Ok - I found myself in town a few days back and decided I needed a takeout sandwich- so I hit up this spot! Highly recommended by my local team, I figured why not? So I ordered a muffeletta as I'd not had one since a trip to New Orleans a few years ago - and I remembered loving that little sammich! I got it - unwrapped it back at the office- and it looked and smelled the part! A good sign, right? Well - not quite so fast - while the flavor was mostly ok, it was the bun that was holding up a perfect score. Kind of was falling apart and tasty kinda corn-like. I still scarfed it down because- damn - I was hungry after all! But had to drop a point for the bun which seemed to be disintegrating faster than I could eat it! Nice - fix that bun up and you'll get a perfect five next time! read more

Nice Sandwich - My sammich! - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Definitely a hole in a wall restaurant. No real signage to see from the street unless you see it from the small parking lot Based on the one pizza it was good but tasted salty to me The sandwiches looked good from what I saw that other patrons got Small restaurant that could seat up to 30 people Only 1 person was working as far as i could tell and that's probably there's a longer wait to get your food etc Would I come out of my way probably not unless someone mentions this establishment read more

See all

The bread was soft and delicious. Got the turkey and ham club. Good portion of meat on the sandwich. Very nice owner. Highly recommend. read more

Local shop- great menu selections. Bread is round and they have regular and large sizes. They didn't skimp on any items and we all enjoyed our meal. Chips, soup, Mac n cheese and other sides were a pleasant addition to our lunch. Coke products (loved that!) and a good amount of seating. We noticed a ton of take out orders while we were there. Give them a try. It's a nice change from fast food. read more

See all

Great place for lunch! Never had a bad meal. Love their specials. It's in a good location so when I'm out and about out in the area it's easy to get to. read more

Amazing food. The cheese sauce is literally amazing, the service was excellent as they at so kind, and the store?? Awesome. Feels very hipster but in a good way. read more

Nice Sandwich - Muffleleta sandwich - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

I ordered the brisket sandwich. I wish I would have taken a picture of the sandwich when I opened it/ first received it! First off, NOT an abundant amount of brisket, and it felt like more than half of the sandwich was just nasty fatty pieces! I was picking out of my mouth. I love my brisket but, NEVER AGAIN here. I wish I would've gone to Mission BBQ instead for the $15 I just wasted! :( read more

Nice Sandwich - Suppose to be "Brisket"... but just fatty pieces! - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

We got two sandwiches and sides for about $30. These sandwiches were huge and well worth the price. Not only were they absolutely delicious but they were filling too. The place is like a cute little dinner. Service was good too. read more

Love these guys sandwiches and they always bring my food out quick. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I was looking for something quick and wanted to try something new. You can use your cell for a detailed menu, they only had the names of each sandwich listed. I only crossed paths with 2 workers, both kind, but not customer service focused, just polite when placing order and giving me my sandwich. It had quite a bit of seating considering how small the area is. The sandwich was quite large for a regular, wondering what a large would look like! The turkey had that "smoked" texture, not slimy, and there was a good size portion. I love toppings, and was pleased with how much there was. I would add some chipotle mayo next time for a little bit more flavor. Overall it was a fresh filling sandwich. read more

See all

Spicy BBQ pizza absolute banger. Better than any franchise pizza. The bread is perfect and crispy. Chipotle chicken avocado sandwich was phenomenal as well. Bread is baked in house and has always been great. Haven't been here in 8 years roughly and was just as good if not better than it was before. Solid 8-8.5 out of 10! Quick service, fresh food and a quality price. Can't beat it. Will be back often. read more

Nice Sandwich - Chipotle chicken avocado - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Sold out of sandwiches at 1:30 in the afternoon but the hours say open until 7? For what. Huge waste of time.

Nice sandwich is our neighborhood go to place for lunch and I love living walking distance from it! I love their Muffuletta sandwich which I was told is the Glorioso's version of the famous sandwich from New Orleans. It was very filling sandwich where the turkey offset the powerful and distinctive flavors of the muffuletta bread. Love their local offering of chips. The service was uncomplicated and easy to navigate and the ambiance is cozy. It really is a hidden gem since it is unassumingly in a strip mall. 100% recommend for their strong flavorful sandwich game. read more

For $30 we got one sandwich, two sodas, and one wrap. Nothing else was included in that you're better off going to Panera where they at least give you a side along with your meal. I ordered the chicken wrap and there was one slice of chicken in it. It was 90% lettuce no sauce it was supposed to have avocado, but I sure couldn't taste any And then there was a woman in the background that was swearing and banging things around while I was trying to eat with my daughter. read more

Cool little sandwich shop. Hard to find because their signage is weak and hard to see. They're right on the SW corner of Cleveland and hiway 100... good location, next to tattoo shop. Back to the food. It was a good sandwich, unique toppings. Give em a try read more

I finally made a stop here after driving by. Located on the corner of Hwy 100 & Cleveland, I had worked up an appetite after doing some damage at HomeGoods. I LOVED Schlostzky's that previously resided in this space, so I had high expectations. First & foremost, the signage is a bit elusive-other than the window decals, there's no real sign. The space was clean and had some upbeat music playing. I ordered a regular sized muffuletta as well as soft pretzel bites (ate them all on my way home so no pic). The sandwich was huge, packed with lots of filling. If you're looking for a traditional muffuletta, this isn't it, however it was tasty in its own right. The olive salad was SALTY; I love salty foods but this made me thirsty all night. All in all, a great spot to grab a unique sandwich-I'll be back to try other offerings! read more

See all

I just had my 3rd or 4th meal from here now and each time it has been unbelievably consistent. Very delicious. I have had a few of their sandwiches now and next time I will be trying their seasonal turkey gouda sandwich. Bread is made in house and is so fresh just makes for that much better of a sandwich. Hands down one of the best sandwiches you can get in the Milwaukee area. The gentleman who is behind the counter is always nice and helpful if you have any questions. Although I haven't eaten there in the restaurant, each time I come in it's very clean and has a nice diner feel to it that's comforting. P.S would have shared a photo but I destroyed it to fast ‍ read more

I LOVE this place. The sandwiches are huge. The bread is fresh. They're reasonably priced. I want more people to know about them so they stay in business. That's me being selfish but they deserve to succeed. If you haven't been here yet - GO! read more

Nice Sandwich - Chicken bacon - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

When I saw that a new sandwich shop opened I was so excited because the area doesn't have any real sandwich restaurants except for all the chain restaurants. I'm a big fan of the Italian muffuletta sandwich and yo don't find them on a lot of menus so when I see one I order them. The menu has a lot of good sounding sandwich's but I'm sticking with the muffuletta because it's been a couple months since I have had one. Something was very off with the smell of the muffuletta sandwich as I drove to the spot to eat it. When I first opened the sandwich I'm like WTF because muffulettas don't come on sesame seeded buns and come they come on nice Italian bread. Next I'm like WTF because real muffulettas don't have a yellow sauce in them so what actually is this sandwich because it's definitely not a muffuletta like I have had everywhere else. Third a muffuletta sandwich is a cold sandwich and this sandwich was like toasted and warm which killed it even more. My first bite was like WTF because I had a mustard taste in my mouth and nothing about this sandwich tasted like an Italian sandwich at all. Is this just artistic license and their idea of a muffuletta sandwich or what because it has nothing authentic about it and it's horrible if you have had a real muffuletta sandwich, see the Italian deli in Kenoshas for what a real one looks like. one and done with this restaurant for sure. read more

See all

Nice sandwich is a cool little spot. You order at the counter and then take a seat. I love sandwiches, they are in my top 5 favorite. I've worked in multiple delis. One Chicago deli I worked for 2 years had lines out the door and down the street. I take my sandwiches very serious. I love that this place is a mom and pop joint. Those stick out to me more than anything. Lots of tables to sit at and if I remember there's coolers with beverages in them and cookies/chips at the counter as well. I got an Italian sando. It was good. My kid got a cookie, my husband got a sandwich (can't remember) and a drink. The sodas are 12oz cans. Regular soda can. The food was good but this is a pretty pricy sandwich shop. If friends and family ask about it of course I'll spread the word they have good food! But be ready to spend a little extra. That being said, I'm glad we tried it! read more

Visited yesterday a little after the lunch rush (2pm) but it was still pretty busy. I wanted a turkey sandwich with lots of veggies and they were happy to accommodate. Bread was great and the ingredients were fresh. I took my sandwich to go. It was nicely packaged and held up well on the way home. Support local! read more

Nice Sandwich - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

I really liked the Muffletta sandwich. There's a regular and then a larger size. The regular in itself is almost two meals. We also bought two bags of potato chips. One Salt & Vinegar and a Jalapeño. One annoying thing I didn't like about not so Nice Sandwich, was they wanted to charge me for a cup with ice in it. All I wanted it for was tap water. This was off putting to me. Especially since to go containers. But they don't charge for those on the left overs. Dumb logic. Go figure. Otherwise, I really enjoyed the food and I would come back However, I'd bring my own cup of water! read more

Nice Sandwich - Lunch. No cup of ice for just tap water allowed. They will charge you for this. Really?! - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Had kept hearing great things about this place, and finally had the chance to try it for lunch. Went at about 11:30 on a Thursday. There were only 3 other people eating at the time, and one person who walked in right before me. Only waited about 5 minutes for the made to order sandwich. I had the turkey and salami. It was delicious! Very big. I only had one half of it for lunch and saved the other half for later. The topping were fresh and crisp. You could definitely taste the garlic butter and it paired so well on the sandwich with the mayo too! Their homemade bread was interesting no didn't dislike it, but it was different than other breads I'd had before. Some of the edges were a little tougher than what I'd personally like, but honestly it wasn't anything to really be disappointed about. It was a good sandwich, and I'll definitely stop in again. I'll even maybe try a different sandwich, but honestly I don't know if I'd be able to not get the turkey & salami again! read more

Nice Sandwich - Turkey & Salami - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Generous portions and nice sandwiches. The obvious is that this deli is in the former Schlotzky's location, and they kept some of what Schlotzkys had done right; mainly the bread and sandwich recipes. We ordered online and the sandwiches were ready on time. The large sandwich can feed 2-3 people, I sincerely doubt any one individual can eat one on their own and still feel comfortable for the next few hours. The rice crispy treats from Carries Crispies were incredible and worth the trip. Root Beer and Pretzel, and Chocolate Covered Cherry were great. Give this place a shot. read more

See all

First time visiting and the brisket sandwich and ham/hot pepper sandwich was so good!!! I will be trying all of their sandwiches on their menu and highly highly recommend. I will be a regular customer for sure! Service was fast too! read more

Fabulous sandwiches at this little deli on Hwy. 100 at Cleveland....watch carefully or you might miss it! They don't have a big sign up yet....but it's in the works. Everything is so fresh and tasty. The regular size sandwiches are very generously sized and they have lots of interesting things to accompany your sandwich - different flavored chips, soup, sodas, and goodies. We will definitely be going back often -- just as we did when it was Schlostzky's! read more

Spicy barbecue pizza was amazing! Spicy jalapeños and sweet bbq sauce. Pizza was filling. Didn't have to wait long for it to be done. Must if you want to try something new !! For sure coming back to try the sandwiches. read more

Nice Sandwich - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

This place is legit. As another reviewer mentioned, this is the old Schlotzky's location on Cleveland. They improved the sandwiches with better ingredients and bread - same style and cooking method, higher quality. Went with the chicken sandwich with avocado on jalapeño bread and it was excellent. This dude's restaurant survived the Covid shutdowns and returned better than before. Will go here every time I'm in the area. read more

Everything tasted so fresh. The wait staff was able to remember all of our orders w/ o writing anything down. We were a larger group too! Amazing read more

Food and service is always perfect! I'm a huge fan of the chicken Philly cheesesteak!

Quick service and the sandwiches were warm and tasty. Will be back again when in the area.

Food was yummy. I think they only serve hot sandwiches. Bread and ingredients tasted fresh. Had the muffaletta and salami & turkey.

Hands down the best sandwich I ever had. No other sandwiches come close. I had the chicken bacon and I'm definitely coming back for more.

I don't know what they do to their GF sandwich buns and pizza crust but they do it right!! So delicious!! We love getting take out lunch here!! read more

Nice Sandwich serves some pretty nice sandwiches. It's low hanging fruit, but I can't help myself. My fave is the Turkey & Salami- it's so flavorful and super filling. The toasted sesame bun is so yummy! I'm a creature of habit, so I've really ordered the same sandwich but I've heard good things about the muffuletta and their pizzas. I love that they have Carrie's crispies for dessert too! If you haven't checked them out, you absolutely must! read more

Get the Cuban sandwich! Ham, cheese and sweet pulled pork on the aforementioned crazy delicious round bread! Goodness!

They do not allow customers to bring their own water bottles and no tap water available. An unnecessary expense to the customer.

Fast, fresh, and delicious. Service was friendly and efficient. The place is clean and well maintained

Food and service were great! I love the sandwiches from here, the Salami and Ham is the best! A new favorite!

I didn't even know this place opened up a year ago, but I will definitely be eating here more often. I got the Turkey & Salami and it was very good. It was also huge for just the regular portion. Service was friendly and fast as well. Can't wait to go back again soon and try more sandwiches and the pizzas as well. read more

Nice Sandwich - Regular Turkey & Salami - Wraps Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin