Of course when I first heard about this place, I was intrigued. It's called Psychic Pie for god's sake. (FYI, I'm super woo :)) Then, my sister-in-law raved about it, declaring it the best pizza she's ever had. (Or something incredibly declarative like that.) We decided to give it a try. Upon walking in, Fugazi was playing in the shop. That was a good sign. When do you ever hear Fugazi playing at an establishment nowadays, the last time was probably in a record shop in the 90s. The pizzas are displayed, and you choose how much of each pizza you'd like and they will cut some off for you and it is priced by weight. Then, they heat it up for you to melt the cheese, and viola! Served with cloth napkins, pizza scissors, if desired when eating-in. (Truly the most brilliant way to cut pizza!) Immediately, I saw "OG Potato" and that was a must have. It was something like Potato, ricotta, chile oil, mozzarella, dill. (Just to cut to the chase on this one, it was incredible! I am obsessed with ricotta, and there was something about all the combination of flavors especially the dill that gave some freshness amongst the rich taste of everything else.) Others we got were the pepperoni, a 4 cheese, and a vegan one with no cheese, just tomato sauce, roasted garlic, olives (there may have been other stuff on it, but that's what I remember) Everything was incredible, even the vegan one. The tomato sauce was so high quality, and I was glad there wasn't any vegan cheese on it. Just veggie tastiness in its purest form. The sourdough crust was light and fluffy. It was all just so high quality, and you can feel the passion for their food. Oh yeah, I almost forgot a big star: the Kale Caesar. Don't sleep on that one. It's one of the best salads we've had in years. It was flavorful, with bits of sunflower seeds to give it crunch. Dressing was on-point with a mountain of fluffy parm on top. And so here's the thing with the current state of eating establishments. There is so much expensive mediocre food out there. Nowadays, you may pay $12 for a salad that's out of a bag with wilted ends and sorry baby carrots. And so, considering there's a place that's putting beautifully intentional food out there, I'd rather choose to go to the place that is high quality and cares about their food and sustainability. We topped off our experience with soft serve and a cookie. The soft serve was amazing. We got it 'eat-in' and it was high quality soft-serve in a whimsical cup and presidential spoons. (Love the sustainability angle, but also the whimsy) You can get it with olive oil and sea salt and other toppings, but I went pure. It was milky and homey, and just gooood. (My hubs wanted the cookie) Not to mention, service was genuine. There was a slow, no-rush vibe to this place that might piss some people off. But given its name, I feel like it's apt. It's Psychic Pie for god's sake, and the ethereal does not rush. In the ethereal, time doesn't exist!!! (lol) You can feel that every part of this establishment is in the vision of its owner, wanting the experience to be a part of their authenticity and values. And we need more of that in this world right now. (And I don't mean some skewed sense of 'authenticity' as in just saying whatever comes to mind and is 'in your face' that has infiltrated our society today) This is true authenticity I'm talking about - an expression of your own Light essence. (See, I told you I'm woo) Speaking of which, the music continued to be my jam at my time here... likely to be a Pixies radio mix, with awesome 90s punk / indie. Some songs I hadn't heard in decades but love. So, it was like entering into someone's establishment that's part of my soul tribe. So, if any of the above sound like your jam too... give it a try! read more

See all

Psychic Pie is a very unique place. The name may confuse some people, but once you get to know this place you will keep coming back. It is really the only place of its kind, at least in the North Bay. They make pizza Roman style, where they bake pizzas in a long, rectangular shape. Then, you get to determine how big of a piece you want. They cut it to your liking (in Italy this is called Al Taglio)and then you pay for it by the weight. They always have several options. The other thing that makes the pizza here so special is their use of sourdough crust. I love the texture and flavor that the crust gives to every pizza here. The service is always really good and very helpful. Once you pick your pizzas they will heat up your slices and then dress it up with extra toppings such as herbs, grated cheeses, oils, etc. One of the owners is typically working and they are such lovely people. On this particular visit, my wife and I ordered five different pizzas to try. One of my favorites is the OG Potato, which is covered in thin sliced, crispy potato, ricotta, mozzarella, creme fraiche, dill and chives. It is so rich and creamy. My new favorite is a pizza with blue cheese, walnuts, and caramelized onions that knocked my socks off. Unfortunately, I didn't get the name of that one. There was another new one to me which was the Hot coppa Striacatella. I don't know if I've ever seen charred chicory on a pizza before but it worked really well with the spicy coppa. I also tried the vegan slice which was really good and the Funguy, which is subtle but still tasty. I highly recommend you come try Psychic Pie if you've never been here. It is a Sebastopol must-do! read more

