Cancel

Open app

Search

Carol Ann's Pizza

4.4 (21 reviews)
Closed 4:00 pm - 8:00 PM

Carol Ann's Pizza Photos

Business Info

CAROL ANN'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Carol Ann's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Awesome thin crust pizza! Got it for pickup but look forward to dining in sometime. Great spot and service!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Great pizza and cheesy garlic bread. Deliver drive was so nice. Will definitely order again

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Sarah K.
30
41
18

2 years ago

Great local pizza place. Yummy breaded mushrooms! Got takeout several times and service was very good.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Ashley T.
17
43
35

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Angela S.
79
270
21

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Looking for a successor now that Aldos is closed. Good pizza. Very tomatoey (is that a word?) sauce.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Always great pizza! One of my local favorites! I stick with the regular crust but one of these days I will give the thin crust a try.

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

We love thin crust pizza and this place is great. Lots of toppings and great value for the price.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 years ago

I love thick crust and I can not lie. Tastes just as good the next day so I always get a large!!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Carol Ann's Pizza

Review Highlights - Carol Ann's Pizza

I really loved the thin sliced peppers and onions so they were properly cooked when the pizza was done.

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 5,082 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Stillery

The Stillery

4.6
(203 reviews)
2.8 mi
$$

My family and a group of people from Indiana were in town for a Martial Arts competition…read more Afterwards, they all wanted to go to Chik-fil-a. Um, no. Besides a strong preference for local non-chain eateries, I'm not coming all the way to Wisconsin and not getting cheese curds. Found this place on Yelp. Aaaaand.....I'm in love. The dark atmosphere and heavy, dark all-wood decor gives a vibe you can't find at any chain eatery. Our server, Bailey, was great at just simply interacting on a human level and making us out-of-towners feel welcome in what is obviously a locals hang-out. And yes, I got my cheese curds. But the star of the night was the beer cheese burger. Quite honestly one of the best, if not THE best burger I've ever had. Get one. You NEED this in your life. Trust me.

The Stillery serves up drinks and elevated pub food in a casual setting…read more We stopped by on a Sunday evening after a trip to nearby Cabela's. We started with drinks. I got the Manhattan off their specialty menu and my husband got their autumn barrel Manhattan. After trying both--highly recommend the one off their specialty menu. It was definitely superior quality. It's served over a block of ice so if you want it up, you may want to mention that when ordering. It tasted more like a classic old fashioned than a Manhattan but I'm not complaining because I love classic bourbon old fashioned cocktails as well. For a starter we got their much raved about bang bang shrimp. It came on a bed of greens and was good! For my dinner I got their seasonal chicken and dumpling soup and a side salad. Both were solid. The salad was definitely more ample than I was expecting. My husband got some sort of salmon alfredo pasta dish that came with roasted asparagus mixed in. I had a bite and he ordered well--it was decadently buttery and delicious. The service was super kind throughout our stay. Our server checked in on us regularly without being overbearing. Get to it!

Photos
The Stillery
Side salad
Side salad
Manhattan x 2

See all

Manhattan x 2
Relish Supper Club

Relish Supper Club

4.5
(84 reviews)
4.0 mi

Came here with another couple of friends. Our previous meals have all been very good, and this…read morevisit was no exception. Food: Three of the four of us ordered the Relish Old Fashioned. It's an excellent take on an old favorite. We started with the Meatballs, which normally wouldn't have been my first choice, but one of our group is a huge meatball fan. They were excellent. The sauce was flavorful without being too thick, and they were served with little pieces of golden-fried bread that added wonderful texture and flavor. We all ended up ordering seafood entrées. I chose the special, Salmon en Croûte. It's similar to a Salmon Wellington, with spinach wrapped inside the pastry. It was outstanding. The salmon was moist, flaky, and perfectly cooked. The cream sauce paired beautifully with the salmon and spinach, and the puff pastry was baked all the way through, remaining crisp rather than soggy. To top it off, the accompanying roasted vegetable medley was perfectly roasted and full of flavor. Altogether, it was an exceptional dish. Service: The service was friendly and personable, with just the right amount of attention. We never felt like we had to watch for our server. They checked on us regularly and made sure our drinks were always topped off. With its consistently high quality, Relish is becoming one of our favorite go-to restaurants.

I wanted nothing more but to give this a great review but sadly couldn't. The supper club has a…read moregreat vibe and we had a really wonderful server, she was so kind especially to my young nephew. We started with a round of drinks, cheese curds, and the complimentary bread and were off to a good start. The drinks were good and the bread was a classic hot supper club bread. A few of us opted for the $5 relish tray and we all felt like that was a waste of money. Maybe $5 a table would be more reasonable? The deviled eggs were what we looked forward to the most but they had zero flavor. There was only one type of breadstick (large, sesame, hard to eat) which was also a bummer. I got the chicken dumpling soup and that only had one piece of chicken and one dumpling. Very bland. For my meal I had the salmon which sounded amazing on the menu, but I was so disappointed. The mushroom/spinach combo was soo salty that it was inedible, the salmon was also incredibly salty with no other flavor at all. I ate about half and gave up. The risotto is another thing I looked forward to and it was also flavorless. Others in my group had the halibut, crab cakes, beef pasta, and a salad. It seemed like all meals lacked overall flavor and interest. Our very sweet waitress did kindly bring my nephew a chocolate cake slice to celebrate his birthday which was unexpected and generous, Based on all the other reviews, I hope that we just got an off night. But based on the food we ate we would likely not return.

Photos
Love the fireplace
Love the fireplace
Chocolate cake
Chocolate cake
Dining room

See all

Dining room
Old Germantown

Old Germantown

4.6
(146 reviews)
4.9 mi
$$

We especially enjoy the fresh, tasty food...friendly staff...relaxed atmosphere. We are regular…read morepatrons.

First time here, on the recommendation of my niece…read more The hardest part was figuring out that we had actually arrived at the right place. Google Maps brought us to what looked like a farm driveway with corn growing on both sides. There aren't many signs, just an old wagon decorated with Christmas lights. It's almost as if they want to keep the place hidden from the traffic on Pleasant View Drive. Food: The menu focuses primarily on wood-fired pizza, with additional offerings including appetizers, sandwiches, and sausages. They also have a large selection of beers, including several brewed on-site. We ordered the Milwaukee Pizza (cheese, sausage, mushrooms, and onions), and I also got the Washington County Smashburger. To drink, I had a margarita, and she ordered the Big Buck Bock. Our food arrived quickly, and everything was amazingly good. The pizza was hot, well seasoned, and generously topped. There was so much mozzarella that the other toppings were practically swimming in it. The smashburger was also excellent. The patty was cooked through with beautifully crispy edges. The pickles were crisp with just the right amount of kick. The crinkle fries were plentiful and well cooked, although they were just a touch too salty for my taste. Service: We received great service from the moment we walked in. You can either order from your table or at the counter. Since it was our first visit, we chose the counter. A staff member greeted us right away and explained how everything worked. Even though it was near closing time, they encouraged us to place our order and then relax, letting us know they would still be around for another hour after closing. Our food was brought out promptly, several people checked on us throughout the meal, and they even proactively brought us takeout containers. Everyone we encountered was genuinely friendly and helpful, making for a very relaxing dining experience. Atmosphere: The restaurant is set on an old farmstead. They've done a wonderful job converting several of the buildings and outdoor spaces into a welcoming destination. There are multiple outdoor seating areas, along with a newer food hall that feels open, bright, and thoughtfully designed. It's also a very family-friendly place, with outdoor areas where kids can play while everyone else relaxes. Even the restrooms were modern, spacious, and exceptionally clean. We'll definitely be back, and next time we'll be bringing more of the family with us.

Photos
Dining room.
Dining room.
Wood-fired sausage & pepperoni pizza
Wood-fired sausage & pepperoni pizza
Stout beers (one medium, one large)

See all

Stout beers (one medium, one large)
Sawmill Inn Restaurant and Pub

Sawmill Inn Restaurant and Pub

3.5
(228 reviews)
1.1 mi
$$

It was a lazy Saturday morning and I was in the mood to go out for brunch with my kids. Of the…read moreoptions nearby that I either hadn't been to before or hadn't been to in a long time, Sawmill Inn was the most appealing given its proximity to Germantown. I got the Head Sawyer (steak, eggs, and hash browns) with the double tenderloin option, one kid got chicken strips with fries, and the other got a kids pizza. We also shared a piece of coffee cake. I don't think my youngest was super enthused by his pizza, mostly because it's not memorable to him. My oldest liked his chicken strips and fries, but I don't know if he's come across chicken strips and fries that he doesn't like, so take that with a grain of salt. The hash browns were ok. They were just fried potato with no other flavor or add-in like onions. I added salt and pepper because they needed it. I got American cheese on the scrambled eggs and they were as you'd expect. The tenderloin was fine. Obviously not as good of a cut as New York strip or ribeye would have been. I ended up sharing a portion of it with my oldest and he ate it without complaints too. The star of our visit was the coffee cake. It was warm and soft and in every sense perfect. Sharing is carrying and I'm fine sharing with my kids most of the time, but man, I wish it had been all for me.

