I'm visiting from out of town and this store was highly recommended by some friends who live in Fishkill. I was really looking forward to trying an authentic New York bagel for the first time. My visit left a lot of to be desired. First off, the staff was incredibly distracted. Several employees passed by me while I was up at the register assuming I had already ordered. When someone finally came up to take my order I asked if individual bagels came with a small helping of cream cheese. The sunken eyed teenager with a frizzy dirty blonde bun snottily said "You can buy some" while pointing at their sign showing the per pound prices for cream cheese ($7.99 per pound by the way) That's right, if you want cream cheese with your bagel you have to buy a whole pound of it even if you're only buying one bagel. The bagel and the sandwich I ordered were very good, but unfortunately does not overtake the subpar service and the fact that I had to buy a pound of cream cheese. read more

The Balboa's revenge sandwich was so yummy! Clean place, lots of delicious options, and friendly service! Looking forward to eating there more. read more

Used to come here a lot when my boys were little and it was always a great place. Joe knew us all by name and was always such a great friendly guy. Everyone who lived in the area knew and loved this bagel shop! I went in today with my son after not having been there in about 8 years and was so pleased to see the same familiar face and the same great food that we were used to. Joe hasn't changed and still runs a great bagel shop. Although he didn't recognize us, we saw the same friendly service we were used to and saw the place filled with faithful regulars and had a great lunch! read more

By far the BEST bagels for Dutchess County! They are so perfect. When you could eat a bagel without being toasted, that's when you know it's good! The coffee is really good as well. This will be my bagel shop moving forward even if I have to drive 15 minutes to get there. It's worth it!! read more

I thought the bagels here were fine. They have tons of variety which is nice. We went with plain, everything, and cinnamon raisin...they weren't the chewiest bagels I've ever had, but definitely not the worst either. read more

Being back home for the holiday , I was so happy to find a place with real NY Kaiser rolls. I had a great ham, egg and cheese sandwich . No complaints there. I used the restroom before leaving and was totally grossed out. It smelled of urine, had urine on the floor, trash can overflowing . The walls were dirty and rusty-YUK. I felt like I needed to take a shower and cha he my clothes after that . read more

my favorite local breakfast & lunch spot. Bacon, egg, and cheeses are always delicious. turkey club - so yummy. & its always a pleasure when Jan takes my order. She's always thorough & super quick. even when they are busy, which they always are. she gets my order right every time. And its always a pleasure chatting with her. Chris too. Have yet to have a bad experience here, and don't believe I ever will. read more

Problem: early afternoon gym trip, but no food all day to provide any energy for a workout. Solution: head into this place for a quick bite, then shoot over to Golds Gym in the same parking lot. Bigger problem: eat too much, go into a food coma and skip the gym. This is a great little bagel/sandwich shop to stop in anytime of the day for a meal to go or to sit down and enjoy. Plenty of fantastic sandwich options and always served on nice fresh bread (hero, rolls, etc). This past week I enjoyed a "New Yorker" on a hero - hot pastrami served with Russian dressing and coleslaw. The sandwich was ready within minutes and full of meat (hate when they go light on the main ingredient). Their coleslaw was a bit light on the creamy side, but mixed with the Russian dressing it wasn't so bad. Overall a fantastic meal and very filling Most sandwiches on a hero fall within the $6-$8 range and are served with a side of coleslaw or potato salad. They have specials that are updated on their site daily. I've yet to try a bagel there but some of the reviews on here make me optimistic that I'll enjoy it. I've had the hankering for a good bacon egg and cheese sandwich so maybe I'll stop back in for one real soon. read more

Was not impressed with this place at all. The lady at the counter did not toast our bagels and got half of the items we ordered completely wrong. I would have complained but we were up here for Thanksgiving and I did not want to make anything bad on our trip. The bagel was good though even though it wasn't toasted. The selection was not as good as I thought it would be though. read more

This is probably more of a 3.5 star. The sandwiches are usually well prepared and the bagels are delicious. However there is an older woman that works there, that just doesn't want to be bothered. It's really frustrating dealing with her. Iv heard other customers complain about her. read more

