Best pizza, terrible pizza, expensive. Never know if your getting something edible or cold undercooked goo. I stopped going there because I had three or four terrible pizzas in a row. read more

I am not sure why it took me so long to try Upper Crust Pizza, I've lived across the street for years. But ok, I finally tried them and it was so worth it. Life in general is so expensive and so, much like life has gotten, I thought it was a bit pricey. I ordered a small 12" Deluxe pizza; it comes with pepperoni, onions, green peeper, and sausage. This was $20. I can't speak for how the pizza used to taste, but I thought the pizza tasted good! The crust was thin. It was cooked perfectly and they were generous with the toppings, which I appreciated for the price. But let me tell you, these Buffalo Ranch chicken wings are seriously fire! If you like wings and you like Buffalo as well, you absolutely HAVE to try these wings. 10 pieces was about $13 or so. They were so delicious and cooked perfectly. I wasn't a fan of their actual ranch dressing but I always have my own anyway. The service, although not overfly friendly, was good enough for me. I don't need constant pleasantries. Food was ready in 30 minutes. I'll definitely be returning although probably not often. It's definitely worth the try. read more

See all

Ordered carry out large pizza and large fried dough bombs. Food was ready very quickly and hot when I picked it up. The staff are friendly and helpful. The restaurant is efficient and delivers delicious food! read more

The lady has never had a cheese steak so I thought that I would surprise her with one, she couldn't figure out why I locked out of the car and that was me placing the order so she couldn't hear. You can't go in because of the virus but they will bring your order out to your car. I ordered two cheese steaks on requested garlic bread because it's like bacon, it makes every sandwich better. The cheese steak comes with a bag of chips for around $9 which is comparable to the chain sandwich shops. The cheese steak looked really good at first look with melty cheese stuck to the paper. My first bite was wow because this is delicious on toasted garlic bread. The steak was real shaved steak and not a beef sandwich with cheese in disguise like some places do. The cheese was nicely melted with onions, mushrooms and green peppers which made for one great sandwich and the lady loved it, she didn't know what it was at first but figured it out. Overall we really enjoyed the cheese steak and I would definitely go back for more of the menu. This just might be my go to place for a cheese steak on garlic bread from now on. read more

See all

We used to buy pizza at upper crust for many years. I don't know if it changed hands or what happened but the sausage resembles Alpo. Makes me sad because he used to be very good. read more

A kind of mediocre only Wisconsin can deliver. It's ketchup with sugar on wonder bread with Kraft singles.

My dad had ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. they seem to be working pretty hard in there when I came to pick it up on a Thursday! read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pepperoni, thin, sliced pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Man have things gone downhill lately at Upper Crust! I've long been a huge fan of their pizza and service, preferring them to other pizza joints, especially those that are franchise or chain options. But an order on June 13 really has me questioning my loyalty to UCP. I used their website--which works pretty well--to place my order for a gathering at my house (yay vaccinations!). Sadly, the order was more than 30 minutes beyond the estimated time provided by the website and confirmation email. While the delivery driver was friendly, there was no acknowledgement of the delay or apology for the tardiness. I quickly moved to feed my hungry guests and that's when I discovered that the garlic sauce was missing from the cheese bread. That garlic sauce is what MAKES that cheese bread. Given how long it took to get my order, I didn't even bother to call and complain about it and made do without it. Jet's Pizza, here we come! read more

I absolutely love this place- usually. Their fried dough bombs are usually the best thing on the planet. However, tonight they did not do so well. I ordered one pizza, cheesy sticks, dough bombs, and a dessert at 6:10 pm for delivery. I live 3 minutes away but was feeling lazy. It said it would take 90 minutes which was a long time in the first place. At 7:50, I called and was told they were loading my food into the car. Then it took an additional 40 minutes, arriving at 8:30. 90 minutes versus 140 seems a pretty significant difference to me... Plus a few of the fried dough bombs were raw dough. read more

Pizza is decent (not great). Service is terrible they are always later than projected pick up times - today they are 20 minutes later than the email confirmation. read more

Good pizza but light on the sauce and could be cooked a bit longer to get some browning on top with some darkening bubbles and help make a crisper crust. Should use canadian bacon ham instead of diced store bought ham. The wings were normal yet still alright but way under sauced. Will try again in a couple months but this was from today. Btw extra should mean extra if paid for and not just the normal amount. read more

We ordered via GrubHub which didn't send our online order right away. We went to this location & they were very accommodating & remade what we ordered. Definitely recommend them. My favorite was the chef salad but everything was tasty for a late night snack. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Breaded Mushrooms Breaded Mushrooms Classic Chicken Tenders Chef Salad - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The pizza recipe has changed and not for the better. I'm guessing sometime since this past winter things really changed. I have usually ordered the Special pizza for more than 20 years and all of a sudden it's now different. The toppings are the same, the thin crust is maybe a little more crispy (if you bent it , it cracks) and the tomato sauce is very different. The new recipe is a darker sauce and not nearly as good as the original. I don't know after all of these years that I will order their pizza again. Let me know when you return to the original recipe. read more

