We stopped by on a Friday night about an hour and a half before closing. I had never been to Si Senor before, but I've seen it all over social media and grew up in Grandview Heights, so I knew their original location had been around for years. Since we were near Easton, we decided to try this location instead.
After looking online, this location definitely has a smaller and more limited menu compared to the others. I got the jumping beef sandwich and my boyfriend got the club. Both were good, but definitely on the smaller side. You'd probably want a side with them, or honestly two sandwiches if you skipped sides altogether. I also wish there was more of the sauce on the sandwiches because that was one of the better parts.
The homemade chips were probably the biggest letdown besides the pasta salad. They had almost no flavor at all. They desperately needed salt, seasoning, or some kind of dip that actually paired with them. I think the server gave us extra mayo from the sandwiches to dip them in, but it really didn't work.
Now the thing I'm most confused about is the cilantro pasta salad because I've seen so many people rave about it. The first bite genuinely shocked me. I honestly thought maybe we got a bad batch, so I had my boyfriend try it before saying anything. We were both horrified. It was unbelievably sweet. It literally tasted like mayo, sugar, and cold pasta noodles mixed together. We genuinely could not stomach more than two bites, and those bites were us trying to give it a chance. It immediately went in the trash. It is a huge portion, so if you happen to love it maybe it's worth the price, but for us the taste was honestly terrible.
Overall, I'm glad we tried Si Senor so we could say we did, but I wasn't very impressed and I'm not dying to go back anytime soon. I might try the Grandview location someday since the menu looks bigger with more sandwich options and sides, but for now there are definitely other sandwich spots in Columbus I'd choose first. read more