Smith Street Pizza

35

177

342

1 year ago

Fast service, good pizza, a bit on the pricier side but would definitely recommend if you just need to grab a slice! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Small little pizzeria with a couple tables inside and a variety of pizzas, pastas and entrees.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Really enjoyed their buffalo chicken slice. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Melissa M.

446

336

261

1 year ago

I tried to go in the bathroom with my toddler before I was going to purchase garlic knots and the man at the counter was very rude about it. He just said "hello lady" and kept saying that until I interacted with him. I decided not to buy anything and just leave so we could find a friendly restaurant for a snack and a restroom visit. We live down the street and both me and my husband will choose a friendlier pizza shop to get a slice. I've had their pizza and it's nothing to write home about any way. Much better off going to Baby Luc's. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Peter D.

4748

3626

14272

2 years ago

Things I Love About Smith Street Pizza: 1. The best garlic knots. I don't say that lightly. 2. The pizza is excellent, as you like to see from a pizza place. 3. A mushroom pie here means real, fresh mushrooms sliced. Not canned. 4. The Caesar salad is damn good. 5. When I get a salad with my pizza, I feel healthy. 6. The penne alla vodka is excellent, as is the Chicken Francese. 7. The pepperoni is the good stuff #ronicups. 8. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a nice little shop, even if I do end up getting delivery more than walking in.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Things I Don't Love About Smith Street Pizza: 1. This one time we ordered a pie that was supposed to be half plain, half pepperoni and mushroom. They gave us half pepperoni, half mushroom. Which I don't really have a problem with, but my kids do. And while part of me thought, "Oh well, more pizza for me," their little cries of hunger put a damper on my enthusiasm. You did that, Smith Street Pizza. You made my kids cry. (They were actually more than happy with the penne alla vodka.) read more

Smith Street Pizza - Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Smith Street Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Smith Street Pizza - Dinner - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 6

Thanks 2

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Glenn C.

Elite 26 All-Star

401

2627

14277

2 years ago

I went into this pizza place a couple days ago. They need a sign up that virtually all other pizza places have which list the prices as if I knew that the mushroom slice was going to be $5 (+ more for paying with card,) I likely would have gotten a plain for $3.50 which is much more reasonably priced. I did check online outside of this and the other topping slices are also $5 which means either that the single topping slices are overpriced or the slices with multiple toppings are reasonable. Outside of the price points, it was a pretty standard slice though I would say the crust was a little bit thick. Sauce was pretty solid not too sweet and the cheese had a good pull. The mushrooms were standard and not really worth the upcharge. The size was a tad smaller than most spots in the area. Alright slice albeit a bit pricey. Mid/low 3. read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

RA W.

6

157

25

8 months ago

Decent, good hours. So far not writing momma, just dig they try to keep REAL NYC hours, yet close at later "baby hours" for this town. Most pizzerias here post covid are PATHETIC. Why live in a city when You can live in suburbs later? read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bunny B.

0

6

0

3 months ago

The pizza is actually pretty good! However the customer serves is unfriendly and sucks more times than not. Went early this morning nobody wanted to help and was unfriendly. I wish the staff was friendlier because the pizza is actually pretty good. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lauren C.

1

42

78

1 year ago

BEST PIZZA EVER LIKE EVER. Vodka and margarita size OMGGNMGMGG. So glad I tried it and didn't get something from a deli. Workers are super friendly and kind, start orders right away. Price of pizza is a lil pricey but it's a good neighbor so ofc. Want to try the chicken parm and some pasta next and I think I saw a chicken bbq slice too! I love a restaurant with not too many options because that means it's very good. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Place is super clean and cute.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Smith Street Pizza - vodka slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Priscilla S.

1567

240

1791

3 years ago

I'm going to repeat this! I am not a huge fan of pizza but when I do have a slice that makes me want more because it's that good I have to yelp about it, lol. I frequent this area a lot but I've never noticed this pizza shop. It's a small establishment in the middle of the block and so easy to overlook. I met my daughter here for a late afternoon lunch date & to my surprise, I enjoyed the slice & garlic knots. The garlic knots are big & so flavorful. The slice tasted & looked fresh. It's worth stopping by if in the area you won't be disappointed with the food or customer service. read more

Smith Street Pizza - a pizza with mushrooms and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 8

Thanks 2

Love this 6

Oh no 0

Alec H.

0

6

5

1 year ago

Best local pizza around - easy, delicious, and good variety. I would definitely recommend to anyone in the area

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eric L.

0

1

0

9 months ago

Came here three times. Twice the pizza wasn't reheated enough. Still cold when I bit into it. The third time I asked for well done and it was the same. They took it out after a few seconds in the oven. Will not be returning. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chuck V.

0

3

0

10 months ago

The pizza is the best in the neighborhood. Thin crust, gooey cheese, spicy pepperoni- it's always delicious. A favorite "go to" spot.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Q C.

11

18

10

3 years ago

Nasty Did not wash his hands after sneezing in them... refused to use soap when I asked! The other workers there are nice and polite. read more

Smith Street Pizza - Does not wash hands after sneezing in them! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Smith Street Pizza - Wash your hands with soap Mr! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Juan M.

6

3

2

2 years ago

Smith Street Pizza is definitely a hidden gem, pizza is second to none, as is the service. I would put this place up against any of the top rated pizza spots in the city. I come all the way from Staten Island to get my pizza fix whenever I get a chance, never disappoints. The fried calamari is on par with the best restaurants out there, and the specialty pies are phenomenal. If you're a pizza lover, you need to give them a try, your taste buds will thank you. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

April B.