The quality of the ingredients is excellent, and the results tasty. The staff continues to cook the Pizza just the way that they like it, with a lightly browned edge crust and soggy doughy center. If you ask for a slight char and a well done pizza, they just don't care what you want, they just do it their way, with a soggy doughy center. As this is the voice of sad experience typing this, I would have to say that the service kind of sucks. The ambiance is non-existent, you pays your money, you picks up your box, and you go. read more

Exactly what I wanted! Perfect NY style hand tossed which is hard to find in one of the worst pizza States in the union. Lovely lady was a pleasure to talk to as well. read more

If you are on the east side, Whitefish Bay, Shorewood, this place is a little gem. Pizza is very good and always on time when we order. Super easy app to order from. Good stuff! read more

Great food and service ! I highly recommend. The pizza is so good. They have one of the best Philly cheese steaks in town.

Amazing food and service. A large variety too and everything is high quality. Tastes home made.

After reading Tim I.'s review I ordered, even though I'm a thin crust square cut pizza girl. I was in a hotel that delivered nothing but Domino's. I had another pizza where all of the sausage was uniformly formed little balls and that just shouldn't be. Upper Crust delivered! I was happy with hand-torn sausage and the amount of toppings. I have left overs for tomorrow as it should be in my world. read more

Best pizza in Milwaukee by far. And worth a debate for the one of the best pizzas in America. I love it.

This place seemed to fall off the map for a bit, but it looks to be growing at a rapid pace now. Their pizzas are great and they've got some real good options aside from the usual sausage and pepperoni. I'm a fan of the Garden Harvest pizza. They recently added a real thin crust to the selection. It should be interesting to see what they do with it in the future. Aside from pizza, Upper Crust has the usual appetizers, salads, pastas and sandwiches. They've got two kinds of Philly cheese steak sandwiches. An "East Coast" that is pretty typical, but their "Italian Style Philly" is a really neat twist on an old favorite. They pretty much stick with carry out and delivery. Times are usually quick, but plan on a few extra minutes nights and weekends during peak hours. Their staff is always friendly. Sometimes a little rushed, but they get things done as fast as possible. As long as you give them ample notice, food is always hot and ready when you want it. Definitely worth checking out. And definitely better than any franchise pizza place. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - This is the Double Decker pizza that got some recognition from the Journal Sentinel. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Great sandwiches and pizzas , prompt service and delivery! The flavors are perfect and Italian inspired

Ordered delivery tonight at 7pm. It is two hours later and we have not received so much as a phone call explaining why our food is this late. *Update* it is now 9:37pm. We called 30 minutes ago and were told it would arrive in 15 minutes. STILL NO DINNER!!!!! Hell hath no fury like a hungry, crabby teacher on a Friday who just wants a dinner I dont have to cook. read more

Here's the thing. We are excellent customers. Their pizza is generally good. Sometimes too soggy. Today we sent our daughter to pick up and they didn't answer the phone when she called to say they she was there. I tried also and left a message. She finally got through and was hung up on. It was a very uncomfortable situation for her. And just disappointing in general. I get busy. But answer the known and be kind. read more

We ordered an extra-large veggie pizza plus cheesy breadsticks for 3 grandkids and us. Order was ready when promised, but when we opened the pizza box at home, we were VERY disappointed to see a burnt to the crisp pizza. So somebody forgot to take out the pizza on time. Then make another. This was disgusting and not how I remember pizza from Upper Crust. Breadsticks were good, but this was not the meal that our grandkids hoped for. read more

One and done. This is the first and will be my last time eating from here. First off, 25 minutes turned into 45 minutes for my pizza to be done. And then when I got home to dive in, 75% of the pizza was soggy from the grease. I could only eat the outer crust. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - The Hawaiian pizza. A big soggy mess. Canned pineapple? Cmon. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Do yourself a favor and avoid this place at all costs. Upper Crust has two major flaws that I think any patron would find difficult to over look. Very poor customer service and inconsistent food quality/preparation. Being a working professional, I have limited time to prepare meals throughout the week and often look to order out. Upper Crust has delivered to my house on five occasions and out of those five occasions, only one was acceptable. On two occasions, they forgot the pepperoni on their Pepperoni Plus pizza. TWO TIMES IN A ROW! Despite this, I decided to give them another try. On my last attempt to order from Upper Crust, it was decided that I would never give them another cent. I experienced possibly the worst customer service I have ever experienced over the phone. The customer service associate was short, rude, disinterested in talking to me and had a very condescending tone. I pointed this out to the gentlemen on the phone and he became angry and confrontational with me. When I asked to speak to his manager, he simply hung up on me. I attempted to call a few more times after this and was hung up on each time. My assumption was that the gentlemen was trying to avoid me talking to his manager. That was the point I decided to never buy from Upper Crust again. Which lead me to discover another pizza joint far more worthy of my coin, Vedo's Pizza. I have since ordered at least a dozen pizzas from Vedo's and have never been disappointed. Great service, better pizza and most importantly CONSISTENCY! read more

Great takeout pizza. Standard New York-style pies served in traditional varieties. Nothing fancy. Good value and consistent quality.

I've been here a few times. I've heard great things from several people so I always would give this place the benefit of the doubt. Sadly after 3 tries I' d have to say I'm done here. The pizzas are kinda pricey (which is ok..) but for what I paid for them I was very unsatisfied. Today I went in there again, and ordered something completely different. Hoping for a redemption. Nope. My sandwich was sub par and the chicken tenders were also unpleasant. I also ordered a dressing w/ my chicken tenders, which I did not get. 4th strike. Unimpressed and disappointed. Never going back. read more

I've gotten grub from this place twice now, and both times it was no disappointment. I've only had the hand-tossed pizza, which is a quality, crisp-chewy crust pizza that tastes homemade, not grease covered and commercial. Big salads. Standard, but well prepared, appetizers. The only better crust I've had in town is Classic Slice, but there's a few spots I need to hit before I crown a pizza sensei of Milwaukee. Upper crust is totally good stuff. When I got delivery it was prompt and hot. Not as cheap as some of the better known pizza joints about town, but still a lesser-known spot worth trying. read more

Visiting home for the holiday, some friends and I decided to order pizza here last night and were not disappointed. We got one pepperoni plus, which arrived gooey and piping hot, a calzone with one of the best crusts I've had in a very long time, and jalapeño poppers which were average quality (but still got eaten within 5 minutes). The online system told us it would be a 55 minute wait- they were here in 30! I appreciated that and the customer service we received just as much as the pizza, itself. If you're in the area, give it a try. The other reviews says it's hit or miss; my experience was a definite hit. read more

Trying to figure out this places' niche... I jumped at it like I thought I should with no menu, called and ordered a meat-lovers for delivery with high expectations. Pizza delivered; but, the center of the crust was extremely soft and I was frustrated with what I received. It wasn't undercooked, but realizing the four meat grease was the most likely culprit, finished the first slice, and threw the box in the fridge. I told myself to relax and that we (proverbial) were going to work with it, since Yelp! reviews led me to believe this pie was something special. Please mind the alternate definitions of the word special (I'm thinking of the bricks of ham placed on the pizza). I lovingly toaster-ovened the slices for the rest of the week with mixed reviews that were not necessarily time-dependent. It went from love at second bite, to confusion as to why it felt so right, to getting downright dirty with it, and then the ounce of regret following an entire week of eating leftover za. Once smitten, forever smitten. My toaster oven is now a total mess; however, my stomach felt damn fine and still think this place still has potential. Next time I will order a less-gratuitus za and more likely be impressed. read more

First- why are none of the staff wearing masks? There is still a pandemic raging. Next- I placed an order at 5:20 and it wasn't ready until 6:10. They said 40 minutes, and on Friday at 5:20 I thought that was acceptable. Maybe 50 minutes is acceptable on Friday at dinnertime and I'd have been ok with that. But when I stand around waiting for 10 minutes and watching all the kitchen staff cook without masks, it makes me less enthusiastic about coming here. The pizza is usually good which is why we continue to come here. read more

This place always served one of the best pizzas in town. Still do. Love their pizza. Last night, they were swamped. Saturday 9/11/21. I think I spooked them when I pushed them to get my order done. They were running late. But in all seriousness, how do you f--- up an order of garlic bread? I got my order of garlic bread with NO GARLIC, NO BUTTER, NOTHING. Just a rubbery piece of bread! Very disappointed there but after inhaling the first slice of pizza, my animosity melted away into a slice of gooey cheesy pizza. The best. So I'm overlooking this mistake and still giving them 5 stars. Their pizza is that good. read more

Rippin hot wings with blue cheese dressing and solid pizza everytime. My neighborhood favorite ! read more

Best pizza around! Found this place just passing through and glad we did. Call in your order ahead and it will be ready when you get there!

Someone at the office asked be to order the pizza for an office party. I said, it's not going to be Domino's. I called in 10 different pizzas yesterday afternoon for pickup this morning fo 11:00 am. All of them were done right, not that I had any doubts. As I told the gentleman at Upper Crust, my family has been ordering from Upper Crust for 40+ years. And after the reception the pizzas received in the lunchroom today, I think you'll have some new customers. Thanks!!! read more

Tried tonight for the first time. Amazing! Friendly counter staff, flavorful sauce and just really great pizza. Will make this my go to pizza spot. read more

Amazing pizza, fast service, good quality ingredients and perfect proportions of toppings. Will drive 15 minutes from our home in Bayside to Upper Crust Pizza again. read more

One of the best pies in the us. I'm a truck driver coast to coast had pizza all over in most states friendly n Great customer service read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin