My new fave spot for New York style pizza. Grab a bite with friends recently and walking in the place was really welcoming. The staff sat us immediately and grabbed our drink orders. We stayed with water but our server returned quickly to take our orders and was very attentive the entire time. My fiancé and I split a medium New York style hot honey and pepperoni pizza. It was perfection, thin and foldable the way I like. It was cut into 8 pieces so the perfect amount to get full and not feel completely stuffed. Now as a sweets lover the gelato really stole the show here. We tried the cookies and cream but the sweet cream base I could devour in gallons! It was perfectly sweet and rich in flavor. I will dream about this gelato for days to come. Overall, a cute and affordable place to stop and catch up with friends. Looking forward to coming back soon. read more

Finally got to try the lunch special at Taglio in OTR! For $15 you get a drink, a salad, and a personal pizza. Upgrades are available if you want a signature style pizza. You can also choose between Detroit style and New York. The Detroit style pizza was so crunch and delicious. Our service was a little slow even though it wasn't very busy, but the waitresses we had were still very nice. Will absolutely be going back. read more

Taglio OTR - Margherita lunch special Detroit style - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Popped in with a party of 11 - easy seating. The 5 kids shared a NY style cheese/pepperoni - which they loved. The adults shared a Detroit style half and half of Buffalo Chicken and Pepperoni and a NY Style Greek/Old Schooler half and half. I really enjoyed them all, with a preference for Detroit Style pizza. Buffalo is very spicy! Pepperoni is perfect. Preferred the Greek over Old Schooler, but both were delicious. Also shared a Pizza Lager with my wife - light and refreshing! Perfect for pizza. 5 stars for the food! Servers could have been a touch more attentive, but we were a lot of people! Definitely would love to try all the pizza options. read more

Taglio OTR - Half Greek, Half Old Schooer - NY Style - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

We eat in Cincy often but had never heard of Taglio until we went there on a brunch tour with Riverside Food Tours. Our server was friendly and got our food and drinks out to us quickly. We had Bianco Detroit style pizza which was very good. The restaurant itself was nice and bright with a lot of tvs set to sporting events if you want to watch your favorite team, but wasn't busy at all at noon on a Saturday, hopefully they are more full later in the day. We definitely want to return and try other menu items. read more

Taglio OTR - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Taglio in OTR is a cozy spot known for its classic pizzas, including Detroit and New York style and gluten-free options, along with fresh salads and crispy fried appetizers. We tried the Hot Honey pizza and the Spinach & Ricotta pizza. Our favorite was definitely the Hot Honey, cooked to perfection with the perfect balance of sweet and savory flavors. Highly recommend checking them out if you haven't already! read more

See all

We stayed at a local B&B and didn't want to go out so we ordered take out. We ordered on line and everything came exactly as we ordered. It also came faster than the app said which was nice. The salad was the freshest salad I've ever had in take out. The pies were all fantastic! We had one of our party that can hardly eat anything and she ordered gluten free and vegan and LOVED it. Will definitely get this again the next time we're in town. read more

See all

Gluten-free pizza was pretty good, but sauce was overly sugary. Wine: although it was good, a glass was served in a mini-wine glass, and i would say it was only a 4-oz. pour (1/2 cup) insted of 6, and at $14 was way over priced! Buyer beware! I will be back, as it is near theatre. But not sure i will order wine. read more

Amazing pizza. We came in on a Saturday night and were pleasantly surprised to be seated right away. The hot honey pepperoni pizza was outstanding. Flavorful, baked to the perfect crisp, and the dough was great. Ladies room was MASSIVE. read more

Taglio OTR - Cheesey bread - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

I had a deep dish pepperoni that really hit the spot but I was eyeballing the, "Queen Coney Pizza" that whole time. Stay tuned for an update... read more

Taglio OTR - Yummers - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Had a pizza and breadsticks. Delicious! And they broadcast Blue Jackets hockey games, too!

Wasn't bad but wasn't anything crazy. Pizza was pretty good. Thought it would be better, it's a popular restaurant and I always hear great things about it. Service was good, place wasn't busy at all, we went on a Thursday night. Nothing bad to say about it, I was just expecting to be wowed. read more

Taglio OTR - Pepperoni Hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Good and service were great. Really good pizza! Prices were also very reasonable. Definitely would recommend.

It's been a month and I'm still thinking about this pizza. Specifically the vegan cheese. We had warm and inviting service, a beautiful glass of dry rose and large TVs at the bar to keep us entertained. I loved that this place is a mix of it all. The Spicy Italian pizza was the favorite of the visit. We also tried the buffalo chicken which was crushed immediately. Perfect for solo diners and groups. read more

Taglio OTR - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Came here looking for dinner a couple nights ago, sat at the bar. Service was friendly and attentive. Prices are slightly high, but the food is worth it. Other than that, it's basically what you'd expect from a pizza place in atmosphere. I had their hot honey and pepperoni pizza, but got a New York style. It was good, but next time I'm likely going deep dish. read more

this small cheese pizza detroit style with (banana peppers) (basil) (mushrooms) cost $25 read more