0

2

0

1 year ago

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Because it's a nice place and I think the food is really good[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] but [[HIGHLIGHT]]if I remember right there is no bathrooms[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kenny C.

Elite 23

1051

4499

19744

4 years ago

The newest slice joint on Smith Street! I've been looking for an alternative to Brooklyn Pizza Market ever since their quality went down, and Smith Street Pizza is a worthy successor! Beautiful space, with a yard to soon open. Everyone working there is super friendly. Lots of variations. I got a Sicilian/square with broccoli rabe, and one with mushrooms. Great crust, good cheese/sauce ratio. $5 a pop makes for a cheap dinner. They said their full kitchen will be operational soon! read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jacob S.

10

11

8

3 years ago

Best slice I had while visiting the city. Doesn't seem super hyped up with ridiculous wait times and lines down the sidewalk (looking at you L'industrie). Options were good, was quick, tasted great, cute little back patio to sit and enjoy in the sun. Would easily recommend. read more

Smith Street Pizza - Back patio seating - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Mark G.

10

229

657

4 years ago

Stopped by Smith st pizza and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza slice I bought was fresh and decent. The interior decor is also unique. If you're in the neighborhood it is definitely worth a try. There are many options to choose from and I am sure you will enjoy your selection as much as I have. read more

Smith Street Pizza - From inside - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Smith Street Pizza - a ceramic figurine of a chef - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Smith Street Pizza - Thick slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Randall M.

30

764

792

2 years ago

I stopped into Smith Street Pizza to grab a bite. I ordered a Margherita slice, and a Mushroom slice. Both slices were properly cooked. They had a crisp crust, and the sauce was just right. The space is nice, and the bathroom was clean. It's proximity to the F/G lines means that I'll be back sooner than later. Two slices and a bottle of water cost $12.00. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Denis O.

0

2

0

2 years ago

Delivery took an hour, the delivery woman couldn't make change because she showed up with no cash, and they gave us the wrong sodas. Nobody at this place cares. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Adam B.

5

8

0

3 years ago

Went once - was disappointed. Average pizza despite the relatively upscale atmosphere. Service was meh for a neighborhood pizzeria. And there was a mouse in the dining area. Do not recommend but others may have a better experience. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Allycia F.

0

18

13

2 years ago

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The vibe is very weird[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]], the pizza is okay. I wouldn't come here again, y'all need to work on your customer service read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mia F.

0

4

0

4 years ago

Highly recommend stopping into this new pizza stop in Carroll Garden's. As someone who is allergic to dairy & eggs, I often seek out good vegan pizza and Smith Street did not disappoint! I was able to get a personal pie with their homemade dough, marinara, vegan cheese, peppers & mushrooms. It was DELICIOUS! Smith Street has VEGAN and GLUTEN FREE options. The best part is that they were super quick! I walked in and out in 10 minutes, even though they had to make my pizza from scratch. Definitely recommend stopping into this new pizza spot. It was fabulous. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Natalie L.

0

15

2

2 years ago

the pizza here is excellent! you can get a big slice with a thin, crunchy crust for a great price. I recommend the bbq chicken pizza

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diana M.

1

38

95

2 years ago

My kids LOVE the pizza here. The slices are big and so are the pie's. Great value for the price. They also have a great menu of pasta and other items. The back garden is great to sit with your family, though not super big. Service is fast. We come here all the time now for tradition New York style pizza. My kids even asked to get veggie slices. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Erika G.

5

95

107

4 years ago

My son and I stopped by this place, since the place we usually go to is cash only. We loved it! I loved the vibes inside, it's super chill and the pizza was delicious. Not too oily, crispy enough, but not burnt. The service was awesome. The other patron's were also very happy in there bc I overheard them telling the cook. This will be our new pizza place! I cannot wait until they open the garden seating. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marissa B.

3

28

7

4 years ago

So glad I strolled into this place. Pizza was amazing! First the dough had good texture. Slightly chewy where it should be, and crispy & soft in other spots. I got the vegan cheese and it didn't have any weird tastes. I saw they had different style crusts and pizza by the slice I think too. I ordered a whole pie with veggies to go. Price was super fair AND the staff was very friendly, fast and you can tell care about what their customers think. Would come again! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

A R.

0

20

0

3 years ago

Decent slice shop. Never disappointed. Great people and service. Would have a slice here over baby luc's any day.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ann R.

0

57

0

3 years ago

Yummy! Good and hot cheese pizza plus friendly staff, and clean establishment. I'll be back!

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

CK J.

0

15

0

3 years ago

This place looks like a fancy slice joint. It is like a slice joint in that you choose your slice, and they serve it piping hot but also soggy right out of the oven. The tables are dirty and you must clean them yourself. It is not like a slice joint in that the slices are $5.00 each and if you ask for a cup of plain water the answer is no. I had the Margarita and sausage/mushroom slices. No reason to go back. Much better choices in the neighborhood (My Little Pizzeria, a genuine slice joint, and F&F, a genuine fancy slice joint worth the price). read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John F.

0

11

3

4 years ago

Loved the pizza here, especially the grandma which was thinner than the usual Sicilian. We went here are first night staying in Carroll Gardens and just loved it read more

Smith Street Pizza - Tried three different varieties, all were great. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Katie D.

