We have been going to this place often. Ever since the egg shortage, the salad that use to be so great with a generous amount of egg, white cheese, nice tomatoes etc. The large pizza tasted like dough. It was terrible. Please try mountain mikes for comparison. We had a large pizza with one topping & the salad for the special of $35.00. read more

We just wanted a simple stay in our room kind of evening so figured pizza was the perfect choice. Didn't want anything fancy, just solid pizza. We really enjoyed this. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Crust was good, not soggy. We were happy. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

Sunday dinner was very nice. Well staffed. The placed was bright and clean. Highly recommend the house salad. It's fully loaded and not your typical "house salad". We enjoyed a small Mary's combo pizza on cauliflower crust (yum). read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Cauliflower crust Mary's Combo - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

Greeted and seated promptly for Happy Hour. The Zucchini Blossoms are delicious. Unique and lightly battered, but nicely bathed in red sauce. It is an excellent appetizer! We always have to have their signature Mary's Salad. Always! And get either their Bleu Cheese dressing (or Bleu Cheese/Italian combo dressing.) My entree, the Ricotta Pasta Alla Vodka, had a slight kick to it, but left a lot to be desired. It could have used more red sauce, as well. (It has zero protein, BTW.) I should've went with the Lasagna. All of their pizzas are very good. Mary's Combo is our usual go-to, with loads of toppings and the best crust. Mary's is a neighborhood staple that could use a tad more warmth. Ample parking adjacent to the Safeway. read more

See all

Marys salad still as great as always miss the days of free breadsticks service was excellent one of us ordered lasagna one ordered napoletena pizza perfecto as usual.why there not as busy as they were before I'm surprised. read more

We usually order the Mary's combo pizza but I was craving for margherita. Did not disappoint. One of the better margherita pizzas I've had in a while. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Margherita & Burrata Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Second time this has happened at this location pickup for 12:30 when I arrived the started. The excuse was cook was on a delivery. Whiskey tango foxtrot! No problem with Mt Mikes! read more

Oh no, what happened Windsor? Got a take out for the first time in a long time and the pizza when we opened it up was literally raw dough!!! What a disappointment, not sure I will go back again. Probably why only a couple tables were taken on a Friday night. Pretty disappointing for sure. read more

I have driven by this place for many years so I decided to finally stop in. I got my order to go. I walked in and my order was taken immediately. I sat on the bench near the front door and waited. Very shortly, my buffalo wings were brought to me, and I was told that the pizza would be coming from the counter. There was plenty of seating, even though I was told that it had been a busy day for them. The seats looked like they were not crowded on top of each other, and there was plenty of lighting. I was pleasantly surprised by how quickly my order arrived. The pizza was delicious. The middle was a little wet, but I'm sure it has to do with the abundant toppings. The crust was just perfect. The edges were great and the center wasn't under cooked. The buffalo wings were tasty, but probably would have been crispier if I had eaten them in the restaurant. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Spicy buffalo wings with blue cheese - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

We stopped at Windsor on the way home from a Northern California vacation, hoping to check out Mary's Pizza Shack. We always enjoyed the Mary's in Walnut Creek, but it was an unfortunate casualty of the pandemic. This Mary's had something special I wanted to try: a low carb Cauliflower Pizza crust! It had been months since I was able to enjoy pizza, as low carbs are not one of pizza's selling points! The cauliflower pizzas are only of the 12 inch personal size with thin crust - but beggars can't be choosers. My wife ordered the calzone, one of their specialties. The cauliflower pizza wasn't bad at all! Of course it didn't help that I was salivating over my wife's thick crust calzone the entire time. But the fact that I could actually eat pizza on my diet was a great thing. This Mary's was great: fast, friendly service, nicely spaced tables and good atmosphere. Fine stopping point on the way back to the Bay Area. read more

See all

Came in on a cold winter night. The seafood ravioli is great. It was a special I had to get as soon as I saw it posted outside. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Seafood Ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

$40 for 2 topping Large. Pepperoni was too salty, had to pick them off. Wouldn't recommend for the price.

Usually, we enjoy Mary's pizza but this time it was definitely off. The toppings on the pizza weren't centered so one side was more crust and very sparse on the other side just no love in it! Service was good. The building itself looks like it could use a little updating or at least the decor. It was very old-school and looking very aged. read more

This is a monthly pick up on my way home. It's always a great experience and the Combo still hits the mark. Consistent since 2008, once a month. read more

always have raved about their pizza. was in town vacationing and haven't been to marys since last year Evidently things have's changed, we ordered two large pizzas one was a titos combination of which the seemed to forgot to put all the ingredients on, just pepperoni some sausage a couple of green peppers and some mushrooms, worst pizza I think I've ever had! Second pizza was cheese and pepperoni of which was a whole lot of grease and not much else! Very disappointed! It used to be a great place , hope it can get better. read more

The food was okay, nothing to write home about. When our party of three arrived, we were told to sit any we'd like. After sitting at a table next to a large party (about 15), I saw table next to us jwaiting to be bussed. I noticed that there were several people in the kitchen but only two wait-staff to serve customers. The young waitress came, was very pleasant, got our drinks and took our order. My salad came quickly but my other two guests didn't receive their orders until 30 minutes after my salad. The table next to us still hadn't been bussed. I noticed during our dinner that the two wait-staff stayed relatively busy while the crowd in the back (kitchen area) were having a good time. Our waitress never came back to check for drink refills. We waited 10+ minutes for the bill which never came. We finally got up and and stood at the register. Our waitress saw this and ran over to check us out. The table next to our table STILL needed bussing. Recommendations from someone who has restaurant experience: 1. Focus on your customers, 2. Have enough staff to complete your mission, 3. Customers recognize when there's no one in charge...where is the manager?, 4. Buss the damn tables. Parting comment: You can have great food, but if the above points are not addressed, you've failed. read more

Today we had a wonderful, polite, efficient, and professional young man serve us. He was the only server today along with the waitress who greeted us. We saw him serve nine tables at once, giving each customer his full attention and happy demeanor. His name is Bailie. Best server ever! read more

I had the best surprise today when I discovered Mary's Pizza has an amazing salad! It's called the Ancient Grain salad and it comes with a lemon Dijon vinaigrette and it was delicious. It normally comes with feta cheese but I got it without. Highly recommend this salad! Also they have the best minestrone soup I've ever had. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Ancient Grains Salad - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

The waite staff is very courteous. We go there so often they know what we like how we like it. When we come in and they see it says they get our tea ready in our water and come over to our table and talk to us. If we haven't been in a while, then they ask us, I wonder where we've been. The food is great great. They cater to my vegan food and make it just how I like it. My son loves their pizza because they have vegan cheese to put on it where most restaurants do not. read more

Terrible service. But great mozzarella sticks. Employees just sat there and chit chatted with 5 tables sitting there dirty. Customers had to wait to be seated for busser to clean the table... read more

Food is fine but not five stars. Salads are gigantic and enough for two and maybe even three people. Im disappointed in the cleanliness. The place is not as clean as I would expect from Mary's. The waitresses are hot and cold, meaning sometimes they are friendly and sometimes they are not and have a tendency to ignore you if you need something. Just poor attitudes. Always cold in there but maybe that's just me. Wait time for food is reasonable and sometimes very fast. read more

I Haven't Had A Calzone In A Long Time But I Loved The Ricotta Cheese! It Was Delicious. The Service Was Really Good As Well. I Enjoyed Getting To Know The Manager Who Was Super Talkative & Friendly (: read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Great Pizza and super friendly staff. Casual atmosphere of course and convenient location. Definitely worth checking out.

Great customer service. We were seated immediately on a weeknight. My 11yo says he'd give it 11 stars if he could. Our pizza was perfect and delivered quickly. We also had the fries which were *chef's kiss* according to the tween, and the bruschetta which was very tasty. Thanks for a very lovely dinner. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Hawaiian Luau pizza, fries, bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

We order all the time from the Windsor location, this will be the last. My online order was 25 minutes late. I understand to a point, but this is where they lost my business and many others. A young lady answered the phone and was really rude, I understand being busy for every reason but this was unbelievable. First she couldn't find the Manager and THEN she gets back on the phone making excuses and when I said just get me the Manager she said " YOU WILL NOT TALK OVER ME " Bye. Worst training for Customer Service ever. I will never ever go to Mary's in WINDSOR ever again . FIRE THAT GIRL read more

the patio space at Mary's Pizza Shack is wonderful! anytime the weather is nice that's where I like to go, their lunch specials deal is great! the staff is always friendly and fast, I highly recommend enjoying the patio at Marys in Windsor read more

We have been eating at Mary's for 30 years, but this is the 1st visit to this store since franchise broke off by family members. Run...don't walk for their "seasonal offerings"! The shrimp bruschetta was to die for and I'm hoping it gets put on the menu permanently! read more

We arrived at about 7 pm and ordered. The food arrived in what appeared to be somewhat spaced out periods of time, with our last plate arriving very late at about 8:15 pm. The food was good; but did not arrive in a timely fashion. read more

