Alert the masses: Potbelly now has wraps and they're actually good! I know I know, it's a debate because their sandwich bread is delicious too, but I had to give the new wraps a go. Popped into this location to grab to orders to take home, and were were in and out in a breeze. Staff was friendly and speedy, and the place was clean as can be. Now they do have dedicated wraps, OR you can turn any sandwich into a wrap, which is what I did with the avo turkey. This thing was packed with all the good stuff: wiss, fresh-sliced avocado, cucumbers, and I added tomato lettuce and mustard. I regret not adding the hot pepper ranch but it was still damn good. And plentiful! I can never finish a whole order. We're Potbelly fans and will no doubt be back for more. read more

See all

Walked in right before the line. The staff was quick and efficient. We got 2 bags of chips, one drink, a cup of Mac & cheese and a regular turkey avocado bacon sandwich and it came out to $25. Food came quick. Mac & cheese was hot and tasted great. They definitely pack a lot into a cup. Overall good little sandwich shop and the dining room was clean. read more

Potbelly - Inside - Sandwiches Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

We like potbelly a lot. They have good seasonal specials but my favorite is the Mediterranean with chicken. A good fast and casual option. read more

See all

I love potbelly in general, but this hasn't been my favorite location in a while, even though it is so close to my home. Just one reason - they're consistently late with their take out order. The whole reason I order online is so that I can be just in and out, but I always seem to be waiting around for them to finish up or start my order. Except this last visit! I was very happy to see improvement! Seems like they've upped their game, and my food was ready exactly on time. Even better, I was greeted by a very friendly guy behind the counter, though he didn't stick around and went inside the kitchen after waving bye and flashing a sweet smile. I only knocked off a star because my sandwich didn't have any lettuce in it... but apparently this is something going on at every Potbelly location. They do ask for our understanding on the website, and I understand, but it still detracts from my satisfaction. This is especially so because I'm the keto diet and I don't eat the buns, so I do need the extra crunch from the lettuce. Or at least extra cucumbers or something. Hopefully this will be remedied soon. read more

See all

Great sandwiches and atmosphere and wait time was short, they move pretty quickly. I would go there again.

Great food and great service! My daughter had a chicken bacon sub and absolutely loved it.

Love Potbelly's sandwich shop. This location is another solid addition. It's really hard to mess up a basic sandwich. The Italian bigs with hot peppers and all the fixings is my thang and it was served up as good as any Potbelly's can do it. The location was relatively clean but it was super busy. We stayed anyways and they handled the line like a champ. We sat down and had a solid lunch Easy peasy. Also had the chicken pot pie soup whcih was OMG great. In general you get what you pay for and for a quick fast lunch you can't beat the price. Also had some live entertainment up front as a young lady was playing the guitar and singing. Potbelly's is a good chain and I get what I expect anytime I come here. read more

Potbelly - The line... - Sandwiches Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Delicious food got the Italian sub and the whole wheat bread! It was delicious kinda salty but great soup as well!

I don't like this Potbelly location quite as much as the downtown or Prospect ones, but I frequently come to this one whenever I'm at Bayshore. It probably does say something about my affection for their food. Why spend way more money for a meal nearby when I can get Potbelly, which I admit to sometimes getting cravings for, for around $10? The employees are still friendly at the Bayshore store, but I've had more mixed experiences. The store is a bit louder. Maybe it's just the "mall" atmosphere. I can't quite put my finger on it. The food is still solid. I usually go for the turkey or the tuna or maybe the roast beef. I always get all the toppings but ask them to go light on the mayo. I like mayo in moderation but it gets excessive very quickly. The employee who made my sandwich today did a good job with not overdoing it. This location also serves the soups really hot, which I like. They've all been good. I like the broccoli cheddar and the chili especially. They also had a live musician playing this afternoon, which is a neat little thing they do. read more

Horrible, I don't know how they are in business! I owned a deli once and this may have been the most tasteless sandwich with virtually no flavor or meat! Gross! 0 stars! read more

Potbelly in Glendale has the best delivery person in the area. The ladies name is Deena. She is always on time and does not just drop your food off, she will lay it out for our company lunch. The food is always hot and fresh. I would recommend calling and ask for her to deliver your food read more

I decided to go because I was in the area I got the pastrami sub it was just ok I also bought the dream bar it wasn't what I expected didn't like it at all but that was my mistake didn't know it was an oatmeal chocolate chip bar not my cup of tea the service was however very good I'll try it again read more

Clearly there are problems at a corporate level. I've had bad experiences at this store, and others. Employees and managers have an attitude. And offer no apologies are concessions when they make mistakes. I too have reached out to corporate at one point--with no reply. I am surprised, that with all the competition, that they choose to continue to do business this way. But I will no longer shop at Potbelly. -------------------------------------- And two days later, I have still not recieved a reply to my response from "Dana" at corporate--who apparently "escalated" the issue... read more

Your service continues to be horrific. As a follow up to this review, Dana asked me to reach out to customer service by email, and I did so on 6/25/19. As of Thursday 7/11 I have not yet received a response back from anyone with customer service regarding my horrible experience. I understand the nature of business is busy, but 2+ weeks to respond to a customer when you reached out to them in the first place asking them to contact you is absolutely unacceptable. I have yet to hear back from anyone. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Favorite sandwich spot around. Food is always great. My girls love the pickles and shakes, which you would think didn't go together but no complaints here. Plenty of different sandwiches and bread choices to satisfy even my picky crew. read more

Sandwich was good. Customer service was not. Ever wonder why when you're the only customer in the building, people are behind the counter working on meaningless tasks, and they fail to acknowledge that you're standing there, you need something, or just standing there for no reason? Placed an online order and that's exactly how it was. Standing there with my thumb in my ass waiting for anyone to make eye contact. Anyone. Finally after no less than 5 minutes I had to speak up versus anyone in the building wanting to assist or genuinely wondering why someone was standing there just for the hell of it. Pass. F them. read more

I love potbelly! This is my go to place for lunch... The portion sizes are good, the atmosphere is nice, and the staff is always friendly and helpful. read more

Seems like this place is always out of certain items. Tonight it was no meatballs (so no meatball sandwiches or pizza sandwiches) and no Mac and Cheese. Works fine I guess u less you have kids with you. read more

Love the mushroom melt skinny! Love the live music at lunchtime! Love the fact that when the line gets long, they kick into high gear and start taking your order in line! Potbelly's is by far my favorite chain sandwich shop. Unforunately, at work Subway is much closer and I would need an hour and a half to walk to Potbelly's, order, eat and walk back...Otherwise, I'd probably eat here every day! read more

I wish I could give this location zero stars. Staff is rude. Refuse to wait on you unless you have placed a mobile order. Terrible, terrible, terrible customer service. Go to Panera. They are kind and actually wait on their customers. Go to Jimmy John's. Just don't come here. read more

Love Potbelly!! This location in particular has a fabulous staff. To whoever's in charge - Erin should be RUNNING this place!!

picky eaters took me here I was pleasantly surprised by the taste. Dont expect much from staff but they did have local musicians playing inside for tips - i dig that. read more

I love Potbelly's cheesy vegetarian sub. I wish they kept it on the menu so when I'm in town I don't have cross my fingers hoping the sandwich maker remembers how to make it. So delicious. read more

Potbelly - Vegetarian sub with cheese and mushrooms served warm with the works. Delicious! - Sandwiches Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

See all

I love potbelly!! Potbelly is the best sandwich shop around. They serve all sandwiches hot through a conveyor oven. Only con I will say there's not many choices of customizing sandwiches as far as choosing meats and toppings. Other than that it's great and that doesn't bother me because I get the same thing every time I go! Lol read more

Haven't even gotten my food yet but the customer experience was fantastic. Online ordering system wouldn't let me put in my order until 3pm (90 minute wait) so I called the store. The employee who answered was awesome, I explained my situation and she passed me along to her manager Sydney. Sydney was kind, she didn't rush me, she took our entire order over the phone and checked it for accuracy. We was professional and very guest focused. Amazing customer service. Nice job!!! I'll be back! read more

LOVE POTBELLY. This is a good location, though it is in the dying Bayshore Mall. Great sandwiches and good service.

Stopped on to get a milkshake, but there was no one behind the counter. Yelled at few times to ask if anyone was there, but no answer, so I left. So did all the other people in line. read more

One child trying to run entire place at dinner rush. Ridiculous wait. All three sandwiches were completely wrong. Out of ice cream so no shakes. Miscounted change to both me and the customer in front of me. Wow. Get your shit together. This is a decent product if you could actually manage the location. The company should yank your franchise, you're damaging their brand. read more

First time I've had a bad experience at a Potbelly 1) They had no cash in the register had to pay with credit card. 2) No Sweet n Low or Equal for my tea 3) my soup was not hot lukewarm at best. read more

I would have given this place a 5 star but the workers here were terrible!! They really don't care about their jobs and will let you stand there while your sub is getting burned while their tallking to their best friend behind you. The food is great here but the workers are snooty and don't care if your food gets burned. read more

Our office ordered online, it was a total of 6 items. The order was not difficult. All the sandwiches looked small, and there was a question of "Are these bigs?" We did not have time to run back and we should have checked before we left, but they should have made them correctly. Word of caution: With any order Double Check. In the future we might not be going back. read more

They have a new sub with roasted chicken and cheddar. The bread and pretty much everything about these subs is spot on! I usually get a delicious savory sub as my meal, I skip the chips and then get a PBJ on white for dessert. I know that's a lot of sub, but it takes me on a satisfying, sandwich journey that leaves me completely satisfied. Get the hot peppers on the side and then just dribble the oil onto your sandwich. The sugar cookies are so dangerously delicious. read more

I usually go to the downtown potbelly which is excellent, the live entertainment is great.the bayshore location makes me feel like I'm downtown the atmosphere is so inviting and the Roast beef sub is the best. I love potbelly's. The Workers are so kind. read more

This is a great deli. I have had their veggie wrap, which is very tasty. Their salads look great as they toss them right at the counter. They have a great selection for lunch. It takes awhile to get your food so I wouldn't go there if you are in a hurry. read more

shockingly, it was my first time experiencing Potbelly's, even though i've seen/passed them for years from state to state. i came in with me & my lady friend for a lil lunch when we had some time to kill while my specks were getting a tune-up over at the lenscrafters.. it was a little overwhelming at first, gazing up at the menu with everything looking delicious, however; the staff was so pleasant & helpful with recommendations & suggestions on what fixin's go best with each sammach! it was a fantastic first time & absolutely killed any other sub shop for me in the area.. jimmy who? read more

I really enjoy the Farmhouse salad as one of the best I've found in a fast food restaurant. Any one who is doing a low carb or paleo diet needs the try this salad. I preferred dressing is the balsamic vinaigrette. read more

So... As far as chain sub shops so, this one takes the cake for me. Maybe it is the toasting of the scrumcious wheat bread before piling on the veggies? Or maybe it is the oil and Italian seasonings they on? Maybe it is the hot peppers? Whatever it is, they are doing something right. I love the Veggie sub...nom nom nom nom :) read more

We have ordered from them a few times over the years, and usually they make some mistake with the order and take forever to deliver it. Today we placed an order for 3 subs and 2 shakes for our office. At 12:15 we called to find out what the hold up was, cuz the order was placed online around 10 am, and said it would be delivered at noon the latest. The manager was rude and said they called us, which they didn't to cancel the order, because they were booked for delivery, as they had 4 orders before us. I don't know why delivery is an option if they can only handle 5 orders during the lunch hour. They just cancelled the order, and offered no apologies. Terrible customer service, you should take delivery from your store off the website as it is not really a true option. Our office will never order from you again. It's sad you treat your customers that way when places like Jimmy John's can deliver a sandwich in under 10 minutes. read more

This past weekend I had the chance to go to PotBelly Sandwich shop by the mall for my second weekend in a row! It is a fast, family friendly restaurant to go to for lunch. The line to order your sub takes a maximum of 8 minutes, and conveniently also offers treats, soups, shakes, and drinks along the line! There are many options you can put on your sub which are heart healthy, and tasty! I particularly like how they warm up the bread, and the possible vegetarian options! The shop was also very relaxing to dine in with the occasional open mike performer, and the warm cozy dining area. The only negative review I have about the restaurant is that they did get my order wrong, but was quick to fix it! I definitely recommend this sub shop after a long day of shopping with friends or family! read more

My first time here, very amazing! Grilled chicken and cheddar is amazing! Haven't tried the others but this sandwich is amazing! Automatic 5 stars read more