Visiting the area for a half marathon tomorrow, and figured pizza would be the best for carb loading. Stumbled upon this place, via yelp. At first, I wanted to go somewhere that had "vibe", rather than just another pizza spot. After reading the bio on the website, and checking out some photos, figured, let's give it a whirl. ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. If you're in the area, you must go. I'm a pizza and ranch kind of guy, this pizza didn't need ranch. The crust was cooked perfectly, without the burnt taste you would get from this style pizza, along with super fresh ingredients. 10/10 read more

Pizzaleah - Old Grey Beard (Award-winner) on top, Sicilian on bottom. - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Damn. The hype is real. We stopped here to get a pie to go (Nico) and agreed to try one slice since it would be fresh out the oven. That didn't happen. The whole pie was eaten there. Thanks also to Katie for telling us about the ranch dip. Holy hell I could have just taken a shot of that. read more

Pizzaleah - Red sauce is preferred for us but JFC the Nico pie kept getting tastier as we ate more of it. - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Pizzaleah has unique flavors and has a crispy chewy crust! The old grey beard: has a wonderful mix of salty, spicy and sweet and orange zest to top it off. Mushroom special: the caramelized onion were the highlight here. I personally would have liked more mushrooms. But everything else was balanced well. The service was quick since we came when they just opened. Around 15mins to to our pizza. read more

Pizzaleah - Mushroom special - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

I just moved to Windsor about 4 months ago and seen this place so many times and never had a chance to come in. I thought it would just be like any other pizza places that taste the same. A couple of my friends told me that I needed to try this place because it's so good. So I decided to order a takeout and omg the portion is huge and it's so good!! We ordered a 16 inch half and half with Roo's and Lola. I like Lola a lot more than Roo's. I didn't know potatoes on pizza would be so good! Roo's is so good too and I am a big fan of mushroom and they gave a lot of mushrooms! This place actually gives you a lot of toppings! Unlike those pizza chains that barely give you anything. The price is high but I totally understand why. I rather spend more money at this place than other pizza chains anyways! The service was great and they finished the pizza super fast. We want to try to eat at the restaurant next time. I am super excited to try other pizzas they have here. Highly recommend this place! read more

Pizzaleah - 16 in of Roo's and Lola - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Came here with a couple of my dogs and my mom, while my mom got us a table outside with the dogs, I went in to order, it's a very clean and open space inside, it has an open layout so you can see into the kitchen as well. The employees who helped me were super friendly and were understanding about my gluten restrictions since I have celiacs, My mom and I got the gluten free mush-a-roni, I will say the gluten free version was a little expensive for the size it was but hey what can you do when you're gluten free, aside from the personal pizza size, the consistency of the dough was amazing, you couldn't even tell it's gf, and the toppings I'm sure would be good on any type of dough gluten free or not, the flavors all combined were definitely a hit. I'm glad that I got to try this place and had a good experience! read more

Tried this place for the 2nd time on our way back home from a trip and passing thru the town. Pizza was delicious and ordered the same pizzas as the first time I tried this place. As far as service this time around felt a bit unwelcomed but it's ok the pizza was great. I had such a great experience the first time around I brought the whole family but did not have the same experience as the first. Pizza was delicious. read more

Pizzaleah - Ricotta Pepperoni and hot honey pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

Tried this place out yesterday and oh my goodness, I think I've found my new favorite pizza joint. Everything from the customer service over the phone to the interaction in the restaurant and can't forget about the FOOD, was stellar! They were busy, but it never got too loud to where we couldn't hear each other talking. I ordered a half Chingona & half Boogie, my husband got the GF/DF Old Grey Beard, kids got cheese and everyone was exceptionally happy. I cannot wait for our next visit and try them all! read more

Pizzaleah - 1/2 Chingona and 1/2 Boogie - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

The food here is fresh and delicious. I really like the salad. Folks that work here are always nice. It's good to go or eating in.

Their margarita pizza is the GOAT!!! I have never had such amazing pizza and I grew up in an Italian family that owned a pizzeria and I've been all over Italy. Also, their Ghost Town IPA is excellent. Will be back. read more

Without a doubt the best crust in North California! Really appreciated the freshness of the vodka sauce! Service was on point with a very friendly staff that made us feel like family! So glad we took an opportunity to stop in and try a great pizza!! read more

Surprise surprise years later it's still absolutely jaw dropping delicious. Flawless excellence! You can depend on perfection. We are incredibly lucky to have this in our neck of the woods. I would drive very very far for it if we didn't. World level award winning pizza for a reason. read more

Pizzaleah - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

I finally made it to Pizzaleah for their Detroit pizza. First of all, I had no clue what my choices were. The girl at the counter was super friendly and helpful. I ordered the Roni, like Pepperoni. It was so good, I can hardly wait to go back and try other pizza versions. Really nice, clean place with good lighting. Parking was no priblem. read more

We'd heard about this small pizza place in Windsor from a friend, and when researching it, saw that owner/chef Leah had won multiple pizza awards and was on the U.S. Pizza Team (who knew?). We had to try it while visiting the area. We went with a group of 5 including my elderly mother at 6:30pm on a Tuesday and sat outside as it was only about 70 degrees and partially shaded. You order inside and they bring it out, and there was chef Leah cooking in the back (a good sign). They forewarned us that the wait for pizza was 45 minutes, but starters would come out faster. So we ordered two Ceasar salads, Frank's meatballs (comes with four so two of us split), the garlic knots and a bottle of Kokkomo Chardonnay. First up were the meatballs, which were tender and served with a red sauce, and very delicious. Salad was very good and came out quickly, a nice tangy dressing, shaved Parmesan, hint of anchovy and homemade crutons. They forgot the knots until the end but they were warm and doughy and served with a ranch dressing and marinara. First pizza was the Boomin' Granny pan pie with red sauce, mozzarella, sausage, mushroom & pecorino. This was almost a focaccia style but with a delicious crispy crust, croissant like. Next up delivered by Leah herself was the award winning Old Grey Beard thin crust, with red sauce, mozzarella, fontina, Italian sausage, Calabrian peppers, hot honey & orange zest. They warned us it was spicy but was a bit too hot for some in our party. Great with the ranch dressing. The inside area had a fun vibe playing 80's music, friendly staff, lots of seating, TV playing the Giants. Outside was a parking lot view of Oliver's and Starbuck's but we love patio seating coming from SF. I enjoyed this pizza over Tony's in SF, the crust was lighter and crunchier. I recommend eating there for a unique pizza experience. read more

See all

It's funny how my reviews tend to disappear from only this restaurant. It doesn't seem to happen at any other restaurant on yelp. I have to agree with what a few other people have already said. The pizza is overpriced and overrated. I also agree with what was said about the staff, especially one of the females tends to be rude for no apparent reason, especially to men apparently. There are better options in the area. Kin has excellent pizza and they're just on the other side of the town green, five minute walk. Try the Mac daddy. read more

Yesterday we ate at Pizzaleah. I ordered the vegetarian Roo. It was delicious. I love their pizza crust. Had a Ceasar salad the Parmesan shavings are so Good! We were there before the rush and enjoyed the music, even sang along with a couple tunes. My husband tried a new beer on tap and really liked it with his pepperoni pizza. I think the beer was called Parliament. I tried the Blood Orange San Pellegrino sparkling water, it's really tasty. The service was excellent and the woman was very personable, makes you want to go back even more. The friendly staff seem happy and enjoying their jobs, always a good sign of being well trained and under good management. Windsor is lucky to have such a good pizza in town. read more

Pizzaleah - Lola Special - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

The worst service ever. I always prefer picking up a pizza rather than ordering a delivery in a cold winter weather to get it fresh and hot. Came to the restaurant to order for pickup. The restaurant was almost empty and i was waiting 35 min to get my pizza and salad. Apparently it was ready after 15 min but NO one bothered to tell me. Not only that, instead of apologizing, one of the guys there acted rudely like he called my name a few times which was not the case (it was empty and quiet, I set near the cashier). Lastly when I got back to the hotel I realized that there are no napkins nor utensils, and since the pizza was "waiting" at the restaurant for quite some time, when I wanted to eat it, it was almost cold. Bottom line, the pizza was still good half cold, but the service is low grade at best read more

This is definitely a place to visit as Pizzaiolo myself I highly recommend this place. the crust was amazing and the toppings were plentiful. The service was awesome and we did come out on a busy night. We had three different pizzas and they were all amazing. Keep up the good work guys. read more

Best pizza ever! Quick service and fresh tasty pizza. Tried it a few times and always impressed. read more

Honey on pizza ? I was skeptical at first, but the juxtaposition of savory and sweet flavors won me right on over. The unappetizingly named Old Grey Beard pizza was really tasty with perfectly baked crust and great texture. The Scurto pizza was tasty but a bit overloaded, leading to a sogginess in the middle - to the detriment of the structural integrity of each droopy slice. Service was friendly and fun and the selection of local beers and wine made for a great pizza pairing experience. I'll be back to try other pies! read more

If you're a pizza lover looking to elevate your taste buds, you absolutely have to try this place! The unique flavors and toppings they offer are nothing short of extraordinary. From The Standard to Po-Tay-To the pizzas are so tasty. I will always get any pizza with mushrooms on it--it's a game changer! The crust is perfectly crispy, providing the ideal base for these innovative combinations. If you're in the mood for something truly special, this pizzeria is a must-visit. So good! Service: A+ Ambience: few tables and chairs. Outdoor seating during the warmer months I would try. I usually take it to go and enjoy at home. read more

The food is great! Prompt. Good service. I've never eaten in but it looks comfy and clean as I buzz in and pick up my take out. Need to put them in my rotation instead of once in a while. read more

Pizza was excellent and some of the best we have ever had. Our toddler has an egg allergy and they were very transparent about cross contamination but also went out of their way to avoid what they could. They were very considerate. We definitely will be going back! read more

I have it three stars because my friend enjoyed her pizza. She ordered a special (I apologize I don't remember the name of the special) I didn't care much for mine. I ordered the chingona. Pizza was average, the attitude of one of the older female employees could have been way better and potentially changed my experience but she was just rude for no reason. The guy was much nicer but eh there's too many places with amazing food AND service to go back to a place that had mediocre food and half decent service. It's also pretty pricy for what you get and unfortunately this place really missed the mark for me. read more

I had Pizzaleah on my to try list for a while, and it did not disappoint. I love pizza and I'd rank this as one of the best I've had. If I lived in Healdsburg this would absolutely become my go to pizza place. The chewiness of the dough was exactly to my liking. Sometimes a pizza gets left in the oven a little too long and burns a bit but the char level in this was perfect. And one of the things J found most impressive of all was how even the tip of a slice of pizza was sturdy enough for me to pick up the slice immediately with my hands without having to knife and fork the beginning bites from a too soggy center. It was everything I look for in a pizza. You can do half and half if you order a large pizza so we pivoted from planning to order a medium to the large in order to try two types. It was really difficult to decide since everything sounded so good. Went with Roo's (olive oil, fontina, mozzarella, mushroom medley, fresh thyme, roasted fennel, shaved Parmesan & fresh Italian parsley) and Old Grey Beard (red sauce, mozzarella, fontina, Italian sausage, Calabrian peppers, hot honey & orange zest). Both were delicious. OGB was described as spicy but it was spicier than we anticipated so I'm a bit glad we only got half a pizza of that but even though my nose started running, I didn't want to stop eating the pizza haha. I would definitely return to try some of the other pizzas if I'm in the Healdsburg area. I'm also curious about the pan pies but those serve 4 and that was too large a size for us that day. read more