0

8

0

3 years ago

There is no gluten free pizza if you are looking for it but everyone else liked it. There is no gluten free pizza if you are looking for it but everyone else liked it. There is no gluten free pizza if you are looking for it but everyone else liked it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

R B.

0

27

0

4 years ago

My husband and I travel from Midwood to enjoy the Pizza at this charming new Pizza Restaurant in Carroll Gardens. There are so many pizza variations to try and we plan on trying them all! So far, we have had the pepperoni, traditional and vegetable and they were all delicious. The toppings are fresh and plentiful. The prices are extremely reasonable. We love the space also. You can sit inside or in the beautiful open garden in the back - perfect for date night or for those who prefer the outside. Miguel, the gentleman who made our Pizza makes them to order. He was very accommodating to our requests and makes a great pie. Let's face it, Brooklyn has a ton of Pizza restaurants and we've tried many of them. This one really stands out as one of the best! If you truly love Pizza, I highly recommend that you try Smith Street Pizza. It is outstanding. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kyle S.

1

20

4

4 years ago

This is my second time and it was better than the first. The grandma and regular slices are very good. My first time, I took the Slices cold and ate at home. so my air fryer reheat just didn't do it justice. Second time, I ate there with the slices fresh out the Oven and crust was way crispier and a lot better. Made a huge difference and it may be my go to slice joint now, esp if I'm too busy to walk to F&F. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

K R.

1

6

0

4 years ago

Angelo is so nice! He gave me a rice ball to try. :-). I have gotten a Grandma slice both times I went and it's excellent. Highly recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mariah M.

0

3

0

4 years ago

We love this place! It popped up and we live in the area and it is our go-to for fast, good quality pizza. The staff is so friendly too! And really cute seating areas. Seriously go here!! Personal favorite is the little pepperoni cups slice read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William J.

0

15

4

4 years ago

Seriously I love this place. The white pizza is some of the best I've had in Brooklyn, the owner is incredibly kind and thoughtful, and the price is fair for what you get. Amazing food on a time crunch :) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William H.

633

2

0

4 years ago

very good pizza place! love the margarita slice here

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Smith Street Pizza

311 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
Gowanus
Directions
(347) 457-6471
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.smithstreetpizza.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Smith Street Pizza open?

Smith Street Pizza opens at 11:30 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Smith Street Pizza close?

Smith Street Pizza closes at 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Smith Street Pizza closes at 9:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Sat 11:30 AM - 10:00 PMSun 11:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Food & Alcohol

Does Smith Street Pizza serve alcohol?

Yes, Smith Street Pizza serves alcohol.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Smith Street Pizza have parking?

Yes, Smith Street Pizza has parking options.

Other Amenities

Does Smith Street Pizza have free WiFi?

Yes, Smith Street Pizza has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Located conveniently by Carroll st station (F, G train), call us in advance for pick up once you arrived. Selection ranging from slices, specialities unique slice, salads, hoagies, wings, various apps and more. Online order available via our website. Call us for more information.

History

Established in 2022.

family owned and operated neighborhood pizzeria

More Info

Health Score

Review Highlights - Smith Street Pizza

“My husband and I travel from Midwood to enjoy the Pizza at this charming new Pizza Restaurant in Carroll Gardens.”

Mentioned in 3 reviews

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 160,230 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Barbalu Bklyn

4.3

(176 reviews)

0.4 mi

Barbalu serves Italian fare and favorites stone's throw away from where we live. So it was just…read morebefitting to give our neighborhood restaurant a try. We came here after a World Cup match between England and Norway. Of course, England won, and we were festive. We were slightly late to our reservation without any problem. We were promptly seated, and to our surprise, the restaurant was actually bigger than how it looks from outside. We started with fried calamari and shrimp with marinara sauce and a nice bottle of Sauvignon Blanc. For the main entree, I selected traditional lasagna verde with three meat Ragù and Bechamel, while my partner chose homemade fettuccine al Ragù with pork and beef. We had a wonderful dinner here. The food was all delicious and came in timely fashion. We will definitely come back here to try the other dishes on their menu.

Grazie! Grazie! Grazie! Special thanks to Adriana for her…read morehospitality and ensuring that our experience was worth the visit. Another special thank you to our amazing waiter, Alejandro. He did not miss a beat and if anything slipped past him, it was swiftly corrected. And lastly, to the chef! Thank you for your culinary creativity shown in each specially crafted dish. Starters: Fried calamari and shrimp- this was a good start although missing a little flavor to the batter but it was good nonetheless. Whipped burrata-this was delicious but it could have been even better with some more of the delicious house bread that we were offered upon arrival. Drinks: Balsamic peach spritz (not pictured) the graduate's favorite drink of the day! She raved about it the entire time. Aperol spritz- very refreshing with a beautiful citrus twist! I loved it. Old fashioned- my boyfriend throughly enjoyed this classic drink. Entrees: Oven roasted branzino- AMAZING! The cook on the branzino was perfect and the broccolini and mini carrots added a beautiful crunch to my experience. I could have taken another order to go. My boyfriend had the house ravioli which was salmon and after taking one bite, I can attest that it was INCREDIBLY delicious! Everyone else thoroughly enjoyed their meals: Ribeye steak Lamb chops with spinach mashed potatoes Lamb chops with roasted potatoes Roasted Chicken Rustichella We ended the celebration with dessert: Olive oil cake- not too sweet and fluffy. Tiramisu- sinfully good! Overall, we had an incredible dining experience and would highly recommend it.

