This was my first time trying Milwaukee Classic Pizza... and I definitely would go back. The pizza arrived in perfect condition and the delivery person was very polite. The pizza tasted great and looked great. The garlic bread was wonderful and very filling. The cheese curds were good. I must say however, the chicken tenders were delicious and were some of the best chicken tenders I've had from a restaurant. You should check this place out. read more

See all

Tried the veggie and pepperoni pizzas and the salad for lunch. It was taken to go so I can only Comment on how yummy the food was! I can attest, their pizzas are great! read more

See all

Still loving this pizza place!! The pizza is always tasty and reasonably priced, the service is always very good, and the delivery and carry out orders are quick. I could not be happier to be in close proximity to this pizza place. The pizza is always hot and fresh and tasty. The pizzas are huge and fairly priced. ***The Milwaukee Classic, the Artichoke, and the Margherita are the three best pizzas in their menu and all the saladas are good. Ordering carry out is a pleasure. The woman who usually takes the calls and works the window is so genuinely friendly and makes it a great experience. If you order carry out, it's usually around a 20-minute wait and delivery is usually to your door in under a half hour. My one small complaint is the pizzas are slightly heavy on the cheese, but that's a personal preference. **Great news! They added more pizzas to their Uber Eats and GrubHub menus which was my one complaint in the past. read more

I had heard very good things about this place and decided to try it I sadly won't be going back. Had ordered a pie and the cheese was undercooked like it had way too much cheese on it. So it couldn't cook properly and also very very greasy. The sauce has no flavor at all as well. The only two good things were the staff was very nice and the prices were nice. Frozen store bought pizza had more flavor read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Milwaukee Classic Pizza! Soooo underrated! The food is always delicious! The delivery is always fast and the customer service is really top notch! If you love a good Milwaukee style cracker crust pizza you must try theirs! It's soooo good! Crispy, crunchy and flavorful! They also offer a gluten free pizza crust too. A few times when I've asked for adjustments or substitutions they've been more than happy to accommodate. I also really like their hamburgers; they offer a really affordable sandwich deal that includes fries and a soft drink. Delivery and take out is available. There are a few chairs to use while waiting for your food. There isn't dine-in service. read more

See all

I ordered for the first time and will not do so again. Price was fine for the size pizza, but I ordered a thin crust and it was so soggy. All of the toppings were dumped in the middle of the pie which contributed to the sogginess and the edges were naked except for the cheese. So disappointing because the taste was decent and the amount of toppings would've been fine if they had distributed them evenly. Sorry won't be back. read more

Somewhat disappointed. Just walked in and ordered a sausage and meatball pizza and mozzarella sticks. When I got home and opened the box, I had sausage and mushrooms. Absolutely despise mushrooms and there were so many that I can't really pick them all off. Cleared a few pieces on the edge, but probably going to throw the rest out. read more

Accidentally came actually this pizza place late at night looking for somewhere that would deliver. Was amazed at how good it was and that we had never had it before. They offer unique toppings and specialty pizzas as well as all the ususal. The crust is good and crispy and delicious ingredients. We've also had a couple of their salads - also great. I especially like the Arugula salad. Delivery was at the time expected and friendly. read more

This is my GO-TO spot for delicious pizza and tasty wings! We love ordering from here. The wings are always crispy and the pizza is always fresh. The prices are very reasonable for the amount of food you're given. When we aren't able to pick up, delivery is always fast. So fast that the food is STILL PIPING HOT! We stepped out of our comfort zone and tried the Fish and Cheeseburgers. SO DELICIOUS!!! We always come back! read more

I was still craving a cheesy sandwich on toasted garlic bread after the last place was a let down. Pizza places usually have garlic bread and sandwich's on the menu so I like to combine the two because garlic bread takes a sandwich to the next level. I have driven past this place many times and even had breakfast next door but I never stopped until today. The place is small with one table and extra seating on the walls to wait for your food so it's basically take out or delivery. The sandwich menu is small but a chicken Parmesan on garlic bread sounded good. I ask the lady if I can get toasted garlic bread and she says yes so I ask if I can pay extra for the chicken Parmesan on garlic bread and she says you don't have to pay any extra if that's the way you want it made, cool. You can hear the fryer come to life so the chicken is cooked order and took about 10 minutes. The sandwich looked good with melty Mozzarella cheese oozing out of it mixed with the red sauce. The chicken looked like chicken tenders which is ok and was white meat. The garlic bread was nicely toasted with a big rich garlic flavor. The sandwich was delicious with that nice salty flavor from the grated Parmesan which reminded me of the Kraft store brand. This sandwich hit the spot for my craving for a cheesy sandwich on garlic bread. read more