Wow! What a great place! The bagels are phenomenal and the food is fantastic! Lots of beautiful sweets too! Real professional. I hear the bagels are 18pc. / dozen mon. - thurs! *************************************************** 12/28/18- OK, so I don't know how to make another review without coming back to this one. Somehow this app won't let me post another review so I'm adding to this older one. Well, I was sold on the bagels already. But now I'm sold on the catering packages Joe offers for holiday dinners. What a great Christmas dinner we had catered from the Bagel Shoppe! Everything was excellent!! A lot of care went into the food, which brought a lot of flavor! I swear, everything was like homemade. Not food service quality, but home cooked quality. And a lot of it. We ordered food for 10 people, but there was definitely enough food for at least 6 more people. Glazed Spiral ham, string beans almondin, glazed carrots, garlic roasted red potatoes, dessert, anti- pasta platter... all at a very reasonable price. Very reasonable. Truly a lot of food! Go for a bagel, while in line ( yes I said line. Always busy!), check out their great food choices in the deli case. All cooked on premises and a crazy amount of choices. Even vegetarian and I believe even some vegan ( but not positive on that). If you haven't tried this place, GO. You won't be disappointed. read more

I didn't have bagel so can't commend on that, I had sandwich and breakfast, but breakfast sandwich was not so hot...egg wasn't mixed well and way too much cheeze cover up going on. With that said, my lunch (Italian sub) was awesome, perfetly executed. So I guess eat bagle for breakfast, and have subs for lunch. Maybe it was my fault to order egg sandwitch at bagle place... read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! Small woman behind the counter is super rude. Food is just OKAY here for the ridiculous prices. Choose bagel world in Wappingers any day they actually treat you like a paying customer and food is better. NEVER AGAIN WILL I GIVE THIS PLACE MY MONEY OR TIME!!!! read more

Never going back. I felt rushed. Customer service wasnt great but not horrible. I also had to wait 7-8 minutes before I was greeted. I ordered a croissant with butter and jelly and a bagel with strawberry cream cheese. The croissant had a half inch thick very uneven smear and a quarter size glob of jelly. Barely toasted. It was almost inedible. The bagel I had hoped would be good since it is "The Bagel Shoppe" but no such luck. The plain bagel I got was not very tasty and the strawberry cream cheese tasted nothing of strawberry. It wasnt very sweet but practically had no flavor. The cream cheese was like a marble look because it had not been mixed completely. It also tasted like all the lox and cream cheeses it was stored with. Basically never returning. Sorry, not sorry. read more

Hello-, This deli is expensive and frankly the sandwich was not very good especially for the price! I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich with lettuce and tomato the price came to $14.00. Furthermore, the portion of the piece of chicken was small. For another $5.00 dollars I can go to a restaurant get a drink, French fries and a sandwich for $20.00. This deli is out of touch with what is going on in today's world. There are many people living check to check and just getting by. Thankfully I'm not one of those people but I believe in fair value and good business practice. I'm afraid charging $14.00 dollars is absolutely ridiculous in todays environment. read more

Very good bagel. Had an everything with jalapeño cream cheese. Pricey at $3.56. Cream cheese had red pepper with the jalapeños which Do Not Belong. Otherwise hit the spot for bagel with schemer to go. read more

I teach in the gym in the same plaza. I am a small woman. I was looked over and they have taken the man behind me on more than one occasion! Of course the man could have been courteous and said I was first and didn't. You would think they would ask "who's next?" Poor service is poor service. I will take my business to Bagel World. read more

Best bagels, deli, sweets and catering. I'm originally from just across the bridge and every time I visit this is #1 on my list! Best bagels north of NYC. read more

Joe and his staff catered yet another lunch for our office. Incredible food, delivered promptly, set up beautifully and great presentation. Joe's catering is too much of a secret. EVERYONE is missing out! Jeff read more

Chaos, every, single, time. Bagels are ok, service is brutal. I've been over charged several times.

Can I say I just had the most worst experience ever here. My mom and I walked in and ordered two simple veggie and cheese sandwiches. A blonde lady behind the counter and I have never seen before looked at us very unusually and by the look of her face she looked off kiltered or confuse. She asked us if she could help us and then she would walk away and then come back and ask us if she could help us again. Then she tried to check in four different spots where the vegetables for the sandwich was? Really really I'm not quite sure what she was doing. She also questioned our order several times. There was no one else in here it was at 2o'clock so their rush-hour was over. One other lady walked in and the guy behind the counter helped her and he also seemed like he was in La La Land as well. I heard her yell at the guy that he messed up her bagel order. It also took her about 30 minutes to make two veggie sandwiches. And at the end she asked us if we wanted potato salad or macaroni salad? I asked her if it came with the sandwiches, she said yes and it seemed like she may have charged us for them. Lastly the lady asked if we were going to stay and she said that we should because they were really messy? And then it wouldn't be a good idea to eat them in the car. For her to admit that they were messy is I feel like a very odd thing? i'm not quite sure what the heck was going on maybe it was an off day. I will give them the benefit of the doubt but really horrible service, and workers. I don't think I will be coming back for a while. Their bagels here have an always really good but after today it's a really bad taste in my mouth. PS the Sandwich was not good :( read more