Daughter pizza is one big bubble. They couldn't even fix it. You do not bring this out to a customer. Have to ask for refills on waters when she dropped our food off when you can see they are empty. Bread sticks we ordered were half the normal size and skinny..... read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Cheese pizza.... - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Beware of the BOGO deal. It looks like they put these pizzas in the oven at the same time. Pepperoni looks great, cheese looks inedible. It's worse in person than in the photo. A fan of Mary's and love they have deals, but deal or no deal, our orders have been so hit or miss the last year. Kept it simple because the deal allowed for one topping. We usually order more. We will keep ordering because it's good food, but will know when ordering there is a 25-50% there will be a burnt or wrong topped pizza. Will have to decide when we want pizza if we are in the mood to gamble. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Medium cheese pizza. "Free" with BOGO. - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

See all

My boyfriend and I came to Windsor to visit one of my best friends and he was really craving pizza so my friend recommended Mary's. We kind of went overboard with the pizzas because we just wanted to try them all.. Ordered : breadsticks, large Signature salad, Garden Ranch pizza, Hawaiian Luau, Tuscan garlic chicken, and I believe the Napoletana We ordered at least 4 different types of pizzas and one large salad total came out to about 120$ I've never spent so much money on pizza before but it was good .. 100% my favorite was the Garden Ranch pizza .. the artichoke on the pizza *chefs kiss* sooo good . Would come back for that ! read more

I've been coming to Mary's for decades because they have the best blue cheese dressing in the world! Think I'm joking? I'm not! You can actually buy their dressing, which I've don't before and find that I eat it all within days of purchase. The Mary's salad is epically amazing and pairs perfectly with the protein plate if you're on the hunt for lighter fare at a pizza joint. The pizza is good but the dough is actually what sells it! Casual vibe and outdoor seating make this location a great summertime spot. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Protein plate- chicken with sautéed mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, California

Great time tonight at Mary's in Windsor. Kelly made it an enjoyable and pleasant visit.

This Mary's is the best I have been to in long time! Moving to Windsor from Los Vegas, I wasn't sure how good the food was. I tried a classic, pizza, because I was too scared to try anything else. All I can say is.... WOW! Although pizza isn't anything fancy it sure as hell tasted so. Not to mention the service, from several townes I heard that the place is basically run by a teenagers. I was a tad skeptical before going in but these "kids" KNOW.WHAT.THEY.ARE.DOING. There is one short girl with brounett hair with a tad bit of blonde streaks, I think her name started with a 'B'. Great job gurl! Everyone in this establishment made it fun and fresh to walk into, I can tell they love it there and so do I. read more

Excellent chili wings and bread sticks as an appetizer. Always love their salad. Nice bar area.

I've gone to several Mary's and I have to say this is by far my favorite location. Something g about this spot is just so much better than the rest imo. The pizza always tastes so good! So much that I can finish a whole pie on my own! Their tomato soup is to die for! It almost tastes like lasagna to me but without the noodles. The staff is very attentive and so friendly. They make me feel as if though I'm the only customer there, even during the busy rush hours. Check them out and support this business if you can. read more

The hostess welcomed us with a very pleasant smile and Kellie was an amazing server. We enjoyed some of the best food. Family friendly with good energy. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Well, this place was a nice surprise. We stumbled upon this place only cause another place across the way was closed for the holiday. Which worked out great! Mary's pizza shack makes really good pizza, and the meatballs for two as an app yum. First off, the pizza was cooked perfectly with plenty of toppings and very flavorful. The meatballs and sauce, oh the sauce, I should have had them put it in a jar so I could bring it back home. I live down south in Orange County, and I haven't come across a restaurant that has sauce as well as Mary's pizza shack! The service was friendly and attentive. The restaurant was clean and busy, which is always a good thing. I really wish I had a place like this down in Huntington Beach. read more

So Time After Time, we've tried this restaurant and every time there's been something not right with the food. Our pieces never cooked enough and as we go, and we watched whoever is cooking the pizza open the doors too many times at the pizza can't get cooked enough. They've always gotten our orders incorrect.. read more

I have been a long term customer over 20 years and 99percent take out instead of dine in. Lately the food quality has dropped. Today (9/4/2024) I ordered salad and pizza family meal, unfortunately on my second bite I found pieces dirty paper towel in my salad & food. I got so disgusted and threw entire thing away. I phone called the manager about my takeout dinner. Jeff the manager with his unmatched attitude; wasnt help, didn't seemed to care about the unhealthily food prep, unsanitary, & contaminated food from his kitchen. Sad truth, I wish this place would treated things at more serious scale. I am sure no one would feed their family with contaminated food. That/s fine - Mary's just lost customer for life read more