Taglio OTR - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I always like to give places another shot, even if my first visit was just okay. Tonight, I stopped by Taglio in OTR and ordered cheese sticks and a personal pepperoni thin crust. Unfortunately, the cheese sticks didn't live up to what I remember--they used to be great, but tonight they just didn't hit the spot. I've had excellent ones in the past, and I was under the impression they were made in-house. The pizza was alright, but nothing standout. I have to say, as much as I enjoy living in Cincinnati, the pizza scene here doesn't compare to my native hometown of Dayton. Places like Cassano's, Flying Pizza, Joe's Pizzeria, and Marion's Piazza (just to name a few) set the bar high. Dayton simply does pizza best. I don't love leaving negative reviews, but honest feedback matters. Hopefully, Taglio can step it up next time! read more

Taglio OTR - PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I really enjoyed our meal at Taglio! They specialize in Detroit pan pizza with a lot of interesting topping combinations. We chose the Pineapple Chipotle which was on point! Savory and sweet met up and danced amazingly! The appetizer trio also featured some amazing mozzarella stix and eggplant parmesan as well as some well made fried green tomatoes. Mwuah! There are a couple of exclusive drafts on tap, satisfactory as well. Service was very attentive and helpful. Very informed and offered suggestions. I would go back! read more

See all

Let's not talk cra* about customers right in from of them ? The larger girl at the bar with the brown hair and nose ring could use an Atticus adjustment. On her phone more than helping. When I asked for simple things, it clearly annoyed her. Get out of the bizz if you don't want to be here. read more

We stopped into Taglio on a Thursday for lunch. We ordered a large cranberry almond salad and a small Detroit style Pepperoni + Honey pizza. The salad was delicious and the pizza was outstanding! Plenty of TVs around the bar to watch college basketball as well! read more

See all

My wife and I were in town for our anniversary and stumbled into this place for dinner. Choice of Detroit or New York style. We both opted for Detroit and it was AWESOME. Crispy edges, fluffy center, and vegetarian meat options as well if that floats your boat. Get the hot honey on your pizza, too. Also our server was super friendly and helpful and gave us great recommendations. read more

Taglio OTR - Old Fashioneds - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The pizza was. I ordered it with hot honey and was charged extra for it, but it wasn't on the pizza. I even asked the waitress before leaving, and she assured me it was included. When I got home, it was clear it wasn't there. So I paid extra for something I didn't get, which was disappointing. Flavor-wise, the pizza could use a boost, and I think the hot honey would've made a big difference. I might consider giving the place another shot, but I hope they're more attentive next time. read more

Taglio OTR - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

All four of us had different small Detroit style pizzas. All four ate every single bite. Great flavor, great toppings and the crust was perfect. It didn't overwhelm the pizza but was a great Part of it. Service was quick, knowledgable and very helpful with a gluten allergy and a dairy allergy. Definitely would go back read more

This is the premier spot to get pizza in OTR. The place is nice and casual and they provide fantastic customer service. The friend green tomatoes and eggplant appetizers are both tremendously good. The deep dish Margherita is some of the best pizza we've ever eaten. Would absolutely recommend trying this place out. read more

See all

So delicious and some of the best pizza I have had. It's fresh and the service and quick and the people are so kind! read more

Taglio OTR - Pepperoni Hot honey and Spinach Ricotta pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Good beer list. Three primes is their brew made by Northern Row. Weird salad. Lettuce with dressing (felt like my college days) Pizza very good. Had Detroit style, friend had NY thin. Both good. Lunch special. Salad pizza pop $15. Layer on brews and it's a $25 lunch oh well. Worth it!! read more

See all

We stopped here after a few shows at the Fringe Festival. We didn't have reservations, but were seated immediately. I loved the ambience, which was comfortably industrial. The beer list is more than satisfactory. Our server was pleasant and helpful. I ordered a Detroit style Spinach & Ricotta. Mark ordered a Detroit style Deluxe. We hadn't had a Detroit style pizza before, but we've had it many times since from multiple restaurants. I believe it is my favorite style of pizza. The crispy edges drive me wild! Both of our pizzas were delicious. We've not been back, but if we're in the area we would absolutely stop in again. read more

See all

First time here! New to Cincinnati area and looking for good pizza. Have been disappointed in places we have tried .... But then we tried Taglios !!! FOUND GREAT PIZZA!!! Awesome toppings and crust was amazing. Service (Mary) was great !! Definitely going to return. read more

Taglio OTR - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Absolutely delicious hot honey pepperoni pizza! We went with the New York style and it was tremendous, but the table over went with Detroit style and it also looked amazing. Next time we're in town we may have to try the Detroit style, but the New York was so good that it would be extremely difficult to not get again. Also ordered the Caesar salad, and somehow it was delicious as well. The dressing and the croutons were great and really took the salad up a level. Our waitress was also so kind and attentive. Highly, highly recommend this place and will absolutely be back again next time I'm in Cincinnati. read more

Taglio OTR - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Stopped by here for an early dinner. Went with the Pepperoni with hot honey pizza, Detroit style. 10 out of 10. From the sauce to the cheese to the hot honey to the quality of the bread. It is a bit on the pricier side than what I'm used to paying for, but the quality of the pizza was really good. Service was attentive. Plenty of seating, as well as televisions to watch whatever games are on. Good spot to start off a date or catch up with a girlfriend. read more

Taglio OTR - Pepperoni Hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Best pizza hands down in the city! Always service with kindness and smile! Deep dish Detroit style our favorite!

