Pizzaleah came highly recommended by a friend so i had to stop on my way home from Clearlake. The staff was extremely friendly and welcoming, Sarah was fantastic. I ordered their Margarita pizza which was cooked perfectly. The sauce was very tasty and complemented the thin style crust which was crispy with a little char. I ordered the their Roo pizza to take home. If you like mushrooms, this hits that craving. They also offer some different brewey choices you might not find at mainstream pizzerias. It turns out that Leah works Sundays so i got to watch her in action. Her passion and attention to detail is exactly what i was looking for in a pizzeria. It was a pleasure for the Legend General to meet her and converse about her great pizza. It was a very nice atmosphere and good experience. It's Definitely worth the stop if your traveling through the area. I highly recommend Pizzaleah! read more

I've eaten a lot of pizza in my life. I've been to New York and tried a bunch of the famous spots, and they were really good. But I'm honestly not joking when I say I prefer Pizza Leah to anything I had there. I don't understand how they get the crust like this. It's perfectly chewy and just cooked exactly right. Usually I like the crust but don't love it. Here, I actually do love it. I've been here at least 15 times and I've tried pretty much everything on the menu. My two favorites are the Roo's and the Po-Tay-To. I love how the place is laid out. You can see into the kitchen, and the eating area is exactly what I think a pizza place should look like. It just feels comfortable. One time on my birthday, my wife picked up the pizza and didn't realize that they gave her the wrong one until she got home. She called and went back to get the right one, and when she got there they had forgotten to remake it, so she had to wait. She was honestly pretty mad at that point after making two trips, which I don't blame her for at all. But they were so apologetic that they ended up giving us the pizza for free, and that honestly made up for everything and turned it into a really nice surprise. She got over it pretty quickly after that. Funny enough, it worked out as two trips for two pizzas, and my birthday is 2/2. Now whenever I eat pizza anywhere else, I end up comparing it to Pizza Leah. Other places have good pizza, but this one just checks every single box for me. It just is the perfect pizza for me. read more

We ordered take from Pizzaleah. We first went to the website and it said it would take 2 hours for our ordered. We ended up calling and they said 20 minutes so keep that mind if you the website gives you a long wait time. When I arrived the place was packed. Every table was taken and they were pumping out take orders which explains why the website said 2 hours they needed a break. It took an extra 5-10 minutes from when they said to actually get my pizza which makes sense because they were busy. Now for the pizza we got an Old Grey Beard it was fine. The topping were unique and the crust had a good amount of flavor. I'm happy I tried it and its one of the better pizza spots in Sonoma but if I'm going out for pizza I'd pick somewhere else. read more

Pizzaleah - Old Grey Beard - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

i've been here a few times one of my very good friends lives in Windsor and we found this amazing little pizza parlor my son used to live in Forestville and would bring pizza over. It was a big treat. The pizza is amazing. They have all these different kinds of pizzas. I think we got one with a gray beard and it had hot honey on it and it was amazing. We ordered three different kinds of pizzas. One was just a regular pepperoni, but my favorite was the gray beard. The service was good and friendly. The restaurant was clean and tidy they're very busy place most people seem to get their pizzas and go all I got to say is as long as I get my pizza and it comes from Pizzaleah it means I'm a very happy girl Cheers my friends SYOY 06/19/25 review #377 read more

See all

We LOVE PizzaLeah and owner Leah rocks! This is some of the best pizza in Sonoma County! It's been awhile and we needed our fix. We were stoked to find them last night on DoorDash, so order we did: Roo's (12" signature pizza): olive oil, fontina, mozzarella, mushroom medley, fresh thyme, roasted fennel, shaved parmesan & fresh Italian parsley We added bacon and loved that flavor enhancement. With or without the bacon, Roo's is a symphony of delicious flavors, and we highly recommend it, especially if you're looking for a white pie (no tomato sauce). The crust is relatively thin, and well structured. Sharing a 12" pie was an act of self-restraint. Normally we order more, and eat more. But this was the perfect amount for two of us trying to be good - we paired it with a salad we had at home and enjoyed every bite. Craving more PizzaLeah and look forward to our next PizzaLeah pizza!!! read more

