Cancel

Open app

Search

Caroline’s Sandwiches

4.5 (13 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 7:00 pm

Order Caroline’s Sandwiches Takeout or Delivery

Caroline’s Sandwiches Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Caroline’s Sandwiches

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Pig in Pig In The Weeds
Katie W.

Ok so initially I thought $18 was too pricey for a sandwich. I thought WRONG!!! I was so wrong. This sandwich was worth every penny. It was huge, full of delicious pulled pork and the sourdough was perfectly crisp and buttery and holy smokes it was the best sandwich I've had in years. Definitely will be back. Also, north market had plenty of great seating and a nice environment!

Menu
Mark K.

Heard about this online, I think they have done pop-ups, and the menu looked amazing. Only half a dozen sandwiches, but each one is an interesting, unique combo. It's at the North Market, right in the corner. A few stools out front to eat there, or of course you can go upstairs. I wanted to try all of the sandwiches. But I went with the Kimchi Cowboy. Pastrami, kimchi, cream cheese with scallions. I also got a pickle. And they do have a few canned drinks. Service was fast and friendly. The pickle was great, better than the Katzinger's one I had last week for probably the last time. (Yes, those are free, and they are worth it.) These are like two dollars and big, crispy, flavorful. The sandwich was a good size, with great bread, lots of tender pastrami, lots of cream cheese, and some kimchi. All in all it was a pretty darn good sandwich, although the kimchi didn't have the heat, or flavor in general, that I had hoped for. Don't worry about getting this if you do not like spice. You'll be fine. All wrapped up very well, and even when the cream cheese oozed out it didn't get messy. I will be back to try all of the other sandwiches. They also have salads, fries, and maybe one or two other sides. A solid new option for the North Market. Don't forget to get your parking validated, I think it is free for at least the first hour or two.

Ranch chicken bacon salad
Douglas G.

I've already ranked the salad as a five star experience but I'd be remiss if I didn't update for the sandwich I just had. First and foremost, the service was great. Friendly and helpful navigating the menu. I ordered the club sandwich and it took about five minutes, which is not bad. The sandwich was delicious; the bacon was crunchy, the cheese was melted, and the meat was great. No complaints at all. Outstanding work!

Truffle mushroom fries
Kate M.

New addition to north market and best sandwiches around by far! We loved the special chicken sandwich more than the kimchi cowboy. The truffle mushroom fries are amazing with so much flavor and a large portion. Their sourdough bread is top notch. We will be back to try other sandwiches!

Three Stacks

See all

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Katie W.
518
18
14

23 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of John M.
163
419
3298

9 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tina S.
0
10
16

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

The spicy stack sandwich was quite possibly the best sandwich I have ever had. I'll be back, and telling all of my friends!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Caroline’s Sandwiches

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Sandwiches 2,802 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Northstar Café - Chicken sandwich

Northstar Café

4.3(1.4k reviews)
0.7 mi•Short North
•$$

Picked up two breakfast sandwiches using online ordering. Delicious and made with real eggs…read morescrambled with cheese. I got a gluten free roll +$1 and it was pretty good. Very polite staff and looked like a nice spot to sit and enjoy a meal and drinks. Would return!

Located right on High St in the heart of the Short North, there is a very limited parking lot and…read moreon street parking. Head to the side door, as you will order first and then find a seat. This can be tricky because there seems to always be out the door, but most patrons understand the assignment and turnover goes quickly. I recommend searching the current menu online so you are ready as soon as you get to the register. This place appears to always be busy and bustling with people. We ordered the Country Scramble, Pancakes, and an Egg Sandwich. Drinks were hot apple cider, hot cocoa, and a Blackberry Fizz. All the food was delicious and are def the highlight. There is self serve coffee and soda(and water I believe although the person who got up to investigate for our table couldn't seem to find it). Honestly, the service is not my jam and why I dropped off a star. They seemed to be serving mimosas, wine, and Bloody Mary's in the line while you waited but the gal that was overseeing the area didn't really make eye contact so we didn't bother with that. Register was friendly and knowledgeable. But then the service gets tricky. There are no dedicated servers / bussers. Just people doing both. So many times you will find a group of people waiting for a table that needed to be cleared. We waited for the table to be cleared and no one was wiping the tables down, just removing dirty dishes. Our table was terribly sticky from the prior patrons but since you don't have a dedicated server, no one was coming back to take care of that. And lord help you if something wasn't right or you needed attention. We had no tableware or napkins and had to take them from another table. One of our meals took 10 more minutes than everyone else's so then our food was cold as we tried to be polite to the person who did not get food (but who do you inquire with?!). And if you wanted something else (another drink, or a pastry), you were going to have to wait in the line again. The food was good, but probably not a place I would return.