See all

Awesome spot for Roman style pizza. My favorite was the sausage + broccolini, calabrian, ricotta. Usually I'm a huge fan of mushroom pizza but I didn't like the texture / flavor of the mushrooms on the Fun Guy. The green garlic, whipped chevre, calabrian, arugula, stracciatella was the most unique, if you're looking for something different. read more

Great pizza, love the idea of pizza by weight. Although I miss pointing to the big/best slice and saying "can I get that slice" however the pizza here is top tier. I live the light airy crumb. Great quality toppings. Customer service is really friendly. And the interior is cozy. I think the one tiny issue I had that made this a 4 star instead of 5 was that I asked if I could have my slices heated "extra crispy" the reason being that on previous visits we noticed that the slices with more topping were still cold in the middle. When I asked for them to be extra crispy I was assured the pizza would be crispy. And again the pizza with the sausage was a bit cold in the center. read more

See all

Pizza delicious. We usually take it home as we live nearby but on a warm day it could be lovely on their little deck.

was doing some restaurant research on reddit and there was an entire thread dedicated to pizza spots in sonoma. psychic pie is served roman style. pizza sold by weight and cut by scissors. got a "three finger" slice of pepperoni and another of sausage. excellent crispy bottoms, airy dough, rich sauce with just the right amount of cheese and toppings. friendly people, outdoor seating available. read more

Psychic Pie - pizza - Salad Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

My girl was getting her nails done next door and we stumbled into Psychic Pie to see what sourdough pizza was all about. The service was fantastic as he asked us if it was our first time and explained how they price their square pizza by the pound (lb). They have four staples and four seasonal pizzas. We ended up trying the PepPep, Funguy, OG Potato, and Coppa. All were tasty and delicious. After picking out the pizza they're weighed and then thrown into the oven for a crispy finish. After the oven the server tops each pizza off with their special toppings. Pepperoni had fresh parmesan, Funguy - lemon zest, OG. Potato olive oil, Coppa- hot honey. Will be back quite often since it's right next door to where my girlfriend gets her nails done! read more

See all

Everyone should agree you should never leave a restaurant hungry, well I just did... and it honestly shouldn't happen at a place that charges as much as Physchic Pie does. The pricing is outrageous for what you actually get. The employees kept insisting the pizza was "very filling," which led me to order less than I normally would. Big mistake. The slice I got was nowhere near enough, and I walked out still hungry after spending what could've paid for a full meal somewhere else. To be fair, the pizza itself actually tasted pretty good, and the employees were nice and friendly while we were there. The issue isn't the flavor or the attitude it's that the portions and pricing just don't match up at all. To make things worse, the service still had some problems. My mom ordered a salad, and they didn't bother to tell us they were out of it until after they had already put our pizzas in the oven. Overall, even though the food tasted good and the staff was kind, the high prices, small portions, and lack of communication made this a frustrating experience. read more

So we are visiting a friend in santa rosa & the girlfriend said we need to come here for lunch because their pies are reportedly pretty awesome. How could anyone say no to pizza & beer so i agreed & wow oh wow the pizza was fantastic. We loved it so much that we came back for lunch the next day before heading home to Sunnyvale with a box of takeout for dinner. I recommend the olive oil & sea salt soft serve & chocolate cookie as well. read more

See all

This place has amazing pizza. Super fresh, cooked in season to perfection. I love the portion sizes and the pizza scissors they hand out to help you cut it down for sharing. So glad I found this place in Sebastopol. Recommend you go out of your way to eat here. Service could not have been better. Dining room is immaculately clean and comfortable. Bathrooms also super clean. read more

This is one of my favorite lunch pizza stops. Very simple to select what you want and how much. I love eating in as they heat the pizza while you wait. They have wine available as well, plus other food items such as salads and bread to go. They have a couple seats outside as well and so makes for great casual dining. The staff are always so helpful and friendly. You should seek them out when In Sebastapol. Enjoy. read more

See all

I love the sourdough bread and the outdoor dining option in this place! The staff were really nice and attentive.

Psychic Pie is amazing. Super fresh ingredients and the pizzas are absurdly good. Great friendly and happy vibe. What a gem.

