Today I stopped off here, got the brisket entree, buffalo wings and italian dry rub wings. Brisket: Overcooked, the put on alot of sauce to coverup the overcooked meat. Not tender, it was like sauce on shoe leather. Buffalo wings: sauce was fine, good heat at the xxheat option, but the meat itself was dried out. Nothing to write home about. Dry Rub Italian: This was super boring, it was literally just wings with italian breadcrumbs on dried out meat. Waste of money. Overall: Not coming back. read more

See all

I can't believe it took me this look to Yelp this Peekskill Gem. Peekskill has become a mecca of fantastic eateries in Westchester ( in my opinion and as reflected in the number of reviews I have done in Peekskill ) but the Firehouse Grill MUST be in that conversation. The staff is awesome, their whole vibe and concept is showing love and respect to all Blue Collar workers and First Responders. ( LEOs, FD, Teachers, RNs,...) Great place to watch a game or a fight and of course the FOOD....is Fantastic! The menu is extensive and very creative..for example I had their famous Chicken Scarp sandwich...YUMMM ! Definitely come is for one of their signature burgers and a nice cold beer..you will not be disappointed..ENJOY! read more

See all

Burgers were really good. Onion rings and sweet potato fries were very good. The restaurant was cold but I always remember it like that. The wings with a dry Greek rub were salty but they took them back and gave us some bbq ones. Service was excellent. read more

We met the most amazing waitress Alana. She was super attentive and welcoming for my fiance, infant daughter and I on our first visit to this establishment. Upon ordering, the food was quick and delicious. Not one thing was a miss. Cornbread is out of this world!!! Burgers are delicious. I love that you can build your own burger. Im looking forward to visiting again soon! I wish I knew this place was so close to home a long time ago! read more

Love this place!!!! Did takeout and ordered two burgers, wings and fried pickles. All amazing and burgers cooked perfectly!!! OMG, if you follow my reviews, getting a properly cooked burger is one of my biggest peeves!!! The inside of this place is very welcoming plenty of tables and a very nice bar area! the staff are just amazing. Food order was ready in no time and this during busy time for them with a full dining room!!! This is a perfect place for both take out or sit down! Good prices and great portions! Two thumbs up here!!! read more

Went to Firehouse Grille to cater our granddaughter's birthday party. The food was outstanding and the service was prompt, polite, and very reasonably priced. All of guests complimented the food. Based on that , we will definitely visit the establishment for a sit-down meal. read more

Great food. Wings. Brisket. Fries are fresh. Services is great. They made suggestions and they were right. Thumbs up. Ask for Troy. read more

This was the worst meal I've had in Peekskill. The burger was overcooked. The brisket was tough and inedible. Told the waiter who said 'Really? I'll tell the cook.' That's helpful. NOT. $90 later...still crying. read more

The Fire House Grille always has a great crowd. Everyone at the bar is so kind and friendly. It's the Cheers of Peekskill. The food is delicious and they have the Best french fries! I give the staff 10 stars they are kind, hard-working, knowledgeable, and very quick to get what it is that you ordered . You are not disappointed. read more

Since moving to Buchanan, family and I have not had a bad meal. Highly recommend. Local restaurant that I'm sure gets many repeat customers read more

Food was great. Services was great very friendly. A place looks like how you would expected to look like with a name firehouse, fun place to hang out . read more

Back home after a decade, I was looking for a place with a large menu and plenty of local flavor. To say I found exactly that would be an understatement. I enjoyed a Gyro sandwich, which was well prepared. The meat was hot, juicy, and nicely spiced. The pita, lettuce, and tomatoes were fresh. My wife had barely bitten her Southwestern Chicken Wrap before announcing that she would definitely eat here again. The only thing that kept this from being a five star review was some slow service, partly resulting from a busy night. read more

The food here is great, but the service is terrible. Wanted to stop in for burger night tonight, but waited 30+ minutes and no one came to take our order. A table that arrived after us had already received their food and we were just being completely ignored. This happened during 3 other dining experience as well. Very disappointing and I guess the people there who work there just didn't like us ‍ read more

always excellent food and service at the firehouse the wings are the best in the area

This place isn't fancy which I appreciate. Rib portion was huge and delicious.The platter included cornbread, fries (subbed tater tots), coleslaw.Everything was delicious and you can't beat the price.Leftovers for 2 days. On another occasion, I had the wings which were outstanding as well. Tom, our waiter, was friendly, knowledgeable, great sense of humor .We had fun talking to him. My drink, which Tom made was amazing. Tequila, triple sec, cranberry and lime. Stop in, you will have a very nice experience. read more

