Oh man, every single thing was delicious! Went in a group of four and sampled roughly half the menu! Here's the breakdown;
-Blue Corn Empanadas - The individual empanadas are larger than I expected, but there are only 2 in an order which I thought was a little silly. However they were delicious - the tomato sauce has a nice kick to it as well.
-Cochinita Pibil (Pork) - This stuff packs a TON of flavor! Even without the sort of slaw that comes with it, the flavor was full and enough all on it's own. But adding the slaw doesn't deter from that at all, it's a perfect compliment to the meat.
-Roasted Goat - Hands down the table favorite. I had never had goat done like this before and everyone was very pleased and pleasantly surprised. (We did order the tortillas to wrap this stuff up in, but honestly everything was so delicious I didn't use any tortillas!) I have no idea what the sauce on the side was, but it seemed completely unnecessary. I couldn't tell any difference when I included the sauce from the goat by itself.
-Lamb - In general lamb is not my favorite thing, but I really WANT to love it so I keep trying it! It came out perfectly seared in nicely sliced bite-size portions. The slight char added a wonderful flavor - but overall I wasn't all that impressed. However my friends who are much bigger fans of lamb to begin with thought it was delicious.
-Wild Mushroom Risotto - Not a mushroom fan, but still wanted to try everything we ordered. I was pleased with the texture - so many places overdo risotto and it ends up a gelatinous blob on your plate. Not the case here! I probably would not order this again, just because it's mushroom, but if they offered another risotto I'd be all over it.
-Wisconsin Mac & Cheese - Totally worth it! The small order (single skillet) is a good tasting portion for two, so it's a good thing we ordered large! The creamy cheese sauce had an incredible flavor without being overly thick, like some cheesy pastas can be.
-Fried Sweet Plantains- YES! I've been waiting to find well done plantains in CO for YEARS. These are a little unusual in the fact that they're rolled in some kind of chili powder (ancho maybe?). Sad to say I am a baby about spicy food, but this was just the right amount of kick- especially with the aioli that comes with. I would come back here for the plantains alone!
-Green Chile Cheddar Biscuit - Not your average biscuit, that's for sure. It's not the light and fluffy thing we're all so familiar with, but I think that made it all the more appetizing. Slightly crunchy outside, but still soft and warm inside. Next time I will probably do without it just because it didn't necessarily enhance the dining experience in any way- but they are yummy.
-Butterscotch Pudding - Surprising flavor from something you don't expect to be surprised by. The pudding has almost a tartness to it that non of us were expecting... some were more pleased than others. I guess I prefer the traditional, sweeter style. But a few at the table really loved it and cleaned the jars!
The cocktails seem intriguing and exciting, but we only tried a few. The Tart Pomegranate-Cucumber whiskey was something I was wary to try, but glad I did. Very light and refreshing, but not something I could drink more than one of in a sitting. The Old Fashioned was a little funny.... someone really took out their anger on the cherry in my glass! Also (and I feel snobby even saying it, but I think it needs to be pointed out) the Old Fashioned came with chipped ice cubes..... so I couldn't take a sip without getting a chunk of ice that I had to chew on. Not only do I not want to be chewing on ice, I feel like it really watered down the drink after a few minutes (this may, in part, be due to the fact that we were sitting under a GIANT heater and those ice cubes never stood a chance). Probably wont be ordering that again, which is unfortunate.
The food was all fantastic - not a single bit went uneaten! The service was also wonderful, our server was very friendly and personable, gave recommendations that were well received, and we never sat without a drink or water refills the entire time. And it was really impressive how quickly the food came out when they were so busy.
This is a new favorite and I cannot wait to go back and try the other half of the menu! read more