This will sound like a bold statement, but I can safely say my experience at Wataru was like a night out of Japan (and for the record, I've been to Japan twice now, and have yet to find a spot that compares to the quality of fish, service, and presentation of food and drinks). A few disclaimers before I go into the omakase food experience:
1) It is VERY competitive to get a reservation here - if Seattle had a sushi restaurant lottery, this would be it. I was lucky enough to have a friend who stayed up until midnight (I'm lame and sleep at 10), to call and ask for availability for a January reservation back in October (3 months in advance, folks). Even that was risky, but we were lucky enough to get it.
2) The sushi bar seating omakase is the way to go, but be prepared to spend $$. We're talking $50 deposit, $150 meal (with sake), per person. It's worth every penny, promise.
3) There are only 2 seatings nightly for the sushi bar with Chef Kotaro Kumita - 5:30 and 7:45 pm. Be on time if you get a spot, because there usually is at least one other party who will be joining you (depending on how big your party size is, I think there were 6 spots total, but worth fact checking me on that one), and the chef starts promptly at that time (like any restaurant in Japan, which always respects punctuality, not tardiness).
4) Sake is some of the best I've had in the states here. If you go, try any of the Dai Ginjo. The waiters have good recommendations as well, there was a fruity one that I loved, which was so refined you could barely taste the alcohol (how I like it).
As for the food, well, I don't know if words do it justice. Since going to Japan, I had yet to find sushi that was comparable in the states, from New York City to Seattle. This sushi was. The quality matches what you'll get in Japan - every slice of fish was fresh, the tastes and textures will make your mouth continue to crave more, and you'll get a wide variety of fish to try - I think we had a total of 22 rolls, all different and unique in their own way. I also can't name one I didn't like.
If I haven't sold you yet (and if you're still reading this novel), the chef is also the sweetest man, with true talent. Did I mention he (and this restaurant) was featured in Seattle Weekly? Article here, for reference: https://www.seattleweekly.com/food/the-student-becomes-master-at-wataru/. Oh and his teacher was Shiro Kashiba, trained by Jiro Ono. Need I say more? Be sure to watch the netflix docu "Jiro dreams of sushi" if you haven't already.
I'll end with one last note - if you haven't had sushi in Japan, try this place for a taste. If you have had sushi in Japan, come here for a night that will help you get over your separation anxiety from the best sushi in the world. read more