Friday afternoon I was hungry and had never tried anything in the area. I stopped at what I thought was a deli, but it was closed. As I drove by the plaza, I figured someone here had to have food. It came down to a deli or takeout, and deli always wins. I walked in and immediately knew I made the right call. Counters filled with breads, sweets, bagels, and fresh food, and the smells in the air matched exactly what was in front of me. That's always a good sign. There was a menu posted with plenty to choose from. I went with the Black Forest sandwich and also grabbed three giant linzer tart hearts and an apple crumb horn. Price-wise, it felt right for what I got, and I'm always happy to support a local spot. The Black Forest was exactly what I needed on a winter afternoon. I ordered it as a hero and could only finish half. It was stuffed with hot turkey and melted Muenster cheese, and the bread had a great crunch while still keeping a nice chew. The Thousand Island dressing and coleslaw made every bite satisfying. It was definitely a wet sandwich with sauce dripping, and honestly, I loved that. I was excited for every bite. The apple crumb horn was delicious and a must-grab if you're there. It's like an apple pie but lighter and airier, with sweet, slightly crisp apples throughout. 5/5 stars. I'll absolutely be back the next time I'm in the area. read more

See all

this review is for the Apple Horne pastry sold at the FishkillBagel Shoppe on Main Street in Fishkill. I recognize that after mentioning this particular pastry during multiple reviews, I've never really shown you the inside. Here it is. Tip: buy two. Put one in the freezer and before serving pop it into a 350° oven for about 20 minutes, serve hot. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Apple Horn - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

Fantastic bagels with extremely tasty cream cheeses. I door dashed to my house in Poughkeepsie. I ordered a 1/2 dozen and two 1/2lb cream cheeses. I selected the herb cream cheese and the strawberry cream cheese. My favorite was the strawberry. It was the perfect sweetness with chunks or strawberries. The bagels themselves had wonderful flavor. I personally feel these bagels were the best I had in my trip. Pricing was very reasonable and they had all the types I wanted. read more

See all

If you're looking for a proper NY deli with a good bagel and a lot of other options you've found it. They have an extensive menu. I counted no less than 21 different menu signs hung up for you to choose from! I just came for a bagel though and for that, I wasn't disappointed. It was good. I got the veggie cream cheese on a toasted everything bagel. I'd eat it again. (I went to Empire Bagel down the road, the other day and ordered the same thing. A toasted everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. I would say the Bagel Shoppe has a slightly better bagel, but Empire Bagel has better veggie cream cheese.) I also ordered a mochachino coffee which was just so so. I think they made it with premade chocolate milk. I wouldn't order it again. Overall, I think most people would be completely satisfied by this place with all of its options. I give it a thumbs up. As someone who worked in the restaurant industry for many years, I will note that while they moved the long line pretty fast there are glaring inefficiencies in the bagel and cash register area. It seemed to me that they were doing so many extra steps and crossing over each other more than necessary. Most people pay with a card and the credit card reader is not next to the register. Instead, it's back in the corner. So for almost every purchase, they had to walk over somewhere else to finish checking someone out, inevitably crossing over each other, and there are a lot of people behind the counter! Regarding my order, another inefficiency I saw was that they're using a standard double toaster that you would see in someone's home to toast the bagels. The toaster is up on the shelf and the woman that served me couldn't even reach the toaster. She had to grab it and tilt it forward to put the bagel in and out. With the amount of foot traffic this place gets you would think they would invest in a small industrial toaster and put it where the employees could reach it. But hey, I don't work here. I don't even live here. I may or may not have a chance to come back, but I do recommend this place. If you're looking for a good bagel, sandwiches, omelettes, premade deli, salads, cold cuts and cheese. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - The Bagel Shoppe - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

4.50 for a black and white cookie is an insane price. It's cheaper in Zabars in Manhattan !!! Plus they put them in a small bag wrapped in flimsy wax tissue paper that sticks to the icing. When you pull the paper off the icing goes with it. Into the garbage it goes Stop being so damn CHEAP !!! read more

Food is great...service system needs to be revamped for the amount of people that come in...customers shouldn't have to figure it out amongst themselves. read more

The staff were very helpful, patient, and friendly. The sausage egg and cheese on a bagel was awesome. Good chewy bagel. Iced coffee was good. The m&m cookie and black and white cookie tasted stale and just not enjoyable. Couldn't finish them. So bagels yes, cookies nope read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Counter - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

I don't know what was going on today, behind the counter. There were four people behind the counter and two customers in front of me that were waiting for their food. It looked as though who ever waited on you, made the meal. Instead of having a cook who took orders and handed them off when ready. When the BEC was done, after a 15 minute. wait, I decided to eat-in. After a bite or two and not tasting or feeling the bacon I opened the sandwich and was surprised to find 2 tiny pieces (see the photo) of bacon. Were they running out of bacon, at 9:30 in the morning?! I've never had a complaint before. read more

See all

Great bagels, with so many different choices for cream cheese flavors. I personally love the poppy seed rolls that come with the breakfast sandwiches. I've had the SEC, BEC, and just egg and cheese they're all good but the most filling is the sausage. The bacon egg and cheese's tend to not be filled with tons of bacon. Which is strange because if you ask for a bagel with bacon on it it's an outpouring amount of bacon on top! Maybe that's why there's a price difference. I've been coming here for years and every time coming in person is 1000x better than ordering on door dash. I don't think I'll order on DoorDash anymore everything always comes wrong or cold. For me the best option is calling my order ahead and doing pickup myself or just ordering in person. My overall favorite item is the large over sized black and white cookie I've ordered it for parties and birthdays it's always enjoyed by everyone. It's a tight fit of a little hole in the wall cafe/deli type but has a good 6-8 tables that seat 4 people each. If you go early in the morning you'll see a usual crew sitting around that are friendly and cheerful. It feels like a little neighborhood corner bodega. read more

See all

This place is awesome. The bagels are fresh and prices are reasonable. The menu has a variety of choices for everyone. And the service was excellent. It was busy however the pleasant employees acknowledged us in a timely fashion. I can't wait to go back and sample other items from their menu. I got a variety of bagels. My favorite the Asiago bagel with the vegetable cream cheese. My nephew had the rainbow with the walnut raisin cream cheese and he was very pleased. Highly recommend and will be a regular customer . read more

There seems to be some confusion as to whether vegan (dairy free) cream cheese is offered, and they do (in two flavors, I believe). It's not explicitly stated on the menu, but if you ask them, it should be available. read more

Didn't love the food or experience at The Bagel Shoppe. Bagels were dry, not particularly flavorful, and cut poorly (super thick top and super thin bottom). Plus, the breakfast sandwich cheese tasted processed. The ordering process was also a bit chaotic -- employees take orders and then disappear for awhile before returning to ring customers up, which causes a backlog by the register. However, the prices were pretty low ($6 for a breakfast sandwich, $3 for a bagel with butter), so it's an alright spot to stop by for a quick meal during a drive. read more

Pretty good bagel spot. I came because I thought they had vegan options (vegan cream cheese) but I was mistaken. They have tons of options to fit almost any picky eater. Bagels, bagel sandwiches with a variety of cream cheese, deli meats, cheeses, salads, pastas, and much more. The menu is massive and they are busy and move fast so you kind of have to know what you want when you go in. read more

See all

I moved to fishkill in 1999 and have been oing to the Bagel Shoppe since... Best coffee around... lol I have used them to cater numerous holiday parties for my family and it was always perfect Joe is one of the nicest guys around and runs a tight ship If you haven't eaten there, try it read more

Great food with large portions! Counter service with table delivery was good. Ambiance was ok. A true deli.

This is my 3rd year getting the Bagel Shoppe to cater our thanksgiving dinner! I cut into the turkey and the knife slid through the meat!! I knew right away that this dinner was going to be amazing and i was right! Turkey was flavorful and juicy! All the sides were amazing. This makes thanksgiving dinners soo good!!! read more

See all

Best French toast bagel! Nice cozy spot. Staff is always courteous. It's always busy in the morning but they move quick. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - French toast bagel with & - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

This place is AWESOME! Its busy and fast paced and small, but service is super friendly and efficient. The prices are cheap for the area and the food is off the chain! I stopped today and got a Turkey, Munster, Pepper & Onion breakfast burrito that came with a 12 oz coffee/tea (your choice) for $6.48 after tax. What a deal! Not only was the portion generous, but it was SUPER tasty. There is a small area inside to sit and eat, and 2 small tables for 2 outside. This place is a full function deli also, so one can all ones deli meats here also. I cant wait to come back and try something else on the menu... Bonus - They also cater to healthier lifestyles by offering egg whites only, and I did see a turkey spinach wrap...I was tempted...next time! read more