Pizzaleah - Half Roo's, half Old Grey Beard - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Pizzaleah serves one heck of a pie! My mom has been wanting to try their pizza ever since my husband told her about them. He ordered a half of the Lola and half the Nico pie to go for dinner last night. I absolutely love their crust. It's hard to make a great crust and Pizzaleah makes an incredible one. I liked both the Lola and Nico pie. I couldn't get enough! I would definitely get those two again, but I also want to get their other pizzas as well. read more

Five star. As a pizza geek, this place was absolutely killer. Great crust, undercarriage, and perfect ratio of flavors. Best pizza in Napa / Sonoma area, perhaps even Bay Area. The folks behind the counter were gracious, patient, and stellar service. Will visit again for sure. read more

See all

Pizzaleah has been on my list to try for a while. I've seen it recommended in the SF Chronicle multiple times. Finally, I'm in the area so it was on the top of my list. I didn't see the pan pies available to pre-order online so I called ahead. Apparently (and later saw in another review), you need to call because they count down how many they have left for the day as they are ordered. They only make so many. I called around 4PM and was able to pre-order one to pick up later that day. Arrived on a Saturday evening around 7PM and it was about 1/2 capacity between outside and inside. Tables are first come first serve. Our group also I ordered 2 16" round pies, altogether fed 5 people. * Old Grey Beard, round pie: sausage isn't my top choice but enjoyed the spiciness particularly from the Calabrian chilies, fontina which I don't usually see on pizza, and pleasant bits of orange zest. The crust was thin, crispy, foldable; solid slice. * Mush-a-roni, pan pie: a comment I saw said a cross between grandma and Sicilian which I'd agree with. Not medium thickness, light, crunchy crust. There was a nice crispness to the top from the brick oven it was fired in. Personally I like mine with some more chew and wanted some more salt but it was pretty good * The Standard, round pie: I didn't try this myself but someone in our group seemed to really enjoy it Nice and attentive staff, solid pizza. read more

See all

Was recommended to stop into Pizzaleah for some of the best SOCO pizza. It's true, it's a hit and a great addition to our county! They have a well liked and limited option of a deep dish Detroit style pizza with ultra fermented sourdough - hubs got this and conquered this is as good as it sounds! They run out, so if available, purchase ASAP! Happily selected a fun pizza option with several toppings and a normal cheese (my go to). Super pleased with both, good drink selection and friendly staff. This place gets busy, they know what they're doing and limited seating remains at dinner time. A little pricier than I'd like, but pizza seems to be increasingly expensive in general these days. read more

I highly recommend PizzaLeah. Tucked away in the same shopping center as the Windsor Oliver's. It an easy destination with plenty of parking. Menu is simple and to the point. I had the Old Grey Beard pizza on the thin crust and my son had the Mush-a-Roni pizza on the square pan crust. Both were great. Staff was welcoming and it was a fun atmosphere. The style of pizza is more American than Italian, which I love equally to Neapolitan style, I like them but in different ways. I will be back. read more

The best pizza in the Bay Area by far! Drove an hour out of our way to come check it out and it was DELICIOUS. Here's what we got: -Caesar salad -Garlic knots -Spayde and Mush-a-roni pan pizzas -Old grey beard and potato thin crust pizzas Everything was amazing. The old grey beard and potato were our faves. The flavors of the toppings were so nicely balanced, everything tasted fresh. The craft cola was also amazing. Staff is really nice and it's a great vibe. I've been telling everyone about how good this pizza was and highly recommend stopping by. read more

See all

Finally have the chance to make a visit to try the pizza ! wow it was amazing ! Bubbly crisp chewy crust with the perfect amount of high quality topping ! We had to order the 16 inch to do the half and half ! A must visit if you find yourself in the area! Definetly stopping by every single time !! Their staff was amazingly helpful with such a upbeat attitude too read more

See all

Been wanting to come here for a while. We finally made it!! For a Tuesday night, it was pretty busy. Being a chilly Sonoma County fall evening, the many outdoor tables were not an option. After we ordered, we found two seats (staring at the wall/corner and then played musical chairs until we found a better location. Besides two local beers, we got the garlic knots and a thick square crust pepperoni, ricotta and hot honey pizza. Everything was very good. Friendly staff. Fun little place for food food. I can understand the appeal. I have had better pizza in the area, but this is a great option for Windsor. read more

See all

27 Aug 2022 Best pizza we've had in Sonoma County! All in the dough and quality of ingredients. Mix it with friendly staff, two TVs showing sports, a short list of local drafts, and a variety of indoor and outdoor seating for families, groups, and solos, and we've got a new go-to. By the numbers: Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Ambiance 4/5 Value 4/5 Mush-a-roni - Excellent. They were out of pan pies, so we got ours on a 12" round. Roo's - Excellent. Lots of mushrooms and cheese. Old grey beard - Excellent. The Calabrian peppers were just the right amount of spicy (and I love spice), and the honey gave it just a hint of sweetness to go with the savory sausage and cheese. Amazing! read more

Pizzaleah - Mush-a-roni - Excellent - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

This is our first time here. The order takers were very friendly. I ordered the garlic knots and a 16" pizza with cream sauce, artichoke hearts, mushrooms and roasted garlic. The garlic knots came first and they were beautiful and more importantly, super delicious. They came with ranch, which was OK and marinara sauce that was so fresh and delicious I found myself eating it alone on the fork! The pizza came after a fairly short wait and we were blown away. There were so many large cloves of roasted garlic!!! I did request it to be cooked lightly as suggested on the menu as their norm is to cook the pizzas on the darker side. It was cooked to perfection!! They offer delicious sodas as well, 55 Miles craft soda. We all got root beer and it did not disappoint! All in all, this place is amazing with the fresh ingredients, friendly service and scrumptious food! The music is very good - might be on the loud side for an older crowd. Everything looked very clean. We will definitely be back. Thank you!! read more

See all

My wife discovered this place because she saw the owner on a cooking TV show! We made the hour trip from Solano County and the pizza did not disappoint! Both pizzas we had were very good. Probably the best pizza we've had anywhere! It's no wonder this place has won plenty of awards! Highly recommend going! read more

Pizzaleah - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

Pizza options are great. Very good pizza and enough for leftovers the next day. This is my favorite spot for pizza when I'm working in town.

1st ever visit. Mightily impressed with the pizza quality and the professional staff. Ordered Roo's pizza (contains No kangaroo), Cesar salad & a Seismic kolsch beer. All items delivered super fast to the table. 3 staff served us. All happy, engaged, helpful. Delicious pizza. The bread has healthy chew, nice texture, and slightly fermented flavor. Cooked perfectly. Cesar salad also tasty. Generous enough size for two adults to share. Fellow Italians note; no anchovies. Sad face. If your experience with pizza is Domino's or Round Table do yourself a favor by upping your game with PizzaLeah. Real good food. read more

Pizzaleah - Cesar - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

Best pizza in Northern California. And that includes San Francisco! Perfect thin crust pizza. Topping combos are creative and delicious. It's a great Saturday night family pizza spot. read more

We tried Pizzaleah while visiting Safari West. We had a picky eater so we only had a 12 inch cheese pizza. The pizza, cheese, and crust were delicious! The staff were very nice and helpful. We watched a young man carry a pizza out for a disabled gentleman. We watched as other staff asked patrons if they enjoyed their meal as they cleaned up their tables. The sodas were limited, which was a bit of a letdown. We would definitely return. read more

I've only done pick up here. It's an extremely casual place but they do make Great pizzas. My husband is a very picky eater and although I only took him leftovers, he still loved the pizza warmed up. read more