Me and some friends stop by here on the way to the Boston area and said wow what a place! Not only were they super nice and asked us where we were from and connected on our hometown in New Hampshire. We've had a lot of breakfast places and this is by far the hottest of the hot read more

Having recently moved to Fishkill this would have been a very convenient location to frequent. Originally from the Bronx so I'm very critical of bagels. I think their bagels are okay, however I have had better in the area. If only this place was as clean looking in person as it is in the photos on their site. If you eat here do not look up, the amount of dust on the vents and the ceiling are disgusting. I had a view of foam caulking in the walls as I ate my bagel indicative that they have unwelcome visitors there. I did visit a second time thinking I just got this place on a busy day and they didn't have a chance to clean and the floor was just as filthy and the top of the napkin holders just is dusty as they were the week before. It's apparent this place has many regulars that probably are either used to the uncleanliness of this facility or just don't notice it because they've become used to it. The workers there are friendly and work hard however, they should clean this place up and do something about the bathroom as well. The first time I was there I mentioned to somebody behind the counter that they needed to clean out the garbage because there was an awful awful smell coming from it. In my opinion ,if you do not care about the cleanliness of your establishment, how can you take pride in your food that you serve? Needless to say I'll be finding another bagel shop. read more

See all

love the place but prices are way too expensive for a breakfast sandwich or bagel sandwich Not a bargain sorry

Rude to customers. Keep you on hold for a very long time. Encourage customers to call in and then make them stand on long lines! Constantly getting the orders wrong! If you want to be disrespected just to get w decent sandwich, then hey go there. Honestly they treat their customers like garbage or better yet, like they're doing us a favor when we're paying. Smfh. read more

Best baked goodies in the area. Also very good catering. I highly recommend them always.

I work in an office very close so we often order delivery from the establishment. The food is decent, nothing spectacular and they consistently forget my co workers drink. However, when going into the business it's been a completely different experience. My husband has gone in on 3 different occasions and the women behind the counter were consistently rude and cold to him. Let me explain that my husband is the most friendly, outgoing and kind man to everyone he comes across. Today was the last straw for him with this place. The woman who took his order was not personable or pleasant and it escalated to her being down right rude and her yelling when my husband's magnetic strip on his debit card wouldn't work. As if it's a crisis to have to manually punch the numbers in as my husband suggested to her. I can't fathom that a small local business would treat their customers in this way. I have had Joe the owner, come to my place of business and he was treated with the utmost respect and professionalism. I'd strongly recommend he teach his employees a life lesson on humanity and respect. Unfortunately, we feel we've given the bagel shoppe adequate opportunity to change, we will no longer patronage you. read more

The food is good here but every time we go here the older ladies have an attitude. I've must have been here several times and not once did she smile or seem pleasant. Almost as if her face might crack from doing such a thing. We're guessing she must be related to the owner based on her working as if losing her job seem impossible. I guess the owner doesn't care about how his customers are treated. Guess we will have to find somewhere else to spend our money. read more

Delicious breakfast sandwiches and subs at affordable prices make this small strip mall deli worth a detour. Staff is very friendly and courteous. Prices are very affordable for huge sandwiches. My wild west sandwich was heaping with roast beef and melted cheese. Don't let the facade scare you away, this is a hidden treasure in Fishkill. Follow the locals. read more

This is not only a great place to buy bagels, but also sandwiches, desserts and more! They have a super special Mondays through Thursdays where you can buy 18 bagels for the price of 12. That may seem like too many bagels for most of us but they freeze well, thaw in 30 seconds in the microwave and taste just as fresh as when you first bought them! The staff at the Bagel Shoppe is friendly and the bagels are top rate. read more

We love this place. Great community spot. Bagels always fresh. Service always great and Joe makes you feel like family!