Homemade Fettuccine with Beef and Pork Ragu'

Broccolini Pizza

See all

Ammazzacaffè

Really a 3.5/5. The drink and one of the appetizers were great, but the entree was disappointing…read more Sunchoke - interesting for sure. The sunchokes and apples are tossed in a creamy and slightly herbal dressing. Burrata - really great. The eggplant base is richly spiced and tart to complement the rich and creamy burrata. Gemelli - disappointing, and the only vegetarian option. The goat cheese totally overwhelms the dish, so you can't taste the pesto at all. The texture on the noodles was perfect at least. Passion project - delicious drink with notes of passion fruit, chocolate, and some spices. The others in my group also had the duck (which they found to be a bit overly loaded with duck fat) and the reginette (which they enjoyed). I'd love to see a more balanced vegetarian main course make it on the menu sometime. The bill for 4 people came to nearly $230 after tax and tip.

I've been back multiple times since my first visit and always get the Reginette and another pasta…read moredepending on my mood for our entrees. We came for dinner today and got lucky because the Sunday only special (Chicken Parm) was available so we ordered that and I decided to switch up my usual to the Spaghetti. My boyfriend loved the Chicken Parm and it comes on top of Vodka Pappardelle which was also delicious and the Spaghetti wasn't too heavy even though it was cream based. I wish they sold the Vodka pasta separately as an entree because I would order that as an entree on my next visit. Another fabulous dinner at Ammazzacaffe!

Mini Martini and Caviar bump

Spaghetti bottarga

See all

Reginetter with pork ragu

Piccola Cucina Casa

4.6

(75 reviews)

0.6 mi

Amazing atmosphere. Small and delightful. Very cozy and authentic. Service is A+ and the food is…read morefantastic! I had the wild bore pasta. Outstanding!

Piccola Cucina Casa Brooklyn delivers the rare kind of meal that makes you rethink what a…read moreneighborhood Italian spot can be. The room is small and romantic, homemade pasta hangs in the front window, and the whole evening felt less like dining out and more like being invited into someone's family table in Florence. We started with the fritto misto, a well executed mix of fried fish and vegetables, alongside an insalata caprese that let fresh tomatoes, burrata and basil speak for themselves. From there we went family style, which is really the only way to do it here. The bucatini cacio e pepe was as much performance as dish, mixed tableside directly in the cheese wheel. The fusilloni di Gragnano from Puglia paired scampi with burrata, cherry tomatoes and arugula for a bright, briny plate, while the tagliatelle verdi brought a rich wild boar ragu finished with fresh black truffle. The two standouts, though, were the agnolotti ossobuco with veal sauce and pecorino fondue rounded out with thyme and lemon, and the lasagna Bolognese. That lasagna, layered with meat ragu, tomato and bechamel, may be the best I have ever had. We paired the meal with a bottle of Salvioni 2022 Rosso di Montalcino, aromatic and beautifully matched to the food. The space is cozy and intimate rather than sprawling, so a reservation is a smart call. Everything else, from the food to the atmosphere to the sense that someone's nonna was cooking just for us, made this one of the most memorable meals in NYC. We would return without hesitation.

See all

Evelina

So a friend and I decided to dine out on a Tuesday, thinking that most places would be empty, well…read morenot EVELINA. We were able to snag an early seating at 6:30. Note: reservations are not required but definitely suggested!! This place was packed. Every table sat, but a few chairs at the bar. I give this place 5 stars, EVERYTHING was lovely! The dim lights, (I love a dark and moody restaurant) noise level, talk-able but good music in the background, food, drinks, service.... all of it TOP NOTCH. Let's get into the deets.... I ordered the Portia cocktail... if you like Mezcal, you should definitely try this one. Smoky and a little sweet, it was a delicious drink We order Pinsa Bianca for appetizers, the bread, roasted peppers and whipped ricotta all made for a light but delish start. We then dove into the rib-eye (for 2) DELICIOUS ! One of the best steaks outside of a steakhouse I have had. The marbling gave it great flavor, salted well and the perfect char on the outside, it was accompanied by French fries and broccolini. All a great addition; The broccolini was surprisingly not too bitter which was nice. To round it off we ordered their version of a Lemon tart! It was the perfect level of sweet and tart! Yummmo Overall a great place for dinner, run don't walk, you won't be disappointed! You'll thank me later

I recently had dinner with friends at Evelina and had a nice experience. We started with the…read morezucchini blossoms, which were okay, and the fritto misto, which was delicious. The calamari and shrimp were perfectly crispy, although I wish the portion included more than two shrimp. For drinks, I ordered the Lavinia, and it was excellent--a refreshing blend of tequila, lime, orange, and a nice touch of honey. For my entrée, I had the grilled pork chops, which were cooked perfectly. The pistachio gremolata added a unique burst of flavor that really elevated the dish. My friends ordered a variety of pasta dishes, which I tried and tasted good, and everyone enjoyed their meals. We ended with dessert and tried both the traditional tiramisu, which was very good, and the budino--a butterscotch pudding with pistachio gelato--which completely stole the show. It was absolutely amazing. Overall, a great dining experience, and I'd definitely return.

Burrata, Asparagus, shaved Bottarga

See all

Michael's

I have been on a quest for tripe -Italian trippa specifically -and I have been through lots of…read morerestaurants in Manhattan and Brooklyn. And this one -by far -in terms of service, ambience, and especially food-is number one so far on my quest. Tripe was meaty and firm -not mushy wonderfully sauced. I will come here again.

You can tell this is a staple Italian restaurant in Marine Park, Brooklyn. Lots of regulars and…read morefamilies. I always pass by and finally decided to try it out. The interior looks like a classic Italian restaurant and service is very formal. It was quite busy for a weekday night. There's valet parking so you don't have to stress about finding street parking nearby. We ordered fried calamari, baked clams, baked vodka penne, and the Fisherman's Platter. We were served bread and some antipasto to start. The calamari was a classic and I loved the sauce -- it had a good spicy kick to it. The baked clams were okay. The Fisherman's Platter is a must and good value with its generous portion of seafood. It can definitely be shared amongst two people. The baked vodka penne was also good but portion was on the smaller side. I would say Michael's is a must try at least once.

Love their bread platter and decor.

It was our first time trying the lobster dish - delicious and fresh. The baked dish tasted too burnt.

See all

Appetizers were so delicious.

Piccoli Trattoria

Cute and heartwarming authentic Italian restaurant on the 6th Ave! They offer some outside tables!…read moreWe were two people around 7pm, that spot is a hidden jam! It was lively :) They have some today's special menu you should definitely check out. Their wine list is awesome! & The beer came ice cold! We started the beet salad and grilled calamari- both are excellent!! The salad was so refreshing! Also grilled calamari was marinated with basil- flavorful with hint of lemon juice. I want to have them againnn! And we got the gnocchi with oil. It was rich and creamy, flavorful and peppery. We were so filled with happiness ･:*+.\(( °° ))/.:+ was already planning to come back xxxx there were only two servers who were working hard, friendly! Thank you so much!!

Great neighborhood spot with fantastic food. Came here on a Saturday for lunch and the weather was…read morebeautiful so would recommend sitting outside. We ordered the duck ragu with tagliatelle, avocado and tomato salad with grilled chicken, and the spinach ravioli (not pictured). The salad was so refreshing and you can tell that the EVOO was very high quality. Grilled chicken was cooked well. My fiancée really enjoyed the ragu and his dad said he was a big fan of the ravioli. Service is attentive but not intrusive and prices are super reasonable. We will be back!

Bread

See all

Lilia

This is a place where everything is done well. Service was very good - our waitress was attentive…read moreand welcoming. Started with the Prosciutto- it had a good pairing of balsamic and parmigian butter. The sheep's milk agnolotti was definitely the highlight - the filling was slightly tangy since it is sheep's milk but that was a great balance to the creaminess. The mafaldini was topped with red peppercorn and the pasta had a good texture and chew. Finished off with the Vanilla gelato which was the perfect ending. Overall I would definitely come back here.

I've been walking past this restaurant allll summer & finally made my way in!…read more This spot did not disappoint. We got the focaccia bread, little gem salad, agnolotti & fettuccine to split. The focaccia is a must try - the bread is sooo soft & I loved the parmesan flakes on top. The butter was also amazing. The agnolotti is also a must try. This is a top 5 NYC dish for me. The flavors are insane - the saffron, sheep's milk, and sun dried tomato combo is sooo good - I could have drank the sauce. Little gem salad was good - nothing out of this world, but a good green to balance the meal.

Housemade Mozzarella on Toasted Garlic Bread

Bar area

Italian job (gelato)

See all

Lillo Cucina Italiana

Overall rating: 4.8…read more Admittedly I was expecting to hate this place. There were so many positive reviews and TikToks, it's hard not to think it's overrated. When I went, it's very small. Seats at max 10 maybe less. Being a single person, it was hard to seat me. But they sat me at a table of 4 and told me if the two seater opens up they'll move me. They were very transparent which I loved. When a couple came, they said they're seating with me and I was fine with it. No complaints. The artichokes were just okay, but the lobster ravioli was delicious. My only point or two off is when they asked for water they didn't give any options. So with the question I said still water. They served it and it was sparkling. I should have said something but I chickened out. And then! I realize everyone around me is drinking tap water! I didn't know that was an option wish that was clear. Will definitely come back when I'm craving lobster ravioli.

This cute little Italian restaurant is pretty awesome in a quiet little neighborhood. The staff was…read moresuper nice and made the vibe feel like a chill place to hangout and enjoy your meal. I got the cacio e pepe which was great. The fresh cracked pepper and the pasta was very fresh and more al dente the way I liked it. This place takes cash only so make sure you have some on you to pay.

Penne arrabiata, rigatoni siciliana

Caprese di burrata

See all

Bamonte's

my experience at Bamonte's was amazing!! the food, environment and service was 10/10 here. my…read moresister was dairy free and they catered to her preferences and never forgot about it! the bread, chicken parm, eggplant parm and pasta was amazing! the prosciutto and cheese here was of quality too.

Oh the old school thrill of an old school beauty of an establishment like Bamonte's!…read more I just love this place so much! I can't say enough great things about the decor the ambience and imagining all of the past goings on in this restaurant. It's been watching over Brooklyn for well over 100 years now! That in itself is a Herculean feat! From what I was told it was very popular with the mob as they say... And that's why the kitchen which is at the very back of the restaurant has full glass windows so that you can see exactly what's going on in there. I guess some of these mob guys were paranoid and rightly so consider considering their history. I arrived with my friend on a Wednesday evening about 6 PM and there were some scattered tables but by 7 PM it was mobbed (pun intended ) in there!! our waiter was affable and patient and a quite enjoyable fellow. As a sidenote, you will not find any female servers they are all male which l lends to the old school vibe in my opinion. My friend ordered the lamb chops with broccoli Rabe. He enjoyed them but did mention that though they had great flavor one of them was slightly tough... It happens... My meal was pasta with Bolognese sauce with a dollop of fresh ricotta on top. It was delicious actually the sauce was excellent. I would've liked to have a different pasta shape but they did not have it. No biggie. I could really say the food was very good but it was not excellent but for me that was not an issue as I fell in love with the place itself. The service was excellent and the ambience was fantastic! I would definitely return again and I highly recommend it if you have never been you must at least go one time!!

