I've been going to Old Chicago Pizza for years for their deep dish pizza and unfortunately, I've noticed quality has gone down consistently over the years. I can no longer justify paying $52 for a single deep dish pizza here. I ordered a double-crust pesto pizza with sausage for pick-up and when we dug into the pizza, everyone had the same reason -- "where's the sausage?" Old Chicago Pizza definitely took a move out of Chipotle's corporate playbook and has clearly mastered "skimpflation." The Bay Area has plenty of great deep dish pizza options that blow Old Chicago Pizza away in terms of quality, pricing, and taste. The pizza we received had far too much mozzarella and too few spoonfuls of pesto and sausages; the balance was terribly off. Definitely look elsewhere for deep-dish pizza, or skip it all together if Old Chicago is your only option. read more

Old Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

Very decadent pizza, with pounds of cheese. It's yummy but I can only eat one or two slices max. The downtown petaluma location is great but the seats are very old and uncomfortable. Just keep in mind that it takes an hour for the pizza to cook. Staff is always nice. read more

That Chicago pizza had a little pop-up takeout shop over here and this is down the street from my house!! Lol I only knew about their location in downtown, which is maybe 2 miles away from my house also but you have to deal with downtown traffic. Lol it was very easy for me to order takeout and pick it up in a timely manner and not deal with the hustle and bustle of downtown People! We got a medium half vegetarian, half pepperoni and pineapple pizza and it was delicious all the vegetables tasted fresh and had a delicious crunch and as always the thick crust was delightful! I actually went to Chicago and tried their pizza at two different locations and sad to say, I thought both places had very weak light sauce that I didn't find flavorful at all. Perhaps I'm just tainted by the fact I've only had old Chicago pizza here in Petaluma! Lol, love this place but I can only eat about one piece without stuffing myself and feeling like a whale on the couch afterwards! Lol I've had three pieces before in one sitting hahaha read more

Old Chicago Pizza - Old Chicago pizza for dinner tonight! Hee - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

Wtf is going on at this place. Ordered on a Tuesday night and picked up my pizza and asking them if it was the correct one. Yes it had my name and label and after getting a very bla salad the pizza was wrong and it looked terrible. So I called and was on hold after telling the cook and he said yes it was wrong and put me on hold for 5 plus minutes and then hung up so I called again and again no answer. We have left messages read more

Omg the pizza is amazing. Deep dish from Chicago served in deep dish pan. We had a great time downtown petaluma !!!Cool spot

Really inconsistent in quality. Sometime it's great and today the ranch and pizza were terrible, called and got nowhere with staff. Will be going to the main location from now on read more

When the main restaurant is closed, thank goodness for this location!! Called in order, was ready in the 30-minute window - allow time for the DEEP DISH! Very quick and easy parking for pick-up, great counter staff as well. Excellent experience. read more

See all

Ermergerd!!!! Aka DELICIOUS!!! This pizza was so good. The atmosphere was perfect. Felt like we stepped into a time/space warp and landed in Chicago. If you know about Chicago deep dish. Then you'll love this. read more

See all

Overall- Pizza pretty darn good. -called in an order to go and they did not ask what type of crust we wanted. -deep dish crust is not what we wanted, but was very tasty. - staff working Weds. lunch were mediocre and not very friendly. Had to ask for plates, forks. The women working couldn't care less about our experience. -very expensive, but client enjoyed pie. - would I return? Probably not. read more

March 2023 3.5 I'd say. We got a combination deep dish to go. Seemed mostly for takeout as far as the setup since there wasn't much in terms of tables and chairs. The only downside was the extra time beyond being able to pick it up. Pizza wasn't ready by the time we had gotten over there so we had an extra 15 minutes to wait on things. The combination pizza was good but not great I'd say. Everything was cooked well though through and through. I'd say between the locations the one closer to downtown is harder to pick up from but the flavor seems more on point. read more

See all

Bimbo non food server told us that " the gluten free pizzas came in all sizes however they are thin crust! That turned out to be a lie so we had to order 2 separate 10" pinned pizzas to make up for 1 large n pay extra $. People will tell u " whatever u want to hear just to avoid confrontation or dismissal of a sale! We ended up paying almost double!- what a rock! Food taste was also just ok! Service was just ok too! Anyway if u want larger gluten free pizzas" look elsewhere"! read more

Wow, I just went to pick up a pizza and was literally almost accosted by Audrey the woman at the register. As the cook was wrapping up my food I hadn't even got a word out of my mouth as I just turned to say "save the tape" Audrey lept out of her seat screamed at me "calm down Buddy. We have a procedure here" With some other expletives. I literally hadn't even said a word. I Let her know that I would be speaking to management which I did. And here I am leaving a review. You'll see from her appearance. She's obviously frazzled and appears mentally unwell. I've been going to old Chicago pizza since the 80s I also have a food and beverage background. I've never seen somebody over react or speak to a customer that way. Incredible. We live in weird times. read more

Save your $50+. Do not come here. Staff was pleasant for the pick up only service, but the pizza was horrible. Tasted like two day old pre-made crust that they threw toppings on and put in the oven to try to revive. My daughter went as far to say that Chuck-E-Cheese pizza was better than this. Disappointing for order-out pizza. On top of that, they tried to offer up a "better salad" price matched to my basic dinner salad. Seemed to be an old salad from earlier that didn't get sold or picked up. When turned down, the employee then went and said she would go make our salad - mind you, order was placed 40 minutes prior to arrival so they just didn't plan on making the salad in hopes that we would take the old salad. This whole experience really just shows that they really put the OLD in Old Chicago Pizza. You're better off getting Digiorno. read more

The pizza was so good. Just had a leftover piece straight from the refrigerator and it was awesome. My stomach is doing somersaults

We love Old Chicago Pizza...it is an institution in this town. While there is a location on the east side of town (where we live), we always go to the west side. In addition to their pizza, we always get their wedge salad...such a perfect starter read more

Wow the pizza here is amazing! Got a sausage and pepperoni pizza and it was huge. Each slice is enough for one meal ( and I'm a big eater). It was cheesy and marinade was delicious. Not overly saucy, just perfect. I love deep dish pizzas and they do them right here! Staff was so nice and attentive. Building has a very interesting history. Definitely worth a try if you're craving some authentic Chicago style pizza at a great price and amazing quality! read more

Just do it!!! Splurge and order your Deep Dish craving! Great food !! Friendly service & staff!! Small town pizzeria tables - window bar in the North McDowell Old Chicago delivery restaurant. Never a letdown meal from here. Give it a try or just go back again for great pizza!! read more

See all

I have been going to the downtown location for 20+ years and decided to try this location for their delivery service. I won't ever make that mistake again! Not going to get into the details but I ended up having to pay for the same pizza twice in an attempt to get my order correct and they still couldn't get it right. The people working here are incompetent and the quality is subpar compared to the downtown location. read more

Hands down the best service and best Chicago deep dish style pizza! The service is always on point and the bakers make the pizzas consistent every single time we order!! I called in tonight to let them all Know how much we appreciate them! And how fantastic the pizza always is! So Thank you!!! read more

Generally love this place, but for the 2nd time now I have placed an order over the phone. Been told the wait time, okay see ya then, and then show up and there is no record of the order at all. Both times the same lady. Very frustrating. She has also denied taking an order an hour before closing a few times, which, fair I guess it takes a while to make one. read more

I ordered a small deep dish combination which took 45 minutes to serve. I wasn't very impressed with it. Presentation subpar. The whole thing was covered in chopped mushrooms, not a lot of meat. Cut in 4slices, one tomato on each slice. If you like cheese it had plenty of it. There's hardly any sauce and it was tasteless. The bottom was just thick, doughy, and on the soggy side. Nothing stood out about my experience there. Sorry to say. read more

This may be a fluke, but everything these days is getting worst. Prices up, quality down. I swear some places are watering things down. This pizza did not have the usual flavor, and being overly cooked with not enough cheese as it usually has didn't help. I may try them one more time, but it looks like they care more about saving money than making a good pizza. If you overcook the dang pizza, why do you tape it shut and still sell it. What is wrong with you people. read more

Love this pizza, but Jessica took our order wrong over the phone and I didn't notice until I got home because of how bad the service for pickup had been. I walked in and Jessica is talking to another employee, but they are talking to each other without making any eye contact with me or acknowledging my presence until I say "Im here for pickup." She gets my order after I say my name while still talking to her friend and says the amount owed and nothing else. I only see 1 pizza, the one she handed me, and not my full order, which included a mini and a salad, so I didn't instinctively pay right away. She seems in a hurry to get back to talking to her friend and repeats the amount owed in an annoyed tone and nothing more. I pause with and uhhh and she says "your salad is in the fridge..." At that point I'm at the tip screen and I already had put 20%, which I usually do, but I toggle back and put 0 tip. Her friend stands up from his chair and puts my salad and rest of my order in a bag after she told me I can get it from the fridge and I walk out with both of them laughing. Super weird service. Always had great service before. read more

