I always like Noah's, I sent people there and to cut it short they were very disappointed with the pizza they ordered, said they would never go back, so sad I always enjoyed their food. read more

The sauce has changed. It is so spicy and hot our throats we're on fire . None of us could finish our food. We use to really love your food. The meatballs were hard as a rock and burnt. Could not even cut them. Garlic bread was the only edible thing. 40 bucks wasted as we had to dump our meals. read more

Noah’s Pizza - Our burnt hard as rocks meatballs and spaghetti we could not eat. - Pizza Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Awesome thin crust pizza. I will be back. Fast friendly folks in a warm home feeling restaurant. read more

Noah’s Pizza - 14 inch thin crust pepperoni with half jalapeño 9.5/10. Well done next time. They're generous w/ cheese and ingredients $18.02 - Pizza Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

Wanted to give a local place a shot and unfortunately it didn't work out so well. Carried out 3 pizzas that had were inedible with massive amounts of cheese. Sauce was a bit salty when you get past the cheese and soggy crust. All of these are headed for the trash can after having only a few pieces. I hope the owner will reach out to make this right. $67 bill in which I gave a 20% tip. I might try this place again, but only if I could get the pizzas with half or no cheese at all. read more

See all

It was ok. Not a ton of flavor, light on the pepperoni, very heavy on the cheese and the thin crust was soft. The inside of the restaurant is tired and could use a good cleaning. We took ours to go. No complaints about the service. read more

Consider trying Noah's fried chicken for dinner or a company meal! My workplace always chooses Noah's fried chicken for Saturday lunch and we continue eating it for leftovers during the week too! This family-owned restaurant's ambiance is less attractive but the school-age cashiers and receptionists are very polite, attentive to phone calls, and conversational, explaining the ongoings of their days to me as I waited for my order. I've enjoyed the fried chicken four times as takeout because the freshness of the meat and breading has a higher quality of taste and texture than a chain restaurant. I'm very pleased with how it tastes as though the chicken has been placed straight into the fryer out of the package. While I haven't asked about their cooking practices or where they receive the meat from, it is certainly an excellent quality of chicken. Really tastes like it's store-bought - SO FRESH! Wow! This menu item is offered in 4 pieces or 8 pieces with french fries and coleslaw. Both sides are fresh, crispy, crunchy, and satisfying! MOST IMPORTANTLY - IF YOU WOULD ONLY PREFER DARK MEAT IN YOUR ORDER, BE SURE TO ASK THEM !! Normally, the order comes with one piece of chicken breast for every three pieces of dark meat, but after I asked for only dark meat, I was provided 4 thighs. Very grateful! Keep up the great work my friends! read more

Really good! I really enjoyed this pizza, it was thin crust and the sauce was really good. I tried the sausage and the pepperoni, they were both really awesome. I really liked the pepperoni because it was underneath the cheese, and the sausage was just really good. The delivery was speedy and it was super convenient. The crust was pretty good as well, I really liked the crunchy thin crust and it wasn't too thin, it was really good. Although we didn't get to go inside the actual store, the place did look a little small from the outside. Overall though, I really enjoyed this pizza. read more

Noah’s Pizza - Sausage Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Checked this place out after a local friend recommended it. The thin crust pizza was really good. Nice crust and not too greasy! We tried the deep dish and it was just ok. It wasn't very flavorful and crust was bland. Pizza was ready in a timely fashion and friendly staff. Would give it another shot! read more

Best Mexican and Italian food in Lake Country--hands down. Excellent caterers too. Family business including kids and all. Love this place. Love this family. read more

Sal's is a family run business that makes really good pizza. We ordered a large thin crust pizza with sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms. They use fresh quality ingredients, the crust was thin with a little bit of chew and the edges were crisp. There was just the right amount of sauce on the pizza too. Glad we took a chance and decided to try Sal's. read more

Noah’s Pizza - Thin crust with sausage, pepperoni and fresh mushrooms...so good! - Pizza Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