Photos
Northstar Café - Vibe

Vibe

Northstar Café - Lemons

Lemons

Northstar Café - Single Ricotta Pancake

See all

Single Ricotta Pancake

Roots Natural Kitchen - Pesto Caesar Salad

Roots Natural Kitchen

4.1(65 reviews)
2.0 mi•University District

Obsessed! I haven't been to the location but have been getting delivery on the apps for the last…read morefew months now. Huge portions and so fresh! When I order from Roots it makes me feel clean and healthy. I've ordered their pre-made bowls as well as building my own. Portions are big and can serve as two meals. If I order for dinner I end up eating it for breakfast. Ingredients are fresh AF and their dressings are all delicious. Sometimes I question how my build-your-own bowl will come out and I do a good job--it's delicious!! I always feel good about the healthy and clean options here!

Formal Complaint: Unprofessional Management and Order Fulfillment at OSU Campus Location…read more To the Executive Team at Roots Natural Kitchen, I am writing to formally express my profound disappointment regarding a recent experience at your Ohio State University campus location on Father's Day. The lack of customer care, patience, and professionalism I encountered from the Manager on Duty was entirely unacceptable, and doesn't deserve even a half star, but I had to choose one. On Father's Day, my family ordered five bowls, two of which were seasonal bowls made with the original ingredients with the exception of extra lime. One of these bowls was specifically meant for my husband, who is currently in the hospital. I had raved to him about your restaurant, as it was one of the few healthy options he could safely enjoy during his stay. Unfortunately, the meal was prepared with a blatant lack of care. Even after it was made clear that this was a special meal for him, his portion size was equivalent to a half-bowl, and it was entirely missing the onions and tomatoes. Seeking to resolve the issue, I called the restaurant and was placed on hold. When the phone was picked up, the staff member did not offer a greeting, a name, or any indication of who was speaking. I politely stated, "Hi, I was holding for the manager," to which she abruptly replied, "This is." When I asked for her name, her response was unclear and unkind. Despite maintaining a calm and respectful tone while explaining that my husband's hospital meal for Father's Day had been made incorrectly, the manager was immediately combative and argumentative for absolutely no reason. Instead of offering a basic level of customer service or empathy, I was met with disrespect. Your company's mission proudly states: *"We strive to empower people through radical accessibility to natural food."* Unfortunately, the radical lack of care and professionalism I experienced completely contradicts that standard. Because of this deeply disappointing experience, I will no longer be a patron of your establishment. Furthermore, I will not be recommending Roots Natural Kitchen to anyone moving forward, including for any future corporate or community events I coordinate. I hope you address this leadership and service failure with your OSU campus team so that no other customer is treated this way in the future. Sincerely, Latisha Roland

Photos
Roots Natural Kitchen - Create Your Own Bowl

Create Your Own Bowl

Roots Natural Kitchen - Balboa

Balboa

Roots Natural Kitchen - Build Your Own Bowl

See all

Build Your Own Bowl

Brassica - Salad- 1/2 Chicken & 1/2 Brisket

Brassica

4.7(1.6k reviews)
0.3 mi•Short North, Italian Village
•$$

SO. FRESH. I was in…read moreColumbus for a conference and stopped at Brassica for lunch, and I'm honestly kicking myself for not going every single day I was there! I had the falafel salad bowl and basically said, "Give me ALL the vegetables." I loaded that bowl up with every veggie they had to offer, and every single one was incredibly fresh and delicious. The falafel was fantastic, too! The staff was also so sweet, friendly, and accommodating, which made the experience even better. You can tell they really care about the food and the people they're serving. If you're in Columbus and looking for something fresh, flavorful, and satisfying, HIGHLY recommend Brassica! I only wish I had discovered it sooner so I could've eaten here every day of my trip!

We stopped by Brassica while we were in town reviewing a few spots, and as usual, this place…read morecompletely knocked our socks off. We arrived fairly close to closing, which can sometimes be risky--some restaurants start cutting corners as the night winds down. Not here. Everything was incredibly fresh, and each bite took our palates on a culinary adventure that had us feeling like champions for choosing Brassica for dinner. The ingredients, flavors, and execution were all outstanding. If you haven't been here yet, do yourself a favor and go. Brassica continues to prove why it's one of our favorite places to eat whenever we're in town.

Photos
Brassica
Brassica - Salad and photobomb Brassica Fries

Salad and photobomb Brassica Fries

Brassica

See all

South Village Grille

South Village Grille

4.4(421 reviews)
2.4 mi•German Village
•$$

Let's start with the dessert. The Gooey Butter Cake is a must-have. The gooey inside is the star,…read morebut the firmer outside of the cake is highly savorable. Once the ice cream starts melting, things get even more gooey and delicious! So. Freaking. Good. I went during lunch and had the benefit of trying my wife's cheesesteak which is only one the lunch menu. Now, I loved my burger and the thick cuts of bacon that overflowed from the circumference on the buns. Somehow, that cheesesteak was a notch above that. The cheese sauce was the key ingredient. If you get a sandwich, my vote is for the fries over the kettle chips. But my biggest vote is for going to South Village Grille in the first place because they really impressed during my lunchtime visit.