See all

I needed to grab some bagels on Christmas Eve morning because of course everyone expected to arrive at my house by 1pm, so, not Christmas EVE. Annoying. But instead of dwelling on the fact that I had about 5 hours of cooking ahead of me, I visited the Bagel Shoppe. The chaotic scene in there didn't cheer me up, but there I was, waiting on a loooong line and admiring platter after platter of Italian goodness coming out. That's right. Italian. This is an Italian deli! And there's bagels. Kind of an interesting mash-up, but I get it. There's tables and I couldn't help but admire a table of Italian American dudes of all ages sitting around, shooting the shit like the Sopranos, while, presumably, their wives were all home getting the Feast of the Seven Fishes ready for dozens of people arriving later. Good thing I had things to observe. I waited about 20 minutes and finally it was my turn... only the grumpy older man behind the counter decided the grumpy older man behind me was more worthy of his attention. I politely but firmly said about three times, I'm next and both of them ignored me. And then I was fuming. But luckily the girls working there are both helpful and nice and one of them immediately helped me when I asked if I could be helped next since I was ignored by the other dude. "It's Christmas Eve," the older lady who was much further behind me on line but suddenly was paying for her order next to me. "Be happy that they are busy." "Oh, I'm thrilled they are busy, but I won't be ignored," I said, conjuring up my best inner Karen. OK boomers, mind yo business! Not to make this a generational rant, but three boomers annoyed me in less than five minutes there. But four stars because I am thankful for the excellent bagels. Shockingly, a dozen means 18 here! The girl even gave me an extra. And they are awesome bagels, not super huge, like you're eating an entire loaf of bread. They have seeded whole grain that goes well with some everything bagel seasoning. Local bagel store. Local Italian deli (this means Italian cookies AND black and whites! If only they were vegan ones). Local Italian American bromance hangout. The very simple name is kind of misleading, no? read more

For our first- and only- trip here we ordered two toasted bagels with creamed cheese and two hot drinks. Waited 14 minutes and received two cold, not toasted bagels with creamed cheese. Seating area was decently sized but be forewarned, the front door is propped open to the outdoors. On an overcast fifty degree morning, it wasn't an ideal place to sit and eat cold bagels in a stiff breeze. When we finished eating I got back in line so I could order a couple of bagels to take home. When it was my turn to order, a customer who had already placed his food order returned to pick up his food. This is moment I evidently committed the cardinal sin of the Bagel Shoppe. As I stood in front of the cash register, I stepped to the LEFT to allow him to him some elbow room to pick up his bag of food, since the rest of the line formed close beyond me to my right. The cashier then proceeded to help the customer who was after me, without taking my order. This customer had to tell the cashier I was next. At this point the cashier exasperatedly informed me that the line formed to the RIGHT of the cash register, not the LEFT. She used the word "cutthroat" to describe The Bagel Shoppe experience . Cutthroat!!! Bagels! This is a strip mall in Fishkill- not Wall Street. Lucky for me she found an ounce of forgiveness in her heart for a first-time customer and I was able to bring my elderly father the raisin bagels he wanted. read more

Stopped by as we were passing through on a road trip. The bagels were good. However the service was not. We were immediately treated with attitudes and disrespect from the two employees taking/preparing our orders. I get it, New Yorkers are direct and that can rub someone the wrong way. However the there's a difference between direct and plain rude. read more

wow this place is honestly terrible got a bagel with lox and it was $20 and they only put a tiny amount of cream cheese on the top that honestly blew my mind def don't waste your time and money here read more

Busy Sat morning. We were looking for dessert to take to a family gathering. Nice choices and speedy counter service. Wish I had time to order a coffee, their selection was very tempting. read more

I freaking love this place . Old school charm . Anything you can imagine . All the bagels are outstanding . When i was little my mom used to make me toasted onion bagel with a lil butter and thinly sliced bologna . Had to order that recently . The amount of options they have is almost overwhelming , in the best way possible . Their chili was delicious . The stuffed peppers were outstanding . The staff is incredibly friendly , practically treat you like family . & of course - can't leave with out taking some of their beautiful cookies . Every kind you can imagine . read more

I was so happy with the large black and white cookie I ordered for my birthday. They did an amazing job and it was delicious. A big hit with the kids too. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Great food, always taste good and amazing bagels. However, the service is absolutely horrible. They are rude, slow, and disrespectful. This is always consistent no matter when you enter. It's a shame, they really need to work on their sense of urgency and customer service. read more