We've tried all the pizza crusts from Noah's, thin, pan and Chicago style. All are very delicious, with pan being our favorite. Tons of cheese and the sausage and pepperoni are yummy. They have crazy deals and coupons and is the best pizza value in lake country. Their cheese bread is great too. Highly recommend!!! read more

I've been searching for good Chicago style thin crust pizza during this quarantine season, and Noah's hits the spot. I ordered a 16 inch thin crust with sausage and onion on one half and pepperoni and bacon on the other half. This pizza reminds me of the pizzas from the mom and pop restaurants I grew up around in Chicago. This particular thin crust is thin, but not cracker thin. There is some pleasant chew to it. The toppings were excellent, including well seasoned Italian sausage. The cheese is high quality full fat mozzarella and there was a generous amount of it which I love. Overall an excellent pizza. read more

See all

We have ordered thin crust from here and it was really good!! We decided to do deep dish for a change and I have to say it was absolutely amazing!!! Some of the best pizza we've ever had, Highly recommend read more

Good pizza, good price amd garlic bread thrown in for free. What else is there to say read more

Noah’s Pizza - Thin crust - Pizza Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

We've had Noah's many times since we found them. Delicious pizza, but you need to tell them NOT to add so much cheese - they are not frugal when it comes to this popular Wisconsin topping! Good thin crust - our favorite - and they do it well. Friendly, family-owned business and good products. They have more than pizza! read more

Pizza was ordered at 6:38pm and arrived at 8pm cold. The cheese was congealed, one pizza was smashed into the box, and part of it was folded over. It was a mess. Extremely excessive on the cheese and it was hard, since it wasn't warm, so it was not really appetizing. I wanted to love it based on other reviews but honestly it wasn't very good. Thick, cold, chewy cheese was about all I could taste even though I spent $1.75 a piece to add sausage, pepperoni, onions, and green peppers. The BBQ pizza had the most flavor but that's the one that was folded over in the box and the BBQ sauce was so heavy on the top that the pizza looked wet. Maybe could be delicious fresh but I was quite disappointed with the delivery. read more

Noah’s Pizza - Slow delivery... - Pizza Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

Great Pizza, delivered fast and HOT!! Thank you for such a great pizza!! Salad was good too. I will order again next time I'm in town. That's all I got to say. read more

Consistently one of the best pizzas in the area. We got the meat lover's and it was heavy with thick cheese that was stretchy. The sauce is delicious and the topping is fresh. We are never disappointed. read more

Called in for pickup. Very good pizza,great portions of toppings. Mixed signage outside as this is what used to be Salvos Pizza. Will definitely go back. read more

First time through. The owner seemed nice. The steak sandwich was very good. Very reasonably priced. Much improved over the previous ownership. read more

Very happy, happy, happy!! Noah's pan pizza is amazingly delicious!!! It's a true pan pizza style so be hungry when you order. Can't wait to try the thin crust next. Seriously very pleased to have an excellent option for a good pizza joint in Pewaukee. read more

I ordered delivery. The pizza came early and it was hot! I do not remember the last time that I had a pizza delivered or any other meal for that matter that was hot. They use their own delivery people and insulated bags. I ordered the double dough pizza. The pizza was not fantastic, but, that is because I prefer more sauce. There were areas on the pizza with no sauce. They definitely give you a lot of cheese. It was a fantastic looking pizza! I will order from them again and request more sauce. It is really nice to order from a local place that does not have to split its income with delivery services. read more

I am not one to criticize but this pizza was disappointing. More cheese than toppings. The mozzarella sticks tasted like plastic and with Wisconsin being known for its prowess of cheese, the worst compared to even a dive bar which has better mozzarella sticks. The garlic breadsticks also lacking crisp. Either the management doesn't care or they need a complete makeover on the menu. read more

Wonderful family owned restaurant, with fast delivery and very good/consistent pizza!