Stopped in this little gem in Scarsdale. We got there at 6 PM. A bottle of tapwater was brought to…read moreour table with menus and bread. Umia our server asked for our drink order. I opted for water as my grandson did and his fiancé order a glass of white wine. It was Sauvignon Blanc, and she found very satisfying. For an appetizer, we shared a truffle pizza. It was a different flavor that I never had before, but very tasty. For entrees they ordered a sliced steak and chicken parm. I went for the seared duck with mushroom gravy. I never had duck served this way. I really really enjoyed it. No one wanted a dessert so my grandson ordered espresso and I ordered a cappuccino. The waitress brought us thin slices of powdered sugar biscotti as a compliment. The ambience is quiet and cozy and dimly lit with an electric light on each table. On the menu it mentions like this restaurant is a sister location of Cafe Alia, also in Scarsdale. This was an excellent choice for Thursday night. You won't be disappointed.Sal E. New Rochelle

I've been coming here since they opened a couple of years ago. The menu has changed from a tapas…read morestyle and meal place to more of an entree style trattoria. The service is always stellar with a good wine menu. The ambiance is peaceful and cozy always with the Garth Road locals who are such wonderful people. But I actually came here twice this week because of their personal pizzas. The manager told me to try it and I fell in love with it, in addition to their mouth watering paella. I even stopped by there yesterday just to have a couple of glasses of wine. Knowing myself, I'll be back there this weekend or next week.

This place gets busy so be prepared for a wait for a table. I sat at the bar and had a beer before…read moreour table was ready (about 15 minutes). The bartender and the server were efficient and pleasant. We ordered the meatballs, wings, and garlic knots. The meatballs and wings were good, the garlic knots were okay. The vodka burrata pie was a nice refreshing slice. The hot honey pie definitely has some kick, so if your spice tolerance is low or you are prone to heart burn, the mix of tomato sauce and spice from this slice might not be a great idea. Fantastic beer selection if you like IPAs. Each of us tried something different and we all found something we liked. There are also plenty of non-alcoholic beer selections too, for those that appreciate the flavor, but don't want ABV.

Amazing bar with amazing pizza!!!…read more I love a really thin crust pizza and this was up my alley. The French onion one was a fan fave! We wished we got more than one. The service was also great. The atmosphere is just like your traditional bar! Only con is that the parking is really challenging so I would allot time to do that!

My husband and I were looking for a nice casual place for lunch yesterday and came upon this…read morerestaurant and decided to try it. So glad we did. We were given the option of sitting inside or outside in the beer garden and chose outside. Our server was very knowledgeable about the beers and menu items and the food was great. Mid meal the manager Patti came out to greet us and asked about our meal and was very welcoming and friendly. She also came by after our meal to see how everything was. Overall GREAT FIND. highly recommend.

The vibe here was great, we sat in the beer garden in the back. The tint of the covering adds a fun…read moreambiance, and the service was quick and friendly. I ordered the Cobb salad, which was very sizable and I appreciated the amount of chicken. The elk burger was also delicious, though the cheese was a bit of an odd texture that seemed to not fully melt.

I haven't been to this place in over 10 years. Being that I was by the area today, I decided to…read moregive this place another try. As always, I often order a plain slice and a Sicilian slice with a Diet Coke. The regular slice was crunchy and firm with a perfect consistency of cheese and sauce. The gentleman behind the counter was so friendly. He told me, "I have a fresh Sicilian pie coming out of the oven. Eat this slice first and I'll bring you your fresh Sicilian." I devoured the tasty slice and couldn't resist waiting for the Sicilian. He brought the Sicilian to me and it was worth the wait. Both slices had the perfect blend and balance of cheese and delicious sauce. Now this place has about 3-4 booths and a few tables. They also sell beer and wine if you feel like having them with your other Italian dishes. I'll definitely stop by again soon to sample some of their other pizza dishes. In addition to their delicious pizza, I felt as though I was at home with family.

Second review here. The chicken Marsala was fantastic! What a value! Only $17 and huge - lasted…read moremore than 2 meals. Came with roasted potatoes plus a huge side of pasta and delicious garlic knots. Incredible value and high quality! Got the rigatoni burrata which was a vodka sauce and absolute perfection! Also a huge portion. So delicious. I would absolutely recommend the pasta and entrees here. The Italian man who works here is also so sweet and friendly - it's a pleasure to visit him.

We stopped in here Saturday night during the street fair for Halloween. They were one of the few…read morebusinesses nice enough to let people use the bathroom even if they didn't buy anything. The staff were friendly and efficient. Pizza was good. I just got a plain slice. Sadly they brought out the white pizza as I was leaving. I would definitely come back the next time I'm in Sleepy Hollow.

Casaletto Pizzeria is legit. Good crust, quality ingredients, and the pizza tastes like it should…read more Not greasy, not dry--just done right. Feels like a real neighborhood spot: quick service, fair prices, and consistent every time. Easy place to recommend and come back to.

Have ordered delivery service. Food is always delivered timely & warm. One time Tony didn't have…read moreanyone to deliver to me so he said it would be a while & about 2 hours later he delivered my order himself. Food is 1st quality & delicious. I order about 2x a month.

The food was amazing. It came very quickly. The fries were great. The pizza was amazing and try the…read moreZeppoli's.

Wow! What a delicious meal, with great, attentive service in a place that felt warm, but also…read morefestive and lively! AND there were vegan options, so my vegan sis had a great meal too! Loved this spot!

Party of three went for dinner and was disappointed with service. Place was practically empty and…read morewe waited over one half hour for service while waiters tended to bar customers and others who came after us. We complained to the floor manager who had a bland response and nothing was expedited. As we were poised to walk out, after 45 minutes, a waiter magically appeared offering more bread and filled our drink order. Food was decent but the take home bag was poorly packaged and the sauce spilled into the bag itself creating a mess. Of note, there were no apologies for the poor service or even the offer of a drink on the house to compensate for the delay. After dining there several times, they are now crossed off the list. Will advise friends and family to go elsewhere.

Not exactly what I was expecting based on the reviews. The good: ample parking, lovely outdoor…read morespace (which we didn't utilize as we visited late November), nice beer selection, fun family atmosphere, decent food variety for a brewery and fantastic staff (easy going, attentive, friendly. Truly, 10/10). The not-so-good: the food. It was unfortunately just mediocre. We ordered the classics - fried chicken sandwich, classic burger, pizza margarita and fries, and felt that each missed the mark. Chicken sandwich's flavors were off; Burger was dry; pizza had excessive sauce and acidity; and the fries were over-salty. I can see myself coming back with a group to just hangout and enjoy the drinks and vibes, but would not vouch for this place if food quality was a priority.

Large parking lot…read more Arrived around 3pm on a nice Sunday and it was fairly empty. Lots of picnic bench-style indoor and outdoor seating. Neat and very well-maintained space. A great selection of beer on tap. There is also a nice selection of food as well. Good mix of diverse people...different age groups including some kids. Friendly and helpful staff throughout. Shop with some merch and to-go beer. Clean bathroom. Would love to return to try some other beers and maybe some food options.

We just used Pizza Luca for our daughter's first birthday and i can't even explain how great the…read moreday was. Dean and staff were amazing and food was so delicious. The truck was awesome and made a statement parked in the driveway for all our guests. We really appreciate how involved and accommodating the team was with our event. Highly recommend booking them, i know we will be again in the future!

What a beautiful experience. Truck was gorgeous and the food was delicious. Thank you!read more