NYC Meatballs was absolutely fantastic. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, the staff were incredibly friendly, and everything we ordered was delicious. We started with the caprese stack, which was unbelievably fresh and full of flavor. The fried garlic knots were one of the most unique things we tried all night - crispy, buttery, garlicky, and honestly addictive. For our main, we ordered the Hot Honey Hustle pizza and it was AMAZING. The combination of ricotta, hot honey, pepperoni, and spice worked so well together. Definitely one of those pizzas you immediately start craving again the next day. We also tried the chocolate cake and cannoli for dessert. They were so fresh and delicious. A huge shoutout to Faith behind the bar as well. The restaurant got extremely busy while we were there and she still stayed attentive, friendly, and upbeat the entire time. Overall, such a great experience. Amazing food, great service, and a really fun atmosphere. We'll absolutely be back. read more

Everything about the experience of this Restaraunt can be summed up to weird and awkward. The food was pretty good. I do think some things are priced weird in a high way. Like the meatball appetizer was good! However, someone I came with got the meatball sandwich. Why is the meatball appetizer $1 more than the meatball sandwich which comes with more meatballs, cheese, and on a hoagie??? Like make it make sense. Like if you want to enjoy meatballs order the sandwich pick off the bread and save yourself a $1. No you don't get the 2 other sauces but again make it make sense. Also, the staff were way weird. Like not only did I feel the waitress has no experience waitressing (not a big deal everyone stays somewhere) but it was like she had no experience going to a Restaraunt at all. We had to ask for drinks we had to ask for straws. She did offer refills but it was super awkward she kept trying to explain herself to us that she didn't know what to do because 3 of us need refills at 1 time. Like we understand you have 2 hands it's ok.... She decided she was going to get something and come back because she couldn't carry the three drinks so we said ok. 5 minutes later she comes out and tells us she is just going to have to refill 2 at a time if that's ok with us... what? It was like she felt bad she only has 2 hands and was apologizing to us over and over again that she could only refill 2 drinks at one time. So weird. Then, one of the members of our party ordered the chicken parm. It seemed like it is supposed to come to the table and the hot sauce and melted cheese is poured over the chicken in front of you. Cool concept. Except, the lady who brought it was rushing and decided she couldn't wait for the other waitress to finish setting our other plates down. So she poured it on to the chicken 6-10 feet away from our table behind the waitress and the member of our party who ordered the meal missed it. If you are too busy just put it on the chicken in the back just like every other restaurant. Another thing that was weird is there's a bar when you walk in but we were not given a drink menu. Maybe you have to ask for that too. Again weird. The Restaraunt is very beautiful I am seeing in the reviews that this might be a new Restaraunt so maybe they will work out the kinks and it'll be better with time. read more

Ate here twice. First time we had the meatball appetizer since if you put meatball in your name it has to be great. Nope. The 4 of us all agreed it wasn't that great. We ordered two pizzas one was the soho white which was good. I enjoyed it even though I'm not a fan of greens on my pizza. The other pizza was half sausage which was good. The crust was good on both, the sausage pie could have used a bit more pizza sauce but was still good. The second time we went back for calzone because we had seen them the first time and we were disappointed. Nothing memorable about the meatlovers or the meatball and mushroom canzone. The other two people in our group ordered chicken sandwiches. Overdone/burnt, the vodka sauce was so far off we told the waitress that she brought the wrong thing. The chef confirmed it was vodka sauce, he needs a new recipe because it was not. So I would go there for pizza, but nothing else. Just don't expect real NYC pizza. read more

Here's the good, bad and ugly for this new business. I've eaten here twice now with the same people and we all grew up within an hour of NYC. GOOD: Get the pizza. The white pizza is paticularly good with arugula, proscuitto and balsamic glaze, with a golden crust. The regular red pizzas need a bit more sauce, but still good. House salad was veey good. Service was very good both times we were there. I kept questioning whether the vodka sauce was really vodka sauce in my sandwich and they sent me home with a free one which was much better. Refurbished decor looks great. BAD: The chicken parm and chicken vodka sandwiches both needed more sauce. Chicken was overdone but a generous filling for the sandwich. The base red sauce was a chunky meat sauce for the calzones and sandwiches, and vodka sauce shouldn't use meat sauce. Meatballs are dense and dry. UGLY: Nothing ugly here. The net is go for the pizza and salad. Bartender is also very good and engaging. read more

Fantastic pizza and chicken parm sandwich! We order the hot honey hustle and love it. Amazing crust and toppings. Great mix of salty from the pepperoni and sweet heat from the hot honey. Service is always good and the restaurant itself is really nice. Especially the bar. read more

Did not read reviews before going and I'm glad I didn't. We ordered pizza, pasta and meatballs appetizer and enjoyed it all. Staff were courteous, service was quick and food was great. Found that the prices were reasonable. The decor seems well thought out and very clean. read more

Don't go here if you are hungry. I have given them 3 chances and never again. Once for pick up, once for delivery and once for dine in. First time I ever went was for pick up - entered restaurant and 5 employees saw me - a few even walked past me - but no one acknowledged me. I waited 5-10 mins then I finally said I was there for pickup. Food takes too long - and always longer than their estimated time - by double (they say 25-30 mins - it will be an hour or more). Don't order online - their tech is not working. Wait staff was clearly inexperienced - and one said she was confused why the place was busy on a Friday night (really???). Multiple owners walking around like busybodies. The flavor of everything I ate was off. Pizza is oily and below average with strange after taste. For some god awful reason their garlic knots are deep fried, hard and dripping in oil. Actually sitting in a pool of oil when served. Messy and nasty. Chicken parm vodka sandwich was over fried and not good either. Too oily and too hot because over fried - it took too long to be edible without burning my mouth multiple times. And not even a true pink vodka sauce - more of an arrabbiata sauce or something. I took a few bites and left it there. Same with the knots - only ate a few because I was starving. Never never again. Remove "NYC" from your name. read more

NYC Meatballs & Pizzeria St Augustine - Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Very inviting decor, nice size bar, great happy hour specials. Our server, Kriscinda, was welcoming and attentive. The chicken parm hero was full of hot crispy chicken cutlet that was bigger than the roll. The pizza crust is thin and crispy and the toppings were plentiful. read more

Great food. Service was excellent. Theresa was an incredible server. We will be back! Such a fabulous experience!

This restaurant is nicely decorated and the service was good. However, what we ordered was not good at all. The calzone tasted like cardboard and wasn't edible. Also, the eggplant parmesan had no flavor at all. It lacked any italian seasoning and I could have made it better myself. It wasn't worth the price we paid! read more

If you're looking for authentic New York-style comfort food in St. Augustine, NYC Meatballs & Pizzeria absolutely delivers. The meatballs are the real deal--tender, flavorful, and clearly homemade, not frozen or generic. The sauce is rich and perfectly balanced, just like you'd expect from a classic NYC spot. The pizza is excellent too: thin crust with a great chew, quality toppings, and that unmistakable New York flavor. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and everything tastes fresh. On top of the food, the staff is friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere is casual and relaxed--perfect for a quick bite or a laid-back meal with family. This place has quickly become a go-to spot whenever we're craving Italian done right. Highly recommend--worth every bite. read more

Real authentic New York / Jersey Pizza! Excellent pizza and food. The place is also very cool looking and the service is great too. I would definitely come back. 10 of 10 read more

See all

I wanted to order delivery, I really wanted to try this new place out. But this company wants me to pay them a fee of almost 8.00 dollars. That's not me paying for a tip. That's a service charge. Plus paying a tip. So i would be paying a service charge and a tip that is as much as the pizza. read more

This was a nice surprise just minutes away from our community. The renovations are just lovely and the food was very good too! We had the calamari and chicken parm. We were early birds, so the meal came with a free glass of wine !! We will be back read more

Paid 29.+ change for what they called a Sicilian pie. Not even close! It was nothing more than a pizza shaped in a square. Flavor was decent, but a Sicilian has a thicker bread like crust. What we received was not that. Not the least bit impressed by this place. read more

Pizza was good, chicken cutlet was fresh and our waitress, Kriscinda, was very attentive! I recommend this restaurant to anyone wanting good pizza in the St Aug area! read more

We went with friends to the new NYC Meatballs and Pizzeria Saint Augustine (2730 Florida 16). We were sad when the previous restaurant closed, but we had an excellent dinner under the new ownership. The renovations are very well done! They have homemade gnocchi, which is one of my favorites, and I paired it with their Bolognese sauce. (on the menu it has pesto, but they were very accommodating.) My husband had pizza and our friends had the calzone and eggplant Parm. The eggplant Parm was served plated, and then the bubbly melted cheese arrived on a heated skillet, and laid on top table side. Five stars on everything. They even offer an early bird menu, which includes lower prices a free glass of wine! They have a family area if you are having a private gathering or dining with a larger group. As with any new restaurant, they are still working some kinks out, but overall was an excellent experience with friendly staff and great food. read more