This was absolutely delicious but the cost!!! Over sixty dollars for two of us. Yes there was some leftover and we did get cookies (yummy but a bit burnt), but still too expensive to repeat. Sad. But we are not super rich and sebastopol businesses would be wise to remember that a good portion of the population in this town are not rich either. I suggest they find a way to reduce prices if they want to continued success in this town of many delicious places to eat read more

Open Wed to Sunday, a no-brainer: you must come by (as early as you can before everyone else gets off work or call and see if you can reserve) because they do SELL OUT frequently well before closing. Like by hours! Omg, the way I feel is so disappointed when that happens. It's like... Worse than being 5 years old and someone telling you Christmas morning Christmas was canceled! The first time it happened, I was so shocked and dismayed. I literally, no lie, wanted nothing else to eat... Nothing could fill the niche and void. I stayed up watching Hulu, YouTube, and Netflix, eating ice cream as if I wanted to melt into the Earth after a break up. Then, even more tragic, I woke to realize, oh no... It's Monday! Even worse than the typical tragedy of being Monday with the jolt back to work reality, Psychic Pie won't be open again till Wednesday. Oh, cruel world! What have you done to me? I'm trying so hard to nix the craving that no other pizza or even my favorite Caramel Crunch Starbucks frap helps. Finally, I wake on Wednesday morning, rearranging my appointments to get off work as early as possible to zip over to psychic pie. Oh, glorious day, get the slices by the pound to go HOT. Your oven unless you have access to a commercial 1 million-degree Kelvin iron slave pizza stove that takes up half your wall at home, you must have them heat it. It makes that chewy, moist inside crackling, ideally outside crisp crust-like perfection. Oh heaven, the caramelized leak, Funguy, and 4 Cheese are my favorite ode to my vegetarian days, to be sure. Still, the shaved parmesan and lemon zest give the pizzas the Pièce de résistance and umami to tip the scale from delicious to addictive. And not the slap-you-in-the-face addiction. The kind that creeps up on you in the middle of the night that sometimes leaves Oreo crumbs and your favorite mug with milk by your bed but didn't quite satiate you, so you're like, oooh, any of that fermented sourdough pizza left downstairs? On that note, the men are more partial to the classic sausage or pepperoni, but I've also tried wilder combinations or cultivations like with beets or broccoli. I do dare say! At any rate, you just 1. Love, and I mean absolutely have to LOVE, sourdough. Otherwise, don't bother. The nuances of this stellar product should be left to those more admiring and deserving. 2. You must be open and flexiblely also LOVE pizza and all its glory of varying degrees. I imagine this style is more similar to what you find in Italia. So that leaves 3. And I hope you can manage this, as I have yet to... Bring someone you LOVE to share your ohs and ahs with; trust me, it's another place where these satisfying moaning sounds make things [insert sense here] better. Mmmmhmmm. So what are you waiting for? If you want something extraordinary. Foodie. And won't break the bank. 10 to 25 dollars for 1 or 2 good sliced portions (men may need 1.5, but women are usually good with 1). Gourmet. Who knows, you may have found a new favorite corner hole in the wall that is eclectic and not divey. Go, what are you waiting for? And please discerningly so, only tell the people who will love it like us. We want less of those sold-out nights, God forbid. Or maybe we can give them so much business that she (the owner) needs to ramp up 24/7. Wouldn't that be the dream? Nothing is open 24/7 Anymore. My votes go to the library, Psychic Pie, and Walmart. Those mandatorily should be open 24/7. read more

Psychic Pie - Caramelized leak forward, funguy in the back. 22$ - Salad Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Their sourdough bread is incredible. I haven't tried anything else and I imagine it would be excellent for how good the bread was.

Phenomenal pizza on a sourdough crust. Unique toppings that are just so good!! Wine and beer in the cooler along with jars of their dipping sauce - like ranch on yummy steroids. Salads are wonderful and the cookies... read more

Unique and absolutely delicious pizza! They serve long-fermented sourdough pizza 'al taglio' (by the slice). The dough reminds me of a thinner focaccia bread: the perfect crisp on the bottom, and a light, airy texture inside. The pies are presented in long rectangles, and cut with kitchen scissors based on the size you want. Then your slices are weighed and you pay by the weight. Note: I said 'slices' as you cannot order just one! Slices can be heated there or they'll give you instructions on how to heat them at home. The Psychic Pie team uses fresh local ingredients and changes the offerings frequently. We recently tried: -potato -mushroom -squash -Margherita (?) or plain -pepperoni LOVED all of them...and the unique flavor enhancements: dill on the potato pie, citrus zest on the mushroom... Yum!!! If you're looking for pizza in Sebastopol, Psychic Pie is where it's at! read more

Psychic Pie - Salad Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Still amazing 3 years later! The family and I moved away and haven't been able to come to our favorite pizza spot for about a year! We can back yesterday and ordered up our favorite mushroom pizza. I swear it's better than it was the first time! I miss having this pizza every week, and we will go out of our way to come back even if we have to drive another hour and a half out of the way. It's seriously that good. read more