Breast Chicken Parmigiana

Interior

See all

Fried Calamari

Olio e Più

Jose and the entire team at OLIO E PIÙ absolutely knocked it out of the park! I stopped in while…read morespending some time in the East Village, and this was easily one of the best Italian meals I've had in New York City. I ordered the Lamb Ragù pasta, and every bite was packed with rich, slow-cooked flavor. To start, my brother and I shared a pizza and the lobster appetizer, and both were incredible. My brother ordered the truffle pasta, and after stealing a few bites, I can honestly say it was just as unforgettable. The atmosphere was on another level. Even on a Tuesday night, the restaurant was buzzing with energy, full of happy people, great conversations, and an authentic Italian vibe that made you want to stay for hours. The service from Jose was outstanding. Friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about making sure we had an amazing experience. If you're looking for incredible Italian food, outstanding service, and one of the best dinner spots in the East Village, OLIO E PIÙ belongs at the top of your list. I'll definitely be back the next time I'm in the city.

Food was good. The service was really good and everyone was hospitable. The ambiance of the…read morerestaurant was very nice and the pizza was my favorite.

Olio E Più NYC Greenwich Ave

Crostata Di Pera e Mandorla (NYC Winter Restaurant Week 2026) - Olio E Più NYC Greenwich Ave

See all

Pinamenta (Non-Alcoholic) Cocktail - OLIO E PIÙ NYC

Radio Bakery

Food/drinks: sooo good! Unique flavors and everything we ordered was a hit. I'd come again for the…read moresavory croissants and their sandwiches!! Huge portions as well! I wouldn't wait in a long line for it though Also very unique, flavorful chocolate croissant, it is heavy heavy on the chocolate Atmosphere: tiny and cramped and usually a line, good for to go and has 4 bar seats and a few small tables outside Service: fast! Usually a line but I got lucky Price: pricey but worth it for size and quality

Croissants: 5/5 triple chocolate $8- so flaky but so good,…read moredark chocolatey, wish there was more chocolate in it 4/5 pistachio $8- really good, not disgustingly sweet altho I can do a bit less sweet in the cream, crunchy, flaky, powdery sweet 4/5 scallion sesame twist $6.5- yum, love anything w/ scallion &/or sesame, well balanced flavors, not too salty 4/5 sandwiches- focaccia is so good, tastes like pizza bread, wanted smoked salmon but they were out of, wish they had halal or more non-pork options, wanna try some of the tomato ones next time 3/5 stone fruit & custard $8- where's the custard? Strawberry? is glazed in super sweet syrup, wish it was less sweet 3/5 cheesy pretzel bearclaw $6.5- cheese too salty, wuda been great otherwise 3/5 iced peach tea $4.50- unsweetened, wuda been great w/ a bit of sweetener but decent otherwise

French Onion Soup Tart.

See all

Classic Croissant (~$5)

LaRina Pastificio & Vino

Ambiance: great ambiance cute date night…read more Service: fast service and very kind Food $$: the food came out fast and the are known for their pasta! We got the smoked spaghetti and the tuna appetizer. We got the croquette and another beef braised pasta and all were so good Audience: Solo Trip [X] Family Friendly [ X] Friends [X] Date Spot [X] Recommendations/tips: I would reserve ahead

I wish I had discovered this Italian restaurant in my neighborhood sooner! The food here is…read moreexcellent. I've tried several dishes now, and everything I've had has been delicious. The Branzino was especially good. You could tell it was incredibly fresh because the flesh was so tender and flaky. I also liked how they served it over a bed of vegetables which soaked up all of the delicious sauce. The octopus was also very flavorful. Their focaccia is probably my favorite and the balsamic vinaigrette was so good that my husband and I had to ask for a couple of refills. We even asked our waitress where we could buy it, but unfortunately she wasn't sure. The seafood pasta was also delicious and loaded with seafood. You probably can't tell from the picture but it also came with plenty of little clams. The beef agnolotti looked a bit rich at first but it wasn't overly heavy at all and we ended up finishing just about everything. I'd definitely recommend this place. Just be sure to make a reservation, especially during peak meal times, because it gets pretty busy.

See all

Forma Pasta Factory

A repeat spot for me! Complimentary focaccia, pasta is affordable and I love that they always have…read morerotating specials. Place is self-service for water/putting away dishes, they just bring you bread and what you order. There's usually seating available and their covered outdoor space is cute too! Some of my favorite pastas they are the pipette ragu, spicy rigatoni, and the Wednesday special (agnolotti). They had a five-spice duck radiatori special once and I'm waiting for the day they'll bring it back!

LOVE FORMA PASTA FACTORY! I can't believe I've never left a review since I DoorDash this place at…read moreLEAST a couple times a month. I'm not a huge pasta girl - so my main orders from here would be the gem salad with grilled chicken. The grilled chicken is VERY GOOD with a great char and my body craves this weekly. The gem salad is very simple but with the freshest ingredients and this Dijon lemony dressing (don't quote me as I am just guessing) but seriously everyone should try this at least once in their life! The fettuccini pasta with mushrooms is also a repeat order for me. I would love to try some of their daily special pastas one day. They sell fresh pasta and sauce as well for takeout! Never ate here but I've delivered and picked up.

Very clean and spacious!

Focaccia Flat Bread

See all

Interior

Greenpoint Fish & Lobster

What a great seafood restaurant! Greenpoint Fish & Lobster has a fresh seafood counter to purchase…read moreitems as well as a full restaurant. Be sure to make a reservation, as this spot is popular, especially on a nice weekend. We recently had a weekend brunch at one of the tables outside. Everything on the menu sounded good, but we decided on a couple of their specials. Started with the razor clams, which were cooked perfectly and topped with fresh herbs. We also had the fried soft shell crab sandwich with the side of Caesar salad. The sandwich was well balanced with the crunchy crab and herby aioli. The Caesar was light and refreshing. The fish and chips came with two fried filets of white fish and a basket of classic fries. The fish was lightly battered and flakey. The house made tartar sauce was a good complement to it. One of my top meals this year so far! Perfect summer meal!

Came by on a Tuesday for happy hour, which appears to be weekdays from 4-6pm. There's ample seating…read moreoutdoor and few tables inside, as well as the bar countertop. Their HH deals are pretty solid -- $2 East Coast Oysters, $10 select wines and $6 beer special. Grabbed a glass of Sauvignon Blanc as I waited for my friend to arrive, which they were very patient and accommodating for. As soon as my friend arrived, we ordered a 1/2 dozen West Coast oysters, which were not on the happy hour menu, and several dozens of the HH East Coast oysters. Our server did an excellent job explaining the origin of the oysters as well as the specials of the day. The West Coast oysters were Kumamoto (California), while the East Coast selection were called Bad Boys (from Nova Scotia, Canada). Normally I'm a big fan of West coast oysters, but the Bad Boys were delicious! They were plump with a bold ocean brine & crisp finish. My friend also ordered a cup of clam chowder, which he thoroughly enjoyed. One of the best oyster HH spots I've come across, because it seems to be harder finding good ones lately. Would definitely come back to try the other seafood dishes.

Brussels sprouts side + Crispy Fish Sandwich with fries

Restroom

See all

Oysters

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Linda L.

81

3

0

7 days ago

The best pizza I've ever had if I had a choice between a puppy or smith street pizza I would choose Smith Street pizza even if it was 1000 puppies I'd rather have some pizza read more

Smith Street Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Smith Street Pizza also viewed

Joe & Sal's Pizza

4.2

(234 reviews)

There's so many pizza places in Brooklyn that it can be difficult to compare. But for some reason…read moreI keep coming back to Joe and Sal's. Crispy crusts, rich sauces, savory and creative toppings combine for some of the best pies in the area. Definitely try the Focaccia crust Sicilian style and extra basil, or anything with caramelized onions. The spicy eggplant is true to its name and will become one of your regulars. Deco is classic NY pizza shop with just a few crowded tables and Italian movie pictures on the walls. Also, say Hi to Alessandro and ask for his daily recommendations. Pro Tip - Get there early for the most choices of slices or have Alessandro make up a special fresh.

Located on Franklin Ave nr Prospect Park, BK Musuem, Botanic garden. I stopped by this local spot…read morefor a slice. Alessandro was maintaining the counter. I got a plain cheese slice which was $3.50. Cash or credit. Was piping hot when taken out of the oven and almost burned my face off. Poor undercarriage. No fold. Broke apart since it was so hot and the cheese fell off. OK neighborhood spot. Seating area inside with tables. And a clean bathroom.

Crown Heights Pizza

4.1

(90 reviews)

best pizza ever tasted absolutely delicious it tasted really good u guys should all come here and…read moreit's cheap

We got the lunch special for 2 slices with free canned soda for $8…read more The thing is that they don't list price per slice so I can only assume it is $4 per slice. Not exactly the cheapest slices out there I do like the pizza tho. Piping hot, and nice crispy thin crust. Great amount of cheese and not soggy from too much sauce. Solid 4.4 for me

Antonio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.0

(314 reviews)

They're going to celebrate 70-years of business in 2027. (Opened in 1957) My family and I have…read morebeen enjoying their pizza for the last twenty-five years when I moved to Brooklyn. We now live in L.A., and we still jump on the Q train (7th Ave.) or 2 or 3 train (Grand Army Plaza) to grab some of their slices. Service is efficient and friendly. One of the brothers says, He never forgets a face." Their crust, sauce, cheese and toppings are all the perfect ratios. They offer a nice selection of different kinds of slices, but oftentimes their regular slice is so satisfying it's difficult to switch to something else. A slice or two, a soda and a seat at one of their tables looking out towards Flatbush Ave. is a perfect moment. Prospect Park is just up the way if you prefer to grab your slice to go. The atmosphere is casual and most people grab a slice on the run, but if there's a table available, I recommend you sitting down for a minute. You might even decide you want another slice.

Really good pizza!! Open late. Cash only!…read more My friend and I got the MVP slice (aka cheese, vodka, and pesto) and vodka slice. Both were great. Small amount of seating. Nuff said!

