I always like Noah's, I sent people there and to cut it short they were very disappointed with the…read morepizza they ordered, said they would never go back, so sad I always enjoyed their food.

The sauce has changed. It is so spicy and hot our throats we're on fire . None of us could finish…read moreour food. We use to really love your food. The meatballs were hard as a rock and burnt. Could not even cut them. Garlic bread was the only edible thing. 40 bucks wasted as we had to dump our meals.

My wife and I drove up from Chicago to have lunch with our Grandson and his family…read more We both agree that this restaurant is deserving of a 5 Star Review for the following reasons: 1. Friendly proprietor 2. Cozy environment 3. Good appetizers 4. Great Pizza We will definitely be back when in Sussex.

I'm glad I gave Tony's a try. We had their meatballs as an appetizer, a pepperoni pinsa and a…read moremedium Noah's pizza. Do not skip the meatballs, I'm going to crave these now. That alone with a side of noodles would be a great meal. The pizza crust was thin and done perfectly. Their sauce is unique and not sweet, which I like. The only reason for four stars is we ordered delivery and ended up having to pick it up. Waited over an hour and pass the delivery time and when I called to check in, they said it would be another 25 minutes otherwise I could come pick it up.

Our families have gotten take out pizza here for decades. Still consistently the best every time…read moreand a favorite for special occasions and a quick quality dinner.

Good pizza, sometimes inconsistently made. Good service, always busy during prime times so there is…read moreAt times a wait. Inside is cute like an old school pizzeria.

I am not sure why it took me so long to try Upper Crust Pizza, I've lived across the street for…read moreyears. But ok, I finally tried them and it was so worth it. Life in general is so expensive and so, much like life has gotten, I thought it was a bit pricey. I ordered a small 12" Deluxe pizza; it comes with pepperoni, onions, green peeper, and sausage. This was $20. I can't speak for how the pizza used to taste, but I thought the pizza tasted good! The crust was thin. It was cooked perfectly and they were generous with the toppings, which I appreciated for the price. But let me tell you, these Buffalo Ranch chicken wings are seriously fire! If you like wings and you like Buffalo as well, you absolutely HAVE to try these wings. 10 pieces was about $13 or so. They were so delicious and cooked perfectly. I wasn't a fan of their actual ranch dressing but I always have my own anyway. The service, although not overfly friendly, was good enough for me. I don't need constant pleasantries. Food was ready in 30 minutes. I'll definitely be returning although probably not often. It's definitely worth the try.

Best pizza, terrible pizza, expensive. Never know if your getting something edible or cold…read moreundercooked goo. I stopped going there because I had three or four terrible pizzas in a row.

Pizza was great, good price,service was good and it's just a pickup place which worked for us. We…read morewill be back and you should go also!

Tried the veggie and pepperoni pizzas and the salad for lunch. It was taken to go so I can only…read moreComment on how yummy the food was! I can attest, their pizzas are great!

Food is always amazing, sometimes service can be a little slow but its totally worth the wait!read more

We decided to try this place at the last minute, on a Sunday, about 4:30. We had heard so much…read moreabout their pizza, we just had to try it. We were not the first ones in, but the bar and dining room were not crowded. We were welcomed like old friends, which was nice. We chose a table near the bar, and as time went on, the place filled up. It appears many regulars like it here, and Bar Dice was banging on the bar often. We were told they were known for their lasagna, pizza, and garlic bread, so we started with the garlic bread, which was thick and very buttery. But I did not taste much garlic until I was told there was a shaker of it on the table, and I could add more myself if I wanted. Done. We then ordered a sausage pizza, which came out super hot (yay!) with really crispy crust, just the way it should be. But the sausage was minimal and kind of bland. All in all it was an OK pizza but not our favorite. The entrances were steps so accessibility is not great. The bar area is crowded even for walking. Apparently, business is really good, so I have to assume it is more my taste that wasn't matched. I'm glad we tried it just to see what everyone talks about.

Tomaso's is a great casual pizza place right downtown Cedarburg! We walked in not really knowing…read morewhat to expect, but we were pleasantly surprised. You order at the bar, and the employees were super friendly. We all really liked the sauce - note, the cheese is UNDERNEATH! A little different, but we had a good time.

Went to Tomaso's on a Friday night during the holiday season with a group of three. As expected, it…read morewas busy. The restaurant is very small, with limited bar seating and booths, and there's no real place to wait inside. Everyone waiting for a table ends up awkwardly standing close together near the entrance, which wasn't very comfortable. You have to check in at the bar, and unfortunately the bartender seemed visibly annoyed whenever groups tried to add their name to the waitlist. He rolled his eyes and came across as pretty grumpy, which was a rough first impression. I honestly considered leaving, but I was really craving pizza, so we stayed. Once we got a table, we had to go back up to the bar to place our order. We got cheesy garlic bread, a deep dish pizza with three toppings, and three sodas. The sodas were poured right away, and I carried them back to the table myself. About five minutes later, the garlic bread was ready, and I went back up to grab that too. When food is ready, they yell out your order and vaguely point in your direction while saying "front" or "back," which works but isn't exactly organized. One positive surprise was the deep dish pizza. It came out much faster than expected. Most deep dish places take 45-60 minutes, but this one was ready pretty quickly. The food itself was very good and definitely the highlight of the experience. When we finished eating, I went up to get a to-go box and pay. That's when I noticed sodas are not free refills, though they're priced at $1.25 each. We ended up paying for six sodas total (three originals plus refills), which honestly wasn't bad and came out to about the same (or even less) than unlimited soda elsewhere. Still, it would've been nice to know ahead of time. I was also unsure about the tipping situation since we did all the running around ourselves: ordering, picking up food, carrying drinks, and paying. I left a 10% tip, but it felt a bit unclear what's expected in this setup. Overall, I really enjoyed the food, especially the pizza. The experience was just dampened by the lack of a waiting area and the initially grumpy bartender (though he did seem to lighten up as the night went on). I'd come back for the food, but I hope the service and organization improve.

I'm impressed with the individual pizza for one. It's large enough for 1-1/2 meals or get several…read moredifferent pizzas to try if you're with a group of friends I'd probably like to see the pizza cut into 8 slices instead of the 4 slices Was not busy at all for a Saturday lunchtime on this particular weekend but I'm sure that by dinner time it will be rather busy It's all street parking but a public parking lot is available 1 block over Prices is average for this small business in my opinion

Lovely pizza place with character and a homey feel. I ordered a make your own with mushrooms, the…read moredough was perfect, light and fluffy dough with crispy crust. The pizza had just the right amount of mozzarella and the portion was enough to give me some for leftovers. Good prices and they offer vegan and gluten free!