb salad for half the costs with many add one for less cost! The associate did not even offer to refund my order and I just walked out after kindly discussing my unhappiness. So I do not recommend Mellow Mushroom for any salads as they are cheap on their quantity and portion size such as chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, etc and for $19.90 with tax and approx. $2 tip, I should have received a better salad. I have attached picture of what my salad should have looked like from Mellow Mushrooms Website, and the salad I actually received, and the high cost of this small side salad when it should have been made with better quantity of food and a bigger portion size for the higher costs However, the location is very beautiful inside and the waitresses and bartenders are very nice. But again, I will not be visiting again nor ordering . read more

See all

Am at this restaurant right now. Simply asked for one small section of the Great White pizza to not have tomatoes for my granddaughter. Was told no not allowed by the kitchen manager. Are these pre made frozen pizzas? No, so what's the problem with leaving tomatoes off the equivalent of once slice? Will not be back. read more

Look, I'm a little shocked at this place's rating. My mom offered to have a sleepover with our kids so we went to Yelp and looked for a 5 star place for a date night. It was awful. On the way home we passed Mellow Mushroom and I was starving so we stoops in and the service was AMAZING. Sat down at the bar and Brian IMMEDIATELY looked at me and said "I'll be right with you darling". He talked to us about beer, we had the best pizza ever, he let me order beers and mix them (it's a thing I do), he talked to my husband about whiskey... we just wanted something in our stomach before we got home and instead were like 4 drinks deep and wondering why this place only has 3 stars on Yelp? Look, the location could be better. This intersection is awful. But the service and food is worth it to come here. Thank you Brian for turning our date night around. We'll be back to visit you next time grandma is willing to keep the kids overnight! read more

Rushed to open with very inexperienced staff particularly the kitchen team. Very slow food at peak times and wait staff routinely messes up credit card charges. Been twice due to other people choosing and had the same poor experience both times. I have spent almost 4 hours there and never saw a manager unless the place is being managed by an 18yo girl in Jean shorts. Will not be going back and have spoken to multiple neighbors in WGV with identical experiences and sentiments. People, you are not that hard up for pizza to be eating here! read more

We checked out the new restaurant in WGV as it opened last week. The service was very good and the pizza was great. We split a white pizza and I loved it. It was a very cool vibe with a nice bar also! read more

Have been soooo excited to have MM close to home now. Went Thursday night. 2-8-24 aroun 5:30pm. Was seated right away at a high top. Sat for 15 mins without 1 person coming to us. Never got a drink order or anything. Got up and left and let hostest know server never even came to our table... One walked by multiple times. Looked at us and even sat and talked to table next to us just chatting while we just sat. Horrible serves read more

I have been to many Mellow Mushrooms and this one definitely is one of the best ones. Especially for just opening. We sat at the bar and the service was great! Food came out in a timely manner and so good! Can't wait to become a regular ! read more

See all

We have been a few times. Nice bar. But the Food takes forever!!!!! Even when the place isn't crowded and the food is not worth the wait. Please add a real kids pizza to kids menu. read more

The food is good, but dang the service is always HORRIBLE at this location. We tried carryout this time because of how long it took to get our meal in the restaurant the last two (2) visits. The buger and pizza sat in the commercial warmer for 20 minutes because of a problem with the dressing for the ceasar salad? Wait, what? They let the warm food get soggy looking for ceasar dressing. Strike 3, MM. I'm sad. read more

Recently went in to check the place out. It just opened and I live right around the corner. This is not a food review as much as a service review. First of all, the place was packed. Parking lot full, SRO at entrance etc. We asked to sit at a high top and were seated right away. There was an abundance of staff (rare these days), and all were quite friendly. Our waitress came over, took drinks, explained the local menu (nice touch), etc, and then I watched her go to 4 more tables - none of which were near each other. Not sure how they divvy up zones, but apparently there are none. Seems like there's a way to make things easier for the staff. No issues with timeliness of order, or frequency of her visiting us- all was great. While sitting at our table, enjoying our food, watching some golf, a party of 18 (not a typo), walked in and wanted to set up an impromptu party. I watched 4 servers, and a manager do what they could to accommodate. They were able to sit down in under 30 minutes. During the process the staff were yelled at by multiple people in the party, wanting to know why it was taking so long. Then, when sat, argued further about the location. You just walked in. 18 of you. No heads up. And they accommodated you. Your behavior? Shocking. You should be ashamed. The staff never lost their cool. As merely a spectator to this debacle I wanted to step in and say a few NSFW words with the apparent ring-leader of the party, but I did not. Instead I thought I'd write this review instead. The food was as you expect for a Mellow Mushroom. The service? Far beyond expectations. Entire team acted like they'd been through the Ritz-Carlton training program (IFYKYK). Hat's off MM crew. I was thoroughly impressed (as was the couple behind me, who assumed party of 18 was all named Karen....or so their comments implied). Can't wait to go back. The service is impeccable. read more

Very little sauce and cheese seems to be what they do. Crust is good but they seem to skimp on everything else. This was a replacement pizza read more

Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine - Murabella - Replacement pizza. Same problem. Little sauce little cheese. No thanks. - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

With the new Mellow Mushroom now open, we thought we would give it a try Thursday before the dinner rush, arriving just before 5pm. We were seated promptly and gave our drink order while studying the menu. We opted for five sweet Thai-chili chicken wings and a small Cesar salad to start off. Then we moved onto a small Buffalo Chicken pizza and a small house special. With the limited crowd at the time our food arrived in a timely manner. Everything came out cooked properly & all quite tasty. The service was friendly & professional (I apologize for not remembering the lady's name). NOTE: Mellow Mushroom cuts their pizza into BIG slices...so ask the server to have the kitchen 'double cut' the pizza! read more

See all

OMG - This place has the BEST Bartender (Manager) EVER. She knows how to make the best drinks. If you are a Bloody Mary person , this is your place. read more

Why to slow. Why to loud. And they brought our pizza to the table next to us and didn't bother to move it or ask it was there's.

The pizza was amazing, and the bartender was awesome. I read some of the bad reviews and feel sorry for MM. Of course, not everyone is going to love this place, but it is a 6 star to me and my followers. We will definitely be back soon. read more

Talk about the best experience I've ever had at a mellow mushroom... Sarah claimed it was her first day serving alone . But you wouldn't have even noticed she had recommendations on the menu and told us about all of the specials they had! Sarah was an absolute blast! She comes with accents upon request and even knows sign language!!!!! How cool is that! I would highly suggest asking for Sarah if you choose to dine at this establishment, you will not regret it!!! I will for sure be stopping by the next time I'm in st Augustine! read more

Terrible service! The staff was rude and inattentive. We had to wait for ages to get our food. The staff said they were very busy but we didn't see that, the wait staff just disappeared and didn't return. We had to look for them and when we found them they still didn't care. I wouldn't recommend this restaurant d/t the amount of time we spent waiting. read more

We go to this location about once a week and have never had a bad experience. The food and service is always great! We also love that they have live music and trivia night. read more

Good service and excellent food A bit noisy but that was fine also Overall I enjoyed my visit with the restaurant And the service was great read more

I usually get a great fresh pizza from this place but today it was like a pizza from and arcade that has been sitting on a warmer all day. Very disappointed! Don let the pizzas set there all day then run it through the oven! I wanted that I would have went to the gas station for pizza! read more