Shiny diner with diner classics, plus a ton more. I wasn't expecting it to be good based on how large the menu was, but the food was amazing. Had the sirloin and scallops dinner special which included soup or salad and a potato. I got 3 meals out of my dinner. My friend got the meatloaf plate and also got 3 meals. I would stop here next time I'm in the area. Friendly staff and very clean. read more

My husband and I took our adult son to the 84 Diner for his birthday breakfast. Great staff - so friendly. Our terrific waiter was very helpful when choosing items from the menu. Everything we ordered was delicious and plentiful. Eggs, sausage, etc., Oatmeal for me. All done perfectly. The booth we sat in was very comfortable and clean. The dessert display looked very inviting. Next time! We had been to the diner before but hadn't been there in a while - no particular reason. We WILL be back. read more

I don't eat at diners. However, this place isn't just a diner. It has Italian and Greek fare,too. We ordered the patty melt with sweet potato fries, both which were great. For dessert, we had baklava. This stole the show. It was dense but flaky, not too sweet and great flavor. The service was fast and friendly, and the atmosphere chill. Great place! read more

It's been a while since we were last here, and it's so hot to even think of cooking. we were sitted as soon as we came in. Our server is very sweet. But I don't know her name. I've made my choice it's stuffed sole with crabmeat and a baked potato with lots of butter. I have a choice of soups, but my choices are my taste so I'll go for the salad. My plate arrived and added butter to the broccoli. My stuffed sole was very good, but unfortunately I can not finish it all. I'll take the salad home read more

See all

I don't live in NY, but I produced a Harry Potter event in NY a few years ago and lived up there for about half a year. I-84 Diner was one of my favorite stops for overwhelmingly hearty breakfasts or delicious dinners, along with everything in between. And good cookies and pastries and cakes, too! Staff is attentive, it's good the awesome diner vibe, and it's overall a really solid choice for a meal by yourself or when enjoying food with friends. read more

I-84 Diner - Omelet and very, very good bacon. - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Server Ashley was the best - a warm smile, kind demeanor, and excellent service. I will request her in the future. Food was HUGE and delicious . My only complaint was my reuben came open faced - Not my favorite, but now I know. It still tasted really good! I've been coming to this diner for 40 years. Never had a bad meal... read more

See all

This textbook-looking diner sits right off I-84, appropriate name, right? It's huge and has a large parking lot to match. They are not open 24 hours though, closing between 9-10 PM depending on the day. In true diner fashion, the menu is a beast! For those who are very indecisive, you might want to add a couple of extra minutes to study the options. I ordered the mac & cheese burger ($17.99) since it was a more unique burger offering. I-84 burgers are 1/2 pounders consisting of a short rib brisket and chuck blend, in a grilled bun. I selected salad for my side, and I was pleased that it came out first since I was quite hungry. Part of my curiosity was reading on the menu how their mac & cheese was "famous" and used a three cheese combo. Well, the mac & cheese did not disappoint. Much of it had fallen off the burger but no matter. It had a great gooey but smooth texture and was fantastically cheesy. Look for the mac & cheese section on the jumbo menu for more offerings. Along with the menu, the portions are also mammoth. Our server and the cashier were very friendly. The restrooms were tidy. There's a discount if you pay by cash. Glad to have tried I-84 Diner! read more

I-84 Diner - Mac & Cheese Burger ($17.99) - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Unfortunately, I've now had three very disappointing experiences at this diner. The first time I visited, I found a receipt inside my sandwich. That alone was extremely concerning and made me question the kitchen's food-handling practices. I decided to give the diner another chance, but on my second and third visit it was just as frustrating. I specifically requested that my food be prepared a certain way, and the cook got the order wrong three times. On my third visit,the same issue happened again. Mistakes happen, but having issues on three separate visits was a bit too much. Unfortunately, after these experiences, I won't be returning. read more