Came here for brunch and the service was fast and friendly. We were seated right away on a Monday…read moremorning. Their water is really good. I got an omelette with sourdough and fries. It was so good! The omelet didn't have as many toppings as I've usually gotten in omelets but it was really good. The atmosphere is very cute and cozy, like an inn almost. I would picture this in a hallmark movie!

Photos
Downstairs party rooms
Downstairs party rooms
Kids pizza
Kids pizza
Bloody Mary!

See all

Bloody Mary!
Water Street Pub and Grill

Water Street Pub and Grill

4.3
(60 reviews)
5.1 mi

Three of were there for Burger night, Enjoyed our meal service was very good We will be backread more

Came here for dinner and unfortunately left pretty underwhelmed overall…read more The restaurant itself was clean, and service initially started off fine. When we first arrived, the restaurant was not busy. Only a couple other tables occupied, so expectations were fairly high for a smooth experience. Unfortunately, things quickly went downhill. The food took quite a while to come out despite how slow it was. When it finally did, it was first delivered to the wrong table before eventually making its way to us. The food runner then randomly grabbed a ranch from our table and brought it to another table. He seemed potentially new, but overall the service felt very disorganized and clueless, especially considering the restaurant wasn't busy. We ordered the cheese curds to start, and they were disappointing. The breading was mushy and extremely greasy, and the cheese itself tasted low quality rather than the fresh curds you'd expect at a Wisconsin pub. We also ordered several wing flavors since they were on special: garlic parm, buffalo, bourbon BBQ, and lemon pepper. One issue right away was the lack of flavor variety overall on the menu. The wings themselves were inconsistent. Sizes varied dramatically, which clearly affected the cook quality. Some were fried so hard they were like chewing leather, while others had soggy, undercooked skin. Flavor wise the buffalo were almost completely flavorless. The lemon pepper was extremely mild. The garlic parm was probably the best of the group, though still just average. The bourbon BBQ was rough. The sauce tasted like an overly sweet, overly salty cheap jarred glaze rather than an actual house-made BBQ sauce. My wife ordered the Mary Mac burger without a bun and was told extra lettuce leaves could be substituted to make it a lettuce wrap. Instead, it came out with just shredded lettuce. The burger itself was overcooked and lacking flavor. The fries were decent enough, but nothing memorable. Overall, this felt like a place with potential that just missed the mark on both execution and consistency during our visit.

Photos
Bar area
Bar area
Beef brisket quesadilla
Beef brisket quesadilla
Water Street Pub and Grill

See all

Bilda's Friess Lake Pub

Bilda's Friess Lake Pub

3.9
(120 reviews)
4.0 mi
$$

Was looking for a locally owned place for food and beverages after a wonderful round of golf at…read moreWashington County so asked the pro shop staff for their recommendations. Luckily for us they recommended Bilda's Friess Lake Pub. What an awesome place. Small, friendly, with a large selection of beers to choose from, and our food was outstanding. Were immediately told by other customers (obviously regulars) that we had to have the smoked wings. Great call. They were perfect. Very casual place. Nothing fancy but very comfortable. Have a great outside area also where they have bands and comfortably host large groups (a large group of local teachers were there celebrating the last day of school). Highly recommend

Stopped in for another meal…read more Food: The food was excellent. They have eleven different sliders, so we ordered four different ones, along with a side of the haystack onion rings. Service: There was an issue with our order. Apparently, it did not "print" back in the kitchen. We ended up waiting an additional 20 minutes before someone figured out what had happened. They acknowledged the mistake, apologized, and comped our drinks. Atmosphere: They now have outdoor entertainment every evening, and there is plenty of seating to choose from. The traffic around the roundabout intersection can get noisy, but I think they simply turn up the volume to compensate. A good spot for smoked meats and other sandwiches.

Photos
Bilda's Friess Lake Pub
Bilda's Friess Lake Pub
Bilda's Friess Lake Pub

See all

Carol Ann's Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...