We have been here a few times, and it was always good pizza. But on this last visit, they upped their game, and it was EXCELLENT. There were fourteen of us in town for a graduation, and they gave use our own room! We had a New York style cheese and mushroom, plus a Peperroni and Hot Honey Detroit style. These were absolutely some of the tastiest pizzas we have had. We will be returning to Cincinnati for some games, and we will be back to Taglio's! The servers and food make it a must stop. read more

This place was introduced to us recently and let me say it's some GOOD pizza!! If you like Detroit style, i haven't had any better locally. The crunch of the corner pieces is to DIE for!!! and the flavors all combined make for a good pizza. We got a medium for 20 people and there was 2 slices left! we were more than full. On top of that I got a cherry balsamic salad (i wanted to get something other than caesar!) it was amazing, the textures that were in it and the Gorgonzola was a perfect punch of cheese as well. We stopped in on a Friday night not too busy looked like a lot of people were coming in for pick up, but we were sat at a high top table for 3 people and were served pretty quickly. Had a waiter change midway but all in all service was okay. This place is a MUST stop if you're in the mood for a new pizza place. 9/10! read more

See all

TLDR; get it for takeout, not dine in. Visited Taglio for Cincy Pizza Week and dined in for the first time. I've gotten takeout multiple times and am a huge fan of their Detroit style pizza - the pepperoni hot honey is my favorite! The pizza they offered for pizza week was a Brooklyn style pizza, which was also really good, but the dine in experience just wasn't the best. We had two servers who checked in with us periodically, but the time between ordering and receiving our food took a while, even though the restaurant wasn't packed. Our server even told us that our food would be out soon, but it was another 5-10 minutes after she told us that our food came out. The pizza was pretty cold when we received it, which is a shame cause the pizza itself tasted good. All of us also ordered Cokes and they were either extremely flat or fizzy but without enough syrup. If it were solely based on my one experience I'd probably give it three stars, but I know how good the pizza is so bumped up to a four. All to say, the pizza here is great; the in dining experience, not so much. read more

Taglio OTR - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I'm a little behind (okay, way behind) on this review. My son lives and works in OTR and we meet here on occasion for dinner or lunch. I love their Deroit-style pizza. To be fair, that's all I ever order. Nice crust, generous toppings, and tasty sauce that doesn't overpower the pie. Good service, decent prices for OTR/CBD adjacent. if you're looking for Detroit-style pizza (thick but crunchy butter crust) this is the place to go. read more

My breakdown is as follows- 4 stars for the food, zero stars for the service - averaging out to my final, 2 star review. Pizza was great, but the service was atrocious. Our server was rude, unattentive and messed up our order but still made us pay for the up-charged wrong order anyway. Not only that, but when he realized his mistake, instead of fixing it, just ignored us for the remainder of our visit until we were sick of waiting and wanted to leave. Honestly, who messes up a pizza order and then never comes back to check if things are ok, offer napkins, red pepper flakes, more drinks, etc? This lack of respect and decency to guests is not acceptable. I wish I could recommend this place, but the server, who will remain nameless, was a reflection of the restaurant and a true disappointment. read more

First time dining here for lunch! The lunch special is such a good deal. $15 for small pizza (Detroit or nyc style), salad (house or ceaser) and a soft drink! You can also order a specialty pizza for a $3 up charge. It's pretty shareable too if you're looking for a lighter lunch. We ordered the eggplant stack as well which as always is so flavorful and breaded perfectly! read more

Taglio OTR - Eggplant Stack - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Great room for family gatherings and super service. The pie was delicious and the ice cream after superb.

Some top notch deep dish!!! Sometimes, pizza doesn't feel special since it's so common, but this place brings the excitement back to pizza! Such good deep dish that just wows anyone. The crust is thick, buttery, and garlicky. The topics are all perfection as well! We got a medium and it was more than enough for 2 people! Also pro tip- they let you split toppings in a medium or large so you can have 2-in1! The service could be better, that is the only drawback but everything else was above and beyond!! read more

See all

Service - 5/5 Food - 5/5 Ambiance - 4/5 Price - 4/5 Wow! This was good pizza. The mozzarella sticks were unbelievable, probably the first homemade mozzarella stocked I've ever had. There was so much cheese! We got the Detroit style pepperoni hot honey which was a great recommendation by the bartender. Crispy and soft with well balanced flavors. read more

Taglio OTR - Pepperoni Hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

We love their pepperoni hot honey Detroit style pizza! Got a large for the 2 of us and we had half leftover. Place was very quiet during Monday lunch hours. Service was great as usual! Little more on the pricey side ($30) but you really get what you pay for! read more

Taglio OTR - Pepperoni Hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio