My dad and I visited Sweet Basil during our first night in Vail solely because my uncle worked here in the late 70s/early 80s. What my dad did not know, however, was that over the past decade or two, this has become the "it" spot in Vail. I looked at the menu online beforehand and I could easily see why--creative, elegant, diverse and of course, expensive. Unlike a lot of overhyped places, Sweet Basil completely lived up to expectations.
While we knew of Sweet Basil long before our trip here, we didn't make a reservation. It IS possible to get a table/eat here without one, but it may require some waiting. One little pearl of wisdom we received from a local was that Sweet Basil has a zero tolerance no-show/egregious tardiness policy. When we showed up here, we were anticipating eating at the bar, as their was an hour wait for a table (they allow this). The food gods had a different plan in store for us, however. After about 15 minutes, the hostess informed us that there was, in fact, a no show! Right place, right time. Off to a good start. My tip if you come without a reservation: arrive on the earlier side. It fills up quite a bit around 8 or so.
First off: drinks. Hard to go wrong here. I'm used to cocktails in NYC, so these weren't as highbrow as I'm used to (go ahead, judge away). That said, I thoroughly enjoyed both of my drinks here. For the health nut, go for the What's Up Doc? (Vodka, Yellow Chartreuse, Coriander, Lime, Carrot Juice, Bitters). Semi-sweet, light and a touch of spice. Perfect to start off the night. I also tried the Alpinist, which is up there with some of the ultimate winter drinks: Sage Infused Buffalo Trace Bourbon, Vermouth, Peach Vanilla Cordial. Sultry, boozy and a bit herbaceous.
The star of the night (as one would hope...) was the masterfully executed food. Obviously, we had to share. It's hard to dine with me without being pressured to share. Just the way I'm wired. Everything we had was its own brand of flavorful/special/creative/scrumptious. Even the entrees here are conducive to sharing (you get multiple slices of protein X in just about everything), so this worked out well. We got:
Salmon Tataki (Soy Caramel + Tempura Avocado + Sesame Puffed Rice + Mustard Seed) - A+++
What a superb dish to start a meal off! Just wow. If you look at my picture, you can see how beautifully prepared this was. I was impressed with the presentation...until I tried it. THEN I was impressed. I'm very into the whole diversity of flavors/textures thing (is that even a "thing"?), but not if its excessive. In this dish, each ingredient had its place, and all contributed to quite the well-rounded, complex taste. There's a hint of spice here (maybe the mustard seed?) but nothing that'll prompt you to start downing water after each bite. We all know raw salmon and avocado go well together--the puffed rice just made it a next-level experience. Just a subtle crunch--yum.
Buffalo Tartar (Parmesan + Horseradish + Pine Nuts + Egg Jam + Brioche) - A
I would say the "least best" but still really damn good. Again, great first impression with the presentation (see image). The buffalo was light and fluffy and paired wonderfully with the mild parmesan. Again, you've got some subtle spice with horseradish, subtle crunch with the pine nuts and brioche, and some nice creaminess from the egg. Dat execution tho.
Ahi with Wild Mushrooms (Pine Dashi + Soba Noodles + Lemongrass Chili Condiment) - A+
We got to enjoy some more Japanese flavors with this gorgeous tuna dish--looking back at the night, we unwittingly ordered ourselves quite the balanced meal. I'd say this is one of the lighter entrees on the menu, but it still manages to be bold and flavorful, as everything else here is. Nothing superfluous about the broth here--they pour it over the tuna when it's served and makes the whole plate cozy/comfy.
Pan Roasted Duck Breast ("Farrotto" + Brussels Sprouts + Preserved Huckleberries + Soubise) - A+++
My dad and I were both fawning over this dish long after the meal ended. The sidekicks were almost better than the duck. Don't get me wrong, the duck was perfectly cooked and super flavorful, but the other components more than held their own. This dish was hearty and warming--perfect for a snowy winter night. A hint of sweetness is always a welcome addition most duck preparations, in my humble opinion, and the huckleberries were just that. It's hard to pick a favorite of the night, but this just might've been it.
Lastly, I need to dole out some high praise to our wonderful waitress. She was so sweet and personable, it caught me off guard at first. Perhaps this is because I'm so used to service i New York, which can be on the brusque side at times. Regardless, she was efficient/chatty-but-not-too-chatty/informative and any other positive adjective you could think of to describe a server. Sweet Basil just exudes class in every area--the five star rating was a no-brainer. We definitely did my uncle proud. read more