The food is amazing, and there are a wide variety of choices as well as specials which change frequently. Many people do take outs, but in restaurant dining is fine. The portion sizes are very large! The staff is so friendly and accomodating. I have a special BLT sandwich I love which is technically not on the menu, but they always make it for me. The sides are great choices. Sometimes we order out for birthdays and entertaining. Few people can actually finish the meal in one sitting. Personal note-they have Dr Pepper which I like, and you can collect coupons for those amazing huge rice crispie squares. This has been our favorite restaurant to take out for a picnic or birthday party or just sit, relax, and enjoy any time of the year. read more

I went to this sandwich shop last week for my first time. I have heard many good things for a while now. I'm so glad I stopped. I ordered the BLT and it tasted so fresh! The ingredients were perfect! The amount of meat to veggies to bread was spot on. What a great hidden treasure! read more

Great subs!! The bread and ingredients taste fresh every time. We love stopping in here for sandwiches.

We love the Picnic basket. Lots of sandwiches to choose from and each one is always delicious. Staff is super friendly and pick up orders can usually be accommodating very quickly read more

Physically inaccessible. The pictures show a ramp but conveniently hide the fact that there is a very large step to get in. Imagine wasting time and money on a ramp just to discriminate against the very people who need the ramp. Believing you don't need to follow the ADA is despicable. read more

Service was friendly, knowledgable and quick. We ate in and our food came out in a timely fashion. The food is really tasty. We pick up from there often. Very popular local spot. read more

Dining at the Picnic Basket is a taste of home. In small town Delafield you cannot find a better mix of service and quality. A consistent, top-notch flavor arrives with each order from customized pizza to the Bomber. You will not regret trying this sandwich shop, because after you do you will find yourself coming back over and over again. read more

We love Picnic Basket! Whenever we're in Lake Country we make a stop. The service is excellent, and the sandwiches, sides and Scotcheroos are fantastic. The portion sizes are generous, and the ingredients are high quality. We most recently dined in - we had a quiet table in the corner and great service. In the past we've eaten outside on the little deck, and taken sandwiches to go. Our favorites are the turkey sub, the bada bing, and the blue moon. The jalapeño slaw is a must have, and we always finish with a scotcheroo (and one to take home!). read more

See all

What HUGE, YUMMY, DELICIOUS sandwiches!! Didn't get guy's name who took our order, but he was patient, as it took me about 5 min to find order I had written, and humorous, as he joked I had until 6:45 to put in my order-it was 3;00 when I started, and all this was done with a smile on his face that was genuine. We order the LARGER of the size sandwiches and they were huge...I was bummed I didn't take a picture until I thought about doing that on my almost last bite and I finished last. The cookies we got were also soft and fresh. If you want a meal for your money JUST order a sandwich!! read more

Had the Razorback Pulled Pork from Picnic Basket - Nashotah The bread, as ussual for them, was soft and chewey like it should be. I got without Tomatoe or Lettuce cuz not a big fan of them on Sandwhiches. The pulled pork is moist & yet the Honey Dijon Pepper sauce I think kind of masks the smoked flavor of the pulled pork with it's peppery spice. Which, in the end isn't a bad thing as I did get hints of the smoked pork flavor as the heat subsided. Paired it with their cucumber salad that adds a sweet yet vinegar like taste to add with the spice. Washed down with Sprecher Creme Soda. Based on the little mental A - F scale I use, the sandwhich gets an A. The restaurant has maintained from my time eating there a fairly solid B rating due to their use of Styrofoam. It's just a odd quirk for me to take off points now for Styrofoam products with so many health & eco friendly options out there for clamshell and all other packaging systems. would recommend. Go try it for a more spicy version of pulled pork. read more

See all

Great first experience at Picnic Basket. I built my own veggie sub sandwich. The staff were so nice and helpful. We got a side with our sub and couldn't decide what to get so they offered to give us sample sizes of each to try so when we come back we know what we would like. I love restaurants like this that just want you to enjoy your order and have a great experience. We did carry out and only waited about 5-10 minutes. The sandwich was so good! It was big and filled with fresh veggies and very fresh bread. I didn't love any of the sides but I preferred the cucumber salad and chips. We also had to get the huge rice crispy which was a great decision. It was clearly homemade with a gooey crispy consistency. The space has great indoor seating and it looks like maybe outdoor seating in the summer. Super easy to pull up and park right out front, they even have pick up parking spots. We will be back! read more

See all

Food is great, service is even better! Friendly and always accommodating. Good place to meet for lunch or dinner.

Great sandwiches! Fast carry out. The bread is great. We usually get the roast beef with Swiss. Try the jalapeño coleslaw! They sell kettle chips but the large bag. It's a simple and delishess family night in! read more

Great sandwich, good size, a bit pricey but worth a stop. They gave us the new customer special on the sides, fun idea!

Great food, great service. My favorite sandwich is the "Porkopolis" a mixture of delicious pulled pork, cold slaw, cheddar cheese, bacon,etc., on a delicious bun. This is addicting, if you ever it, your hooked. Plus great sides with the sandwich. read more

Very good food, good service, but over priced for a sandwich shop. Otherwise, I would rate this a 10 star if I could.

