Best pizza in North Bay! Can't recommend it enough. The staff *chefs kiss Love the food, love the people, will forever be a fan read more

Hit up Sal's pizza spot for a late dinner and really appreciated the warm, welcoming feel and friendly staff. The space is smaller inside with a bar, a few long tables and some seating outside. They do pizza by the slice, NY style which makes it easy to try a bunch of different ones. I got the pig on a mushroom and poor man combo and my friend got the flying Hawaiian. We also ordered the meatballs which were super tender and had lots of flavor. Decent pizza at great prices. Definitely a solid choice if you're looking for something higher quality and not super expensive like acre or Tony's. Can for sure see myself hangin outside with a bomb slice, brew and a book on a nice day! read more

I decided to give Sal a second try. So many people rave about it being the best in Cotati I thought maybe my first experience was the one off. Upon entering it's a nice friendly atmosphere. The selection of pizzas is wonderful and the desserts I definitely would come back for. I got a vegetarian pizza with ricotta and spinach. It looked amazing. I just find the crust really dry and bland. The toppings were fine. I was hoping my second visit would convince me that what people are saying it's true. That being said everyone has different taste and I prefer a better crust. read more

See all

Great find! Tasty pizza. Pizza was HOT! Be aware. Hazy beer hit the spot. We will add this place to our dinner options. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Meat lovers pizza. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Ordered four large pizzas online for a get-together and everything was great! The staff was super friendly when I went to pick them up, and the place smelled amazing inside--like, you instantly get hungry walking in. It was also really clean and well-kept. I asked for some ranch on the side and was told it's normally $1 a cup, but they threw them in for free since it was a big order, such a nice gesture. (Would be awesome if there was an option to add sauces when ordering online!) The pizzas were seriously delicious. We got the Truffle Hog, Margherita di Bufala, Meat Lovers, and BBQ Chicken Luau. Every single one was a hit, nothing left but crumbs. Definitely coming back! read more

See all

Sal's is great. Employees are tentative and friendly, especially Rowland. There menu has alot of variety and everything thing is delicious. As an experienced pizza connoisseur my favorite is pepperoni calzone. read more

I love coming here. I think the cannolis are my favorite. They have a great pear salad and it's delicious with their garlic bread. Always fresh, always reliable. Best pizza joint in the area. Seriously. Enjoy. read more

Another perfect pie from Sal's!! Anthony suggested the limited release Old Caz beer to wash it down with! We appreciate Anthony, Matt & Roman! Still my favorite place to grab a beer or a pie. My favorite is the hot pepperoni with cupped pepperoni, just the right amount of hot honey & kick from Calabrian chilies & lots of fresh basil. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Hot Honey Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Decided to branch out for lunch and found Sal's! Fantastic service and amazing food!!! Will be coming here again read more

Sal's Pizzeria - SM Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Stopped in for pizza by the slice and it was honestly some of the best pizza I've ever had it was so flavorful and fresh. The service was great and the vibe inside was really chill, making it an easy place to relax and enjoy. I wish I lived closer because I'd definitely be here all the time. The pizza was that good! I also noticed they had pesto twists on the menu, and I'm already looking forward to trying them next time I visit. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

This place is so good! I was passing through Cotati in my way to a bakery and so glad I stopped. MUST check out their happy hour starting at 3, a slice & a beer for $12. Their tap options are limited but all 4 options are really good breweries. Pizza was fresh & so good, beer was also nice & crisp. Check them out! read more

See all

First time I ordered pizza from here. I got the spicy pepperoni, it was very good everyone loved it.

This is the best (as in most NYC like) pizza I've had in Sonoma County and maybe even the overall Bay Area. They really get it on the crust, sauce, and flavors combination feeling. I came in another time and loved it, now I'm doing it again. Plus the vibe and people are nice and they have some specials. I love Sal's! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Cheese slice, NYC style - delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

It breaks my heart to have to do this, but oh how the mighty have fallen. The last few times we've splurged and gotten take out have been mediocre at best, and this last time was just unacceptable. 1 large cheese and 1 large pepperoni, a simple order, but clearly not made to order. If I had to wager these pies were made at the earliest at the beginning of the day and just reheated. The pepperoni at least tasted like it had a bit of sauce, but the cheese was just dried up cheese and cardboard. I can't believe the difference in just a few months! We LOVED it here! Unfortunately, paying almost 60 bucks for two mediocre pizzas is just ridiculous - and I hate comparing to chains since I WANT to support local - but for half the money I could have gotten twice the amount of food at a higher quality at Dominos. I really really hope they can turn it around but for now I'll be going elsewhere. read more

Favorite new (for me) spot! Great pizza. Whole family loved it. This is going to become a habit. Anthony the 'beer guy' was super cool. And they had a handful of great beers on tap. Best pizza in Sonoma County as far as I am concerned. read more

Top 3 sandwiches I've had in my life - I did it with no bacon and the flavor balance was 10/10. Spicy, sweet, and quality chicken. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Matacus Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Super yummy, I'm not a pizza fan but this was good. It's a pretty nice spot. The staff is very welcoming.

As a fellow New Yorker I will say the pizza is pretty good for the area. At $6 for a plain slice and up to $9 for a specialty slice this place is way overpriced. To put in context a slice in New York is half the price and twice as good. read more

This place was sooooooo good. We placed an online order because we were not sure if there would be seating, but there were a few indoor tables and a bar we could sit at! The inside was really cute and you could tell they put a lot of effort into the decor. The man who served us was very friendly and recommended us some beers while we waited for our order. They serve local beers and have a pretty good selection. We got the small chipotle chicken pizza and a small vegan pizza (forgot to get a picture) and both were delicious. It was slightly pricey, but if you have the money it is well worth the price! Nothing better than a delicious pizza made with love :) read more

Sal's Pizzeria - SM Chipotle Chicken (pico on the side) - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Best pizza in this entire area! . The cheese is phenomenal. The sauce is great. The staff is helpful and the pizza is always done perfectly. I often order a pizza to be half done and uncut so I can finish it in my own oven. read more

This is just about as good as a real NY slice! Stopped in with my kiddo in the middle of the afternoon, a little nervous, knowing that time of day isn't ideal for a fresh slice, but enticed by some pictures I saw online and feeling super meh about the other two well known options in Cotati. Ended up being the best slice I've had in ages (never mind the nice guy who was working the counter and the awesome mural and overall vibe.) Those other two slice shops with local name recognition are now in my past. Sal's is now my go-to. (Wish I'd gotten the name of the man working today. He was just. Nice. Genuinely nice and working hard.) read more

I liked your pizza. The salads are pretty good too. I'd go back for more. Nice little corner spot amongst the rest of the stores. Friendly service in a timely manner. read more

Vegetarian review - their pesto bread is absolutely the best. We also tried the vegetarian pizza which was great. Repeated the vegetarian another day and felt it wasn't consistent but we'll try it again for sure. Absolutely recommend. The service for seating or take out is great. Ambiance is very cool, love the look. read more

See all

Just left Sal's Pizza in Cotati. We had a 12" meat pizza and a 12" veggie pizza and a green salad. Everything we ate was 5* delicious. Thin crust pizza, but not 'crackery'. The wet ingredients didn't sog out the bottom of the pie. Very good crust. The salad was a good sized salad, not dainty, with an excellent oil/vinegar dressing. Our waiter is a very nice guy named Roman; you can tell he enjoys his job; very pleasant fellow. The bill was about $50 for the two pizzas; we'll get 2 full meals for the two of us, so @ $12.50 for each meal; quite reasonable. Inside and outside seating, very clean. They have a happy hour special: one large slice and a 16oz beer for $12. Seems like a good deal to me. Enjoy! read more

Our absolute favorite pie in Sonoma County. Great crust and sauce are priorities for me and they kill it. Even their gluten free is great. Well done, fellas. read more

I really cannot get enough of Sal's. Good every time. I tired the cannoli's and they were delicious, wish I would've taken a picture but they were just gone too fast. And of course I always get great service. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - The Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

I wish I took pics of this amazing place and food! Do not even consider any other pizza place when you come to this town. You will be sadly disappointed if you don't get to experience this amazing food. The food was EXCEPTIONAL, absolutely blew us away. We got the specialty pizza (paperella -stratietella, pepperdew peppers and hot honey). My kids ordered the Hawaiian pizza and the Nutella calzone and it was delicious! You can taste the quality in the food!! The service was excellent but we are most definitely coming back for the food!! read more

I've been here a couple of times now and the food has been great every time. The marinara sauce is rocking, pizza as close to NY style I have found here and calzone is delicious. The staff is so friendly and engaging I really recommend trying this little hole in the wall. You won't regret it! read more

Came here for lunch and got the chicken parm sando. Very fresh ingredients, soft bread, lots of sauce. The staff were very friendly and the restaurant was very clean. I was watching them make pizza as waited for and ate my sandwich, and it made me want to come back for a pie or some slices. Will be back when I'm in the area. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Tiny place but oh so cute! And the food! Omg the pesto twists were amazing, I could have a million. I tried the Buffalo chicken and truffle hog and both were great. I picked up at closing and the staff were super friendly. I appreciated that even though it was the end of the night their customer service was great. read more

Bruh, this place is legit! Find Sal's Pizzeria on Yelp and I'm beyond happy I tried them out. Terrific and personable service. Very friendly staff. Pizza was excellent, and I truly mean this. I'll definitely be going back there before my wife and I head home to Southern California. Great job, guys! read more

One of our favorite pizza places around, fresh ingredients, pesto bread is so amazing.

The food was extremely enjoyable. The pizza had a nice little crunch when you first bit in, and it was extremely enjoyable! Fresh ingredients, (trust me, you can taste them) and the service was great too. Second I walked in, he started recommending pizzas or sides, and wasn't overly pushy, either. The ambiance was also very nice, with pictures and photos of what I was guessing to be Sal, and the inside had this nice rustic cabin-y look to it, feeling very homely. Would come back! read more

We do pizza Friday almost every week and Sal's is always in the rotation! Their ranch and pesto breadsticks are a dream combo, definitely get them. The owner is super friendly and you can tell every pizza is made with love and care. We generally get it to go but next time we are going to eat in because the vibe is so cozy and feels like a true pizzeria! read more

Meatball Parmesan sandwich was so tasty and delicious! It tasted like pizza in a sandwich! I could not decide on which beer to try so the server allowed me to sample before choosing. I made my selection and I can't remember the name, but it was. So refreshing and helped wash down the delicious sandwich. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Meatball Parmesan sandwich! - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Omg just dined on the best pizza I've had in years. Sal's Pizzeria remember that name. Best pizza ever. The crust absolute heaven. Just the right amount of olive oil. Love the pizzas... read more

I don't write many reviews, because I just don't have the time, but when I find a place like Sal's, I make time. I'm originally from New York and a bit of a pizza fanatic... The type that eats it for breakfast, lunch and dinner when I go home 3 or 4 times a year, and bring back 20lbs of it in my duffel bag every time, to stick in the freezer. Heard about this spot and was lucky enough to find myself in the neighborhood the other day and swung by to try it out. Was greeted by Anthony as soon as I walked in the door and knew right away by his knowledge and enthusiasm that he was the rockstar of this place. Food is going to speak for itself, but service unfortunately is something that is lacking nowadays. He told me all about the history and how everything was made, including their homemade Panna cotta. Saw on the menu that there was a chicken parm hero which I am always on the hunt for and decided to put the pizza on pause until my next trip. Started with a Caesar salad with nice crunchy croutons, and that signature tang of Caesar dressing that I love. Next was a pretty amazing chicken parm hero on a nice toasty piece of Italian bread and finished it off with the star of the show, some of the creamiest panna cotta that I am told is made in house and it shows. Life is too short to eat crappy food and I can't wait to get back to try the pizza...seriously read more

See all

We decided to try sals pizza for an easy dinner and they were fast and close by. They were very friendly and easy to find in cotati near the bars. We got a half and half on a large pizza and the combination was good! The sausages are a must! They were delicious. The other half was ok but a little sour tasting for me with the olives and artichoke heart. I did think the salad was a little small too but was pretty good the croutons were bomb! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - 1/2 combination 1/2 specialty - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Customer service is awesome. Food is awesome. Nice atmosphere. This will be a go to when I come to town to visit my daughter. read more

Just got a Pizza! It's back open! Pizza is delicious and they've expanded their hours so they're open now for lunch. Give them a try for the rest of Football season! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Large Combo Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California