See all

I was looking for a pizza place that was open on a Monday and MKE Classic Pizza fit the bill. I had the pizza once a year or so ago and really did like it so I knew I needed to go back there. I ordered the Artichoke pizza with extra garlic sauce and extra crispy. The toppings were ample and the crust was perfectly crisp. For $22 you get a HUGE pizza so the value is definitely there. Many good pizza places are really expensive so this was nice to have good food at a very reasonable price. The menu is extensive but it will be difficult for me to try something other than their pizza. I did carryout so I don't know how good their delivery will be - with all of the personnel shortages I probably will stick to carryout or know that it might be a longer wait than normal. read more

We ordered pizza to be delivered to our hotel room on a weekend visit to Milwaukee. It was after 8pm so Ned's was out. We ordered from Milwaukee Classic basically because close by. The service over the phone was excellent and the pizza was delivered quickly. Nice delivery guy and the pizza was great. Very good experience. read more

My first experience with MKE Classic Pizza was great. Loved the pizza. My second experience was last Sunday. We ordered garlic cheese bread and a pizza. The garlic cheese bread was cold. We ended up reheating it. The pizza was also not warm. The pizza just seemed off to us. I get places have off days but with so many pizza options in Milwaukee, I don't see myself frequenting this place in the near future. read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

The pizzas were put together a tad bit sloppy. I ordered with anchovies on mine and since they're salty, should be spreaded out so that you're not eating a gollop of salted anchovies in a bite. Ditto on the onions in one of the photos in luced. Both my roomie and I felt that there was a bit too much cheese as well. read more

Big slices made oven fresh. There is a wait time since the pizzas and pizza slices take time to cook. Friendly staff. Only been here for lunch. read more

Real pizza crust was excellent not greasy and right amount of sauce and they deliver it themselves not stupid grub hub or other third party. Found my new favorite place. read more

Excellent pizza with a wonderful crust. I was a little hesitant about ordering after reading some of the online reviews but I'm glad I decided to try them out! Also, I expected to wait over an hour because I chose delivery on a Saturday night at 6. PM. They arrived in about 40 minutes with a hot and delicious pizza. read more

Very good pizza and a nice simple easy convenient place to be and friendly people Very good pizza and a nice simple easy convenient place to be and friendly people read more

This has been my go-to place for years. If you're hesitant about ordering, don't be! You won't regret it.

I would not recommend or eat here again. I could get a thin crust from pizza hut and get a better quality pizza for cheaper price. The Chicken Spinach Florentine Pizza is by far the worst pizza I have ever eaten. It should instead be called "Buffalo Chicken Spinach Florentine Pizza." read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - Chicken Spinach Florentine Chicken Spinach Florentine Chicken Spinach Florentine - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Love it. Found this place through Yelp (where else?) and the reviews, setting the bar high, lived up to the expectations. I ordered a pepperoni online and although they had not started on my order when I went to pick it up (30 mins later) the guy at the counter promised it in 10 mins. A very short wait later (maybe 8 minutes!) the pizza was ready and so delicious! They definitely don't cheat on the pepperoni, it wasn't greasy and the sauce was just right. I will absolutely be back here. I thought the price was really reasonable also. read more

One of our go to spots for pizza during this new abnormal.for pub style thin crust pizza cut into the awesome little squares (while still a round pizza). They have a $19.99 special thats large pizza with 2 toppings (we do beef pepperoni and mushroom) + garlic bread with marinara sauce (similar.to how my mom used to make in the oven on some French loaf) + a 2 liter Easy pick up or delivery. If you do.delivery, recommend calling them directly over an app to use their coupons and get cheaper delivery fee (give those fees in an increased tip to your delivery driver!). Give them a shot if you love thin crust pub style pizza. read more