Picnic Basket is a family favorite! The subs are not only delicious but humongous! Today my fiancé got a rotisserie turkey sub that came out warm. I got the seasonal soup - cheesy bacon potato which was quite good. I have also tried a pizza from here that was very tasty as well! Will be back as always. read more

Picnic Basket - Rotisserie Turkey Sub - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

See all

It's been awhile since I've had the Picnic Basket and figured it was time to check them out again. Ordered online and curbside pickup was super easy. You text them when you get there with your name and car info and my order was out super fast (about a minute later). I got the Nashotah Sunset sandwich and a side of the Cucumber Salad. The cucumber salad is one of my favorites! Remember to add on dessert too, their Scotcharoo bars and cookies are fantastic! read more

Picnic Basket - Rice Crispy and Scotcharoo Bar - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

See all

$15 tax included for a 8 inch sub $10.99 for 6 inch not including tax is a little high priced for just a sub Sandwich. Over all yet sandwich was tasty read more

Picnic Basket - Chicken avocado wrap with little meat - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

See all

Food and service were outstanding. Waiting time for takeout was short. Several cashiers were on duty.

I was driving through town and thought I would stop. I had two small 15 lb dogs on leash . I ordered and then got my dogs out of the car and was going to sit outside in the corner on the patio. A worker came out and said " no dogs allowed on the patio". He then told me I could "wait for my food on the sidewalk". Not very friendly , food was good. Just sad that in a small town like this you can't sit on a patio with two small dogs. There was only one other person on the patio and she was petting the dogs. Not dog friendly - the delivery of the message came off rude and unwelcoming. They obviously don't need my business or others stopping through this town. read more

Dined in yesterday for lunch. The food was fine, but the waitress wasn't friendly at all and rushed us through our entire meal. She even asked us to leave right after we finished eating because people were waiting for a table. I hadn't finished my drink and my friend hadn't finished her coffee. The people at the table next to us were treated the same. When asked if they wanted a to-go box one person said she would like to finish her soup. They both had full plates of food. We quickly picked up our things and rushed out. Not a pleasant dining experience at all!! Will not go back! read more

The food, especially the sandwiches, is always exceptional. I'm never disappointed eating here. The staff is very accommodating and kind. I enjoy dining in. It reminds me of a small diner/ mom and pop shop atmosphere. read more

Outstanding sandwiches and subs Great service Consistent Everything is fresh Easy location read more

Channel your abusive boyfriend mentality and demand they make you a sandwich because this place is legit! The type of sandwich shop you hope exists near you when buying a house. Huge portions, great ingredients, friendly staff. Khaleesi fire, bourbon chicken, corned beef (with pepper) a few faves but wraps and salads both good. House Italian oil dressing is . Pizza just ok IMO but you didn't come here for that. Tiny seating area so prepare for takeout. Just make sure you got space in the fridge for after cuz you're not finishing in one sitting. read more

Food excellent, fresh, homemade, and reasonable. Fast service. Excellent variety of sandwiches, sides, desserts.

Delicious! One of my favorites. The house made cole slaw is amazing. Service was fast and accurate read more

Amazing sandwiches. My work office goes here semi-frequently in the summer. Filling sandwich. Highly recommend the rotisserie turkey hot sandwich. The seasonal lemonade is also very good. Definitely do not order the mozzarella sticks. Love everything that I've eaten here, but the mozzarella sticks were very dissapointing. read more

Just really overpriced for what you get. They put limp shredded lettuce on everything and it's a total mess, the amount of meat on the sandwiches is lacking. My prime rib sandwich was basically just a hunk of fat. read more

Food always fresh and tasty. Way more than can be eaten in one sitting. This is definitely a case of getting what you pay for. worth the money! read more

Below average sub and wrap l. Over spiced - wouldn't return. They are "known for their sub bread" nope - not good.

Hard to find a little sandwich shop with so many choices on the menu. Everything is made in house and so delicious.

The food is great! You can buy party packs. And we got a free rice crispy treat because that day we had conferences and we did awesome! Service is the best very nice people. read more

Awesome place. Good food and service. Wonderful atmosphere. The place to go for a family meal.

Very clean very good customer service they help you out very fast. Their food is crazy. I love their service.

I am actually shocked at all the good reviews. I went there and ordered a corn beef sub. It was a carry out. When I opened it up at home what I saw was what looked exactly like a few slices of deli lunch meat. They say that they cook their corn beef! No Way! This was a few sparse slices of thin looking deli slices! It had no flavor! The sub was mostly lettuce. Very disappointing! I really feel like I got ripped off because their subs are not cheap! I will not be back! read more

Best sandwich I've ever had! I can't believe the quality of the bread and the service is really good too!

Wow! Best sub samwichs ever. My favorite is the aPorkalypse; Cooked in house shredded bbq pork, bacon, ham, cheddar, jalapeno cilantro coleslaw and pickles on a buttered bun , a serious flavorbomb! My only criticism is their bread is not as good as Cousins. read more

Oh my gosh.... had this place for the first time and wow I was blow away. HUGE delicious sandwiches. The bread they use is soft and crusty on the outside... divine flavor. Pastrami is amazing. Italian oil/vinaigrette is to die for. I cannot wait to order and try more. tip- they deliver if you call ahead in advance. read more

Picnic Basket - Pastrami sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Nashotah, Wisconsin

Great sandwiches, easy ordering and pick up. Was happy they kept the drive up and text for pick up post pandemic. Roast turkey hot sandwiches is a favorite go to. Wraps also delicious. Overall solid , consistent selection that you can't go wrong with whatever you choose. Scotcheroo (?) dessert is pretty yummy too! read more