While we are staying in Buchanan NY visiting family, we took our daughter-in-law for breakfast here. We got here at 8:30 am and we basically had the whole place to ourselves. This was Monday morning and the venue was meticulously clean and looked like it was totally redone. It was very impressive. We had a table and Carolina was our friendly and welcoming waitress. We had coffee almost immediately and ordered. I had 3 very large whole wheat pancakes, Celeste had the open faced omelet with prosciutto, arugula, tomatoes, on top. Wow! That was outstanding and delicious! Paul had the French toast with crispy bacon. All our plates were filled with generous portions and all were delicious! I wouldn't hesitate to come back. About 9:30 am, patrons started walking through the door. It's about to get busy. read more

Westchester Diner - Inside decor - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

I had just finished hiking Anthony's Nose and was starving, Westchester Diner was exactly what I needed. Nothing fancy, just ​your typical, old-school diner with a massive menu that has everything from breakfast all day to burgers and Greek specialties. I'll be honest: after that hike, anything probably would have tasted good, but the food here is solid and the portions are huge. ​The staff is friendly and it's a great, no-frills spot to refuel. It's not fancy, but it hits the spot when you're exhausted and need a mountain of fries. Plus, they have a full bakery if you want to grab a massive slice of cake for the road! read more

See all

A tremendous menu of breakfast, lunch and dinner. This is a classic diner both clean and friendly. This is another go to when I'm in town. They are a good Door Dash option if needed. I really enjoy their California Breakfast Burrito, Reuben and Bread pudding. I like the bread pudding so much I made it breakfast once. A little guilty pleasure of mine. Thank you to their cooks and wait staff for taking care of our group when we were in town for work. read more

Westchester Diner - Bread Pudding to go! - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Food was good and provides a classic diner experience. Great service and you're served quickly. An old-school diner atmosphere!

Despite our brunch order being received with the wrong ordered cheese, the service/attention by Westchester Diner was spot on! The waitstaff came around to the tables not too often and not too little. The restaurant is one of the cleanest I've visited in a long time! Gave us the feel that this can be and/or is a regular spot for the "regulars" lol which is a most good thing! We will be back. read more

Westchester Diner - Inside of Westchester Diner. Peekskill, NY USA come give this place a try one day - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

The food tasted stale! How could chicken and fries taste old!?! I ordered a burger. What a disappointment! Don't bother frequenting this diner!!! read more

Westchester Diner is a mega diner with an extensive menu that has just about everything you could want. They're under new management, but since this was my first time here, I can't compare it to before. That said, I thought the food was great, the restaurant was clean and the staff was very welcoming. Service was quick, and the waiters checked on us regularly. The wings were fantastic especially for a diner. I was really impressed! My only small complaint is that I wish the waiter had mentioned how large the side of fries would be. I ended up with a full plate, which was way more than I needed. Would definitely come back! read more

See all

We love this place. the food is delicious and the waitstaff are the nicest and most professional people we've ever encountered in a restaurant and the new owners did a wonderful job on the place, it was just average before they took over. read more

Real Nice Dinner For Any Meal Of The Day. They Treat You Great .And The Food Is Top Of The Line.

We are from Florida and my husband is working up here and we ran into this amazing little diner that my husband and I absolutely Love! It's the best! Stop in if you are In the area! The people are so welcoming! Very friendly and the food is absolutely awesome!!!!! Hope you enjoy as much as we have! I'm really going to miss it when we go back home! The food and the people that work there! They are all so sweet! read more

See all

Some of the reviews are years old and the diner has been completely redone and things are much better. I've been here twice in the past year to meet up with friends and it's a good diner. My food was good, the coffee was good. The staff was prompt and courteous. I will go back and recommend. Omelettes are my go to but the burger was also very good. read more

The service and atmosphere are outstanding! I had the sourdough turkey melt - excellent! The perfect mix of slow roasted, thin sliced turkey, cheddar cheese, bacon, tomato, and avocado on sourdough! The homemade coleslaw was delicious. The French fries were perfectly cooked. read more

Very disappointed with the service at Wetchester Diner. We ordered a skirt steak and got a sirloin that was mostly tendon instead of meat. My husband and I are regular customers and always tip well, so being treated this way was upsetting. We both work as servers too, so we understand the industry, which is why the poor service from the waitress was even more disappointing. read more

I don't think I've ever updated a review 2 times but with the new management comes a reason to wipe the slate clean. What a night and day difference. Back is a traditional NY diner menu. The service is great,attentive and friendly. The one knock would be the prices. I still have it in my head that a diner is a price-point below a restaurant. The prices are inline with a restaurant which I think is a bit high with things like a cup of soup. read more