Straight off the bat - great pizza. I had ordered an old gray beard pie and a mush-a-roni pie, both as the 16" pie option. For both pizzas, the crust was crispy and airy with good chew. The crust had a good subtle flavor as well. The undercarriage was well cooked, leaving a crispy bottom. The sauce tasted great and had a good cheese to sauce ratio. The toppings for both pizzas were well placed - not overwhelming the other flavors, and they complimented one another. I would recommend the old gray beard if you like a little spiciness in your pie, and the mush-a-roni is a solid choice too if you want a little more "safer" flavors. I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza here and hope to be back again. read more

See all

Huge pizza with a lot of meat/ingredients! Love the crust that was so crispy and airy at the same time. The pizza was so good that you need to be careful of over-eating. Staff was extremely nice and the vibe was very casual and comfy. read more

Pizzaleah - Boomin granny - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Pizza. . Pizza. . Pizza . . I can't think of a better food. As someone who's had pizza almost every Friday for the last 5+ years, I've tried a few good ones, bad ones, and amazing ones. Pizza leah no doubt falls under the amazing category. I've been coming here many times, and each time it puts a smile on my face . Such a tasty pizza . The quality of ingredients you can taste- fresh, delicious, and gets ya hooked on what fresh flavor is. The dough is thin and crunchy , chewy crust. Some pizzas I've tried . . The dough sits in me, just feels heavy and super hearty, but the fermentation pizzaleah has going on here really hits the spot- goes down easy. I could eat a whole pie. Old grey beard was my first. Woah. Perfect flavor combo (orange zest??! Who knew it would add such an amazing flavor). They have great in-house pizzas, and come up with some creative specialties throughout the year. If you're iffy, then just try your favorite toppings. You'll notice the difference . I mix it up with specialties and MYO (make your own) . Great service every time. Indoor seating, outdoor seating, and some bar seating. Feels like a cosy pizza place to sit down and enjoy. I actually even recognized the owner, Leah, from Best in Dough (a pizza competition cooking series). Even took a pizza making classes she taught. Shes not sitting on the sidelines, but front and center cooking alongside her great staff and skillful pizza makers. Aside from that they compete internationally! How many pizza places do you know do that? Kinda cool! I've tried a lot of pizza, but if anyone asks my favorite . . It's someplace that checks off great service, amazing flavor, and order repetition- pizza leah checks it all off. It's a pizza place you DEFINITELY should check out if you're a pizza lover. A great staple of Windsor and should be a staple to all pizza lovers. Try it out! read more

See all

We were in Windsor for a day trip, and decided to come for dinner. Despite the town being relatively quiet, I was surprised to find the Pizzaleah was full and we had to sit outside. There was a line just to order at the counter, and then they bring out the pizzas to you. I tried their award winning "Old Grey Beard" and "Lola" pizzas. I could see why the the award winning pizza was so popular--it wasn't too spicy, and had a slight sweetness and tanginess to it from the honey and zest. The Lola was also good as I really enjoyed caramelized onions: just wished they put more on it! Overall, they're a solid choice for pizza and I would recommend taking it to go as well, since they're pretty packed! read more

See all

My family and I were in town; it had been some time since our last meal here, so we were really excited to return. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and the Boomin' Granny. The pepperoni was a fantastic classic, and the Boomin' Granny certainly turned heads, as a few people stopped to ask us what was the name of the pizza. The food was delicious, and our 17-month-old loves pizza and it is safe to say Pizzaleah is her absolute favorite pizza place. My husband and I finished our meals, and our little one just couldn't stop, I think she managed to eat maybe 2 slices of the pepperoni and even snagged a slice of the Boomin' Granny from my husband's plate. We will definitely be back and bring some friends with is next time, service was extremely friendly. Ambiance was fantastic, they never slowed down people kept coming in sitting down or getting take out. read more

Pizzaleah - Boomin' Granny - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

If you're looking for terrific pizza in the Windsor area, you have to go to Pizzaleah. Founder Leah Scurto is a bonafide pizza champion (5 times!), competing in competitions in Italy and across the U.S. When we dined here for lunch in June on a Sunday afternoon, the place was not that busy. There is ample seating inside and out and the staff was very welcoming. We ordered the FG Special with red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey--wow, that was delicious! It was the perfect size for my husband and I and we left no crumbs. This was a square pan pizza, but they also have signature round thin crust pies if you prefer those. If we are ever in the neighborhood again, we will be back. read more

Pizzaleah - FG Special - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

This was the place to be on a Saturday night! I ordered take out online through their website and was given a 35-40 minute wait. I arrived around the 35 minute mark and my food was not ready yet. All of the staff there were very friendly and apologetic that my food was taken longer than anticipated. They had indoor and outdoor seating. I ordered the "Lola" pizza which was a pesto base with mozzarella, roasted potatoes and caramelized onions. Though the onions were not caramelized, I did enjoy the pizza, it was different. read more

Pizzaleah - Lola - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Delicious Pie in a vegetarian/vegan friendly place. We had the Thin crust Half-n-Half Roo's + Lola and both were amazing. Pie was perfectly made. Service was quick, you order at counter then get pie served at your table . Outdoor seating with a shade for our dog made our day ! read more

Pizzaleah - HalfnHalf : Roo's + Lola - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Great pies in a fast casual atmosphere. Beer and wine menu. Family friendly. Thin crust and sourdough deep dish offerings. Definitely recommend checking them out! read more

Pizzaleah's deep dish Mush-a-roni is next-level. The crust alone is worth the trip--golden, buttery, and perfectly crisped on the outside, yet tender and flavorful all the way through. It holds up beautifully to the generous layers of toppings without ever feeling heavy or doughy. The ingredient quality really shines here. The pepperoni is rich and perfectly curled with just the right amount of crisp, the cremini mushrooms add an earthy depth, and the shaved parmesan brings that salty, savory edge. The red sauce is vibrant and tangy, clearly made from great tomatoes, and the fresh basil gives a pop of brightness that cuts through the richness in the best way. Every bite is balanced, bold, and made with care. You can taste the difference in quality--and that crust? Absolute perfection. read more

Pizzaleah - Boomin Granny - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

This places doesn't even need reviews if your local or not , this is by far one of the best fresh pizzas you can enjoy. Simply wanted to share the seasonal pizza I just tried, I was so worried to try something new and unusual for my taste buds but it didn't disappoint... So this review is to step outside your box and try the specials they. Do! read more

Pizzaleah - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

I've visited Pizzaleah the last couple of times driving up to the Russian River and I can't think of a single thing that's wrong with this place. The workers are so welcoming the moment you walk in. There's outside/inside eating. While there's some normal pizza options, there's some pretty gnarly ones that I never thought I'd eat on a pizza slice. We tried a peach/jalepeno special today, and as interesting as it sounds.. the taste pallet was there. It made sense. Idk how but it just did. Their old grey beard is my personal fave (so far) because of the hot honey Will be making it my personal goal to try all the pizzas on their menu. read more

My favorite pizza in the whole entire world. I fly home to Sonoma County every year so that i can eat this pie. The Boogie, with sausage and fresh thyme. Thank you Leah and Crew!!! read more

See all

Friday-pizza night. Another delightful visit to PizzaLeah, and it did not disappoint! We indulged in the large Roo topped with a mushroom medley, and it was simply perfection. The combination of olive oil, fontina, mozzarella, roasted fennel, and fresh herbs made every bite a taste sensation. If you're a mushroom lover, this is a must-try! Can't wait to come back for another slice of heaven! Service: A huge thank you to Pauline and Mason for their fantastic service. Fun atmosphere. read more

See all

Pizzaleah is the best pizza in Sonoma County. Leah is known for her terrific crust and original pizzas. It is our go to favorite.

Wowza! Talk about an incredible pizza! This place has made it to my #1 pizza spot, ever. I listened to my fellow yelpers and asked them to cook ours lightly and it was absolute perfection. We ordered the 16" thin crust, half Old Grey Beard and half Sicilian. The crust elevates this pizza to the next level. It's light and airy but holds all the ingredients in place. The flavors all meld perfectly together. It's not your typical pizza where stringy mozzarella cheese comes oozing out. Ingredients are tastefully added to give you that oh my, this is heaven in a bite. The people working at the counter are all very kind and accommodating. I asked them to wipe off a table for us and they were happy to do so. They have two TVs going on opposite corners and they have seating indoors and out. My husband and daughter agreed with me that this pizza place is a solid 5 stars. We are looking forward to trying some of their other pizzas and menu items. I can't wait until next time! Located in the Oliver's shopping center with plenty of parking. read more

See all

we ordered the old grey beard and it was pretty good! the pizza dough is solid and I'm super picky about my dough. for the toppings I liked it but prob try something else next time. nothing wrong with it just had Honey pizza somewhere else that was really good and I think I was expecting too much. the server was super nice and the pizza was quick! would be down to come back and try something else. read more

Pizzaleah - old grey beard - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

First time being back in the area after FOUR YEARS and I knew I had to stop in at Pizzaleah. We used to eat here a few times a month and have missed it since moving away. 4 years of searching and we still haven't found a place that rivals Pizzaleah. I'm not sure if The Boogie is a newer addition or if I'd just missed it before but this pizza was EXCEPTIONAL! The onions and zucchini were sliced to the perfect width to have good flavor and just enough tooth so that they didn't feel mushy. The flavors all mixed together perfectly with the garlic to taste like "MORE"! This pizza is almost as delicious cold as it is hot, too. Definitely not always the case with pizza. And dipping it in ranch? Absolutely, yes. 100% do reccomend! And the staff was so nice! They let me prattle on about missing this place and how good it is and made sure I was well stocked to head back and start packing to go home. Thanks, Pizzaleah crew! Maybe think about opening a branch in Kirkland WA! read more

See all

This pizza place is a gem. My kids have gone here before me so they already knew what they wanted... the first thing that came out of their mouth was HOT HONEY. Well, I trust their advanced taste buds so we went with the old gray beard. I was impressed with the crust first of all. The chilies on there were sweet and spicy. Over all the pizza was a hit. 2 slices per person at the 16" size. We also got the garlic knots. Sooo buttery. I enjoyed and will definitely be back. I will have to try their other pizza with hot honey, pepperoni and ricotta cheese! read more

See all

Pretty tasty pizza, and decent selection of toppings. The crust is a nice and chewy, while being pretty thin. The sausage & mushroom was a classic with very flavorful sausage. The Po-tay-to had big chunks of soft potato and big pieces of bacon, that was super tasty. read more

Visiting the area for a half marathon tomorrow, and figured pizza would be the best for carb loading. Stumbled upon this place, via yelp. At first, I wanted to go somewhere that had "vibe", rather than just another pizza spot. After reading the bio on the website, and checking out some photos, figured, let's give it a whirl. ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. If you're in the area, you must go. I'm a pizza and ranch kind of guy, this pizza didn't need ranch. The crust was cooked perfectly, without the burnt taste you would get from this style pizza, along with super fresh ingredients. 10/10 read more

Pizzaleah - Old Grey Beard (Award-winner) on top, Sicilian on bottom. - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Damn. The hype is real. We stopped here to get a pie to go (Nico) and agreed to try one slice since it would be fresh out the oven. That didn't happen. The whole pie was eaten there. Thanks also to Katie for telling us about the ranch dip. Holy hell I could have just taken a shot of that. read more

Pizzaleah - Red sauce is preferred for us but JFC the Nico pie kept getting tastier as we ate more of it. - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Definitely a place to stop for a delicious pizza. Saw this little restaurant advertised on Yelp and decided to judge for myself. I love pizza so I had to try it out, we ordered this traditional pizza that was the bum. I also but 3 chocolate chip cookies that were delicious. This place I highly recommend to go with the family or on a hot summer day and sit out side or even grab a pizza and walk to the town green that is in proximity. Service is excellent as they make you feel at home. Another great find. Giving this pizza restaurant 5 stars for great food and excellent customer service. read more

See all

Tried this place out yesterday and oh my goodness, I think I've found my new favorite pizza joint. Everything from the customer service over the phone to the interaction in the restaurant and can't forget about the FOOD, was stellar! They were busy, but it never got too loud to where we couldn't hear each other talking. I ordered a half Chingona & half Boogie, my husband got the GF/DF Old Grey Beard, kids got cheese and everyone was exceptionally happy. I cannot wait for our next visit and try them all! read more

Pizzaleah - 1/2 Chingona and 1/2 Boogie - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