Absolutely LOVE this place. My wife and I just moved from Indianapolis to the Village of Fishkill to be closer to our kids and our new grandson. We've only been here for about a month so we're still finding our way, but we've been to the Bagel Shoppe twice now for their amazing bacon egg and cheese on a bagel breakfast sandwich, we both absolutely love them and can't wait to go back and try more of their food and sweets. We will be visiting often. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Bacon egg and provolone bagel sandwich - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

The bagel Shoppe is great place for breakfast and lunch. I get all of my holiday catering from them and there has been nothing but delicious. It makes cooking for the holidays so much easier and so much less stressful for the Holidays. read more

Everything bagel all the way This is the way to start your day The best deli in the Hudson Valley read more

The Bagel Shoppe - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Bagel's were great! However, with the increase in COVID recently, it would be nice if the employees were wearing masks. Only 2 out of the 8 employees were wearing one, yet 9 out of 10 of the guests who come in were wearing it. Probably creating a cultural rift and making it super uncomfortable as an employee. With the large amount of tri-state area traffic that comes through beacon, it would be wise to protect your employees from each other as well as the foreign contaminants. Wearing a mask is a sign of mutual respect and a simple way to show you care about those around you. This would be a 5 star review, but that one more step would make for service excellence. read more

A tourist's and local's MUST! This is the classic NY bagel shop, deli meat and lox options, delicious and fresh bagels. They have a great selection of Italian baked goods as well, gotta' love those black and white cookies. This is where the locals go after Church on Sundays to get some normalcy and some delicious breakfast. Stop in and don't let the plaza/ strip mall thing turn you off, that's just the way Fishkill is! read more

See all

Good prices, fast service, always go on Sunday's but had my order messed up. I ordered two bagels with Cream cheese and one with butter for myself. They were all cream cheese. read more

The Bagel Shoppe - The bagel that was supposed to be butter. - Caterers Near Me - Fishkill, New York

If it was in NYC I would give 4/5 (Russ & Daughters is my high bar), but for the Hudson Valley you will not find a better Bagel and Cream Cheese. I LOVE the Jalapeño Cream Cheese and the Lox is also great on the right Bagel. read more

See all

We had bagels and fish platters from the Bagel Shoppe for our after wedding brunch. Joe provided great bagels, fish, spreads and fruit. Everything was delicious and fresh. Several people commented how delicious the whitefish salad was. It was delivered beautifully displayed on platters and at the time requested. I would use them again for another event in the future . Marian B. read more

So yummy! I got a plain with cream cheese, and they loaded it up. I also got a variety dozen, both sweet and savory were delicious and held up well in my backpack though 2 flights back to MS. I've never been to New York City but the vibe in here felt mighty authentic to me! The service was quick even though it was pretty busy at 7am. read more

Had to kill time waiting for the bus, so I decided to give The Bagel Shoppe a try. Noticed that many locals were there. Had a large coffee, breakfast sandwich with cheese and a piece of carrot cake. Loved the generous large breakfast sandwich, fresh large coffee and the large, fresh piece of carrot cake. Am attending a function next week with a girlfriend of mine, and I am going to order a dozen of their boiled bagels and a pound of fresh made cream cheese. The restaurant is immaculate and their customer service is outstanding. They remain me of the delis in my old neighborhood in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn! read more

I use to go hear before this pandemic, never had issue , when in today to pick up food...nobody wearing gloves , during times like this that's a big no no , call me crazy , but I threw my food out read more

Beat sausage egg and cheese I've had since I can remember, possibly ever, definitely the best everything bagel I've ever had, stop eating like a bird and get three eggs on your breakfast sandwiches, you'll never look back read more

Bagels are good, have gluten free bagels too that are okay. The salads are horrible though. The chicken is thick and rubbery and very tasteless. read more

I'm visiting from out of town and this store was highly recommended by some friends who live in Fishkill. I was really looking forward to trying an authentic New York bagel for the first time. My visit left a lot of to be desired. First off, the staff was incredibly distracted. Several employees passed by me while I was up at the register assuming I had already ordered. When someone finally came up to take my order I asked if individual bagels came with a small helping of cream cheese. The sunken eyed teenager with a frizzy dirty blonde bun snottily said "You can buy some" while pointing at their sign showing the per pound prices for cream cheese ($7.99 per pound by the way) That's right, if you want cream cheese with your bagel you have to buy a whole pound of it even if you're only buying one bagel. The bagel and the sandwich I ordered were very good, but unfortunately does not overtake the subpar service and the fact that I had to buy a pound of cream cheese. read more