Cancel

Open app

Search

Caroline’s Sandwiches

4.5 (13 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 7:00 pm

Order Caroline’s Sandwiches Takeout or Delivery

Caroline’s Sandwiches Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Caroline’s Sandwiches

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Pig in Pig In The Weeds
Katie W.

Ok so initially I thought $18 was too pricey for a sandwich. I thought WRONG!!! I was so wrong. This sandwich was worth every penny. It was huge, full of delicious pulled pork and the sourdough was perfectly crisp and buttery and holy smokes it was the best sandwich I've had in years. Definitely will be back. Also, north market had plenty of great seating and a nice environment!

Menu
Mark K.

Heard about this online, I think they have done pop-ups, and the menu looked amazing. Only half a dozen sandwiches, but each one is an interesting, unique combo. It's at the North Market, right in the corner. A few stools out front to eat there, or of course you can go upstairs. I wanted to try all of the sandwiches. But I went with the Kimchi Cowboy. Pastrami, kimchi, cream cheese with scallions. I also got a pickle. And they do have a few canned drinks. Service was fast and friendly. The pickle was great, better than the Katzinger's one I had last week for probably the last time. (Yes, those are free, and they are worth it.) These are like two dollars and big, crispy, flavorful. The sandwich was a good size, with great bread, lots of tender pastrami, lots of cream cheese, and some kimchi. All in all it was a pretty darn good sandwich, although the kimchi didn't have the heat, or flavor in general, that I had hoped for. Don't worry about getting this if you do not like spice. You'll be fine. All wrapped up very well, and even when the cream cheese oozed out it didn't get messy. I will be back to try all of the other sandwiches. They also have salads, fries, and maybe one or two other sides. A solid new option for the North Market. Don't forget to get your parking validated, I think it is free for at least the first hour or two.

Ranch chicken bacon salad
Douglas G.

I've already ranked the salad as a five star experience but I'd be remiss if I didn't update for the sandwich I just had. First and foremost, the service was great. Friendly and helpful navigating the menu. I ordered the club sandwich and it took about five minutes, which is not bad. The sandwich was delicious; the bacon was crunchy, the cheese was melted, and the meat was great. No complaints at all. Outstanding work!

Truffle mushroom fries
Kate M.

New addition to north market and best sandwiches around by far! We loved the special chicken sandwich more than the kimchi cowboy. The truffle mushroom fries are amazing with so much flavor and a large portion. Their sourdough bread is top notch. We will be back to try other sandwiches!

Three Stacks

See all

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Katie W.
518
18
14

24 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of John M.
163
419
3298

9 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tina S.
0
10
16

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

The spicy stack sandwich was quite possibly the best sandwich I have ever had. I'll be back, and telling all of my friends!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Caroline’s Sandwiches

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Sandwiches 2,802 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Flatiron Tavern

Flatiron Tavern

4.3(135 reviews)
0.4 mi•Downtown
•$$

Stayed at the Canopy and wanted a late night bite to eat. We come down to the convention center all…read morethe time for volleyball tournaments and didn't even know this place existed! It is our type of bar... Small and just a nice little place to hang out. Bartender was super friendly and service was great. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak and it was so fresh and delicious. My husband ordered a Smashburger and thought it was really good. I had a martini and it was a bonus they had blue cheese stuffed olives! :)We will definitely be coming back when we return for tournaments!!

I've always passed Flatiron Tavern on walks and runs and assumed it was just a bar with typical bar…read morefood. Little did I know, when I finally checked out their website, they have a TON of Philly cheesesteaks! I love a good Philly, so I knew I had to give it a try. Our service was pretty slow, but honestly, that's kind of on par with a bar, so I wasn't too surprised. Still, this could be worked on. We were on the patio and our server admitted he didn't know who was helping us. It turned out to be him - but after 15 minutes of waiting lol. The space is super cool and really unique. It has a fun atmosphere that makes it feel like more than just your typical neighborhood bar. The food was great! They have lots of different ways to build your own Philly, which I loved. There were also a bunch of different sauces to choose from, and I especially enjoyed getting to try those. The fries were thin, crispy, and came with a CRAP ton. They were really good and definitely not skimpy on the portion! Overall, I was pleasantly surprised by Flatiron Tavern. Definitely not just a bar with bar food like I originally thought. I'll be back for another Philly!

