Its been a while since we had pizza from Pepinos. We went with the special and some garlic bread take out. We were surprised! Nice medium thin crust, ample toppings, on time and not too pricey based on our location. Definitely worth it and will be back read more

I was really craving a thin crust pizza one evening, so I searched for pizza spots along my route, and luckily I found and tried Giuseppi's Pizzeria. After browsing the online menu, I called to place an order for a large thin crust pizza with beef meatballs and extra cheese. Within half a hour, my pizza was ready for pickup. The restaurant doesn't seem to be setup for dining in for its a cute spot with ample parking and near a Main Street, so very convenient for ordering takeout. Unfortunately, I forgot to take photos of the gorgeous, cheesy pizza - but prehaps I'll post another review with photos the next time I order from this pizzeria. The pizza was delicious, glad I requested extra cheese and the toppings wed evenly distributed over the pizza so each bite was great. Also, I really enjoyed the pizza sauce, it was mild and flavorful. Great spot for pizza, thank you! read more

The service was very good. Old school Italian hospitality. Family owned business that is close to us, so we thought we would give it a try. Pizza was thin crust. Sauce was good. All toppings were delicious. Garlic bread was good as well. Give this small business a try! No real ambience to speak of as it was a pick up and takeout place. read more

Good sausage Lots of toppings Take out this pizza. We like ours well done. Nice thin crisp crust. read more

Giuseppi's Pizzeria - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

Pizza was excellent, my grandparents went to the original location in Milwaukee 70 years ago. Staff was friendly as we asked about the history. read more

I had a craving for pizza and was looking at two different nearby bookmarks as options to try. I was intrigued by pictures I saw of the pizza from Giuseppe's Pizza and they were a little more affordable than the other option, so I chose them. I ordered a 12" thin crust sausage pizza and one of their plain homemade cheesecakes. The sausage pizza was phenomenal; so much so that I called Giuseppe's afterwards to complement them. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy on the edges, the sausage was fresh, and there was a ton of cheese on it. Trying to not use too much hyperbole, this might be one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The cheesecake was ok. It was a good portion for the price compared to what you'd get at a sit down restaurant. I didn't love the flavor, though, so I probably wouldn't get it again, but if I did I'd get one with fruit topping instead of just plain. read more

See all

Solid pizza, great atmosphere and excellent customer service. The pizza is not on the level of Lou Malnati's of Chicago which is the best I have ever had but it's close. Their pepperoni lacks flavor and the crust is crispier than it should be for Chicago Deep Dish. This is nit picking but I wanted to explain why it's not a 5 star place. It is good enough to be 4.25 though and I would go back! read more

Giuseppi's Pizzeria - Large deep dish with sausage, pepperoni and pepperoncini - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

My son just moved to the New Berlin area. After a day of golfing with him we decided to pick up a pizza somewhere near his home for a quick dinner. Came across Giuseppi's. We are so glad that we did! We ordered a Giuseppi's special and we "built" our own for the other pizza - ham and pineapple. Service was fast and friendly. Both pizzas were delicious! Perfectly thin crispy crust. Generously covered in toppings. You can tell that the ingredients were fresh! The cheesy garlic bread was a perfect blend of crispy on the outside and garlicky goodness on the inside. My husband and I have be searching for great pizza near our home but have had no luck! I guess my son will be seeing us a lot more for dinner in the future. read more

We are always looking for a great pizza! Giuseppe's was that and more! Crisp crust, fantastic sauce and lots of toppings! Will definitely be our new go to place ! Don't wait get some now!! read more

We're in town for a family gathering. We ordered 7 pizzas to go, including their house sausage + mushroom + onion. They had it ready in 30 minutes. This pizza is fantastic! Wow. The crispy thin crust. The cheese. The meats. Absolutely delicious. Highly recommend this pizza. read more

The pizza and service were both great. We had a supreme pizza, pepperoni pizza and garlic bread.

We love this pizza. Kind of hard to find the first time I went there but it definately was well worth the adventure. The pricing was in line with other places. If not a little cheaper. Lots to choose from. read more

Perfect crust, delicious fresh toppings and made by people who care! So happy I found them, perfect pizza stop on the way home from work.

First timers at Giuseppi's Pizzeria. Everything is take out or delivery. Old school delicious thin crust pizza with sausage, mushrooms, onions and pepperoni. We will be back to try more. We are finicky foodies and give Giuseppi's two thumbs up. read more

Giuseppi's Pizzeria - Delicious thin crust sausage, mushroom, onion and pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

Had multiple hairs on my pizza. Before noticing the hair, the pizza was very bland tasting. Would have rather bad dominos pizza. Wouldn't highly recommend trying somewhere else. read more

We've ordered from here twice, once using Door Dash and once calling directly, I highly recommend calling for a few reasons: restaurant avoids fees, quality of delivery (DD person turned our pie on the side and forgot our desert) and you'll get to speak with the lovely staff. The pizza is solid, definitely worth putting in your rotation. One final note: for that Door Dash delivery where our driver messed up our pizza and forgot our desert, the owner came out personally to deliver the desert and make things right. Good people deserve good support from you! read more

Ordered the Supreme pizza with the thin crust and cheesy garlic bread! Delicious! Crust was cooked just right. Don't like my crust soggy and this crust was perfect. The cheesy garlic bread was very good too. Loved the pepperoncinis with the order! Definitely found our location pizzeria! read more

Local Pizza and a true Italian owned place. Love it. Met the owner and his sister at Cup'a Tosa (great place especially for remote work). They are a lovely family and ones with passion to bring back amazing food. My family loves this place. A small spot to get pickup/delivery. Authentic pizza's that taste amazing. This is my go to Friday night pizza place. Easy Packing, no sit down. Order online and pickup quick and easy. I haven't had delivery done yet so not sure about that. SUPPORT LOCAL. read more

My Grama loves this place so i checked it out for my family and was pleasantly surprised! Theres a lot of pizza in the area, this place might be the best! The service was fast and friendly! Great ingredients, the crust is flavorful and the perfect thin-ness!!! Highly recommended! (The prices are great too!) read more

Giuseppi's Pizzeria - Green pepper and pepperoni pizza! - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

We ordered two more pizzas for delivery. We specifically asked for well done so they'd be crispy. When these pizzas are crispy they are exceptionally delicious. What we got were two medium mushy pizzas that were not done. And because they were underdone and our delivery person turned the pizzas on their side while walking up our front sidewalk they slid into a sloppy ball. It was impossible to eat. It was disgusting. I don't want to leave a negative review! I'm sure the owners are hardworking people. These pizzas have so much potential, but 95% of them are not cooked sufficiently. I'm sorry. read more

Best pizza crust and sauce! The meatballs also are really good!The service is so friendly too! Always happy to see you and please you.

I have tried many pizza takeout places in the Milwaukee area. Giuseppi's in New Berlin is now my favorite. Pizza is excellent, my order is accurate and on time, every time. Staff is friendly and happy to serve you. And the prices are very reasonable. read more

Ordered large pizza and meatball bombs. OMG, both were delicious. Ordered right at 4 when they opened and had my pizza within 25 minutes. Great food and great customer service. read more

My bad for not taking the picture prior to digging in. Staying in town for an evening and I'm happy that we found this pizza place. Ordered online (fast and simple) and the GrubHub delivery guy was awesome. Garlic bread was great, the pizza was great, and thanks for a great experience... read more

Giuseppi's Pizzeria - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

I have been wanting to try a new pizza place and found this one on yelp. I was not disappointed. The garlic bread was awesome! The pizza was yummy! I was so glad I tried it. It is difficult to get good pizza sometimes and this place was fast and yummy and just what you want. The crust was even tasty! I will definitely be getting this again. read more

Not sure why posted pictures and hours are for the previous pizza place, Basils, but my review is for Giuseppi's. I remember when the original restaurant located on Hwy 100 & Bluemound Rd existed in the late '70s. The new incarnation is owned and operated by family members of the original Giuseppi's. The hand-tossed pizza and garlic bread are true to the original recipes and quite good. This is a carry out only restaurant but the service is friendly and efficient. My only reason for not giving 5 stars is I wish it opened earlier than 4pm daily. But, perhaps that will change in the future. If you remember the Giuseppi's from decades ago, you won't be disappointed in the new place. read more

The pizza is good. I'll order again for sure, but I have an issue with their delivery service. They refuse to bring the food to the room in the hotel I stay at, despite the hotel allowing room delivery. If I wanted to walk to the lobby to get my food, I'd have ordered pick up and driven there to get it and saved the tip money. I tip 30% or more at times so I expect better service. read more

I ordered delivery. The pizza arrived hot and delicious. The crust is nice and cracker crisp. The sauce is on the sweeter side. Which is fine by me. I don't have a preference as long as it's flavorful. The cheese was nice and gooey. It was cooked to perfection. I would definitely order from them again. read more

Fantastic! First time we tried it as our usual places are Marty's and Balistreri's which we are getting tired of. It was great! Cheesy, crunchy crust, sausage was awesome and so was the pepperoni. We were at the original Giuseppi's on Bluemound and Mayfair rd. years ago and so happy this has re-opened. We will be back time and time again. Thank You!!!! P.S. I am not from California. We live in Tosa. Don't know how that got on the review. read more

Pizza was nothing to write home about. Crust was boring. Wanted to love it and support the local establishment. Sorry!

We recently had a cheese, sausage, mushroom, green pepper and black olive 16" pizza. We liked it - I'm not gonna lie! But I personally feel it was too salty and did not have enough tomato sauce/or pizza sauce on it. Just my opinion, of course. But pizzas are so darn salty in the first place, it's not good when the salty taste jumps out at you. read more

This place is great! We tried it for the first time and got two pizzas for pickup last night (the BBQ Chicken and the Healthy Supreme), and they were both very tasty. The crust was thin and crispy, the pizzas were both delicious, and the staff were very friendly when I picked up the pizzas. The place is a little hard to see from the road (around the right side of the strip mall as you look at it from Greenfield), but we'd definitely recommend it. read more

We moved and had to find an authentic pizza place to make traditional pizza. We found it at Guiseppi's Pizzeria in New Berlin. Excellent pizza dn garlic bread. My daughter tried the thick crust today and it was delicious. The thin crust is also excellent! Carry out or delivery only. Definitely a mistake try. read more

Highly recommend Giuseppi's. Faster service, with perfectly-cooked pizzas. Absolutely delicious. We also enjoyed a salad, which was huge! We'll definitely be back. read more

Lately due to the Covid-19 mess, we have been looking at local businesses to help support and try some tasty food. Let me tell you, Basil's did not disappoint. The friendly staff made it so easy from call in to pick up. The restaurant is clean and the pizza is amazing!!! We tried the Ranch Chicken Bacon and the Healthy Supreme and it was so great. If you want awesome pizza with awesome service, go to Basil's! read more

Been eating Giuseppe's pizza for 40 years at their various places. Worth following around! Excellent crust, sauce and the good cheese - nothing skimpy. Awesome pizza. Best in town hands down. read more

I was excited to see a new pizza place nearby. I went 3 weeks ago and none of the workers were wearing a mask. My sister went that same week and still, no masks. She called and asked them to wear masks and the "manager" thanked her for the call. I decided to give them one more chance today and still no masks. It's unfortunate because they have good pizza. My family and I will not be returning. read more

Basil's Pizzeria is a wonderful new establishment to New Berlin. We have ordered three times in recent weeks for delivery. The best pizza we found since moving to the area three years ago. The delivery is fast and friendly! read more