The food was horrible. The matzo ball soup had just a few shreds on the bottom. Everything was overcooked and slapped together. The carrots were badly peeled with dirty edges. Not what it used to be at all. read more

We ordered the chicken soup the fried chicken and the buffalo calamari. Everything was bad!!! Tasteles ,cold,not fresh. Its a first and last time for me. read more

Bacon mac-n-cheese was AMAZING. We had Kayla as our server and she was super polite, and dealt with the horrible dad jokes my dad was making, the outside and inside of the whole place looked great, %100 would recommend, also the french dip was so good, portion sizes are HUGE so do expect to have leftovers read more

I-84 Diner - Bacon Mac-n-Cheese! - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

My Boyfriend and I went here for dinner and we LOVED it. We're diner connoisseurs and this one is by far our favorite that we've tried. I really like the cozy, homey, vintage atmosphere, and the food is also great. I got a super yummy Belgian waffle, and he got the French dip sandwich and fries. And we were both very satisfied with our meals. Our waitress was very friendly, but we were left waiting a few times. The desert selection was also super impressive and everything looked amazing. We were too full to get any to eat there, but we got some cake to go and enjoyed a lot at home. Definitely would recommend! read more

After a long drive from the Island, and a storm of biblical proportions, didn't feel like cooking; this is our go-to restaurant. Had a roast beef sandwich on rye. There must've been at least a half a pound of roast beef in there! See the photo. Service is always prompt. The place is always clean and inviting. I'm not a dessert person, but their pastries are eye-catching. read more

See all

Our server Tina was so friendly. Along with the Texas Toast chorizo grilled cheese the Buffalo and Garlic Parmesan wings were out of this world. Highly recommend to anybody traveling to or thru this area. read more

The pluses: very extensive menu, very nice dining room, desserts are amazing. The minuses: service is a bit spotty and the location is right off the interstate so it's a little hard to get in and out of. read more

I never leave reviews but the negative energy and comments, both between the staff (towards each other) and about their tables was so bad. I get this industry can get stressful but bicker about each other and about your tables in private, not where customers can hear you cursing, heavy sighing, and being passive aggressive to one another read more

A memorable bite of nostalgia with a generous portion of hospitality is the only proper way to describe the I-84 Diner. Our family has travelled all over the U.S., being fortunate to have dining experiences from Disney to the Grand Hotel, so our standard of comparison is high. From "Eye of the Tiger" playing in the background, to the on point mid-century furnishings, to the massive menu and front dessert display it made us forget 2026 exists! Most importantly, the service from our waitress Tina C. - who seemed able to make every guest feel like a welcome friend while keeping those plates moving - was truly one-of-a-kind! Clean, efficient and warm, it even satisfied a 17-year-old after a long day's haul in the car. Save your money and skip fake dining at places like like Disney. Visit this diner instead and enjoy an unforgettable serving of authenticity! read more

I-84 Diner - Side facade of I-84 Diner - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

I asked for a lamb burger, and it was burnt on the outside. Roll in the inside, and the salad was an edible, and the olives were taste like it was sitting under the heat lamp and then when we told the manager, he was annoyed and said that the salad was supposed to be dry. read more

Always great to go to the I-84 Diner. Convenient location on Route 52 right off of Interstate 84 in Fishkill. Service is always fast and friendly. Food is always large portions of deliciousness. A lot of choices on the menu for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. An amazing assortment of desserts in the display case up front. read more

Better food. Better service. Coffee refills are fast too. A neighborhood staple for years. Why I always go back. A regular stop for my family. read more

Overall very good. Been coming here for close to 20 years and literally always a good meal. Had the lamb burger special and man, it was good. Order of grape leaves, some mozzarella sticks, Greek salad, matzo ball soup...yeah I went Greek heavy! Everything was great! Service was very good, really good waitress, super attentive. Ambiance was dead, quiet, and chill. Love the old time music read more

Came here withy my brothers and dad on the day after Black Friday. We found the staff to be friendly, the service to be quick, and the food was fresh and delicious. My dad was impressed with the salad with all the different mixed greens (not just romaine), my brother wished his Nutella waffle was just a tad more cooked, and I loved my buffalo chicken wrap! I subbed ranch for blue cheese and was impressed with the crunchy chicken and the cooked wrap. If this was closer to home, I would absolutely come back! read more

See all

I'm a truck driver from Alaska and every time I come through here to the high 84 diner I gotta stop in there and get a real good meal. People are friendly. Food is good reasonably priced very good. Do I recommend this place? Oh yeah 100% read more

Comfortable diner off of 84 with fantastic service and a very friendly ambience. You're seated almost immediately and given a warm welcome from your hostess. I would advise against ordering one or two of the appetizers or breakfast as they are massively proportioned so you're better off sharing with whatever you plan on getting. Definitely a place for a quick turnaround when you need it. read more

The first thing that struck me was the chrome facade was so shiny. As I entered the diner through a hallway leading up to the main floor, it was apparent that this place is kept sparkling clean. That made me know I was in for a treat. I have eaten here over the past week both for dinner and for breakfast. Good food, large portions and plenty of old time diner food and desserts. The menu is so large that you have to be able to find something to suit your taste. They also have Greek food, which is fabulous!beer and wine seal the deal. Service is friendly and speedy. Bathrooms are spotless. I have absolutely no complaints. read more

See all

The food was delivered in a timely manner. The staff was quick and friendly. I am always impressed with their food. This is a great place to visit read more

I was on a bus tour and staying at a motel next door. The bus dropped us off We were going to just order something to go and take it back to our room, but the host was so congenial, saying Oh no! It will be better if you eat here, so we stayed. We each ordered a quesadilla and did not regret staying to eat it fresh off the grill. They were stuffed full of chicken/steak and really tasty with guac and sour cream to top it off. We were just traveling through but would recommend to anyone to stop in and check out their huge menu! read more

My husband and I happened upon this diner while out and about last weekend. Although we've passed it several times, we had never dined there. We were both pleasantly surprised, and had one of the most delicious breakfasts we've had in a while. Both the eggs and pancakes were cooked to perfection. The ambiance was lovely, and the place was spotless, bathrooms 5 stars. Our server was prompt and attentive. We will definitely be back! read more

I-84 Diner - Eggs over medium and the most delicious pancakes! - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

I live in NYC, and about 4 -5 times a year I go upstate to spend weekends with my relatives. Each time we ALWAYS go to the I-84 diner, it's our go to - the last two times we ate here the service was a bit spotty. The last two times they got my order wrong, what I ordered was the simplest thing one could order. I ordered a grilled cheese with bacon on whole wheat bread with a side of fries. When the waitress bought our food to the table she handed me a grilled cheese with no bacon. I mentioned it to her and she said she would bring a side of bacon to the table which takes away from the experience of actually eating a grilled cheese with bacon. I was annoyed to say the least as I tried to put some of the bacon in between the bread with no success. This past Saturday we went to the I-84 diner like we always do, I ordered the same thing grilled cheese with bacon on whole wheat bread and received a grilled cheese with bacon this time (I give them points for actually including the bacon in the sandwich) but it was on Texas toast. I mean, really? How hard is it to make a grilled cheese sandwich the way one asks for it? I even thought about it for a sec, and asked my brother - "I did say whole wheat bread right"? And he said "yes you did". I didn't mention it the waitress this last time, as I was fearful to have it sent back and re-made again, I'm not a fan of sending food back. It's a shame because the food is good, the portions are generous, the menu is extensive. But I told my brother let's try another diner the next time I visit. read more