I feel like this place is so under rated. It's one of those places we're the locals meet up but is also great for new comers. The staff is really friendly and attentive. What's really crazy is that you can pick what kind of dining experience you want. You can have wings and beer or something sophisticated like salmon. Either way, you're in a relaxed environment. The food is absolutely delicious. I've never had a bad meal. We drove almost an hour to have dinner here. The food is really worth it. If I lived closer than I'd probably be there more often! read more

See all

Please pay no attention to any negative reviews. Very friendly staff, quick service with hot food full of flavor and ice cold beer on tap! I had to try this place after 3 people from my hotel recommended them right away when asked about good, local food. Contrary to reviews I had read an hour before going, this place is a cozy, seat yourself locale where you will be greeted with a smile. Crystal was my serving professional with a rich NY accent and was very friendly, offering descriptions of some of their best food and didn't simply serve drinks and food then disappear. She remained focused on her area, even assisting with bussing a table or two. Please give them a try. Locally owned and pleasant atmosphere. Ask for Crystal, you won't be disappointed. D. McKinley. read more

Great food! Exceptional service! Awesome atmosphere! Extensive, interesting menu.Will definitely be back.

Idk, it might have been because it was a Saturday evening (busy time) but the wings that I ordered were not up to the quality I've heard people talk about. The buffalo wings I ordered came with absolutely no sauce. I ordered online and there was an option called "False Alarm" under the Buffalo section. I assumed that False Alarm would be considered to be "Mild" when thinking of Buffalo sauce! Just disappointed by this. The wings could've also been a little warmer and cooked more like I requested as well. In addition I also had Lemon Pepper wings, I wished it could've been coated more. Also disappointed over having to pay for my order all over again. After giving a call too! This was a situation where changes have to be made on their online ordering. If I'm already allowed to select "No heat" (which I didn't) that's when I wish for my wings to be dry with nothing on them. Regardless of my disappointment, the actual Chicken itself was good. Tasted real and wasn't squishy at all. Amazing ambience for a sit down, will definitely give it a try! read more

Our first delivery - so we tried a few things... Delivery was prompt. Varm Bites Boneless chicken bites tossed in homemade vodka sauce and smothered in melted mozzarella cheese $11 These were fried boneless nuggets - a bit too fried, dry and overcooked - in a delicious vodka sauce buried in melted mozzarella. This would be outstanding if the chicken nuggets were more appealing. Pulled Pork House smoked pulled pork piled high on a brioche bun and topped with coleslaw and cheddar cheese $12 with waffle fries Didn't realize there was BBQ sauce involved here. The pork was tender and delicious, the cole slaw fresh and tasty and a lovely brioche bun. The waffle fries were stupendous. French Dip Thinly sliced rib-eye steak on a garlic wedge topped with Swiss cheese and served with au jus dipping sauce $14 Too much bread, and wound up eating out of it like a bowl. Thinking this would be better in a tortilla or with the dough out. Overall, good for bar food but uneven. Definitely will try some other dishes! read more

My friend and I decided to try firehouse grille while we were in Peekskill yesterday. I heard about it through the Elite Yelp group I am in. All I have to say is it is my new favorite place!! I ordered the macaroni and cheese fries and boneless wings with bbq sauce. Everything was sooo delicious!!! I'm a huge macaroni and cheese fan and this was definitely the best macaroni and cheese I've ever had!! Our waiter was really cool too. My friend got the brisket and said it was so moist and juicy, you can tell just by looking at it. She really enjoyed her meal! We can't wait to go back and will be taking the hour drive just to come eat!! read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Brisket - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Updating my review since it's 8 years later. Picked up a delicious meal tonight for takeout: -- steak tacos (3) with rice -- Wolverine -- which is basically everything you could ask for on a roll (pulled pork, mac n' cheese, onion rings, bacon..... with sweet potato fries Both dishes were $15 and I was pretty amazed with how much food there was for that cost! The food was delicious and the staff at the door while I waited was so courteous. I will have to come back when COVID is over and I feel more comfortable with indoor dining. They change their specials on Friday and the owners just opened a new restaurant in the Somers/Baldwin Place area called Chicken Coop, which I can't wait to try since it's 5 minutes from my house! read more

See all

I visited again since the first time went so well. My extremely beautiful server was very helpful and the food came out perfectly and quickly. My full rack of ribs were great and the guacamole appetizer was amazing! Thank you for another good adventure!! read more

See all

I came here with my kids, who each have very different tastes. Something on the menu for everyone, my meal was fantastic (got the steak tacos), the service was excellent (Tom was very knowledgeable, took careful note of our allergies, and was patient with the kids) and the price was excellent. read more

I highly recommend this restaurant! The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Thank you Ryan!! read more

Food is really good and is good quality, place looks nice. I feel like it deserves 5 stars.