Joe the owner is a nice guy and the food is generally good to very good. The only blemishes are the sometimes long waits and spotty service (e.g., one woman regularly overcharges). read more

Really, really love this place. All their food is insanely good and the service is usually wonderful, however there is one employee, an older woman who is often rude and seems exhausted/annoyed that you are there. I wouldn't have even mentioned her in this review if it wasn't for this one instance: I ordered a bagel with cream cheese (shouldn't be an unusual request in a place called "The Bagel Shoppe") and she made some kind of obvious inside joke with another employee by asking me with a smirk if I wanted a knife to scrape off the cream cheese and save it for later.....She laughed really loudly looking at her coworker. It was very awkward, unprofessional and made me feel uncomfortable. If she didn't work there the place would honestly be perfect. read more

For a local business in a thriving business area their staff friendliness could definitely improve, and maybe they could be a bit more helpful with possibly asking if the customer may want anything additional to make them feel more comfortable with ordering since they do offer a lot of options. Having a degree in Hospitality & Resturant management, and having worked in many food related businesses customer satisfaction is key. I was also going to gauge this place as a possible suggestion to my company for future lunch orders, but now I will not. Sorry guys, but customer service is everything in the food industry, and pricing should be mentioned if it is not listed so a customer is not shocked after their food is already made. Making prices up as you go along without saying "Oh sure we can do that, it's $2.00 more is that still okay?" Give the customer the option. My experience is listed below. Being a local worker in the Fishkill area I was looking for a place to order a fresh handmade wrap that fit my health needs. It was 12:35 PM prime lunch rush. However, there were a couple people ahead of myself and my friend and they were all served just waiting on their orders. So we waited..not long mind you which was great!. My friend placed her order a wrap with egg whites, green peppers, onions and bacon. Which for the record she said was delicious. Then I get asked by Carmen, "Who's next, so I hold up my hand and she coldly asked, "What do you want?" I asked if they could do a tuna wrap as it was not an option on their menus. Her response sounded as sarcastic as could be, "yeah" with an eye roll. So I felt slightly stupid for asking but wanted to make sure it was an option. Then I asked if they had spinach...(the leaf,) I was quickly told, "We do not have spinach wraps, white or wheat" Okay I guess I asked that incorrectly. So I said wheat would be great, then asked do you have both lettuce and spinach thinking that would get my answer. I questioned even if i should ask for anything special at this point..I got another cold response. "Yeah we have both". Again in my head I am thinking it's my first time here, I feel bad for asking questions but I did not see these options listed anywhere. So I say I would like spinach please, and at this point I was thinking let me get this finished because my order is already irritating this woman. So I end up asking for American Cheese and that's it. Even though I would have liked to add more. After being rung up I am told my very plain Tuna wrap on wheat with spinach and American cheese plus my iced tea cost $10.59. I was blown back by the amount but didn't have time to argue or cause a scene and at that point was hoping my wrap had not been tampered with. My friend I referenced above, her wrap cost her $5.40 very reasonable for what she got. read more

Love this place. Speedy service, even if the line is long, the food is usually done in less than 10 minutes. The workers are pleasant and so is the crowd. Every time I come in and there is a crowd, they're very inviting and talkative. Highly recommended, sandwiches are great. read more

Best bagels around! The service is too notch and. I love the small town feel and Joe and his crew keep it alive. They greet you hello by name and thank you for coming in. The actually appreciate your business. I highly recommend you try this place once and then you'll be hooked like me. read more

We were so excited to find the popular rainbow bagel craze had found its way here! We were having a rainbow party and had only known about another place in Brooklyn that had them... which didn't ship. I worked with Joe ahead of time to arrange for mini rainbow bagels (which were beautiful!), as well as some of their awesome water bagels and a tray of bacon. Everything was a huge success. I would absolutely order from here again. Everyone asked me where I got the bagels- I will try to post a photo as well. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Rainbow mini bagels - we ordered them for a party. - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Slow service during busy hours. Literally waited 20 minutes for one breakfast sandwich. Which was made wrong. Understandably mistakes are made but the set up of order taker/cook/cashier does not seem to be the wisest decision. It lacks consistency and return business needs consistency. read more

Amazing atmosphere and friendly staff. Real downstate bagels made upstate!

The Bagels are the best in the area. The staff is efficient. In addition, cold cuts, bread, soups, and desserts are delicious. It's rare to see an establishment that cooks all their food on premisis. In addition, the catering menu is good. I ordered a Turkey at Thanksgiving and it was great. I highly recommend it. read more