Walking this strip mall, I found this place knowing the history of old Chicago and being a frequent customer to their business i was kinda shocked I didn't know they had a location here. I took a couple photos of the hours of operation to post on here and I opened the front door to ask a question if they did delivery as well. I noticed there were 4 ppl in the business. 3 employees and 1 customer. Immediately I got two of the 3 employees staring at me from behind the counter. One taller Caucasian guy with a beer belly, looks like he was making something in the back and a shorter Hispanic guy staring at me not doing anything but standing by the front counter. Conscious to not wanting to interrupt the 3rd employee, an older lady on the phone likely taking an order. I asked my question only to have both men completely ignore me and the Caucasian guy shoot me a dirty look before looking away. The poor lady on the phone at the counter had to stop what she was doing and respond and even she wasn't very kind in her response, obviously cuz now she had to stop what she was doing on the phone to answer me. I apologized and said I'm sorry mam I didn't expect you to answer since the two gentlemen were obvious staring right at me when I asked the question. These people are rude and I wouldn't trust them to make my food with any level of kindness or consideration. I will not be going back. Very poor experience. read more

The cheesiest pizza ever! A yummy treat! Best deep dish pizza north of San Francisco. Pizza has loads of meat and cheese. The price is a little high, but it is well worth it, and you get a lot of pizza for the money. Less crust and more filling is the best way to describe this pizza. read more

They have good pizza. I do not recommend u do pepperoni and black olives. This combo might be salty. But otherwise it's good. read more

Best pizza EVER. Highly recommend this restaurant. Best "deep dish" pizza's. Atmosphere is historic

The pizza was ready at the time quoted to me. The price was fair and the flavor was amazing. Definitely will be back!

dont come to this place! service is horrible and workers are lazy! it took them 1 hour to cook one lg pepperoni and sm cheese pizza. go somewhere else! i would have given zero star if its an option! read more

It was okay , would go if I was in the area. Got the deep dish Had better deep dishes read more

Was greeted and treated courteously by the staff there. Deep dish pizza was super tasty!

Best place for to-go pizza orders. Love their sausage, mushrooms, and onion pizza. The pizza is big, very filling, and delicious. I would even say that I like Old Chicago pizza from this location more than from the one downtown. It's always a hit and never a miss. Also much easier to park :) read more

Excellent customer service! OCP is doing it right! After a long week I phoned in my order on Friday evening only to be disappointed the pizza was not what I ordered. The cashier saw the disappointment on my face and offered to make another. I was tired and didn't want to wait. She provided me with a 1/2 off coupon for my next visit. Just used the coupon and was reflecting on the transaction. Thank you Pizza was great as always. read more

Pretty ok pizza not gonna lie was heavily disappointed afterwards. Nothing really stood out with the personal pizza just tasted pretty generic and meh read more

Upon ordering we were told we would get a text for when our order would be ready. We never did. They asked for my phone number and never received anything. I came to pick up my order since I thought enough time had passed. I was told by whom I assume is the owner if I had paid for the order as if they don't keep track. I was given the two pizzas, completely forget the salad I ordered and had to remind them. They almost forgot the chicken I added to it as well. When I got back in my car, I realized a dipping sauce was not in the bag. Had to go back and ask for it. I don't like to leave bad reviews for places, but please be more aware of the items in an order. You should get exactly what you pay for since the food isn't cheap. read more

Really, really good pizza. Driving thru Petaluma in our way to Dillon Beach and decided to order a couple pies to pick up along the way. Thin crust half pepperoni/half cheese was delicious and a deep dish sausage, mushroom, green pepper and onion was incredible - loaded with tons of fresh toppings, super deep and delicious crust. Highly recommended. read more

Service was good, just a bit slow (even for Chicago style) and I even called in early for pickup. Toppings are ok, nothing amazing. However the worst part is that the dough on our "thin crust" was very under cooked. We also got the deep dish and it was fine. Just disappointed mainly. I understand the pizza is huge, but still it was very expensive read more

I don't care much for deep dish pizza so I get the thin crust pizza with red onion, olives, garlic, pepperoni, sausage, and tomatoes which is good. Crust was a little hard and chewy last time but still thick. Garlic bread was good. Real bread not like some pizza places do. They did their own delivery not using Doordash or Deliver Club. read more

Another great place for Pizza ! deep dish, there is a Old Chicago Pizza restaurant on the west side of Petaluma that is sit down, but this place is take out only on the east side of Petaluma, and it is the same as the restaurant as far as the delicious pizza. Delivery is available too. read more

A FB foodie page in another county raved about this place. So I put it on a list for the next time we were in Petaluma. Very greasy. Not very flavorful ingredients and a dough that wasn't interesting. It was like those white bread doughs you can buy in the freezer section of the grocery store. A big wad of doughiness covered in greasiness. Sigh. Gonna have to take greater care in taking recommendations from those so-called foodies. read more