Layla Jones

3.9

(213 reviews)

I ordered directly through their website because I didn't want Seamless to get a cut of their…read moreprofit. But they messed up the delivery. When the setting clearly indicated they should meet me at the door, they left the pizza in the lobby of the building without letting me know and it was stone cold when I picked it up after I called them to find out what happened to the pizza. That wasn't the first time they messed up the delivery when I ordered directly. Another time they were 30 minutes late and when I called to ask what happened, they said the delivery guy hadn't picked up the pizza. Ordering through Seamless would be best with this place.

Love this place! The pizza and salad special is my go to. The pizza is so good I easily put away…read morethe 4 generous slices. The sauce has a nice touch of sweetness without being cloyingly so and I love the crust and when it burns a bit on the edges. Toppings are generous. My go to salad is the Ceasar. Those crutons are amazing. These are for sure house made and not out of a box as they have a perfect garlicky crunchiness to them. Delivery is always fast and pizza is hot when it gets here.

Baby Luc’s

3.4

(154 reviews)

I simply love Lucali so it was inevitable to stop by Baby Luc's…read more Overall I was very satisfied especially for their Margherita and Vodka slices, each slice had a great undercarriage while using quality ingredients however I ultimately thought their slightly higher prices doesn't 100% justify a smaller than usual square pizza. Yes this is just my take, to each their own. Overall Baby Luc's is service with a smile with ample indoor dining area however it's where their outdoor picnic like area plus sidewalk tables truly shine. Outdoor dining here is great to soak in the quiet atmosphere of the neighborhood.

As a lover of Lucali, I had to stop in to try Baby Luc's. We had the margherita and the vodka…read moreslices, along with a froze. What stands out the most is the crust - it had a very nice crisp and was perfect for the thicker square style. The taste on the margherita was good - generous with the parm, and an intriguing kick. The vodka slice was by far the best of the two. You get a nice chili kick, a creamy sauce, and an odd but easy to remove topping of scallions. Definitely worth stopping in!

Piz-zetta Pizzeria

4.4

(369 reviews)

This is one good pizza! Generally pizza for me is an okay food but damn this place has the best…read morepizza I had. Location: It is located along Livington St. Great display of ready to eat pizza. You can see also a big oven behind the counter. Lot of seating inside. Service: not much interaction, just point what I like and pay. Food: I only ordered the Margherita slice. I was not expecting but it was soo good. The cheese melts and i think they drizzled pesto sauce on top. The pie was also crispy. This is the perfect pizza for me. Price rating: 6/10. It was not expensive. Around $7 per slice Definitely will come back to try other pizzas.

One of the best tasting in Brooklyn. You definitely can't miss stopping by for a slice, as you can…read moresee what slices I have purchased so far.

Ogliastro

4.1

(239 reviews)

Wasn't sure if a small boutique pizza spot would have vegan cheese and plant based pepperoni but lo…read moreand behold they do!! Woot! Ordered a glass of Lambrusco and Peroni on draft and enjoyed a relaxed atmosphere for a Saturday date night without needing reservations with soft warm lighting that was easy on the eyes, and cozy atmosphere with warming chili oil to drizzle over the pizza on a cold winter night. The pizza was just enough for two, with crust that was hand tossed with loose bubbles in the edges, the vegan cheese was melty and flavorful, and the plant based pepperoni had an excellent near familiar flavor (not the chorizo substitute kind). When these were paired with the artichokes and onions and a dash of rosemary on the Coppa- the result was absolutely delish *chefs kiss*. Service was always nearby and accommodating of special requests which made this an excellent option for a definite return visit!

I went here after the BK Museum First Saturday & it was clear that a lot of people had ventured…read morehere. They were gracious enough to keep open for a bit longer even though they genuinely didn't have to. I got the carbonara pizza without the meat & it was great. Also shout out to the bartender Fabian who was really nice & attentive despite having a lot of customers. I would venture back if I'm in the area.

Nate's Detroit Pizza

4.0

(9 reviews)

I love finding these types of treasures. While people look for certain aesthetics, I aim for…read moreauthenticity. Nate was working the day I came by. He helped me figured out which pizza to order. My favorite was the hot honey pepperoni. Gaaaaah......That Detroit style crust....one bite and it was over. I wish I had more room to eat more. Fun fact: they make almost everything in house. Croutons for their salads. The honey. Yum!

Just watched a review of your pizza and it had to be brought to your restaurant from somewhere…read moreelse? Why tf are you even selling pizza if you're not making it in the restaurant? Dude shows up 40 minutes after placing the order just to be told it'll be another 15 minutes just to have some goon come in the door with the fucking lid propped open. Goes behind the counter to put some basil on it and be like " okay here ‍" Detroit pizza is NEVER floppy but that bullshit was. What. The. Fuck.

Giuseppina's

4.3

(388 reviews)

If you're looking for elite pizza in Brooklyn and don't want to wait in line at Lucali,…read moreGiuseppina's is an absolute home run. Without a doubt, this is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Cracker thin crust meets great sauce and cheese. The fresh basil is a must add. Cash only.

My friends and I each got the 12" calzones here not realizing how large they were. To be fair, the…read moremenu warned us. Add-ins were very pricey at about $4 each. If you're sharing the calzone, it would be a much better deal. Otherwise, the menu is pretty straight forward. They only have pizza and calzones. The calzone had the perfect crispy exterior and the cheese inside was rich and abundant. You must order the tomato sauce that comes on the side. I would absolutely come here again. They have a brick oven in the back of the restaurant, and I think it elevates the meal to have that perfect charred flavor. Service was fast and the waiters were attentive. The ambiance felt moody with all the candles around the entire place.

Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza

4.1

(193 reviews)