This place was amazing. Definetly wish we found this place years ago. Delicious Matzo soup and Chicken Fajitas. Staff was amazingly efficient and nice. Interior looks recently redone and bathrooms were VERY clean. 5 stars, great job! read more

THANK GOD they opened DD Diner in Ossining, WAY WAY better and cheaper. So funny when you walk in and you're look at the TV and you see the owner promoting the business with another guy that he himself closed a bunch of Restaurants. Cocky little owner that his family owned the one that burned down in Ossining and the price they charge? For the type of food they serve please!!! They are just like the mobil station, waiting for people to come off 9 to fuel and eat, locals don't know better read more

This place 'supposedly' changed hands a few months back (or at least that was what they were promoting). Look, this is a tough call because this could just as easily be a rightful 4-star! This is no diner, this is a regular restaurant and their prices reflect that! I've been here for breakfast, lunch and dinner in recent past and I don't recall ever experiencing a problem as their food really is quite good (they really like to heap on the fries!), but you're going to spend money to sit in a diner with televisions coming at you from every direction, listening to loud obnoxious people and having to request a lot of things (just from my observation). Their turkey dinner and fried chicken are to die for, but way over-priced! I think my turkey dinner was $31 and a cup of soup (like in a coffee cup!) was $6.95! I never let price dictate where I dine but sometimes things are so ridiculously high you just have to pass. By the way, lousy coffee. Friendly and understanding servers! read more

As a local I hadn't been to this diner in 6+ years- poor food quality, sanitary issues and better options in the area. After hearing some good things about the new ownership and menu, we gave it another try and wow! All of food was spectacular. The salad was fresh and the quesadilla was one of the best I've had. The staff was also very kind and attentive. So happy to have another good local option! Now if only they went back to open 24 hours! read more

Westchester Diner - French Dip Melt, Crunchy Ranch Quesadilla, Adult Grilled Cheese - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

As diners go, this one is solid and one I strongly recommend. Greatest thing about diners is that they have e a TON of variety. Don't expect Michelin star or Emril, but do expect good wholesome food at reasonable prices and good portions. The staff here are always friendly and as most diners, running around like crazy doing the best they can serving up the food and handling all our crazy order changes and condiment needs!! Food is good, nice selection of deserts. Coffee is always fresh and if not, (decaf drinkers). They will make a fresh pot, just for you!!! I have been coming here for over 17 years, haven't had a bad meal once. Strongly recommend this place to all of you!!! Only bummer is they are not 24-7. Sniff, does that mean they should count themselves as a restaurant and not a diner??? Debates?? Eat, be happy, enjoy!!! They are great for large parties also!!! read more

We first came here for breakfast and it was awesome so we came back for dinner and we were equally impressed. We were hesitant due to the 3 star rating but that must be prior to the new owners because the food flavors were much better than a 4 star deli we went to the day before several towns away. The matzoh ball soup far exceeded the delis. For breakfast we had two different Mexican offerings. Both quite good. For dinner I had the turkey dinner and husband had the truffle burger. My dish could have served several people so looking forward to the leftovers. We were told by a patron not to miss the cheesecake. My husband ordered that and is was light and creamy. Not dense like many cheesecakes. I ordered the chocolate mouse cake which was very good. Once again to-go boxes. Lots to enjoy later Servers were extremely friendly and helpful. read more

Went last night food had no taste and Chicken was so tough . My husband had omelet awful . Told Manager and after we were done he asked if i wanted anothet. Will not go back any time soon read more

My parents and I swung by for lunch this past weekend and wow... we were completely blown away by how expensive this place has become. The chicken parm costs more than the chicken parm from my favorite authentic Italian restaurant in Bronxville, which is typically an expensive town! The chicken noodle soup was good, but $8 for a cup?! WHOA! I got a toasted bagel with butter which was $3.79 and wasn't very good. My mom got the BLT and it looked pretty good and was a nice portion. Sadly, even though the service was great, the prices are enough to keep us from going back. I know inflation is a thing, but this just felt like highway robbery! read more

The updates are nice! It took the inside to an elevated diner experience. They have a running train, which was great for the kiddos. The menu had a little of everything. Not super allergent, friendly. Food was what you'd expect from a diner. Service was great and responsive. read more

My go to diner no matter how busy it gets service is always on point. Their burgers are so good and most importantly not dry. Highly recommend visiting them. read more

Over priced for the disappointing food we received. My vegetarian salad was an odd mixture of what they had on hand topped with bland tzatziki, the flavors didn't work well together at all. My friend's meal was equally unsatisfying. However the service was good. read more

Definition of great place with terrible food. From the moment you walk in, you're take away by the cleanliness and quality service. The decoration of the interior and exterior is gorgeous. However, that's where it all ends. The food is atrocious with no flavor. Very over priced for Diner food. Awful choices of menu items that aren't even what they say it is. read more

The new ownership has turned the diner experience around 180 degrees. We had the meatloaf that was served with a sherry mushroom caramelized onion gravy with mashed potatoes and crisp broccoli . The portion was plate filling and satisfying. It was the best meatloaf I have ever had. It was pricy for diner fare, but worth it. read more

Westchester Diner - Sherry mushroom caramelized onion gravy was so savory. - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Service was great, food was below average and overpriced. Very bland tasting omelet. Hash browns tasted very undercooked. Price did not match the food that we were served, definitely better dinners in the area read more

Go to mac Donald's instead Food is hella bad Service is really slow took 1 hour and 30 mins to get food read more

Westchester Diner - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

I am very fond of this diner! Their food is just delicious and the service and staff are stellar. We've enjoyed many meals here over the last 7 years and look forward to many more. I had the French Toast with Bacon and Eggs special for lunch today and it was just delicious. Their burgers are also delicious, as are their French fries and salads~ all this and lots of parking! read more

This place is a joke their prices are out of touch! A five star high end restaurant wouldn't have ridiculous prices like those of this diner! read more

Absolutely love this place! Big portions, big on customer service and the food was absolutely fantastic. Such a nice atmosphere and family atmosphere. Our waitress was amazing! read more

Best tasting thing we got was chicken fingers and fries... burger was underdone and pancakes were super dry. SUPER EXPENSIVE for no reason and they charge for everything extra they can read more

Why bother? Breakfast sausage was only warm in the middle, wrong toast, and very stale home fries. Menu is limited. I really can't say I have a desire to return here. Maybe if I have an emergency for sunny side up eggs as those were perfect. Waitress was ok. Not over friendly and not angry. Meh. My daughter enjoyed the waffle. read more

Westchester Diner - Looks can be deceiving stale home fries flies and the sausage isn't hot it's warm - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

New owner and chef. Dinner amazingness to the max. Delicious to the turkey and all else!

Took my in-laws here for breakfast. Several pieces of the silverware were dirty when delivered to the table, and it was honestly shocking that not one employee noticed hunks of food dried onto them. It was only once I finished the omelette and dug into the home fries that I noticed several strands of hair in it. We won't be back unless they bring back the former operators, who at least understood basics of cleanliness and safety. I'm so disgusted. read more

Service, food , environment is all amazing . From getting greeted with a smile at the door to even having great conversation with the staff. I look forward to always coming back and knowing the food will always be good no matter what I order highly recommend coming and trying for your self. read more

Great spot to enjoy lunch with our family. The waitress Aura was super helpful and nice, we went there the day before and the waiter was not the best, our order was all wrong so we were happy to see a different server the second day. The dining room is clean and very welcoming and pretty but the bathrooms were dirty both days. The coffee was really fresh and the food was delicious both days. read more

See all

Terrible bland food. Weak coffee in dirty, dingy mugs. Went in for breakfast on a Saturday morning with 3 friends. Fairly empty restaurant, fully staffed, no apparent explanation as to why the food was so bad. We ordered normal breakfast staples: eggs and home fries, western omelette, pancakes, coffee. All awful. We should have stayed home and cooked because our food tastes better. The staff was attentive and polite and our food came out quick. But man, the food and the coffee were terrible. And the coffee mugs are super dingy and way past their time to be thrown out. There are other much better options for breakfast in Peekskill, like the Peekskill coffee house and Fuhgettaboudit. We were looking for a diner nostalgia and sit-down atmosphere, but it was not worth it because of the bland food. It was about $80 for the 4 of us and I cannot say this enough: IT WAS NOT WORTH IT. read more

New owner (also owns Pleasantville Coach Diner) has taken over here. The menu has been refreshed and simplified, and should make it easier for the kitchen to execute well. They have added some tasty treats in the milkshake category (similar to Pleasantville) that should be a hit for the children and late night arrivals. Emphasis has been placed on burgers and comfort foods...more "dinerish" The interior has been cleaned and brightened up, but no major renovations. Still convenient to Route 9 with plenty of private parking. Our service was prompt and friendly, and our breakfast spot on - crispy bacon was crispy, the omelette was not drowned in cooking oil, and the coffee was above average. We will surely head back to try pancakes and other goodies. read more

See all