One of the best places to eat locally Food is always prepared fresh and always delicious Can't go wrong here read more

Amazing atmosphere! Sit in the bar, in the restaurant or outside on the patio. Staff is always fun and friendly, owners are super friendly! Food is hands down amazing! Wings are award winning, lots of original menu options that are fun and so good! You won't be disappointed read more

Got off on the Peekskill Metro North and was looking someplace not too far and came across this grille. It was only 3-4 minutes away and we'll worth the trip. Started with the chili. It came with the colorful nachos but the chili was on point. It had the sweet savory taste with a little kick to it. We moved on to the Asian lettuce wraps. These wraps were so fresh. The lettuce was crispy and tasty. The accompanying Asian chicken, walnuts, and sauce were fantastic. We also tried the boneless teriyaki wings. They were crispy and the sauce was perfect. It wasn't too much, just right. As the food kept coming we realized we made a huge mistake because the portions are humongous!! Moving on to the steak burrito. It was big, tasty, and the meat was delicious. The steak tacos were also plentiful, full of meat , and delicious. We had the giant steak that was cooked perfectly and juicy. Heavenly. All the dishes in these pictures were amazing, delicious, and full portion sized. They even throw in a plastic fireman's hat for the little ones. I wore mine with pride. Great place. Looking forward for another firehouse round. read more

See all

Good burgers. Nice staff. I usually make my order a To Go and have a tap beer while waiting. The beer is always good. It's a cozy, homey local spot. I was there one night while a children's sports team was celebrating the end of their season. The owners seem very community minded. I love that. read more

We've been here twice already and we are very impressed. From the food to the service, everything was great! Absolutely loved the way they decorated inside. I can personally recommend the pulled pork, brisket, mac and cheese as well as the cheeseburger French fries. Oh, and the 4 alarm buffalo wings are a treat. We look forward to exploring the menu further. read more

First time here. Everyone was extremely friendly in this place. We sat in the bar area he decided to order some drinks and food. They don't normally make a chocolate martini, but the bartender made me a fabulous one! For food, I ordered a Greek salad with Gyro meat on top, and my friend ordered A fish sandwich Panini. The food was great! My friend adored the fish sandwich, the tilapia was tender, and the panini was very crisp, with melting cheese oozing out of it. My Greek salad hit the spot, quite big with nice toasted pita points and tender gyro meat on top. It was perfect. Service was excellent, and we even got free entertainment! There was a fabulous magician named Phil who did some great tricks at our table. This I could see being a wonderful place to bring kids While mom and dad have a quality meal. The menu is very extensive, with many kid friendly items and lots of choices of wings! I can't wait to come back and try some of these! read more

See all

Whether it's take out or dine in the food is amazing! Whatever they did after the fire and remodeling, they have done a great job all around! Well worth the trip read more

Picked up some sandwiches the other day. Very good. The Chicken Scarp sandwiches was incredible! If you finish the whole thing you'll probably need a nap but otherwise I highly recommend! read more

OMG DELICIOUS, my good friend took me here, extremely good, can't even describe! Ordered the pork ends appetizer, and then the brisket OMG, absolutely 10/10, I'm a tough critic and only give 10/10 to truly good places, waitress was excellent, fast, polite and cute too and very fitting interior decorations, rustic, westernish, overall excellent, will be returning! read more

See all

Picked up take out and warmed it up at home. Half rack ribs and two different orders of wings. The half rack came with a very generous side of fries the wings were pretty good. Got the Buffalo 3 alarm (hot) and they were the right amount of hotness. Also tried the wizard? Cajun /teriyaki I think. Also good. They have 50 types of wings so it's a challenge choosing. The place looks really welcoming for a local tavern appeal. Friendly service. And good social distancing is being made. read more

See all

Great food, great service, fun environment, cheap prices. Great for football Sundays and Monday nights.

YES! A must stop for a great burger and a cold pint! Burger temp (med/rare) perfect! First time I have ever been here, I'm up from North West Bergen to go to the VA. It was a recommendation from the ladies at the VA. Tom & Griffin super cool dudes, if I'm back up here I know where to stop for a burger! YOU NEED TO STOP IN AND TRY THEM OUT!!! read more

So we were at Bear Mountain for a Hike for Hope Event and found this place via Yelp. Great food, server Tom was friendly and recommended the PB&J dessert, OMG! read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Great food and our server Tom, was very nice, friendly and engaging. This is their fried PB&J dessert with vanilla ice cream! - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Usually get a delivery once a week. I've tried almost everything on the menu and everything is delicious. You also receive a side with the sandwiches which is a plus. read more

NY Firehouse Grille - Santa Fe Wrap - American Near Me - Peekskill, New York