1st time ordering last night. Delivery was stated at 1-1:15hr. Pizza was delivered in about 45 min. The menu states that an order of garlic bread is included with every order. Not mine. I ordered the chicken florentine, this was quite honestly the worst pizza that I have ever had. It arrived early but the pizza and the onion rings were cold. I'm only 3 miles from the restaurant. Milwaukee has many better places to spent your money at. Beware. read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Can't say enough good things! Pizza = amazing thin crust. Delivery is on point!! Arrived 45 minutes before 'expected'. I will say, pass on the chicken tenders barely any breading, dry and gross. Updating this review for the terrible customer service and pathetic excuse for an 'app'. Advertising a deal and price without stipulations and not honoring it when the technology doesn't work. Please also note that in the many years on yelp this is my first negative review!!! 'Free appetizer when you download and use our new app!' - charged for the full price for everything. Never worried about it! Figured I was giving my money to a good business. Ha!! '$10 Wednesday special for lg 1 topping pizza' - try to order online - try to order on the 'app' - finally call the store - get the run around from the incompetent phone person saying I have to do the order online or physically show up with a coupon - she then proceeds to tell me how she's getting loads of other orders and she has no idea why mines not working but advises me I am probably doing something wrong. I then asked her if I brought my phone in and showed her what was happening if she could explain to me how to do it correctly - "Oh no! I have no idea how online ordering works"!! Ok so let me get this straight - if I come there and show you my phone and that the app isn't working and don't have that physical coupon but I have coupons from my other past orders and proof under my account that I have ordered multiple times your manager wouldn't understand you honoring the advertised price??? Ok - I'd rather give my money to any other local pizza joint at this point I told the worker I would appreciate an explanation from the manager as they have my contact info. There pizza is 'ok' everything else on the menu is barely edible. Please take your money elsewhere. De Marini's here I come. read more

I think it's the best pizza by far anywhere in the area I really like the crust good sauce plenty of toppings

Great pizza. The best in Milwaukee in my opinion. We always get the large veggie. Perfection.

Was in town for my son's AAU tournament. I notice this place was close to our hotel. So I stopped order a Milwaukee classic. Was greeted right away staff was very nice. It was a little crowed to I decided to wait in the car with my children. Pizza was done in 15 minutes as stated and they were so kind enough to bring it to the car. If I in the area again I will definitely be returning. read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Ordered two pizzas after a long day of traveling and delays. Tired and hungry after ordering at 10:45pm that delivery was between 12:30-12:45am. Not happy I called to cancel. I found that the pizzas were on their way for delivery. Our pizzas arrived a few minutes later and it was hot and fresh. The pizzas were delicious, the salad fresh, as was the calamari. I'm glad I decided to order from this local Milwaukee pizza restaurant and would recommend it to anyone tired and hungry. read more

After seeing how they treated someone. I watched from my car in front. Looks like they couldn't get an order correct? read more

Excellent pizza and great staff. Ordered carry out and pizza was hot and fresh. I love the fact that all toppings are pork free.

Greasy pizza and gluten free crust was pretty close to cardboard. It was late at night and nothing else delivered to the hotel... we ate it because we were hungry but wouldn't have if there were other choices read more

I love this Pizza, and other delicious dinners and sandwiches !! It's small, but big on taste !! Can't eat inside, but it might be better in front of the TV at home !! Give it a try !! read more

Lovely place in the neighborhood!! I'm a huge pizza fan, and I just love the vegetarian pizza that they make. All the ingredients are fresh and the cheese they use on the thin crust is just absolutely delicious!! Very nice staff and owner. Be sure to try the Philly Cheese Steak sandwich too ! They also do catering upon request. Definitely happy this Gem of a pizzeria is next to me :) read more

$18.00 Pizza Not Worth It. Get Soy Cheese, Please! We ordered the Primo Veggie Pizza because on our app it said they offer vegan options. We asked for soy cheese, but they said they didn't have any. So we ordered it with no cheese at all and they got it right! Usually, pizza places automatically dump cheese on everything, so we're always happy to find a place that actually follows directions and we don't have to send the pizza back. Unfortunately, we should have added our own vegan cheese because this pizza really needed it. The ingredients were fresh, and the amount of basil was terrific, but the sauce was bland. Overall, we both had to say it was a bland pizza, could have used more seasonings, and definitely vegan cheese. Also, it was a very large pizza, but at $18.00, it wasn't worth it. We want to go back and give this place another shot because it's in our neighborhood and we want to support local businesses, but we'll wait and read other reviews and see if they improve the flavor and get some soy cheese in. read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - Cheeseless Primo Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Had to have pizza so I ordered from here. It is very very good. It arrived on time, was hot, and tasty. This is my go-to pizza place now. I might try some of the other menu items IF I ever get tired of pizza. read more

It was my first time at Milwaukee Classic Pizza and I ordered the Summer Margherita. It's a 16" thin crust pizza topped with red sauce, slices of sweet roma tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, a drizzle of olive oil topped with a splash of balsamic - just as described on the menu. This pizza is amazing and wonderfully fresh, tasty and light. Carry out service was friendly and prompt and greeted with a smile. Yum Yum Yum read more

Milwaukee Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I don't live in Milwaukee so I can't compare to other local pizza places and have only had pizza from three other places (during the times I visited and none were any good). I live in DC and eat pizza a lot there and in NYC. Not to brag but I know good pizza. The thin crust here is just about perfect and the sauce has great flavor. It's seasoned well (not bland) or too sweet. The choice of toppings and their freshness are spot on. It's definitely the best pizza I've had in Milwaukee and one of the best I've had. It's a solid four and a half. It's tough to get a five from me unless it's authentic NY pizza. read more

Pretty good pizza... TERRIBLE experience. I ordered this evening as a first time customer. In my quest for Milwaukee's Best Pizza, I've been reading up on numerous reviews. I came across MKE classic and thought "maybe this will be our new *spot*!" Good prices, pictures looks nice, and good reviews! Let's try it out! We ordered a large pizza and garlic bread. Upon arrival, the delivery handed me one pizza box and turned to leave. I stopped him and reminded him that we had ordered garlic bread, to which he replied "No you didn't." ........yeah. We did. He looked back at the receipt, smacked his forehead, and said he would bring it right back. A while passes and I called to check on the status. The girl who answered was not apologetic about the mistake and didn't seem to care at all. She said he still had other deliveries to make and wasn't even back to pick up the bread yet. Disappointed and increasingly hungry, I asked if there was any way they could just give me a refund for the bread. She told me there was "nothing she could do" (And again, didn't apologize.) I declined her offer to "save it for next time" because there was a flyer with coupons on the pizza box that said "free garlic bread with purchase" so I wouldn't have benefited from a credit. SO I just proceeded with having the driver come back. He arrived way later (after we had already finished eating) with the soggy and burnt garlic bread -- that was definitely not worth the wait or the initial purchase of it. All in all... if we just ordered ONLY the pizza, I would be a return customer. Sometimes delivery people forget things and I understand that. Nobody's perfect and an honest mistake wouldn't prevent me from returning. But how the mistake was handled and in no way rectified, AND because the quality of the product that we waited for was extremely underwhelming when it arrived... I don't know that I'll be ordering again. The ONLY thing that saved this from a one star review is that the pizza was actually decent. Everything else was a thumbs down. I was really hoping to find *our spot* ... but the quest continues... read more

There's pizza and there's delivery pizza. The latter category is tough on the near South Side. My favorite neighborhood pizza place, Fixture, does serve up a better quality product but they can't be fairly considered because they use Uber delivery and it's more often not available than it is. MCP arrived quickly and hot, faster than the ETA (be ready) on a Sunday football evening. The driver was not stoned and able to find my address without any help (well maybe he used Google maps unlike the the marijuana addled competitors' delivery drivers) and was even polite. This place has never been disrespectful and insulting like Transfer, so it starts out up at the top of my delivery pizza list. It's a New York style thin crust so you can fold it and eat it (I am from Chicago so I don't) and they offer the anchovies option. The least ordered pizza topping ( ordered on less than 1% of all pizzas in America), anchovies were actually a more common topping on actual Italian pizzas than cheese according to an immigration historian I once shared pizza with. I once stayed too long in a relationship that was otherwise not working because she also liked anchovies on her pizzas. The one drawback is that my cats shift from being respectful of me as their human master to seeing me more like competition in some household ecological niche when the aroma of pizza anchovies is delivered. MCP seemed a little pricey but actually their delivery charge is a little lower and their pizza ingredients are generous so I think it's worth it. read more

It's 12:08, all advertising says they close at 1am, including this Yelp page. Just called to order, and was told they closed at midnight tonight, on a Saturday. Closing early because it's slow, or because you feel like it, is the epitome of poor customer service and inconsistency. As a business owner myself, (in Las Vegas) I have to wonder if this was employee nonchalance that the owner is not aware of? Or maybe the owner just doesn't care? Either way, shame on you. read more