Came here with a couple of my dogs and my mom, while my mom got us a table outside with the dogs, I went in to order, it's a very clean and open space inside, it has an open layout so you can see into the kitchen as well. The employees who helped me were super friendly and were understanding about my gluten restrictions since I have celiacs, My mom and I got the gluten free mush-a-roni, I will say the gluten free version was a little expensive for the size it was but hey what can you do when you're gluten free, aside from the personal pizza size, the consistency of the dough was amazing, you couldn't even tell it's gf, and the toppings I'm sure would be good on any type of dough gluten free or not, the flavors all combined were definitely a hit. I'm glad that I got to try this place and had a good experience! read more

Tried this place for the 2nd time on our way back home from a trip and passing thru the town. Pizza was delicious and ordered the same pizzas as the first time I tried this place. As far as service this time around felt a bit unwelcomed but it's ok the pizza was great. I had such a great experience the first time around I brought the whole family but did not have the same experience as the first. Pizza was delicious. read more

Pizzaleah - Ricotta Pepperoni and hot honey pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

The food here is fresh and delicious. I really like the salad. Folks that work here are always nice. It's good to go or eating in.

It's funny how my reviews tend to disappear from only this restaurant. It doesn't seem to happen at any other restaurant on yelp. I have to agree with what a few other people have already said. The pizza is overpriced and overrated. I also agree with what was said about the staff, especially one of the females tends to be rude for no apparent reason, especially to men apparently. There are better options in the area. Kin has excellent pizza and they're just on the other side of the town green, five minute walk. Try the Mac daddy. read more

Pizzaleah has unique flavors and has a crispy chewy crust! The old grey beard: has a wonderful mix of salty, spicy and sweet and orange zest to top it off. Mushroom special: the caramelized onion were the highlight here. I personally would have liked more mushrooms. But everything else was balanced well. The service was quick since we came when they just opened. Around 15mins to to our pizza. read more

Pizzaleah - Mushroom special - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

I finally made it to Pizzaleah for their Detroit pizza. First of all, I had no clue what my choices were. The girl at the counter was super friendly and helpful. I ordered the Roni, like Pepperoni. It was so good, I can hardly wait to go back and try other pizza versions. Really nice, clean place with good lighting. Parking was no priblem. read more

Surprise surprise years later it's still absolutely jaw dropping delicious. Flawless excellence! You can depend on perfection. We are incredibly lucky to have this in our neck of the woods. I would drive very very far for it if we didn't. World level award winning pizza for a reason. read more

Pizzaleah - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

I just moved to Windsor about 4 months ago and seen this place so many times and never had a chance to come in. I thought it would just be like any other pizza places that taste the same. A couple of my friends told me that I needed to try this place because it's so good. So I decided to order a takeout and omg the portion is huge and it's so good!! We ordered a 16 inch half and half with Roo's and Lola. I like Lola a lot more than Roo's. I didn't know potatoes on pizza would be so good! Roo's is so good too and I am a big fan of mushroom and they gave a lot of mushrooms! This place actually gives you a lot of toppings! Unlike those pizza chains that barely give you anything. The price is high but I totally understand why. I rather spend more money at this place than other pizza chains anyways! The service was great and they finished the pizza super fast. We want to try to eat at the restaurant next time. I am super excited to try other pizzas they have here. Highly recommend this place! read more

Pizzaleah - 16 in of Roo's and Lola - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

My friend recommended this place to me, and I loved it! I always order the Lola . it's my favorite. The Caesar salad was also really good. The service was great, and the atmosphere was very nice. Highly recommend! read more

See all

The worst service ever. I always prefer picking up a pizza rather than ordering a delivery in a cold winter weather to get it fresh and hot. Came to the restaurant to order for pickup. The restaurant was almost empty and i was waiting 35 min to get my pizza and salad. Apparently it was ready after 15 min but NO one bothered to tell me. Not only that, instead of apologizing, one of the guys there acted rudely like he called my name a few times which was not the case (it was empty and quiet, I set near the cashier). Lastly when I got back to the hotel I realized that there are no napkins nor utensils, and since the pizza was "waiting" at the restaurant for quite some time, when I wanted to eat it, it was almost cold. Bottom line, the pizza was still good half cold, but the service is low grade at best read more

Best pizza ever! Quick service and fresh tasty pizza. Tried it a few times and always impressed. read more