Stopped here on a recent trip, as it was late and not much else was open on I84. Checked reviews before hand and they looked good. Didn't disappoint. Service was good, food was good, place was clean and well maintained. The only negative was the prices were on the high side. Of course this is shortly after tariffs so we'll assume that's the cause. We'll definitely be back as we pass through the area quite often. read more

Great highway break. After a long drive a nice cold Modelo and a sandwich were in order. Great menu choices. The gyro was hefty and delicious, lots of tasty lamb. The huge portion of clam strips tasted fresh, loads of flavor not overbattered. Its display case full of cakes & sweets was enticing though we were too full to partake. Friendly service and diner-sized generous portions, highly recommended. Just be warned that the bathroom stalls are so small you may hit your head getting up; no space between the toilet and the door read more

I-84 Diner - Gyro w cole slaw - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

Been coming here for a while now. Food is always good. They give you a lot of food. Clean. Service is good too. My go to spot when I'm traveling though the area. read more

Chicken broccoli penne with garlic sauce. The portion sizes are huge.I go to the Tuesday night car cruise. Get dinner, and have the remainder of it for breakfast; all for $25. Great deal! read more

I-84 Diner - Chicken broccoli penne with garlic sauce. - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

My girlfriend and I were to meet a mutual girlfriend of hours at another restaurant when she cancelled at the last minute. So we decided to eat out at a closer restaurant. She had a Belgian Waffle and I had a Chicken Gyro with chicken soup. We both had a diet soda. We both loved our meals. She has to eat soft foods due to having a lot of dental work and I am on a strict low fat, sugar-free, low carb and low salt diet. I had gone months earlier to celebrate a good checkup at an oral surgeon next door, having had an omelet and coffee, also excellent. The ambience is very relaxed, and immaculate. The restrooms are very clean. Next time, when we get together with our mutual girlfriend, all three of us are coming here instead of going to the restaurant she originally suggested. Yes, my girlfriend and I are going to return! read more

came here on long drive. like any other diner. mac n cheese not have a lot of cheese tho tbh but it was all good. server sweet

The food was delicious. The service was great. The Ambiance was good. My only issue was I ordered a simple rum and coke, and was charged $13.99. read more

Fantastic waitstaff at this famous diner! The salmon salad with goat cheese, cranberries and walnuts was delicious. The onion rings are good too. The Greek salad looked amazing too. The steak and cheese was good too! read more

I-84 Diner - Grilled Salmon Salad with walnuts, cranberries and goat cheese. - Diners Near Me - Fishkill, New York

We have been here twice. Both times it's been so extremely clean. WOW I was impressed no cobwebs or dust dangling from the ceiling as you see in many restaurants. Our waitress a small mature lady who had a beautiful accent and was very attentive to our table. My two companions weren't very impressed with their plates. I was ok with my gyro. The meat was flavorful and a nice portion. The sauce was also very creamy and delicious. Truly Greek flavor! On our second try we had a different waitress, mature slender woman. She was very friendly with her usual customers. We ordered breakfast, Scottish Benedict would've been better if the corn beef wasn't out of a can. The hollandaise sauce needed to be much more lemony and thinner. The poached eggs were a tad too cooked so I didn't get a drip out of the yolk. We ordered a cannoli French toast platter and that was pretty good. The omelette lacked seasoning and once again eggs were over cooked. The last order was chicken and waffles. The chicken was a bit dry and had a bones. Waffles were crispy. I do recommend this place although the two times haven't been all that great. There aren't many other options near by. But at least the place is super clean! read more

See all

It exceeded my expectations for a Diner in terms of quality and experience. Our waiter, Michael, was superb. He took great care of us.... funny guy. But the amount of food they give you for the price is unbelievable. I had to loose a few notches on my belt. We ended up taking half of our meals home. They have a french fries section with all the toppings you can choose that is a nice addition. My wife and I left very satisfied, and we would definitely return next time we are in the area read more

Best diner anywhere I have ever traveled. Beautiful art deco era decor, great good, portions and price with very nice owner.