My first time here...I fell in love with the pizza, so I had to come back for more! Had a special request that normally can't be done, but my guy Wilson, the manager, hooked it up! You guys can't go wrong here, food is outstanding and the service is top tier. You can tell when someone genuinely cares about what they do and the service they provide. It was a rough day, but this amazing pizza and service made it all better! Thank you Wilson and NY Pie! read more

A decent slice. Tasty and big. Probably 3.5-4 stars. Crust was a little more chewy and not as crispy as I'd prefer. We stopped by after eating next door at the Ethiopian restaurant to finish the night off. So this was a random pop in experience read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

My family and I have been long-time patrons of NY Pie, but our experience this past Friday night was unacceptable. We took an Uber from Sonoma specifically for your pizza, arriving at 11:30 PM a full 30 minutes before the midnight closing time. Despite being well within operating hours, we were turned away. The staff explicitly stated they would not take our order because the kitchen was already cleaned and they did not want to re-clean it. It was clear the team prioritized an early departure over serving customers. We were forced to order a return Uber and leave empty-handed. Ownership should be aware that revenue is being turned away by a staff that lacks basic hospitality and a commitment to posted hours. This experience left a very bad taste in my family's mouth. read more

This was my first visit since they reopened, and happy to say that the pizza is delicious. Great environment with games on while you eat. Our waitress was phenomenal, wish I could have remembered her name. The place was busy, but you couldn't tell as she made sure to make sure the table I was sitting at was doing good read more

When it takes 14 MONTHS to get a response from a business do they really expect that you'd ever want to return? Not likely. And nice try blaming it on the kitchen. The waiter/manager knew exactly what he was charging and never bothered to mention it. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

We decided to have lunch here ( we always get to-go, I brought my dog and sat outside. The staff was very busy, lots of to go orders and people eating lunch, they still were able to open the umbrella for us, get our dog some water and bring our drinks, even being so busy. I ordered at the counter because we did leave limited time but who cares. The food came out perfect! We had a large Caesar salad, enough for three adults, and then two small pizzas, a Hawaiian with jalapeño and a Longfellow. When I tell you we devoured it, we did. This iso ur new pizza spot for sure! The patio was clean and so welcoming I'm glad we brought our dog. read more

Driving through town and stopped here for a late lunch. Pizza slices are large portion and perfect thin NY crust. We sat on the patio with a nice shade and the service was very accommodating to the 2 dogs and 2 kids with us. Great place to stop for a slice! They have salads and wings too! read more

See all

First time, won't be the last. Kerren (forgive the spelling) was incredible! Totally professional, friendly, interactive, efficient. We ordered two slices, two beers and two salads. Approx. $45. So many local breweries represented - love that! Hubby chose hazy IPA and I ordered a Pilsner. It was nice to have a 10 ounce option. I ordered the arugula, salad and hubster got the Caesar Both were fresh, plentiful and dressings flavorful. The housemade croutons tasted brioche-esque. Buttery and airy. Pizza was also on point. I couldn't really taste the sausage but it didn't detract from the slice as a whole. Crust had a nice chew, sauce complimented, and it had good amount of cheese. I don't really have a comparison for what it used to be like, but we can definitely see this place being added to our list of favorites for when the pizza craving hits. read more

See all

My first time there and it was great. The cashier greeted me as I came in and the ambiance was nice. I ordered a personal size pizza and they made it fresh even if it was 10:30 at night! He recommended the hot honey pepperoni cheese pizza and I tried it and wow pretty good place definitely recommend read more

For the second year in a row our group, the St Rose Choir. Celebrated our fourth year anniversary together. Once again, the service that we were given was totally AWESOME. Our waiter, Wilson, once again, made our night special. The food was delicious and we all had a great time at NY Pie. The service once again was outstanding. I recommend NY pie to anyone who loves pizza and is a sports fanatic. They have TVs with different baseball, basketball and the other sports on while you enjoy a delicious pizza. The place is full of love and good atmosphere. Once again, with the greatest service that God has created. Thanks again, Sincerely, Randy Larsen with the St Rose choir. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Been a regular here off and on for a number of years, and I've loved it from day one. Staff are always very welcoming and nice., pizza is delicious and it always consistent. Not sure why people are saying otherwise? Literally one of the best spots on Santa Rosa, and the fact that you can walk in and get fresh made slices all day makes it even better read more

I love the pizza im went with my friends every body eat salad, pizza im recommend exelent services.

Caesar salad was the large and it fed 3 adults. Pizza was the large and we took 2 slices home. Add some oregano and it is heavenly The wings were flavored so well. They came out heat hot so be prepared. They were mild but they had a slight kick to them. Service as awesome. Our server was so on top of things and she had such a great personality. I wish I knew her name but she had ink up her arm which was cool. We will back. read more

See all

Horrible service. No acknowledgement. No, "we'll be with your shortly, nothing". Yes, they were busy-I guess that's the exception it was to ignore other customers. I had to ask an employee for help or for someone to take our order at the counter. When we finally got our pre ordered sliced pizzas they were stacked on top of each other so the toppings and cheese was all messed up. Disappointing because I know they can do much better. read more

See all

My friend went there on Friday and ordered a pizza. About 20 minutes later, the server informed them that the order hadn't even been started yet because the restaurant was extremely busy. My friend said she was happy to wait. About five minutes later, the owner personally came over, apologized for the delay, and gave her a $25 gift card. She really enjoyed the pizza, and she thought the owner's gesture was incredibly thoughtful. My friend doesn't use Yelp, so she asked me to write this review on her behalf. She said she will definitely come back for more delicious pizza! read more

This restaurant has been our go-to pizza place for years! I would say they serve some of the BEST pizza in Santa Rosa. Highly recommend.

First time trying NY pie, and certainly will not be the last. I went with a piece of pepperoni and had a small Caesar salad. Before. I describe the great food, I noticed they had four of my favorite breweries, Cooperage, Parliament,Old Caz and Henhouse... I went with a new west coast Caz with citra, was delish! The piece of pizza I got was very big and was super good, with ample sauce that may have made it my new favorite. The Caesar was fresh and it was the small serving, but was a generous small, I only wish I had asked for some anchovies, was perfect. They have great seating inside and out, a perfect vibe! Our server was absolutely amazing and really completed the evening!! She was amazing !!! THANK YOU-------KARREN!!! Yes, that's with two r's! We will be back!!! read more

I'm still thinking about this pizza! It was so good, the only downside is that it's a bit pricey per slice. But the place itself is really nice for hangouts as they open till 11-12 depending on the weekday/weekend. The taste of pizza is really good and it's even better washing it down with good beer / cider read more

This right here was one of the best tasting pizzas I've had in a long time! They serve by the slice with over 6 pizzas to choose from or you can order the whole pie. I was driving by and it was my last day in town, i wasn't even hungry but i had to try it lol, made a U turn and bam!!! Enjoyed my slice of pepperoni, ricotta and hot honey, The vibe is chill, they have a few big TV's to watch the game (Sports) it was nice and cold inside, very comfortable place to enjoy a few moments and people watch. Definitely coming back next time I'm in town. read more

NY Pie - A slice of pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Pizza is delicious and customer service is out of this world. Don't sleep on this place.

When I tell you you should RUN NOT WALK to NY PIE I'm not exaggerating. There are new owners. The staff are super friendly. The service is fast. The food is obviously made with love and fresh ingredients. The beer selection is HUGE. The environment is a total vibe. Freddie and friends..nice to meet you and keep it up!! You're our new favorite date night. Cheers !! read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

We love NY Pie, especially for the the late night happy hour. Our recommendation is to go Thursdays or Sundays because Jenna is absolutely AMAZING! She offered the best customer service and recommendations. P.S. Get the garlic knots, it's worth it. read more

Thought about trying the spot for a long time and finally did it. Parking is not impossible and there is plenty of parking half a block away. It was welcoming and busy. We timed it perfectly as my husband walked in, and his pizza was being placed into the box. Ordered two large pizzas for takeout. The Flatbush and the Fulton Street. The Flatbush was substantial, and meaty for a thin crust pizza. He said that it was flavorful without being sharp. It was filling and not very greasy. The Fulton Street was different because it didn't have red sauce, only olive oil in the base. I added chicken to it, but I'm not really sure I needed it. The flavors were just kind of fantastic along with a very good crust and a final element of lemon. It felt like a perfect spring pizza! The only thing I would add would be a sweet element like spring peas or something. All I know is I didn't need to add the chicken as the flavors were perfectly complex. The question of whether it was worth the price. With the two ads, it brought the price up pretty substantially for one element that should not have cost that much. The pizza was good though, and I will get three meals out of it so I guess value for money! read more

See all

Popped in here for dinner since an event we are going to is close by, and it was a great decision! We got a garden salad with the chunkiest blue cheese dressing I've ever had. The. We got a pizza with half sausage and half pepperoni and black olives. So delicious! I highly recommend this pizza place! Oh and their beer selection is top notch as well! The staff was very attentive and friendly. read more

NY Pie - Half sausage half pepperoni and black olives. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Sooooo Good! Stopped here by recommendation from one of the wineries we stopped at with some east coast friends from out of town. It's not exactly NY pizza but it's pretty darn close! Closer than any other pizza place claiming they are NY pizza. Hands down the best I've had since moving out to California. The sauce is spot on! Talking with the owner Doug, they have been there 8 months. He is originally from NY and moved out west like so many of us many years before but I'm glad I got to chat with him. I got one white slice that I ate while sitting down and had one plain to go. I took a bite and it was delicious but next test was to taste it the next day which is why I chose a plain slice. It was still delicious and tasted like what I remembered! I'm so happy. I don't live that close but I plan to be back on my days off next month! Thank you NY Pie! They also serve salads, wings and knots. They serve beer (big selection) too. read more

NY Pie - Bar area and several tables available for sitting. There was an outdoor area too. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

See all

This spot has been revitalized since the change in ownership. Would recommend 10/10 times to anybody looking for a good slice. Great service as well read more

New ownership, great pizza. Don't judge this place by old reviews -- the quality is night and day. Gave New York Pie another chance and it paid off. One of the best in Santa Rosa. read more

My husband has been wanting to try this pizza for awhile now. It's a nice pizza place, all table/chair combos no booths and also has outdoor seating. Lots of beers on tap. We got the all meat large pizza. They put a good amount of toppings on but the crust is tough and chewy. I like to bite off pieces of my slice, I hate having to grip and tear it free. The sauce is very mild and definitely tasted like canned sauce. It is a good pizza but $47 (with $7 tip) for one pizza , only water to drink, it's should be better. Tastes very mediocre but the service was good. They have great ranch though. You can also get some good people watching done here with all the huge windows. read more

NY Pie - Homemade ranch and parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

See all

After a long day, I ordered a pizza and didn't choose delivery on the website! When I called to check, after a while had gone by, I spoke with the nicest manager, who offered to void the pizza I had ordered for pickup by accident. He did not need to do that. It was my mistake. It's hard to find that level of customer service, especially at 11pm:) Great pizza, great service, and open late. Thank, NY Pie! read more

First time to NY Pie and it was amazing! Thin pizza with a perfectly crispy undercarriage. Staff were super friendly and helpful. Will be back! read more

Place was great! I had literally never been here, not since or before the new ownership. We came here hoping for a slice & beer to watch a game and we ended up taking a leap of faith and ordered a full blown large pizza. This was meant to be, because the Longfellow Ave pizza was sooo good! Service was pretty quick considering rhat it was a busy football Sunday. I do wish theyd play the games a little louder on the speakers, but thats just my personal opinion. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

I decided to try this place and made a pit stop for a hot and tasty slice of pineapple, pepperoni and jalapeño pizza, with a 10oz of beer from West Coast brewery. They have a friendly and attentive staff, clean and enjoyable dining space, with a bar and stools and a big TV screen for sports, high end decor but casual atmosphere. Super affordable and generous slice portion, loved the beer too. It's been a while and I enjoyed every sip even though I'm kind of a lightweight almost non drinker now. The pizza was right on the mark for me. I can be a bit picky about pizza but this place lives up to its name NY Pie. Almost like being back in New York, I can smell the hot nuts now, jk. But yea this place is located super centrally in Santa Rosa and it's a great place to pit stop for a slice or a whole pizza pie, and they have some a great variety of brews on tap too. Thanks NY Pie for great food and brews! read more

NY Pie - Pina, pepperoni, jalepeno slice and beer - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

See all

I was happy to see the location for NY Pie reopen with a revamped design, upgrades to pizza, and new owners. We've been to this spot twice now, and ordered out once, and the pizza was delicious both times. I liked it slightly more in person but I think that's because it came out piping hot and nicely presented. We also had the buffalo wings and I've tried two salads which tasted made with fresh ingredients. The dressing is something they make in house, and it is so good. A nice change from bottled packaged stuff. The owners are kind, and when they're around the place runs like a tight ship. Great vibe. Good place to catch sports and be social. I'm so glad to see this neighborhood spot open once again after the prior decline, and I will be back again for more. read more

See all

I loveeee this place!!! They have a fabulous beer selection, and their pizza is soooo good. My kids always ask to come here on Fridays. This place can get busy(duh), but the service is still top notch! Lots of happy smiling faces , the manager even came by to make sure everything was ok! This is definitely our favorite local pizza spot, it should be yours too! read more

Went there yesterday at 3 with another couple as they loved the old NY Pie when it was on their game as did we. Sadly before it closed it had slipped badly. The new owners have brought it back to better than ever with excellent pizza as they used to but even better service and a better selection of local beers. Four thumbs up from us all. Friendly service, the restaurant seems cleaner and better organized and certainly better staffed. read more

They definitely cleaned the place up! Loving the new pizza selections (I loved The Fulton Street with the goat cheese- we added the Mike's Hot Honey to it too. There's also a huge beer and cider selection! read more

NY Pie - Beers and ciders - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Never been here so decided to get some slices. Little did I know that the slices were bigger than my head which makes sense given the price. Nothing spectacular about the pizza, wasn't too greasy which was good, maybe could have used a bit more sauce but otherwise pretty good. Didn't get to go in but based on what it looked like from outside, seemed like a chill place to hang. I'd probably give it another go. Ear well or die trying -ant read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Love this place!! Great pizza (can get it by the slice too) and super nice workers. I'll be back!

When I moved to Downtown Santa Rosa a little over 2-years ago, NY Pie was the first pizza place that I tried in the neighborhood. I thought it was solid, but not spectacular and I continued to explore other options and ended up never going back. I saw that they reopened under new ownership recently, so I decided to give them another try last night, and I was very impressed. I ordered an 18" pie with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and olive and it was fantastic! In addition, all of the staff that I interacted with on the phone when ordering and in the restaurant when picking up, were extremely friendly. They also did a really nice job updating their space. It's really nice and I would definitely eat-in there. I highly recommend giving them a try if you're in the area! read more

NY Pie - 18" pie with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and olive. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Just tried NY Pie again after 3 years. Did not like it back then and still feel the Pizza is overpriced and not worth the $$$. Pizza was very dry and not much flavor . read more