Pizza is solid. But way too expensive. Was basically $12 for a single slice of their sausage/ onion. Much better value at Acre pizza. Wont be back. read more

Aug 2023 Cool little spot. Always fun to check out new pizza places. The place looks really clean on the inside and the guy at the front was really helpful with any questions I had. I took the order to go and they have a little sign posted at the place for cooking instructions for the pie. I had gotten the Fun Guy, Shishito Zucchini, Coppa and Beets, and the Pistachio and Basil Pesto. Everything had good flavors heated up. I liked the chewiness of the dough that they used. The one that stood out among the 4 was the shishito zucchini. It had a good light savory and freshness to it that lent well to a nice balance in each bite. The fun guy had a nice amount of toppings to it with various mushrooms. The Coppa and beets had a good sweet savory between the ingredients. The pistachio and basil pesto missed for me since the sauce wasn't too strong and I wanted more richness from the pesto itself. Would be interested to try some of the other offerings, if only they delivered where I'm at. read more

See all

Great pizza! Like amazing. And the salad is great too. Low key place offering high quality pizza- not like you've ever had.

The pistachio pesto was very good! The deck was not as comfortable as I would have hoped but it was dog friendly so we will be back soon!

Unique, Delicious and creative pizzas. Love that you choose size of slice from a number of available, freshly made pizzas. Pizza dough is delicious, light sourdough style. Great kale salad. Casual and fun place. Great fresh ice cream and creme brûlée for deserts. Can't wait to return, read more

This is a cute little pizza place, obviously a favourite with the locals for take and bake. We were up visiting my daughter and she recommended them for a bite to eat. It was a Sunday morning and we were heading back home so we ordered a couple of their brunchy, breakfast slices - one sausage and gravy, the other a croque monsieur - with an egg on top of each. Their crust is made with a sourdough starter so it has a wonderful texture and excellent flavour. I don't usually eat the crust but theirs is exceptionally delicious. It was a nice morning so we sat outside where they have three or four tables to dine al fresco under an umbrella. On Sundays they have slices geared more toward brunch that you can eat there or take away. Friendly staff, service with a smile. Priced by the pound, extra charge for eggs and other extra toppings. read more

See all

Best pizza ever! The bruschetta pizza was unique and fresh and so incredibly good! As was every other bite we had! Pizza is not my typical go to favorite, but this one, this one is incredible. If you haven't been, this is you cue to go! read more

GOOD handmade pizza hence the price - Not for everyday but a good splurge if you're passing by. Best eaten here right out of the oven. The bruschetta hit the spot! read more

Service good. Food great. Pricing horrendous. Enjoyed my meal. Didn't enjoy paying $38 dollars (before tip) for a one person meal. I got a regular piece of the pepperoni and jalapeño bacon, and thought the pizza was very tasty. Really good food. The service was also fine, and the food came out in a timely manner. No issues there either. In general, this would be a five star review if the prices weren't so exorbitant, and I hope that whoever owns the restaurant can come to the realization that a one person meal should not cost $40. If you are willing to cough up that much for lunch, I would recommend this place. read more

The good part is the crust. I love the use of local ingredients. But really was hoping to get a standard cheese slice not with multiple cheeses etc. and some of the other toppings were exotic to say the least. What really made me drop the rating was the price. It's quite high with fees upon fees. Service was ok. read more

Stopped by on a rainy Saturday afternoon looking for some interesting pizza topping combinations. We were not disappointed! They sell pizza by the pound as well as some baked goods and salads. Our group ordered a variety of slices. Service was quick and friendly. Our favorite was the Greenzo (broccoli, braised beet tops, and cheddar). The crust reminded me more of a flatbread compared to a more traditional pizza. We also appreciated that we were provided with a special pair of scissors for cutting the slices into smaller pieces to share. The cookies we ordered for dessert were flavorful and had a chewy texture. I would definitely visit again to try their other pizzas and salads! read more

See all

My husband has been eyeing this location for sometime. We finally got a catch to try it during new years and we're super happy with what we tried! We played it safe and order cheese and pepperoni and they were both amazing. The cheese can stand alone which is a great sign of the locations pizza abilities! We had the thin crust and it has the perfect sauce to dough ratio. Can't wait to come back and try again we have started to spread the word as much as we can read more

Psychic Pie - Pepperoni and hot honey so good - Salad Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