Photos
Flatiron Tavern - Inside

Inside

Flatiron Tavern - Steaming hot wings with mild buffalo sauce

Steaming hot wings with mild buffalo sauce

Flatiron Tavern

See all

Brassica - Salad- 1/2 Chicken & 1/2 Brisket

Brassica

4.7(1.6k reviews)
0.3 mi•Short North, Italian Village
•$$

SO. FRESH. I was in…read moreColumbus for a conference and stopped at Brassica for lunch, and I'm honestly kicking myself for not going every single day I was there! I had the falafel salad bowl and basically said, "Give me ALL the vegetables." I loaded that bowl up with every veggie they had to offer, and every single one was incredibly fresh and delicious. The falafel was fantastic, too! The staff was also so sweet, friendly, and accommodating, which made the experience even better. You can tell they really care about the food and the people they're serving. If you're in Columbus and looking for something fresh, flavorful, and satisfying, HIGHLY recommend Brassica! I only wish I had discovered it sooner so I could've eaten here every day of my trip!

We stopped by Brassica while we were in town reviewing a few spots, and as usual, this place…read morecompletely knocked our socks off. We arrived fairly close to closing, which can sometimes be risky--some restaurants start cutting corners as the night winds down. Not here. Everything was incredibly fresh, and each bite took our palates on a culinary adventure that had us feeling like champions for choosing Brassica for dinner. The ingredients, flavors, and execution were all outstanding. If you haven't been here yet, do yourself a favor and go. Brassica continues to prove why it's one of our favorite places to eat whenever we're in town.

Photos
Brassica
Brassica - Salad and photobomb Brassica Fries

Salad and photobomb Brassica Fries

Brassica

See all

Ted's Montana Grill - Kids Kid's Bison Cheeseburger and side of Salt & Pepper Onion Rings.

Ted's Montana Grill

3.7(301 reviews)
0.3 mi•Arena District
•$$

My fav place for bison I normally get the Cadillac burger and mashed potatoes w/ gravyread more

This location specific on W. Nationwide Blvd was terrible with customer service. It took 90 min…read moreafter placing the order to have it delivered 1/2 mile away at the Renaissance Hotel. I love Ted's Montana Grill but don't know why this location delivery service via DoorDash is so bad. I placed an order and received a confirmation email for a chili and loaded baked potato. The email confirmation was at 6:28 PM on Sunday, Aug 23 with a delivery time estimate of 6:50-7:09pm. The location of the restaurant is half a mile away. DoorDash sent someone within 15 minutes to go pick the order up. When the delivery person got there, they waited 15 minutes and had to leave for another order, then another DoorDash delivery driver arrived waited 15 minutes and had to leave, then a third DoorDash delivery driver arrived and was told it was gonna be 20 minutes so they had to leave then a fourth Driver and then a fifth Driver. No joke. When the fifth Driver was there I personally called Ted's explaining the situation and to ask if there was an issue with my baked potato and chili. Whoever I spoke with didn't even know there had been 5 doordash drivers waiting for the order or that anybody was waiting for the order. Meanwhile, he goes back to check in the kitchen and it's sitting there waiting to be picked up in the window. I received my order at 8:02PM. The driver sent photos of the restaurant and kitchen staff to show it wasn't even busy - be aware. They may not be your best choice for dinner if you are on a timeline, however, the chili & baked potato was delicious especially since I was starving after waiting an extra hour.

Photos
Ted's Montana Grill - Directly over table and food

Directly over table and food

Ted's Montana Grill - That's a medium, not medium rare beef steak

That's a medium, not medium rare beef steak

Ted's Montana Grill - Sign outside

See all

Sign outside

R Bar Arena - Barbecue wings and celery

R Bar Arena

3.2(112 reviews)
0.1 mi•Short North
•$$

On a Saturday night it was pretty packed at R Bar past 10 pm. But we found two seats at the large…read morecircle bar and our order was taken under 10 minutes upon arrival. We just ordered some cocktails and an appetizer of potato skins. The potato skins came out in a timely manner and was steamy and fresh. Nice portion of real bacon crumbles and cheddar cheese. Accompanied with a pile of jalapenos which I really appreciated. Served with one small pack of sour cream... I had to ask for another it only sufficed 3 skins. I do love me some ranch with potato skins but I didn't ask so that's on me. Tito's redbull was 10$ and the potato skins were 14$. I would stop in for a drink to catch up with friends.

We came in before a Blue Jackets game. We got here pretty early. My husband ordered mozzarella…read moresticks- they were just ok. Let me tell you about our bartender, Ryan! He was amazing!! He didn't let us have an empty glass and made sure our food came out hot. This absolutely IS a game joint! It's loud! Increasingly louder closer to game time!!If you come 1-2 hours before or directly after the game, you may not get things off the menu and you may have to go to the bar and get your own drinks. We had a great time here though. Know what you're heading in to and enjoy it!! Go Jackets!!

Photos
R Bar Arena - At bar.

At bar.

R Bar Arena - Buffalo wings and celery

Buffalo wings and celery

R Bar Arena - I won the duck in the claw machine. They're rigged. Tighter than the slots in Vegas. Seriously. Just don't.

See all

I won the duck in the claw machine. They're rigged. Tighter than the slots in Vegas. Seriously. Just don't.

Caroline’s Sandwiches - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...