Service was okay, food was okay. Place had so much potential, but overall it was pretty meh. Had a…read morereservation for 2 for a Saturday brunch. Got seated at a table for 8 in the bar. Took a while to get served. Ordered a Bloody Mary spicy. The bloody was good, but not spicy. Asked for Tabasco to make it so. Had chicken and waffles for my entree. Very small piece of chicken that had more breading on it than meat. At least it was white meat, although juicy it was not. The waffle was good, but equally small. No syrup. Mashed potatoes were bland. Took a bit longer to pay and get out. No sense of urgency by anyone on the waitstaff. Place is so small, you can observe everything that is happening. Watched our drinks being made, set on the bar, and waited. A server casually made her way over to retrieve them to deliver to our table. Maybe they just need some good management.

Photos
South Village Grille
South Village Grille
South Village Grille

See all

Astra Rooftop - Whipped Feta

Astra Rooftop

4.2(94 reviews)
0.1 mi•Short North

Astra is a hopping place at the AC Hotel. Nice restaurant and an even better bar with a great…read moreoutdoor space. I've been here for drinks before but tonight was dinner at the inside bar area. Service is great. Very friendly and attentive. Miriam regularly checked on me for both delivery of my meal as well as any drink needs. The Caesar salad is not traditional as it also had tomatoes. Interesting flavors. For my main course, I got the Steak Frites. The steak was cooked perfectly to medium rare and properly seasoned. The fries were excellent. Well done. The music is kind of loud as it caters to the bar atmosphere. Lighting is a bit low. It all fits the atmosphere well. Great service, good drinks and food. Lots of great appetizer choices too.

3.5 star for the service 3 star for the food…read more 5 star for the vibes and interior design This place is more for wow factors and the vibes, if you are a picky foodie, it might not be a perfect spot. Really in love with its vibes, both indoor dining room with different segments of seatings and outdoor patio tables are amazing. The interior design here is truly unique and artistic. Great for big groups, date night, or even just chilling with friends. Not sure if it's the standard here, but there was never anyone filling our water during the entire dining time after they left 2 bottles of water on the table. Our server is patient and friendly but not on point. They messed up our orders, forgot one order and brought one wrong (we ordered smashed burger but received chicken sandwich). Very surprising that the staff didn't do anything or offer to send in the correct order. The chef of table service for Tomahawk is fun and enjoyable to carry conversations but unfortunately our Tomahawk was overcooked. We loved the presentation for sure though. Their smoked ribs is not "smoked" but boiled and soaked in sauce. The "smoked" part refers to its presentation, but their machine was down, and we were not told, so we basically got the ribs, neither smoked in cooking method nor smoked when it was brought to our table. The donut tree is another one great for eyes and cameras. It comes with little fireworks at the table service. Overall we enjoyed the breeze and atmosphere here. Will come back for relaxation if in town.

Photos
Astra Rooftop
Astra Rooftop - Caesar Salad

Caesar Salad

Astra Rooftop - Steak

See all

Steak

Market 65 - Harvest salad with Blackened Chicken (substitute for Turkey Breast) with Carmel Apple Vinaigrette

Market 65

4.2(160 reviews)
0.9 mi•Downtown
•$$

A good experience! quality food with a conscience. My experience : first day ordered a Korean…read morechicken salad modified to remove the blue cheese, artichoke hearts (Never seen Artichokes or blue cheese anywhere in Asia) and add avocado. MAN was that Tasty! Lettuce and greens that just melt in your mouth, tender and flavorful chicken, savory onion strings and red bell peppers. Didn't think I would like the fresh jalapeños but wow... Tasty! Left very impressed and satisfied. Couldn't remember the last time I had a salad that good... Maybe never... Second day, tried the Wakame and was not as impressed. Tried to spruce it up with some roasted brussel sprouts but the tofu and soybeans with seaweed (which I normally love) just weren't doing it for me. I sat for a minute and thought... Why suffer through this. I promptly went back to the chef with no expectation and told him I was sorry for not digging his salad. The reaction was "no problem, totally understand, do you want something else?" That, my friends, is what is called customer service! No extra charge, they joyfully made me another Korean chicken salad with avacado. Not saying this place is perfect. They are cranking at lunch during the week so if you want something special or different you better speak up! Its like a machine back there. Overall, I highly recommend this place. The attitude is good, the food is great (if you know what you like), the service and humanity runs deep. Just ask for what you want. You shall receive!

Just had the WEIRDEST Cobb salad I've ever eaten. No bacon or blue cheese. Instead they put pinto…read morebeans and feta cheese in it, and serve it with a chipotle ranch dressing. It just does not work.

Photos
Market 65 - Pay here

Pay here

Market 65 - Tons of seating

Tons of seating

Market 65

See all

Caroline’s Sandwiches - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...