This restaurant is a great place to hang out! I stopped by during trivia night. I didn't know it was trivia night, so I came late and didn't have a time. I just listened along and answered what I could. Still great fun! The pizza was also amazing. I had the pepperoni slice and it was very crispy and cheesy. I did not like the Dino sauce as much; it's too sweet for pizza. The aesthetic inside is very modern but fun. Great midtown spot! read more

I love their pizza! The sourdough crust is amazing and definitely helps them stand out. They use a lot of local ingredients and always have seasonal toppings. They cut square pizzas with scissors to the size you like, and charge you by weight of the slice. I've never seen this done at a pizza place. I understand why they do it, however a slice of cheese for 1 person costs around 12$. Which is a lot for most people. The space is small but has seating for 15 or so. They make their own ranch and chili drizzle for dipping. As well as homemade soft serve. Expensive, but worth it. read more

If you haven't eaten here yet then I feel sorry for you but I also am jealous of you because experiencing this pizza for the first time is LIFE CHANGING. Since it entered my world I have been back so many times. The pizza combinations are so incredible and they always have a cheese free option which is is special to my heart. COME HERE IMMEDIATELY! Oh also get a cookie they are delicious. read more

See all

Brilliant! Sausage and Gravy pizza with an egg on top! 1 - I had a hangover and couldn't image a better cure than this pizza 2- I'm not a big pizza person so when I do eat pizza I want I to be special - no pepperoni on it let's make it interesting and exciting! I love that they have different pizzas all the time depending on season and time of day - just show up and be delighted. 3- Holy cow it was soooo good! The crust is amazing!! I can't wait to try more and today when I went they were playing Simon and Garfunkel which is perfect for a Sunday morning and the owner was so nice - even when my Beagle howled so loud!! Can't wait to try more! read more

This is supposed to be Roman-style pizza, cooked thin-crust in long rectangular pans from which, if you're buying by the slice, the servers cut a cross-slice to your specification of size, with the minimum being three fingers thick. (I say "supposed to be" because when I was in Rome I never had pizza made like this. But that was 20-odd years ago; who knows how things have changed?) Anyway, the serving guy said a typical order was two three-finger pieces. That sounded good to me, so I ordered that much from the pepperoni and the sausage (with pickled onions and jalapenos) from the half dozen varieties on display. They heated them up and behold, good and tasty pizza. I was satisfied. Lots of people coming in and taking heat-at-home pizzas to go. read more

Left is blackberry and bro on right is sausage. Delicious. add this to my previous visits. Metta j read more

Psychic Pie - Photo of black berry and Brie and on the right is sausage and red onion. Delicious !! - Salad Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Would definitely recommend!! We drove from st Helena and it was SO worth it! Yes the style is different with paying by weight but I thought that was a neat concept and was honestly not that expensive/bad for some QUALITY pizza. You should know and understand what you're getting/paying for before you go.. so the reviews that bash the price come'on! Look before you buy! Lol All of the pizzas looked delicious and unique in their ingredients. The crust was super tasty too. Chatted with the owner and he was a cool dude! Love this place hope to be back soon! Oh and they gave us some scissors to cut up our pizza cause we wanted to share all the pieces we got, super great staff. read more

Psychic Pie - Pizza by the slice! - Salad Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Why did I think this was a apple cherry blueberry pie pie place lol omg I came in wanting sweets and walking out craving more savory pepperoni psychic pie! They must a knew I was coming. This place is so delicious! Perfect 3 finger slice. I want more! I saw a buffalo cheese ice cream on that menu. I'm definitely trying that next time. They have a vegan option too. Everything looks incredible. Don't skip on this spot if you're a pizza lover like me! read more

Never been to a pizza place like this! Such a unique, new way to go about serving pizzas. Just visited Psychic Pie for my first time after passing by it quite often on my way to Avid Coffee. Sharing a parking lot with many other little local businesses, Psychic is kind of hidden in the back. Walked inside to a bright open room with a handful of tables of to the side and some scattered plants and art all around. I headed to the counter to order and see what they're all about. They charge for slices by the pound, so choose what size of a slice from any of their available pizzas. It appears that they may have weekly menu changes. Likely keeping a couple staples and then changing it out a few from time to time which is a fun reason to want to come back and try more! They had about 7 different pizza choices on the day that I went, as well as 3 different salads, and some dessert! They also have beer and wine to choose from, including non alcoholic drinks as well. I ordered a salad for there and some slices to go. Salad was not only pretty but very delicious as well. Once we got home, we followed their easy re-heating instructions. Each slice was unique in its own way and sooo good! Given it was a little pricier, it was all worth it in my opinion. :) read more

See all